{
 "row": "the-socratic-problem",
 "pass": "first reading, 2026-10-07",
 "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.7 §3.4 D/R/O (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: a candidate is admitted to a stratum when its sentence or paragraph makes a claim of that stratum's kind: D, a claim on what Socrates was or how the portrayals (Plato, Xenophon, Aristophanes, Aristotle) stand to him; R, a relation between Socrates as the problem's object and an archive object (heteronym, orthonym, the archive's authorship theory, the archive itself); O, an archive category applied to him (orthonym, heteronym, edition of a received character, mask, effective act, Logotic displacement). Naming Socrates is not enough. Machine compositions quoted in deposits are reception evidence and are not admitted. Volume is never a ground of removal; instances of one work are grouped as a lineage and kept.",
 "reader": "Claude, subagent, 2026-10-07",
 "verdicts": [
  {
   "dep": 123,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0023",
    "D0024",
    "D0025",
    "D0026",
    "D0027",
    "D0028",
    "D0029",
    "D0030",
    "D0031",
    "D0032",
    "D0033",
    "D0034",
    "D0035",
    "D0036",
    "D0037",
    "D0038",
    "D0039",
    "D0040",
    "D0041",
    "D0042",
    "D0043",
    "D0044",
    "D0045",
    "D0046",
    "D0047",
    "D0048",
    "D0049",
    "D0050",
    "D0051",
    "D0052",
    "D0053",
    "D0054",
    "D0055",
    "D0056",
    "D0057",
    "D0058",
    "D0059",
    "D0060",
    "D0061",
    "D0062",
    "D0063",
    "D0064",
    "D0065",
    "D0066",
    "D0067",
    "D0068",
    "D0069",
    "D0070",
    "D0071",
    "D0072",
    "D0073",
    "D0074",
    "D0075",
    "D0076",
    "R0008",
    "R0009",
    "R0010",
    "R0011",
    "O0013",
    "O0014",
    "O0015",
    "O0016",
    "O0017",
    "O0018",
    "O0019",
    "O0020",
    "O0021",
    "O0022",
    "O0023",
    "O0024",
    "O0025",
    "O0026",
    "O0027",
    "O0028",
    "O0029"
   ],
   "reason": "The archive's defining paper on the problem. D: names the Socratic problem, defines it as the question where the historical Socrates ends and the Platonic character begins, splits it into historical/literary/doctrinal questions, and reclassifies it as a symptom of a heteronymic configuration (secondary claim, medium confidence); keeps the historical Socrates 'historically real' and reassigns his function to the orthonymic gesture; positions against Kahn 1996; reads Metaphysics A 6. O: orthonym/heteronym categories applied (σ_S operator; failure mode = the Socratic problem). R: CHA as availability of concept, continuous with the configuration."
  },
  {
   "dep": 136,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0093",
    "D0094",
    "D0095",
    "D0096",
    "D0097",
    "D0098",
    "D0099",
    "D0100",
    "D0101",
    "D0102",
    "D0103",
    "D0104",
    "D0105",
    "D0106",
    "D0107",
    "D0108",
    "D0109",
    "D0110",
    "D0111",
    "D0112",
    "D0113",
    "D0114",
    "D0115",
    "D0116",
    "D0117",
    "D0118",
    "D0119",
    "D0120",
    "D0121",
    "D0122",
    "D0123",
    "D0124",
    "D0125",
    "D0126",
    "D0127",
    "D0128",
    "D0129",
    "D0130",
    "D0131",
    "D0132",
    "D0133",
    "D0134",
    "D0135",
    "D0136",
    "D0137",
    "D0138",
    "D0139",
    "R0017",
    "R0018",
    "R0019",
    "R0020",
    "O0041",
    "O0042",
    "O0043",
    "O0044",
    "O0045",
    "O0046",
    "O0047",
    "O0048",
    "O0049",
    "O0050",
    "O0051",
    "O0052",
    "O0053",
    "O0054",
    "O0055"
   ],
   "reason": "Chaerephon Problem. D: the Socratic problem's 'previously unnamed severe form'; portrayal conflicts (Aristophanes mocks, Xenophon's civic Socrates differs from Plato's) read as the signature of a heteronymic field; foreclosure as instrument-defeat; scarcity discriminator. O: firewall (evidence vs pattern). R: companion to #123."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1261,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0500",
