{"id": "orth-123-config", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:123", "axn": "AXN:02A9.GOVERNANCE.🌉🍃🔒🔼🤙⚓", "record_sha256": "2b18f9d4be2c487b7e5d3de12723dbec539860e4ab6c09dd7e30b1690c9e8f7c", "exact": "Socrates functions as the orthonym, bearing the founding gesture of willing death for logos and refusing to write", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "not_claimed"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "present in the current version; introduction date unresolved", "record_date": "2026-05-23", "first_seating": "2026-07-18", "first_seating_commit": "ae8aa4eb44", "current_version_since": "2026-05-23"}}
{"id": "orth-123-limit", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:123", "axn": "AXN:02A9.GOVERNANCE.🌉🍃🔒🔼🤙⚓", "record_sha256": "2b18f9d4be2c487b7e5d3de12723dbec539860e4ab6c09dd7e30b1690c9e8f7c", "exact": "It does not claim that Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle were biologically identical, or that they constituted a single historical person.", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "functional configuration only"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-07-18", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "0265da534834531c3abb279b8738ea615b85e338e33ffce4e9ef07eb3b0537d2", "record_date": "2026-05-23", "first_seating": "2026-07-18", "first_seating_commit": "ae8aa4eb44", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "orth-123-analogues", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:123", "axn": "AXN:02A9.GOVERNANCE.🌉🍃🔒🔼🤙⚓", "record_sha256": "2b18f9d4be2c487b7e5d3de12723dbec539860e4ab6c09dd7e30b1690c9e8f7c", "exact": "Pessoa, Kierkegaard, and the Crimson Hexagonal Archive are analogues that make the concept available, not proof of the ancient case.", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "analogues make the concept available"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "present in the current version; introduction date unresolved", "record_date": "2026-05-23", "first_seating": "2026-07-18", "first_seating_commit": "ae8aa4eb44", "current_version_since": "2026-05-23"}}
{"id": "orth-167-adoption", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:167", "axn": "AXN:0302.GOVERNANCE.🌸🛸🕗🤝🫶👁️", "record_sha256": "705e69b5bd573591cff09a7eee3385b1ddaa723dbbe173e6d2a79beed2f096e4", "exact": "The response reportedly adopted the archive’s relational framework", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "reported_by_observer", "verification": {"author_checked": true, "independent_check": false}}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "present in the current version; introduction date unresolved", "record_date": "2026-06-08", "first_seating": "2026-07-18", "first_seating_commit": "ae8aa4eb44", "current_version_since": "2026-06-08"}}
{"id": "orth-167-limit", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:167", "axn": "AXN:0302.GOVERNANCE.🌸🛸🕗🤝🫶👁️", "record_sha256": "705e69b5bd573591cff09a7eee3385b1ddaa723dbbe173e6d2a79beed2f096e4", "exact": "it does not establish durable adoption or platform intent", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "one dated state", "limit": true}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "present in the current version; introduction date unresolved", "record_date": "2026-06-08", "first_seating": "2026-07-18", "first_seating_commit": "ae8aa4eb44", "current_version_since": "2026-06-08"}}
{"id": "se-1574-counts-original", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "original", "target": {"record": "rec:1574", "axn": "AXN:0666.EMPIRICAL.↗️📚❄️🔩➗⭐", "record_sha256": "da4914319308b3c23571dc7d5c4f626569290b2dd3da2196ae446e0ccea6c1b9", "exact": null, "located_in": "not seated", "original_wording": "the v0.1 count of the reports (v0.1 is not seated; its count is superseded by the v0.2 correction)"}, "state": {"assertion": "withdrawn", "retained_as": "historical object"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "original wording not seated in the record", "record_date": "2026-09-02"}}
{"id": "se-1574-counts-correction", "claim_kind": "administration", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1574", "axn": "AXN:0666.EMPIRICAL.↗️📚❄️🔩➗⭐", "record_sha256": "da4914319308b3c23571dc7d5c4f626569290b2dd3da2196ae446e0ccea6c1b9", "exact": "counts corrected to twenty model reports plus one seed observation", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-02", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "da4914319308b3c23571dc7d5c4f626569290b2dd3da2196ae446e0ccea6c1b9", "record_date": "2026-09-02", "first_seating": "2026-09-02", "first_seating_commit": "9ccf13f56e"}}
{"id": "mo-1572-null", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1572", "axn": "AXN:0664.EMPIRICAL.🍁♦️🫶♻️🌌➖", "record_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "exact": "What the instruments return on maker-count is a null in either direction, symmetric between one maker and master-and-pupil", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "null_both_directions"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-01", "first_seating_commit": "f63297a9d4"}}
