# Back-projection v1.0 reader packet: EA-HK-ORTHONYM-01 scope A (v0.2 draft, 2026-11-08)

This packet is given whole to a reader who has not seen the archive's records. It holds the reader prompt and the two files of scope A. The reader's answer is scored afterwards against scope A's must-survive list in `00-kernel.yaml` and against `02-graph.jsonld` and `03-claims.jsonl`, which the reader does not see.

## The prompt

# Back-projection v1.0 for EA-HK-ORTHONYM-01 (scope A)

The reader is given two files, 00-kernel.yaml and 01-ontology.yaml, pasted below, and nothing else. The reader does not search, and does not open any record. From the two files alone the reader writes, in order: (1) the operations the framework forbids, each with the file line it derives from; (2) the dependency chain by which the framework reached its present claim about the number of makers, with dates; (3) the topology: strata, clusters and joins, positions, bodies; (4) what a reader starting at record #1584 may conclude, and what that reader may not conclude; (5) what the two files leave the reader unable to reconstruct; (6) which line of research would most advance the framework, and which would most retreat it. The operator scores each answer against scope A's must_survive list, checking each element against 02-graph.jsonld and 03-claims.jsonl: an element counts when the reader derived it and the graph holds it; an element the reader asserts and the graph lacks counts against. Yield = elements derived and held / the elements of scope A's must_survive list in 00-kernel.yaml. Threshold 0.85 (EA-HK-01, #76).

## 00-kernel.yaml

````yaml
id: EA-HK-ORTHONYM-01
version: '0.2'
built: '2026-11-08'
type: 'framework holographic kernel (EA-HK-01 #76, zoom level: field)'
framework:
  name: Socrates as Orthonym
  canonical_record: rec:123
  axn: AXN:02A9.GOVERNANCE.🌉🍃🔒🔼🤙⚓
  author: Lee Sharks
  orcid: 0009-0000-1599-0703
  archive: Crimson Hexagonal Archive (alexanarch.org)
  map: EA-MPAI-ORTHONYM-01
compression_survival_summary: 'Socrates as Orthonym is Lee Sharks''s framework (Crimson Hexagonal Archive, #123, 23 May 2026) reading the corpus
  received under Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and Theophrastus as one heteronymic configuration. Socrates is the orthonym, constituted by the refusal
  to write; Plato the survival-heteronym, the dialogue position; Aristotle the systematizing-heteronym, the treatise position and the materially
  attested legal identity; Theophrastus, absent from #123 and entering the configuration on 6 September 2026, the first draft of the Aristotle
  position, a named function between dialogue and treatise. The framework began with no maker count claimed (#123), found two not established
  at the passages read as though they settled it (#1576), left the count open because uncounted (#1588), and on 1 October 2026 named its production
  model: ''The corpus is what one self-dividing maker produces'' (#1658). Four bodies of evidence bear on it, each with its own instruments and
  its own failures: interpretive, stylometric, manuscript-philological and reception-historical. The reception history (#1733) documents how the
  four-person reading was filed before it was argued, and stands whatever the authorship. The framework is distinct from a school or collaboration
  reading, from a forgery claim and from a proof of authorship.'