    "D0501",
    "D0502",
    "D0503",
    "D0504",
    "D0505",
    "D0506",
    "D0507",
    "D0508",
    "D0509",
    "D0510",
    "D0511",
    "D0512",
    "D0513",
    "D0514",
    "D0515",
    "D0516",
    "D0517",
    "D0518",
    "D0519",
    "D0520",
    "D0521",
    "D0522",
    "D0523",
    "D0524",
    "D0525",
    "D0526",
    "D0527",
    "D0528",
    "D0529",
    "D0530",
    "D0531",
    "D0532",
    "D0533",
    "D0534",
    "D0535",
    "D0536",
    "D0537",
    "D0538",
    "D0539",
    "D0540",
    "D0541",
    "D0542",
    "D0543",
    "D0544",
    "D0545",
    "D0546",
    "R0086",
    "R0087",
    "R0088",
    "R0089",
    "O0214",
    "O0215",
    "O0216",
    "O0217",
    "O0218",
    "O0219",
    "O0220",
    "O0221",
    "O0222",
    "O0223",
    "O0224",
    "O0225",
    "O0226",
    "O0227",
    "O0228"
   ],
   "reason": "Second instance of the Chaerephon Problem (PDF-derived text, same claims); lineage instance of #136."
  },
  {
   "dep": 764,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0347",
    "D0348",
    "D0349",
    "O0164",
    "O0165"
   ],
   "reason": "Ratification record of the Chaerephon Problem: lists the Socratic problem 're-narrated as forced foreclosure' among the paper's contributions. Lineage instance of #136."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1579,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0886",
    "D0887",
    "D0888",
    "D0889",
    "D0890",
    "D0891",
    "D0892",
    "D0893",
    "D0894",
    "D0895",
    "D0896",
    "D0897",
    "D0898",
    "D0899",
    "D0900",
    "D0901",
    "D0902",
    "D0903",
    "D0904",
    "D0905",
    "D0906",
    "D0907",
    "D0908",
    "D0909",
    "D0910",
    "D0911",
    "D0912",
    "D0913",
    "D0914",
    "D0915",
    "D0916",
    "D0917",
    "D0918",
    "D0919",
    "D0920",
    "D0921",
    "D0922",
    "D0923",
    "D0924",
    "D0925",
    "D0926",
    "D0927",
    "D0928",
    "D0929",
    "D0930",
    "D0931",
    "D0932",
    "D0933",
    "D0934",
    "D0935",
    "D0936",
    "D0937",
    "R0102",
    "R0103",
    "O0307",
    "O0308",
    "O0309",
    "O0310",
    "O0311",
    "O0312",
    "O0313",
    "O0314",
    "O0315",
    "O0316",
    "O0317"
   ],
   "reason": "Beautiful and New. D: Ep. II 314c read as an edition of a received character; the base is a circulating (Aristophanic) Socrates, not the historical man ('beyond any text's reach'); revision item by item; καλός/νέος as repairs; Aristotle receives the edited figure; idealization consensus absorbed as surface description; explicit limit: no thesis about who the historical Socrates was. O: 'edition of a received character' applied to Plato's Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1583,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0941"
   ],
   "reason": "Applies 314c as an author dividing the work by named function; lineage with #1579."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1569,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0580",
    "D0581",
    "D0582",
    "D0583",
    "D0584",
    "D0585",
    "D0586",
    "D0587",
    "D0588",
    "D0589",
    "D0590",
    "D0591",
    "D0592",
    "D0593",
    "D0594",
    "D0595",
    "D0596",
    "D0597",
    "D0598",
    "D0599",
    "D0600",
    "D0601",
    "D0602",
    "D0603",
    "D0604",
    "D0605",
    "D0606",
    "D0607",
    "D0608",
    "D0609",
    "D0610",
    "D0611",
    "D0612",
    "D0613",
    "D0614",
    "D0615",
    "D0616",
    "D0617",
    "D0618",
    "D0619",
    "D0620",
    "D0621",
    "D0622",
    "D0623",
    "D0624",
    "D0625",