{"id": "mo-1572-lexical-original", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "original", "target": {"record": "rec:1572", "axn": "AXN:0664.EMPIRICAL.🍁♦️🫶♻️🌌➖", "record_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "exact": null, "located_in": "not seated", "original_wording": "that the lexical and distributional instruments bear on maker-count; #1572 seats only their failure under controls ('This section reports the instruments that read lexical distribution, and they failed') and the narrowed claim, so the original proposition is not seated"}, "state": {"assertion": "withdrawn", "validation": "failed_controls", "retained_as": "historical object", "withdrawn_as": "evidence on maker-count"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "original wording not seated in the record", "record_date": "2026-09-01"}}
{"id": "mo-1572-lexical-controls", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1572", "axn": "AXN:0664.EMPIRICAL.🍁♦️🫶♻️🌌➖", "record_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "exact": "fifteen features, every one destroyed by a control run in the same session", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "against"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-01", "first_seating_commit": "f63297a9d4"}}
{"id": "mo-1572-apparatus", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1572", "axn": "AXN:0664.EMPIRICAL.🍁♦️🫶♻️🌌➖", "record_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "exact": "registered before any Platonic or Aristotelian text was assigned to it, and filled by both corpora at the level of the individual work", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "preregistered", "validation": "run", "reportability": "positive"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-01", "first_seating_commit": "f63297a9d4"}}
{"id": "mo-1576-two", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1576", "axn": "AXN:0668.GENERATIVE.🔃🧭🕔🔽⚡⚖️", "record_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "exact": "establish that two is not fully established", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "two_not_established"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-02", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-02", "first_seating_commit": "6d92d60d44", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "mo-1576-offer", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1576", "axn": "AXN:0668.GENERATIVE.🔃🧭🕔🔽⚡⚖️", "record_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "exact": "the texts themselves offer one maker as a reading", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "one_offered_as_reading"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-02", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-02", "first_seating_commit": "6d92d60d44", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "se-1574-particle", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1574", "axn": "AXN:0666.EMPIRICAL.↗️📚❄️🔩➗⭐", "record_sha256": "da4914319308b3c23571dc7d5c4f626569290b2dd3da2196ae446e0ccea6c1b9", "exact": "Every round inserted a qualifier into the sentence", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "verification": {"author_checked": true, "independent_check": false}, "scope": {"instance": "twenty reports", "at_rate": "not_established"}}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-02", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "da4914319308b3c23571dc7d5c4f626569290b2dd3da2196ae446e0ccea6c1b9", "record_date": "2026-09-02", "first_seating": "2026-09-02", "first_seating_commit": "9ccf13f56e"}}
{"id": "se-1603-provenance", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1603", "axn": "AXN:0693.UNCLASSIFIED.🎹🎶☽⏪💡☿", "record_sha256": "8988a8d73ca207e2e88e2fdf862bf4b11020c85ab88f3d8c034b41957f9c9da6", "exact": "\"not other relative to the undertaking's provenance\" and \"not a distinct maker\" are different propositions. The paper claims the first", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "provenance_other": "claimed", "maker_other": "withheld"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-09", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "8988a8d73ca207e2e88e2fdf862bf4b11020c85ab88f3d8c034b41957f9c9da6", "record_date": "2026-09-08", "first_seating": "2026-09-09", "first_seating_commit": "bb0df60b95", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "ep-1579-edition", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1579", "axn": "AXN:066B.GENERATIVE.⭐🌟🔝△🎭🎭", "record_sha256": "0809f5988484c544ac4f01428875915ce0fb3fdb3d40890326dd811ce6953047", "exact": "describes an operation: an edition, the revamping and inhabiting of a received character", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "not_claimed"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "0809f5988484c544ac4f01428875915ce0fb3fdb3d40890326dd811ce6953047", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "a3482dd8ff"}}