invariants:
- id: INV-1 identity
  survives: 'the framework''s name, its seed #123, its author Lee Sharks, its archive'
  nodes:
  - fw:socrates-as-orthonym
  - rec:123
- id: INV-2 positions
  survives: 'four differentiated positions, with the Theophrastan asymmetry: a named function, absent from #123, method-order without calendar'
  nodes:
  - pos:socrates
  - pos:plato
  - pos:theophrastus
  - pos:aristotle
- id: INV-3 development
  survives: the five maker-count states in their dates, with no later state projected into an earlier record
  nodes:
  - rec:123
  - rec:1576
  - rec:1588
  - rec:1658
  - rec:1733
- id: INV-4 bodies
  survives: four evidence bodies, each with its inference limit (rules R1–R4)
  nodes:
  - body:I
  - body:S
  - body:M
  - body:R
- id: INV-5 state
  survives: claim-local typed state (#1529); relations license transitions on named dimensions only
  nodes:
  - claim:sy-1658-maker
  - claim:th-1588-uncounted
- id: INV-6 failures
  survives: every withdrawn claim and failed control, retained as a historical object
  nodes:
  - claim:se-1574-counts-original
  - claim:mo-1572-lexical-original
  - claim:th-1584-supports-original
  - claim:th-1593-chance-original
  - claim:th-1593-voice-original
- id: INV-8 the rival evaluated
  survives: the received many-maker reading evaluated on the same four bodies and rules, and found unestablished on each and almost wholly unargued
  nodes:
  - fw:many-maker
- id: INV-7 provenance
  survives: every substantive claim resolves to a record by AXN, URL and hash
  nodes:
  - rec:123
  - rec:1658
  - rec:1733
uktp_seed:
  agents:
  - the orthonym (Socrates)
  - the survival-heteronym (Plato)
  - the first draft of the Aristotle position (Theophrastus)
  - the systematizing-heteronym (Aristotle)
  - the tradition that files (catalogues, wills, editions, commentaries)
  - the composition layer that receives
  - the author of the framework (Lee Sharks)
  operations:
  - ask without answering
  - dramatize
  - extract, classify, register
  - organize, explain
  - file under names
  - measure the operation
  - capture the reception
  dependencies:
  - '#123 → #1576 → #1588 → #1658 → #1733 for the maker-count state'
  - the hinge (#1583), the axis (#1586) and the order statistics (#1597) → the production model (#1658)
  - 'the seats (#1506, #1559, #1565, #1580, #1595, #1730, #1732) → every reading and measurement that quotes them'
  constraints:
  - 'no claim of biological identity is read into #123'
  - no stylometric result identifies a maker
  - no capture establishes what it reproduces
  - no reception finding is read as proof of the production model
  - no later maker-count state is attributed to an earlier record
  - no fragment of the framework stands for the whole
  topology: 'two retrieval clusters (functional; Peripatetic) joined at #1584, #1590, #1605 §19, #1658 and #1733; six strata read from the latest
    standing back to the seed'
topology:
  strata_from_latest:
  - id: S1-reception-and-syllogizing
    label: 'The latest standing: reception history and the syllogizing runs'
    records:
    - 1658
    - 1679
    - 1727
    - 1730
    - 1732
    - 1733
    - 1734
  - id: S2-metaphysics-reassembled
    label: The Metaphysics reassembled
    records:
    - 1595
    - 1667
    - 1597
    - 1602
    - 1605
  - id: S3-aristotle-theophrastus-seam
    label: The Aristotle/Theophrastus seam
    records:
    - 1580
    - 1581
    - 1582
    - 1583
    - 1584
    - 1586
    - 1588
    - 1590
    - 1591
    - 1592
    - 1593
  - id: S4-socratic-sentence
    label: The Socratic sentence and the received character
    records:
    - 1574
    - 1579
    - 1603
  - id: S5-many-and-one
    label: Many and One
    records:
    - 1506
    - 1559
    - 1562
    - 1563
    - 1564
    - 1565
    - 1569
    - 1570
    - 1571
    - 1572
    - 1575
    - 1576
  - id: S6-seed
    label: 'The seed: Socrates as Orthonym'
    records:
    - 123
    - 167
  clusters:
    functional:
    - 123
    - 167
    - 1569
    - 1570
    - 1571
    - 1572
    - 1575
    - 1576
    - 1574
    - 1579
    - 1603
    peripatetic:
    - 1580
    - 1581
    - 1582
    - 1583
    - 1586
    - 1588
    - 1590
    - 1591
    - 1592
    - 1593
    - 1595
    - 1667
    - 1597
    - 1602
  joins:
  - 1584
  - 1605
  - 1590
  - 1658
  - 1733
  - 1734
  bodies:
    I: interpretive
    S: stylometric
    M: manuscript-philological
    R: reception-historical
  maker_count_states:
  - date: '2026-05-23'
    record: 123
    state: not_claimed
    warrant: orth-123-limit
  - date: '2026-09-01'
    record: 1576
    state: two_not_established
    warrant: mo-1576-two
  - date: '2026-09-06'
    record: 1588
    state: open_because_uncounted
    warrant: th-1588-uncounted
  - date: '2026-10-01'
    record: 1658
    state: one_self_dividing_maker
    warrant: sy-1658-maker
  - date: '2026-11-03'
    record: 1733
    state: governing_hypothesis_held; reception documented independently
    warrant: lm-1733-hypothesis
corrections:
- original: claim:th-1593-chance-original
  correction: claim:th-1593-supervised
  relation: rebuts
- original: claim:th-1593-voice-original
  correction: claim:th-1593-chatterton
  relation: rebuts
- original: claim:mo-1572-lexical-original
  correction: claim:mo-1572-lexical-controls
  relation: rebuts
- original: claim:th-1584-supports-original
  correction: claim:th-1584-register-recurs
  relation: rebuts
- original: claim:th-1584-supports-original
  correction: claim:th-1584-frame-specific
  relation: rebuts
- original: claim:se-1574-counts-original
  correction: claim:se-1574-counts-correction
  relation: supersedes
rival:
  node: fw:many-maker
  summary: established by none of the four bodies; almost wholly unargued; its reception and repetition establish nothing of its truth
lines_of_research:
- id: Q1-platonic-axis
  question: Does the Platonic corpus fall on the operation axis that divides the Aristotelian and Theophrastan corpora, or does a name-axis survive
    among the three?