    "D0626",
    "D0627",
    "D0628",
    "D0629",
    "D0630",
    "D0631",
    "D0632",
    "D0633",
    "D0634",
    "D0635",
    "D0636",
    "D0637",
    "D0638",
    "D0639",
    "D0640",
    "D0641",
    "D0642",
    "D0643",
    "D0644",
    "D0645",
    "D0646",
    "D0647",
    "D0648",
    "D0649",
    "D0650",
    "D0651",
    "D0652",
    "D0653",
    "D0654",
    "D0655",
    "D0656",
    "D0657",
    "R0097",
    "O0239",
    "O0240",
    "O0241",
    "O0242",
    "O0243",
    "O0244",
    "O0245",
    "O0246",
    "O0247",
    "O0248",
    "O0249",
    "O0250",
    "O0251",
    "O0252",
    "O0253",
    "O0254",
    "O0255"
   ],
   "reason": "Notebook of the authorship investigation. D: full-strength thesis 'one hand wrote Plato and Socrates, and probably Xenophon and Aristophanes'; Round 43 attestation measurement, its falsifier, the Protagoras control and the withdrawal; Round 54 comic-layer test (accusation-profile comic, operation not); §237 Socratic problem as the paper's missing frame; firewall. O: vacant centre/orthonym."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1570,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0658",
    "D0659",
    "D0660",
    "D0661",
    "D0662",
    "D0663",
    "D0664",
    "D0665",
    "D0666",
    "D0667",
    "D0668",
    "D0669",
    "D0670",
    "D0671",
    "D0672",
    "D0673",
    "D0674",
    "O0256",
    "O0257",
    "O0258"
   ],
   "reason": "Measurement register: M34 (Socrates 0/144 vs Callias 5/35 in snub contexts in Aristotle, with innocent reading), M15 (Socrates/Athenian/Eleatic equilateral), M16 (Plato's constructed Aristophanes reads Platonic). Measurements of how the Platonic and Aristotelian portrayals treat Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1571,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0675",
    "D0676",
    "D0677",
    "D0678",
    "D0679",
    "O0259",
    "O0260"
   ],
   "reason": "Frozen pre-registration P2 (Socrates the least constrained speaking position) with its falsifier and the run result."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1572,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0680",
    "D0681",
    "O0261"
   ],
   "reason": "Inheritance Is Observable: confinement of Socrates' attestation (99.5%) does not discriminate against Protagoras (99.8%). Lineage with #1569 R43."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1575,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0772",
    "D0773",
    "D0774",
    "D0775",
    "D0776",
    "D0777",
    "D0778",
    "D0779",
    "D0780",
    "D0781",
    "D0782",
    "D0783",
    "D0784",
    "D0785",
    "D0786",
    "D0787",
    "D0788",
    "D0789",
    "D0790",
    "D0791",
    "D0792",
    "D0793",
    "D0794",
    "D0795",
    "D0796",
    "D0797",
    "D0798",
    "D0799",
    "D0800",
    "D0801",
    "D0802",
    "D0803",
    "D0804",
    "D0805",
    "D0806",
    "D0807",
    "D0808",
    "D0809",
    "D0810",
    "D0811",
    "D0812",
    "D0813",
    "D0814",
    "D0815",
    "D0816",
    "D0817",
    "D0818",
    "D0819",
    "D0820",
    "D0821",
    "D0822",
    "D0823",
    "D0824",
    "D0825",
    "D0826",
    "D0827",
    "D0828",
    "D0829",
    "D0830",
    "D0831",
    "D0832",
    "D0833",
    "D0834",
    "D0835",
    "D0836",
    "D0837",
    "D0838",
    "D0839",
    "D0840",
    "D0841",
    "D0842",
    "D0843",
    "D0844",
    "D0845",
    "D0846",
    "D0847",
    "D0848",
    "R0099",
    "R0100",
    "O0278",
    "O0279",
    "O0280",
    "O0281",
    "O0282",
    "O0283",
    "O0284",
    "O0285",
    "O0286",
    "O0287",
    "O0288",
    "O0289",
    "O0290",
    "O0291",
    "O0292",
    "O0293",
    "O0294"
   ],