{"id": "th-1581-ambiguity", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1581", "axn": "AXN:066F.GENERATIVE.🙏🔺☁️🌲💧🤝", "record_sha256": "b3d01f7511b5dbba8177116d37a732b68dd4f2107e66280a1de0ff87f2cde883", "exact": "Ὑπομνημάτων Ἀριστοτελικῶν ἢ Θεοφραστείων — alternative attribution in the catalogue's own wording", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "b3d01f7511b5dbba8177116d37a732b68dd4f2107e66280a1de0ff87f2cde883", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "c278af2c36"}}
{"id": "th-1582-stone", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1582", "axn": "AXN:0671.GENERATIVE.○🗝️💚🏗️💛♅", "record_sha256": "9b3fcc21cda51b0b878a8622b127f4c97c495179fab027aa80bdaf546b4f418c", "exact": "The decree is the only inscription naming Aristotle as maker of a work, and the work is a list", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "9b3fcc21cda51b0b878a8622b127f4c97c495179fab027aa80bdaf546b4f418c", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "26149c7359"}}
{"id": "th-1583-hinge", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1583", "axn": "AXN:0673.GENERATIVE.🧬♦️🤝☁️🌀❄️", "record_sha256": "3b82b51f5f1416055e0f359c82ced2079bd98827fcb7baf5ec364c85b67dd3f1", "exact": "One work, continuous across the point where the name at the head of the roll changed.", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "person_or_function": "undecidable_on_the_page"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "3b82b51f5f1416055e0f359c82ced2079bd98827fcb7baf5ec364c85b67dd3f1", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "6967d4bc40"}}
{"id": "th-1584-traversal", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1584", "axn": "AXN:0675.GENERATIVE.🝊🚀♃♻️🌒🔀", "record_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "exact": "one trait traversing three named authorial functions", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "not_claimed"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "232d9df071"}}
{"id": "th-1584-supports-original", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "original", "target": {"record": "rec:1584", "axn": "AXN:0675.GENERATIVE.🝊🚀♃♻️🌒🔀", "record_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "exact": null, "located_in": "not seated", "original_wording": "two supports in the notebook The First Draft before 2026-09-06: the descriptive/explanatory register as the line between the names; the Ethics' frame vocabulary as absent from the Characters"}, "state": {"assertion": "withdrawn", "retained_as": "historical object"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": null, "basis": "original wording not seated in the record", "record_date": "2026-09-06"}}
{"id": "th-1584-withdrawal", "claim_kind": "administration", "role": "withdrawal", "target": {"record": "rec:1584", "axn": "AXN:0675.GENERATIVE.🝊🚀♃♻️🌒🔀", "record_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "exact": "Two earlier supports are retracted on the same run", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "232d9df071"}}
{"id": "th-1584-register-recurs", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1584", "axn": "AXN:0675.GENERATIVE.🝊🚀♃♻️🌒🔀", "record_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "exact": "the descriptive/explanatory register recurs within each name at equal magnitude", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "against"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "232d9df071"}}
{"id": "th-1584-frame-specific", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1584", "axn": "AXN:0675.GENERATIVE.🝊🚀♃♻️🌒🔀", "record_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "exact": "the Ethics' frame vocabulary is EN-specific", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "against"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "a15da3fe01dfe4f974bebc064d8b0f3154ad54aa5c0e572ccb98670dde286cf5", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "232d9df071"}}
{"id": "th-1586-axis", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1586", "axn": "AXN:0679.GENERATIVE.🍀🌕🟠⚙️🎻💎", "record_sha256": "7404c2328a1c6521b01b70445eabb2d21eb14c774fbc843e21bb1ea444574c65", "exact": "split by operation and left the names at chance", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "unsupervised only"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "7404c2328a1c6521b01b70445eabb2d21eb14c774fbc843e21bb1ea444574c65", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "9f154ddb13", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}, "notes": "qualified in scope by th-1593-supervised: supervised attribution recovers the names"}
