{
 "row": "vesuvius-challenge",
 "pass": "first reading, 2026-10-31; second pass with one citation hop",
 "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.9 §3.4 D/R/O (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: D, a claim on the Vesuvius Challenge with the entity named; R, a relation the archive states between it and an archive object; O, an archive category applied to it or to a class the field and the census source for it (the Herculaneum papyri: B1, B4, B12, census text_object; machine reading of ancient texts, virtual unwrapping and ink detection: B1, B3, B4, B7, B12, census intersection 'ai-ancient-texts', evidence_kind, method, unit, worked question 'machine-dating'; papyrological discovery, new texts recovered: B3, B4, B7, census intersection 'papyrology-discovery'). A bare mention, a reference-list entry or a keyword is not a claim. Beyond the string pass, every archive text matching a class pattern (data/texts and data/deposits) was read at its passage.",
 "reader": "Claude (Opus 5.5), subagent, 2026-10-31",
 "admitted_surface": [
  {
   "dep": "capture",
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/vesuvius-challenge-aio-20261031/",
   "reason": "the Capture Registry's findings, reading, analysis, PER notes and query note for the entity's capture (OBS-c89c95b2cf7e, 2026-10-31), the archive's statements on the entity's composition",
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-01",
    "CAP-1-02",
    "CAP-1-03",
    "CAP-1-04",
    "CAP-1-05",
    "CAP-1-06",
    "CAP-1-07",
    "CAP-1-08",
    "CAP-1-09",
    "CAP-1-10",
    "CAP-1-11",
    "CAP-1-12",
    "CAP-1-13",
    "CAP-1-14"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": "RF",
   "url": "https://www.revelationfirst.com/aggregators/vesuvius-challenge/ (source: /home/claude/fleet/revelationfirst-com/data/rf-census/census.json rows[slug == 'vesuvius-challenge'], organizing_question, correction; questions.json 'machine-dating')",
   "reason": "the Revelation First census record of the entity, the archive's formalization of it, and the worked question that names it",
   "claims": [
    "RF-01",
    "RF-02",
    "RF-03",
    "RF-04",
    "RF-05",
    "RF-06",
    "RF-07",
    "RF-08",
    "RF-09",
    "RF-10",
    "RF-11",
    "RF-12",
    "RF-13",
    "RF-14",
    "RF-15",
    "RF-16",
    "RF-17",
    "RF-18",
    "RF-19",
    "RF-20",
    "RF-21",
    "RF-22",
    "RF-23",
    "RF-24",
    "RF-25",
    "RF-26"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "verdicts": [
  {
   "dep": 1443,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "The Photograph of the Handwritten Original (Lee Sharks, 2026-08-09): §2.4 'Vesuvius Challenge (2023–2026) — and the readability score of zero' names the entity and states what it establishes and cannot do (D); the readability finding 'transfers exactly' to the archive (R); §7.4 (ii) applies the archive's category, the optical unconscious, to its result (O-direct); Part X's 'Vesuvius and Ithaca work on authors who cannot be consulted' names it by context (D). The heading sentence D0001 is the candidate; the two reference-list sentences (D0002, D0003) are bare and rejected; O candidate at p217 is §7.4 (ii).",
   "claims": [
    "D1443-01",
    "D1443-02",
    "D1443-03",
    "D1443-04",
    "D1443-05",
    "R1443-06",
    "D1443-07",
    "D1443-08",
    "D1443-09",
    "O1443-10",
    "D1443-11"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0001",
    "D0002",
    "D0003",
    "O0016"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "not_admitted": [
  {
   "dep": 56,
   "cands": [
    "O0001",
    "O0002"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 203,
   "cands": [
    "O0003"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 636,
   "cands": [
    "O0004"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 639,
   "cands": [
    "O0005"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 969,
   "cands": [
    "O0006",
    "O0007"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 970,
   "cands": [
    "O0008",
    "O0009"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 971,
   "cands": [
    "O0010",
    "O0011"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1101,
   "cands": [
    "O0012",
    "O0013"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1213,
   "cands": [
    "O0014"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1226,
   "cands": [
    "O0015"
   ],
   "reason": "the papyrological record of New Testament manuscripts (Revelation among the earliest NT texts preserved, P18, P47, P98; or the evidence-type table of the Revelation-priority reading): a claim about NT papyri and their dates, which the record states the entity cannot answer (RF-15); no claim on the entity or on texts recovered from unopened papyri"