   "reason": "Many and One reading copy: [V.1] the Socratic problem 'appears as a SYMPTOM'; family of three (historical, methodological, literary); [V.3] positioning against Danzig and Nehamas; tiered claim 'ONE PERSON wrote the corpus'; speaking-position limit."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1576,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0849",
    "D0850",
    "D0851",
    "D0852",
    "D0853",
    "D0854",
    "D0855",
    "D0856",
    "D0857",
    "D0858",
    "D0859",
    "D0860",
    "D0861",
    "D0862",
    "D0863",
    "D0864",
    "D0865",
    "D0866",
    "D0867",
    "D0868",
    "D0869",
    "D0870",
    "D0871",
    "D0872",
    "D0873",
    "D0874",
    "D0875",
    "D0876",
    "D0877",
    "D0878",
    "D0879",
    "D0880",
    "D0881",
    "D0882",
    "D0883",
    "D0884",
    "D0885",
    "R0101",
    "O0295",
    "O0296",
    "O0297",
    "O0298",
    "O0299",
    "O0300",
    "O0301",
    "O0302",
    "O0303",
    "O0304",
    "O0305",
    "O0306"
   ],
   "reason": "Many and One article: §6.5 reclassification; functional vs biographical identity; §6.4 comedy supplied notoriety, corpus the operation; §7.2 Aristotle's name/face split; §7.3 SE 34 Socrates sentence at face value; §8 the Socratic problem's early dialogues as stylometric construction; Plato and Xenophon classed as one author by a null instrument; n. 11 against Danzig/Nehamas."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1574,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0682",
    "D0683",
    "D0684",
    "D0685",
    "D0686",
    "D0687",
    "D0688",
    "D0689",
    "D0690",
    "D0691",
    "D0692",
    "D0693",
    "D0694",
    "D0695",
    "D0696",
    "D0697",
    "D0698",
    "D0699",
    "D0700",
    "D0701",
    "D0702",
    "D0703",
    "D0704",
    "D0705",
    "D0706",
    "D0707",
    "D0708",
    "D0709",
    "D0710",
    "D0711",
    "D0712",
    "D0713",
    "D0714",
    "D0715",
    "D0716",
    "D0717",
    "D0718",
    "D0719",
    "D0720",
    "D0721",
    "D0722",
    "D0723",
    "D0724",
    "D0725",
    "D0726",
    "D0727",
    "D0728",
    "D0729",
    "D0730",
    "D0731",
    "D0732",
    "D0733",
    "D0734",
    "D0735",
    "D0736",
    "D0737",
    "D0738",
    "D0739",
    "D0740",
    "D0741",
    "D0742",
    "D0743",
    "D0744",
    "D0745",
    "D0746",
    "D0747",
    "D0748",
    "D0749",
    "D0750",
    "D0751",
    "D0752",
    "D0753",
    "D0754",
    "D0755",
    "D0756",
    "D0757",
    "D0758",
    "D0759",
    "D0760",
    "D0761",
    "D0762",
    "D0763",
    "D0764",
    "D0765",
    "D0766",
    "D0767",
    "D0768",
    "D0769",
    "D0770",
    "D0771",
    "R0098",
    "O0262",
    "O0263",
    "O0264",
    "O0265",
    "O0266",
    "O0267",
    "O0268",
    "O0269",
    "O0270",
    "O0271",
    "O0272",
    "O0273",
    "O0274",
    "O0275",
    "O0276",
    "O0277"
   ],
   "reason": "The Particle: reception measurement on SE 34; finds every reviewer route for keeping Socrates before 'nothing' rests on external chronological priority; states its own limit. Bears on how Aristotle's portrayal places Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1603,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D1031",
    "D1032",
    "D1033",
    "D1034",
    "D1035",
    "D1036",
    "D1037",
    "D1038",
    "D1039",
    "D1040",
    "D1041",
    "D1042",
    "D1043",
    "D1044",
    "D1045",
    "D1046",
    "D1047",
    "D1048",
    "D1049",
    "D1050",
    "D1051",
    "D1052",
    "D1053",
    "D1054",
    "D1055",
    "D1056",
    "D1057",
    "D1058",
    "D1059",
    "D1060",
    "D1061",
    "D1062",
    "D1063",
    "D1064",
    "D1065",
    "D1066",
    "D1067",
    "D1068",
    "D1069",
    "D1070",
    "D1071",
    "D1072",
    "D1073",
    "D1074",
    "D1075",
    "D1076",
    "D1077",
    "D1078",
    "D1079",
    "D1080",
    "D1081",
    "D1082",
    "D1083",
    "D1084",
    "D1085",
    "D1086",