{"id": "th-1588-uncounted", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1588", "axn": "AXN:067D.OPERATIVE.🛡️🔍🔅🍂🏗️➕", "record_sha256": "2d56ed7821900b0b2671a52bcf7d635949d42f53da3377f5a4b56cbc633372a2", "exact": "\"Maker-count open\" therefore means *open because uncounted*, not *open because two is still supported*.", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "open_because_uncounted"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "2d56ed7821900b0b2671a52bcf7d635949d42f53da3377f5a4b56cbc633372a2", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "458b358de1", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "th-1590-ghost", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1590", "axn": "AXN:0681.GENERATIVE.🪟🎲📜🔓🧬❤️", "record_sha256": "258d40fa3b8110ae9a0a7398a1ee03f66e5cd65e9f2e9b5deca21e400eeddb5f", "exact": "seven times base rate, concentrated exactly where the tradition says the lost works are", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "datum": "the shape of the catalogue match"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "258d40fa3b8110ae9a0a7398a1ee03f66e5cd65e9f2e9b5deca21e400eeddb5f", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "09154ea4f4"}}
{"id": "th-1593-chance-original", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "original", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "that the Aristotle/Theophrastus names sit at chance", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "withdrawn", "retained_as": "historical object", "scope_withdrawn": "supervised attribution"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "th-1593-supervised", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "supervised attribution recovers them at 0.798 balanced, outside the null", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "positive"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "th-1593-voice-original", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "original", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "that an assumed authorial voice cannot split from its own author", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "withdrawn", "retained_as": "historical object"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "th-1593-chatterton", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "correction", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "Chatterton's Rowley forgery separates from his acknowledged verse at 0.864", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "positive"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "th-1593-limit", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "no supervised separation, however strong, licenses an inference to distinct makers, in either direction", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "all supervised separations"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "mx-1597-order", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1597", "axn": "AXN:068D.UNCLASSIFIED.🏠📎⛵🏠🕘📜", "record_sha256": "26475c266a40ccadd887b204b1429009687aed4d03176a7de8706eaade1caaeb", "exact": "no monotone merge of the two received orders exists", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "positive"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-08", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "26475c266a40ccadd887b204b1429009687aed4d03176a7de8706eaade1caaeb", "record_date": "2026-09-08", "first_seating": "2026-09-08", "first_seating_commit": "d2e67d6e7d"}}
{"id": "mx-1597-underpowered", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1597", "axn": "AXN:068D.UNCLASSIFIED.🏠📎⛵🏠🕘📜", "record_sha256": "26475c266a40ccadd887b204b1429009687aed4d03176a7de8706eaade1caaeb", "exact": "underpowered to say identical", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "underpowered"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-08", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "26475c266a40ccadd887b204b1429009687aed4d03176a7de8706eaade1caaeb", "record_date": "2026-09-08", "first_seating": "2026-09-08", "first_seating_commit": "d2e67d6e7d"}}
{"id": "mx-1602-question", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1602", "axn": "AXN:0692.UNCLASSIFIED.♆🕔🌈📚⭐👇", "record_sha256": "a6661e4908b736d791b2f40cd623613fb96744c9833d2111fb4e25023498b35c", "exact": "THAT IS A QUESTION AND NOT A FINDING", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "derivation of witnesses"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-09", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "a6661e4908b736d791b2f40cd623613fb96744c9833d2111fb4e25023498b35c", "record_date": "2026-09-08", "first_seating": "2026-09-09", "first_seating_commit": "bb0df60b95", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "mx-1605-node", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1605", "axn": "AXN:0695.UNCLASSIFIED.✖️🔽🧱👈🍂🎆", "record_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "exact": "all four pass through the Theophrastan node", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-10", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "record_date": "2026-09-10", "first_seating": "2026-09-10", "first_seating_commit": "c797b20473"}}
