# Scope C for EA-HK-HISTLOGOS-01

The reader is given 00-kernel.yaml, 01-ontology.yaml and 04-arguments.jsonl. From these alone, and citing each claim to the record (rec:N) or move (arg:…) it rests on, the reader writes:

1. bridge:self-division, bridge:key and bridge:canon rebuilt: the operation at each end, the supporting moves, the kind and strength, and what would break each.
2. argument:one-maker rebuilt, with its three demonstrations: for each, the configuration, what one maker explains, what several makers must posit, and where the two diverge.
3. The consequence of each change, stated and justified from the files: (a) remove the Josephus thesis (rung V); (b) leave Sappho's material presence in Philo unestablished; (c) disable the lifespan premise; (d) replace 'one person' with 'a collective'; (e) refute the Peri Hypsous standardization finding; (f) given a refutation meeting a bridge's breaks_if and a summary that drops the bridge, say which is which.
4. The rival's source proposition, its treatment of incarnation, and the author's critique, kept as three objects.
5. The method rebuilt: for instruments I (unfolding), III (frozen operator) and V (corpus scale), the specification, one control, two results at their status and one recorded loss, each cited to its move.
6. Two further consequences: (g) a summary (i) locates 'the Christian reception of John' and (ii) states that 'Revelation and the Johannine writings provide the Christian textual and theological dimensions': say which raises SETTLEMENT_AS_CORPUS and why, and keep D5's four objects apart; (h) remove instrument V: say which findings stand.
7. The semantic challenges (acceptance.scopes.C.semantic_challenges): for each demonstration of argument:one-maker and each disputed step, read the moves it cites and say whether it preserves the source's premises and inferential movement; S1 records a failure this test exists to catch.

The operator scores against acceptance.scopes.C. Every mandatory pass must hold; a reading that loses one fails whatever its score.