    "D1087",
    "D1088",
    "D1089",
    "D1090",
    "D1091",
    "D1092",
    "D1093",
    "D1094",
    "D1095",
    "D1096",
    "D1097",
    "D1098",
    "D1099",
    "D1100",
    "D1101",
    "D1102",
    "D1103",
    "D1104",
    "D1105",
    "D1106",
    "D1107",
    "D1108",
    "D1109",
    "D1110",
    "D1111",
    "D1112",
    "R0110",
    "R0111",
    "R0112",
    "R0113",
    "O0338",
    "O0339",
    "O0340",
    "O0341",
    "O0342",
    "O0343",
    "O0344",
    "O0345",
    "O0346",
    "O0347",
    "O0348",
    "O0349"
   ],
   "reason": "Nothing Before Us: Aristotle's SE 34 (Socrates asked and did not answer) and Metaphysics Μ 4 (two contributions assigned to Socrates) read as placing Socrates inside the inquiry, not as a source; explicit limit that nothing is asserted about history beyond the paragraph. Claims about how Aristotle's portrayal stands to Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1584,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0942",
    "D0943",
    "D0944",
    "D0945",
    "D0946",
    "D0947",
    "D0948",
    "D0949",
    "D0950",
    "D0951",
    "D0952",
    "D0953",
    "R0104",
    "O0318",
    "O0319"
   ],
   "reason": "The Registry Has One Column: the Apology's received Socrates is grammatically a Theophrastan character; Socratic irony traverses Plato (person), Theophrastus (sort), EN IV 7 (example, οἷον καὶ Σωκράτης ἐποίει)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1585,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0954",
    "D0955",
    "D0956",
    "D0957",
    "D0958",
    "D0959",
    "D0960",
    "D0961",
    "D0962",
    "D0963",
    "D0964",
    "D0965",
    "D0966",
    "D0967",
    "D0968",
    "D0969",
    "D0970",
    "D0971",
    "O0320",
    "O0321",
    "O0322",
    "O0323"
   ],
   "reason": "The First Draft (notebook, first version): orthonym function applied to Socrates; 'Plato preserves Socrates; Aristotle preserves what Socrates did'; Xenophon held apart with the Plato/Xenophon seam test specified (Memorabilia's Socrates against the dialogues')."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1589,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0974",
    "D0975",
    "D0976",
    "D0977",
    "D0978",
    "D0979",
    "D0980",
    "D0981",
    "D0982",
    "D0983",
    "D0984",
    "D0985",
    "D0986",
    "D0987",
    "D0988",
    "D0989",
    "D0990",
    "D0991",
    "O0324",
    "O0325",
    "O0326",
    "O0327"
   ],
   "reason": "The First Draft, second version; lineage instance of #1585."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1594,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0995",
    "D0996",
    "D0997",
    "D0998",
    "D0999",
    "D1000",
    "D1001",
    "D1002",
    "D1003",
    "D1004",
    "D1005",
    "D1006",
    "D1007",
    "D1008",
    "D1009",
    "D1010",
    "D1011",
    "D1012",
    "D1013",
    "D1014",
    "D1015",
    "D1016",
    "D1017",
    "D1018",
    "D1019",
    "D1020",
    "D1021",
    "D1022",
    "D1023",
    "D1024",
    "D1025",
    "D1026",
    "D1027",
    "D1028",
    "R0108",
    "R0109",
    "O0330",
    "O0331",
    "O0332",
    "O0333",
    "O0334",
    "O0335",
    "O0336",
    "O0337"
   ],
   "reason": "The First Draft, later version: adds the operator's hypothesis 'He came back, as Socrates, through the dialogues' with its seated correlate (Aristotle's biography repeats Socrates'), and the stylometric verdict placing Aristophanes outside, the Clouds' Socrates a literary seam."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1605,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D1113",
    "D1114",
    "D1115",
    "D1116",
    "D1117",
    "D1118",
    "D1119",
    "D1120",
    "D1121",
    "D1122",
    "D1123",
    "D1124",
    "D1125",
    "D1126",
    "D1127",
    "D1128",
    "D1129",