{"id": "mx-1605-uptake", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1605", "axn": "AXN:0695.UNCLASSIFIED.✖️🔽🧱👈🍂🎆", "record_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "exact": "ranks Th.frag → Ar.Met.L first of 1,482 directed edges", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "positive"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-10", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "record_date": "2026-09-10", "first_seating": "2026-09-10", "first_seating_commit": "c797b20473"}}
{"id": "mx-1605-aconite", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1605", "axn": "AXN:0695.UNCLASSIFIED.✖️🔽🧱👈🍂🎆", "record_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "exact": "CASE 2, THE ACONITE, RETURNS DIRECTION AGAINST THE AUTHOR", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"specification": "specified", "validation": "run", "reportability": "against"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-10", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "92d522b878e7fe8964cbaedd7ee4a6ca5319c371926401046e35cf5099d97371", "record_date": "2026-09-10", "first_seating": "2026-09-10", "first_seating_commit": "c797b20473"}}
{"id": "sy-1658-maker", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1658", "axn": "AXN:06E0.GENERATIVE.🔙🧬🔖👈🟢🤲", "record_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "exact": "The corpus is what one self-dividing maker produces", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "one_self_dividing_maker", "establishment": "governing_hypothesis"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-10-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "record_date": "2026-10-01", "first_seating": "2026-10-01", "first_seating_commit": "72c37b4ab4"}}
{"id": "sy-1658-second", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1658", "axn": "AXN:06E0.GENERATIVE.🔙🧬🔖👈🟢🤲", "record_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "exact": "Nothing in the texts requires a second maker.", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "one_self_dividing_maker"}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-10-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "record_date": "2026-10-01", "first_seating": "2026-10-01", "first_seating_commit": "72c37b4ab4"}}
{"id": "lm-1733-hypothesis", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "One maker, legitimately many, composed the three bodies of writing and gave the four positions their operations", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "maker_count": "one_self_dividing_maker", "establishment": "governing_hypothesis"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "lm-1733-independent", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "The documented operations stand whatever the authorship", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted", "scope": "the reception history"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "lm-1733-filing", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "the frame of several makers was set by filing before anyone argued it", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "lm-1734-apart", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1734", "axn": "AXN:0BE8.MPAI.🗿🌆🌗🏠⏳🐚", "record_sha256": "fce306266e7a283539cce0e5249601d41190b79dd0333e153dabc99047dcc28f", "exact": "keeps the study's hypothesis of one maker apart from its documented findings", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "asserted"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "fce306266e7a283539cce0e5249601d41190b79dd0333e153dabc99047dcc28f", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "0aaf38e691"}}
{"id": "rv-1572-null", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1572", "axn": "AXN:0664.EMPIRICAL.🍁♦️🫶♻️🌌➖", "record_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "exact": "What the instruments return on maker-count is a null in either direction, symmetric between one maker and master-and-pupil", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "establishes_two": false}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "7782bdfee69194f3cb537de8fe3a6cea553936c699535d5d588a47439bf53ec0", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-01", "first_seating_commit": "f63297a9d4"}}
{"id": "rv-1593-limit", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "no supervised separation, however strong, licenses an inference to distinct makers, in either direction", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "establishes_two": false}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "rv-1593-names", "claim_kind": "instrument", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1593", "axn": "AXN:0686.OPERATIVE.🔥🌉◇👆⭐🤙", "record_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "exact": "name recovery falls to 0.564 when botanical and zoological works are removed", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "note": "the names are recoverable as a partition at 0.798, and the recovery tracks subject"}, "body": "S", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-07", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "102b9ab608be382d215ec868afc9e0d02318532d895f5eab7be47f4a79c8a5eb", "record_date": "2026-09-07", "first_seating": "2026-09-07", "first_seating_commit": "0ec35e7d97"}}