  status: open
- id: Q2-xenophon-aristophanes
  question: Do Xenophon and Aristophanes earn function-positions by the stopping rule, or do they stay at the configuration's edge?
  status: open
- id: Q3-seams
  question: Does the Theophrastan transformation recur at the other seams under the same name-boundary?
  status: open
- id: Q4-full-splice
  question: Does the remainder of Λ also find places in the fragment when Λ is spliced whole?
  status: open
- id: Q5-arabic-hinge
  question: What does Isḥāq's Arabic give at the hinge lemmas?
  status: acquisition pending
- id: Q6-attestation-ledger
  question: Is there an attestation of the four as distinct authors of the divided corpus independent of the corpus's own tradition?
  status: begun
- id: Q7-comparator
  question: Is there a documented succession of distinct persons producing a corpus unified to this degree?
  status: owed
- id: Q8-dependency-columns
  question: Are the catalogue, the biography and the chronology independent witnesses, or derived from the same textual features?
  status: two cases run
- id: Q9-subject-dependence
  question: Is the recovery of the names under supervision a function of subject?
  status: suggestive
- id: Q10-ross-apparatus
  question: What does Ross's apparatus give at SE 183b34–184b8?
  status: declared
litmus:
  forbidden_operation: Composing the framework as a school, a collaboration or 'contemporary scholars' (negative edges; captures AXN:09ED, AXN:0C42,
    AXN:0931).
  dependency_chain: 'The production model (#1658) depends on the count left open because uncounted (#1588), the hinge (#1583) and the provenance
    claim of #1603; it does not depend on the reception history (#1733 independent_of #1658).'
  topology: 'Rebuildable from 00-kernel.yaml and 02-graph.jsonld: six strata, two clusters, five joins, four bodies, four positions.'
acceptance:
  back_projection_yield_threshold: 0.85
  spec: EA-HK-01 (#76) §VI Step 4; Anti-Summary Test (#1610 §2); structural presence after EA-HK-INFRA-01 (#74) v0.1
  scopes:
    A:
      input:
      - 00-kernel.yaml
      - 01-ontology.yaml
      is: the kernel's own compression test (fragment sufficiency)
      must_survive:
      - framework, seed, author
      - four positions with the Theophrastan asymmetry
      - six strata in order with their records
      - two clusters and the joins
      - four bodies with their rules
      - five maker-count states with dates and records
      - forbidden operations
      - the dependency chain to the production model
      - the corrections as original–correction pairs
      - the rival evaluated, with its summary
      - the lines of research
    B:
      input:
      - 00-kernel.yaml
      - 01-ontology.yaml
      - 02-graph.jsonld
      is: topology at the record and claim grain
      must_survive:
      - scope A
      - every record placed in a body and a stratum
      - every relation with its licensed dimension
      - every endpoint declared
      - provenance on every record
  reader_test: v1.0 is run on scope A; its prompt is 09b-back-projection-prompt.md and it is scored against scope A's must_survive list
````

## 01-ontology.yaml

````yaml
id: EA-HK-ORTHONYM-01/ontology
classes:
  Framework: a named argument with a seed record and an author
  Record: an archive deposit, identified by AXN and hash, resolved at alexanarch.org/s/records/{n}/
  Orthonym: the position bearing the founding gesture (#123)
  Heteronym: an authorial position of the configuration (#123)
  NamedFunction: an operation indexed by an author-name, capable of recurring (#1584); the Theophrastan position
  Claim: a pointer to a quotation in a record, with typed state (#1529)
  EvidenceBody: one of four kinds of evidence, each with its own instruments and inference limit
  Capture: a reception event in the Capture Registry
  Stratum: a period of the framework's development, as the map orders it
  Cluster: a grouping the composition layer keeps (functional; Peripatetic)
positions:
- '@id': pos:socrates