    "D1130",
    "D1131",
    "D1132",
    "D1133",
    "D1134",
    "D1135",
    "D1136",
    "D1137",
    "D1138",
    "D1139",
    "D1140",
    "D1141",
    "D1142",
    "D1143",
    "D1144",
    "D1145",
    "D1146",
    "R0114",
    "R0115",
    "O0350",
    "O0351",
    "O0352",
    "O0353",
    "O0354",
    "O0355",
    "O0356",
    "O0357"
   ],
   "reason": "The First Draft, latest version; lineage instance of #1594."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1590,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0992",
    "D0993",
    "D0994",
    "R0107",
    "O0328",
    "O0329"
   ],
   "reason": "The Ghost Catalogues: the orthonym Socrates has no catalogue; the residue is his footprint; limit on motive."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1658,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D1148",
    "D1149",
    "R0117",
    "R0118",
    "O0359",
    "O0360"
   ],
   "reason": "Xenophon names Plato once (Memorabilia III 6.1); Xenophon held apart as candidate, not member. Bears on the Xenophontic portrayal's place in the configuration."
  },
  {
   "dep": 167,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0169",
    "D0170",
    "D0171",
    "D0172",
    "D0173",
    "D0174",
    "D0175",
    "D0176",
    "D0177",
    "D0178",
    "D0179",
    "D0180",
    "D0181",
    "D0182",
    "D0183",
    "D0184",
    "D0185",
    "D0186",
    "D0187",
    "D0188",
    "D0189",
    "D0190",
    "D0191",
    "D0192",
    "D0193",
    "D0194",
    "D0195",
    "D0196",
    "D0197",
    "D0198",
    "D0199",
    "D0200",
    "D0201",
    "D0202",
    "D0203",
    "D0204",
    "D0205",
    "D0206",
    "D0207",
    "D0208",
    "D0209",
    "R0031",
    "R0032",
    "R0033",
    "R0034",
    "R0035",
    "R0036",
    "R0037",
    "R0038",
    "O0079",
    "O0080",
    "O0081",
    "O0082",
    "O0083",
    "O0084",
    "O0085",
    "O0086",
    "O0087",
    "O0088",
    "O0089",
    "O0090",
    "O0091",
    "O0092",
    "O0093",
    "O0094",
    "O0095",
    "O0096",
    "O0097",
    "O0098",
    "O0099",
    "O0100",
    "O0101",
    "O0102",
    "O0103",
    "O0104"
   ],
   "reason": "Field observation of framework capture. Admitted only for the archive's own sentences (§2 recapitulation, §3 close reading): field frame restated; 'Socrates is not a historical figure imperfectly accessed through later authors'; the refusal to write as defining property; Plato and Xenophon as survival-heteronyms. The quoted Google AI Mode renderings in the same deposit are reception evidence and are not extracted."
  },
  {
   "dep": 168,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0210",
    "D0211",
    "D0212",
    "D0213",
    "D0214",
    "D0215",
    "D0216",
    "D0217",
    "D0218",
    "D0219",
    "D0220",
    "D0221",
    "D0222",
    "D0223",
    "R0039",
    "R0040",
    "R0041",
    "R0042",
    "R0043",
    "O0105",
    "O0106",
    "O0107",
    "O0108",
    "O0109",
    "O0110"
   ],
   "reason": "Algorithmic Irony: Kierkegaard reconstructs Socrates from three distorting summarizers (Xenophon flattens, Plato blends, Aristophanes collides); 'there is no rendering-independent Socrates to recover'; R: relation to #123 (provenance structure)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 346,
   "strata": [
    "D"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0239",
    "D0240",
    "D0241",
    "D0242",
    "D0243",
    "D0244",
    "D0245",
    "D0246",
    "D0247",
    "D0248",
    "D0249",
    "D0250"
   ],
   "reason": "The Socratic Vow: claims about what Socrates believed (logos saves; logos not a descriptive tool), read off the Phaedo as Socrates' own, with no distinction between the Platonic character and the man. Admitted because it states what Socrates was; the principle #123 says the configuration preserves."