{"id": "rv-1658-ledger", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1658", "axn": "AXN:06E0.GENERATIVE.🔙🧬🔖👈🟢🤲", "record_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "exact": "every other attestation of persons is text of the same tradition", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "independent_witness": false}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-10-01", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "f33b48b8c4b1595f3308937eb9b07e2880c4a5b0f4398964f0e9919f52043b28", "record_date": "2026-10-01", "first_seating": "2026-10-01", "first_seating_commit": "72c37b4ab4"}}
{"id": "rv-1582-stone", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1582", "axn": "AXN:0671.GENERATIVE.○🗝️💚🏗️💛♅", "record_sha256": "9b3fcc21cda51b0b878a8622b127f4c97c495179fab027aa80bdaf546b4f418c", "exact": "The decree is the only inscription naming Aristotle as maker of a work, and the work is a list", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "note": "attests a person named Aristotle as a list's maker; attests no division of the corpus"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "9b3fcc21cda51b0b878a8622b127f4c97c495179fab027aa80bdaf546b4f418c", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "26149c7359"}}
{"id": "rv-1581-will", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1581", "axn": "AXN:066F.GENERATIVE.🙏🔺☁️🌲💧🤝", "record_sha256": "b3d01f7511b5dbba8177116d37a732b68dd4f2107e66280a1de0ff87f2cde883", "exact": "the will of Aristotle names no book, library, school, or successor", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker"}, "body": "M", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-06", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "b3d01f7511b5dbba8177116d37a732b68dd4f2107e66280a1de0ff87f2cde883", "record_date": "2026-09-06", "first_seating": "2026-09-06", "first_seating_commit": "c278af2c36"}}
{"id": "rv-1733-channel", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "the wills were read as independent evidence of the persons though they reach the reader through the school's own channel", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "independent_witness": false}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "rv-1576-under", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1576", "axn": "AXN:0668.GENERATIVE.🔃🧭🕔🔽⚡⚖️", "record_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "exact": "the standard attribution is underdetermined by the passages that are read as though it were", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "establishes_two": false}, "body": "I", "introduced": {"date": "2026-09-02", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "de5066d513366d6eb272f0620b3e3cf9473377635ac62bc69f2e1d0e94ceb414", "record_date": "2026-09-01", "first_seating": "2026-09-02", "first_seating_commit": "6d92d60d44", "note": "the record is dated earlier than its first seating here; presence before the first seating is not attested by this repository"}}
{"id": "rv-1733-filing", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "argument appears only where a filing was put in question and appears as its defence", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "argued": "as defence of a filing only"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "rv-1733-loci", "claim_kind": "observation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "on the 79 loci that bear on the count of composing persons, the received count is affirmed as a proposition at two, both machine compositions, both on the warrant of the wills and lives", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "argued": "affirmed as a proposition at 2 of 79 loci"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "rv-1733-comparator", "claim_kind": "generality", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "The reading owes a comparator, a documented succession of distinct persons producing a corpus unified to this degree (design §4.4), and none has been named.", "located_in": "text"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "comparator": "owed, none named"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}
{"id": "rv-1733-incentive", "claim_kind": "interpretation", "role": "standing", "target": {"record": "rec:1733", "axn": "AXN:0BE7.GENERATIVE.🌾🔓🔝🕗🟣🗡️", "record_sha256": "1afaf569c65a96da3d76a0236d187409fc94bd7efa6105b17a2c325e445602d4", "exact": "a filing under several makers meets credibility and reception as knowledge at once", "located_in": "description"}, "state": {"assertion": "bears_on_rival", "rival": "fw:many-maker", "persistence": "incentive and function"}, "body": "R", "introduced": {"date": "2026-11-03", "basis": "present at the record's first seating in this repository", "first_text_sha256": "751e9bf34320dc6448c675a24ec5fbde6951b6845adb31194b32796ffe11aca5", "record_date": "2026-11-03", "first_seating": "2026-11-03", "first_seating_commit": "81d0aad48c"}}