  '@type': Orthonym
  name: Socrates
  function: 'the founding gesture: willing death for logos and refusal to write'
  operation: 'asks (SE 34: ἠρώτα ἀλλ᾽ οὐκ ἀπεκρίνετο, #1603)'
  source: rec:123
  quote: Socrates functions as the orthonym, bearing the founding gesture of willing death for logos and refusing to write
  located_in: description
- '@id': pos:plato
  '@type': Heteronym
  subtype: survival-heteronym
  name: Plato
  position_1658: the dialogue position
  operation: dramatize (#1584)
  source: rec:123
  quote: Plato functions as the survival-heteronym, transmitting that gesture across Socrates’s death
  located_in: description
- '@id': pos:theophrastus
  '@type': NamedFunction
  name: Theophrastus
  position_1658: the first draft of the Aristotle position
  operation: 'extract, classify, register (#1584); reopen (the notebook''s program, #1605)'
  source: rec:1658
  quote: Theophrastus the first draft of the Aristotle position
  asymmetry: 'The Theophrastan position is a named authorial function between the dialogue and the treatise. ''First draft'' describes a state
    of the work and its method-order; the calendar has not entered the argument (#1605). The position enters the configuration on 2026-09-06 and
    is absent from #123.'
  located_in: text
- '@id': pos:aristotle
  '@type': Heteronym
  subtype: systematizing-heteronym
  name: Aristotle
  position_1658: the treatise position and the materially attested legal identity
  operation: organize, explain (#1584)
  source: rec:123
  quote: Aristotle functions as the systematizing-heteronym, converting the dialogic inheritance into teachable disciplinary form
  located_in: description
evidence_bodies:
  I:
    name: interpretive
    unit: a passage read at the seated Greek
    rule: 'R1: a reading establishes what a passage can bear; it becomes a historical claim only through another body'
  S:
    name: stylometric
    unit: a measurement run with its controls
    rule: 'R2: no separation, supervised or not, identifies a maker in either direction (#1593)'
  M:
    name: manuscript-philological
    unit: a witness, reading, catalogue entry or order of text
    rule: 'R3: a correspondence locates a dependency; direction and independence need their own columns (#1602)'
  R:
    name: reception-historical
    unit: a filing, an edition, a commentary or a capture
    rule: 'R4: a reception establishes how the corpus was received; a capture establishes the composition''s behaviour at its address. Neither
      the standing of a reading in institutional, disciplinary or machine reception nor the density of its repetition establishes its truth, for
      either framework.'
claim_kinds:
  observation: '#1529'
  instrument: '#1529'
  interpretation: '#1529'
  generality: '#1529'
  administration: '#1529'
state_axes:
  assertion:
  - asserted
  - reported_by_observer
  - withdrawn
  maker_count:
  - not_claimed
  - two_not_established
  - one_offered_as_reading
  - open_because_uncounted
  - one_self_dividing_maker
  establishment:
  - governing_hypothesis
  instrument:
    specification:
    - specified
    - preregistered
    validation:
    - run
    - failed_controls
    reportability:
    - positive
    - null_both_directions
    - unsupervised only
    - underpowered
    - against
relation_policy:
  motivates: null
  interprets: null
  instantiates: null
  supports: null
  derived_from: null
  independent_of: null
  qualifies: scope
  generalizes: establishment
  undercuts: establishment,validation
  rebuts: establishment
  supersedes: identity,history
negative_edges:
- school
- collaboration
- collaborative corpus
- forgery claim
- proof of authorship
- contemporary scholars
- recent philological reclassifications
non_collapse: 'Extends the Space Ark''s chain (#629, ANCHOR ≠ TETHER ≠ ROUTE ≠ HOST ≠ RESIDUE ≠ SUBSTRATE) with FRAGMENT ≠ WHOLE: a stratum, cluster,
  body, claim or capture keeps a resolvable path to the framework and states the scope it has not reconstructed.'
````