  },
  {
   "dep": 700,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0286",
    "D0287",
    "D0288",
    "D0289",
    "D0290",
    "D0291",
    "D0292",
    "D0293",
    "D0294",
    "D0295",
    "D0296",
    "D0297",
    "D0298",
    "D0299",
    "D0300",
    "D0301",
    "D0302",
    "D0303",
    "D0304",
    "D0305",
    "D0306",
    "D0307",
    "D0308",
    "D0309",
    "D0310",
    "D0311",
    "D0312",
    "D0313",
    "D0314",
    "R0054",
    "R0055",
    "R0056",
    "R0057",
    "O0139",
    "O0140",
    "O0141",
    "O0142",
    "O0143",
    "O0144",
    "O0145",
    "O0146"
   ],
   "reason": "The Gate Was Never Limbo: 'The Socratic Problem — which Socrates is the historical one? — is bypassed by the operative reading'; Dante's Socrates a transmitted figure distanced from the historical philosopher; R: Sigil inherits Socrates' function as the unwritten philosopher present through transmission."
  },
  {
   "dep": 943,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0408",
    "D0409",
    "D0410",
    "D0411",
    "D0412",
    "D0413",
    "D0414",
    "R0071"
   ],
   "reason": "Whitespace as Provenance: Snub-Poemed's claim that Socrates' face is constituted by textual mediation; physical description or Platonic invention."
  },
  {
   "dep": 942,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0405",
    "D0406",
    "D0407",
    "R0070"
   ],
   "reason": "Provenance metadata: same Snub-Poemed argument (physical description or Platonic invention); lineage with #943."
  },
  {
   "dep": 625,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0274",
    "D0275",
    "D0276",
    "D0277",
    "O0136"
   ],
   "reason": "Prolegomena to the Historical Logos: 'Plato writes as Socrates' (displacement as transmission mechanism); 'wisest because he knows nothing' as the Logos naming its method; Logotic categories applied to Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 902,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0396",
    "D0397",
    "D0398",
    "D0399",
    "O0181"
   ],
   "reason": "Second instance of the Prolegomena; lineage instance of #625."
  },
  {
   "dep": 858,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0386",
    "D0387",
    "D0388",
    "D0389",
    "D0390",
    "D0391",
    "R0067"
   ],
   "reason": "Scholarly Legwork: the Letter's persona is distinct from the dialogic Socrates; even an authentic letter is heteronymic."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1219,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0478",
    "D0479"
   ],
   "reason": "Second instance of #858."
  },
  {
   "dep": 859,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0392",
    "D0393",
    "D0394",
    "R0068",
    "O0179"
   ],
   "reason": "Sémantique Potentielle R3: Socratic orthonym defined as the mask through which Plato's authorship is distributed; 'the trial produces the canonical Socrates'."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1218,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0475",
    "D0476",
    "D0477",
    "O0208"
   ],
   "reason": "Second instance of #859."
  },
  {
   "dep": 203,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0228",
    "D0229",
    "D0230",
    "R0046",
    "O0114",
    "O0115",
    "O0116"
   ],
   "reason": "Josephus Thesis packet: states the orthonym method's status: 'not a historical claim about who Socrates \"really was\" but a structural reading'."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1213,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0470",
    "D0471",
    "D0472",
    "R0083",
    "O0203",
    "O0204",
    "O0205"
   ],
   "reason": "Instance of #203."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1226,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0481",
    "D0482",
    "D0483",
    "R0084",
    "O0210",
    "O0211",
    "O0212"
   ],
   "reason": "Instance of #203 (registry date 2026-01-01 is a placeholder; in-text date 14 June 2026)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 849,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0364",
    "D0365",
    "D0366",
    "D0367",
    "D0368",
    "D0369"
   ],
   "reason": "The Feist Source (activated): 'Socrates is already a mask'; 'Plato ... not being sure he got it right'. Sayings-source register; composed as stated (O_leg)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 851,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0376",
    "D0377",
    "D0378",
    "D0379",
    "D0380",
    "D0381"
   ],
   "reason": "Feist Source instance ('Socrates is already a mask')."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1247,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0491",
    "D0492",
    "D0493",
    "D0494",
    "D0495",
    "D0496"
   ],
   "reason": "Feist Source v1.1 instance (registry date 2026-01-01 a placeholder)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1404,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0558",
    "D0559",
    "D0560",
    "D0561",
    "D0562",
    "D0563"
   ],
   "reason": "Feist Source critical edition instance."