  },
  {
   "dep": 832,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep in data/deposits (not a string-pass candidate): 'Papyrological evidence: earliest physical NT witnesses are Johannine (P52 ~125 CE, P98 ~150 CE)' in the Revelation-priority packet; as above"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1211,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep in data/deposits (not a string-pass candidate): 'Papyrological evidence: earliest physical NT witnesses are Johannine (P52 ~125 CE, P98 ~150 CE)' in the Revelation-priority packet; as above"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1216,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep in data/deposits (not a string-pass candidate): 'Papyrological evidence: earliest physical NT witnesses are Johannine (P52 ~125 CE, P98 ~150 CE)' in the Revelation-priority packet; as above"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1217,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep in data/deposits (not a string-pass candidate): 'Papyrological evidence: earliest physical NT witnesses are Johannine (P52 ~125 CE, P98 ~150 CE)' in the Revelation-priority packet; as above"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1400,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep in data/deposits (not a string-pass candidate): 'Papyrological evidence: earliest physical NT witnesses are Johannine (P52 ~125 CE, P98 ~150 CE)' in the Revelation-priority packet; as above"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1572,
   "cands": [
    "O0017"
   ],
   "reason": "Many and One (apparatus [II.4]): the Corpus dei Papiri Filosofici named as the standing external check on the Plato–Aristotle question, not consulted; says something of papyrological evidence but applies no archive category to the class as the field sources it and says nothing of the entity; recorded, not admitted under the O guard"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1575,
   "cands": [
    "O0018"
   ],
   "reason": "the same note in the reading copy ([VIII.4]); as #1572"
  },
  {
   "dep": 1576,
   "cands": [
    "O0019"
   ],
   "reason": "Many and One §9.5: the papyrological record, inscriptions and transmission history are the evidence that would bear on how many makers there were, and the paper's claim ranks below them; as #1572"
  },
  {
   "dep": 281,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep ('papyrological discoveries'): Sappho 31's reconstructed stanza 'stands as hypothesis' until future papyrological discoveries confirm, modify or refute it; a limit on the archive's own reconstruction, no archive category applied to the class and nothing said of the entity (neighbour row sappho-31.json); recorded, not admitted"
  },
  {
   "dep": 864,
   "cands": [],
   "reason": "found by the class grep ('tomography'): muon tomography of the Great Pyramid; not a manuscript or a reading of text"
  }
 ],
 "hop": {
  "from": [
   1443
  ],
  "candidates": 35,
  "admitted": 0,
  "reading": "each hop candidate read by title and by a scan of its text for the entity, the class patterns and Herculaneum, PHerc, unreadable, readability, papyr, Ithaca; the matches are other senses ('readability' of extracted web text, #127; of compressed objects, #29; a steganographic 'unreadable', #616; the Feist Source's 'unreadable' files, #1404; Ithaca as a publisher's city, #123; papyrology venues listed, #1444; Sappho and Thomas papyri in the prediction index, #1684), and the analog-inscription line (#1406, #1409, #1444) reads contemporary handwriting; none says anything of the entity or its classes"
 },
 "observations": "One archive text names the Vesuvius Challenge: #1443, the field survey of machine-eligible handwritten artifacts, which gives it its own section (§2.4) under the convention 'what it establishes, what it assumes, what it cannot do', and returns to it in §7.4 and Part X. The archive's bearing is direct and ontological through that one paper; the Revelation-priority line's 'papyrological record' is a different class (the NT papyri), which the census itself sets apart from the entity (RF-15, RF-26).",
 "counts": {
  "string_pass": {
   "D_sentences": 3,
   "D_deposits": 1,
   "R_sentences": 0,
   "R_deposits": 0,
   "O_direct": 0,
   "O_class": 19,
   "O_deposits": 14,
   "H_candidates": 35
  },
  "class_texts_read": 21,
  "deposits_candidate": 15,
  "deposits_admitted": 1,
  "deposits_admitted_with_claims": 1,
  "instances_grouped_S4": 0,
  "hop_candidates": 35,
  "hop_admitted": 0,
  "archive_claims": {
   "capture": 14,
   "rf": 26,
   "deposit": 11
  }
 }
}