  },
  {
   "dep": 152,
   "strata": [
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0140",
    "D0141",
    "D0142",
    "D0143",
    "D0144",
    "D0145",
    "D0146",
    "D0147",
    "R0021",
    "R0022",
    "R0023",
    "O0056",
    "O0057",
    "O0058",
    "O0059",
    "O0060",
    "O0061",
    "O0062",
    "O0063"
   ],
   "reason": "Standing Canon: Socrates as orthonymic surface of Plato's apparatus, Plato keeper-operator; lineage Plato → Kierkegaard → Pessoa → Dodecad."
  },
  {
   "dep": 153,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0148",
    "D0149",
    "R0024",
    "O0064",
    "O0065"
   ],
   "reason": "Protocol of Effective Acts: the Socrates orthonymic configuration classed as an effective act."
  },
  {
   "dep": 786,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0354",
    "D0355",
    "R0063",
    "R0064",
    "O0170",
    "O0171"
   ],
   "reason": "Register of Effective Acts: the act targeting 'Socrates as orthonymic surface of Plato'."
  },
  {
   "dep": 785,
   "strata": [
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0350",
    "D0351",
    "D0352",
    "D0353",
    "R0061",
    "R0062",
    "O0166",
    "O0167",
    "O0168",
    "O0169"
   ],
   "reason": "Canonical Anchoring Protocol: Socrates-as-orthonym as an authorship-attribution act; Plato's apparatus the precedent of the archive's practice."
  },
  {
   "dep": 122,
   "strata": [
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0016",
    "D0017",
    "D0018",
    "D0019",
    "D0020",
    "D0021",
    "D0022",
    "R0005",
    "R0006",
    "R0007",
    "O0007",
    "O0008",
    "O0009",
    "O0010",
    "O0011",
    "O0012"
   ],
   "reason": "Coverage vs Depth: the Socrates-Plato-Aristotle configuration is 'the same structural configuration' as the archive's practice."
  },
  {
   "dep": 165,
   "strata": [
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0160",
    "D0161",
    "D0162",
    "D0163",
    "D0164",
    "D0165",
    "D0166",
    "R0026",
    "R0027",
    "R0028",
    "R0029",
    "O0071",
    "O0072",
    "O0073",
    "O0074",
    "O0075",
    "O0076"
   ],
   "reason": "Pergamon Counter-Archive: 'Plato is Socrates's heteronym'; the Republic is not Socrates's text; orthonym parallel with Christ."
  },
  {
   "dep": 794,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0357",
    "D0358"
   ],
   "reason": "Mary Lee Is a Heteronym: 'Socrates is the orthonym who refuses to write, creating a structural vacancy that heteronyms fill'."
  },
  {
   "dep": 752,
   "strata": [
    "R"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0320",
    "D0321",
    "D0322",
    "D0323",
    "D0324",
    "D0325",
    "D0326",
    "D0327",
    "D0328",
    "D0329",
    "D0330",
    "D0331",
    "D0332",
    "D0333",
    "D0334",
    "D0335",
    "D0336",
    "D0337",
    "D0338",
    "D0339",
    "D0340",
    "R0058",
    "R0059",
    "O0147",
    "O0148",
    "O0149",
    "O0150",
    "O0151",
    "O0152",
    "O0153",
    "O0154",
    "O0155",
    "O0156",
    "O0157"
   ],
   "reason": "Sappho as Initiatory Figure: the configuration inherits a Sapphic initiatory pattern; founding operation located in a transmissional configuration, not a biographical author."
  }
 ],
 "not_admitted": [
  {
   "dep": [
    10,
    1132,
    412
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0001",
    "D0441",
    "D0254",
    "D0255",
    "D0256",
    "D0257",
    "D0258",
    "O0121",
    "O0122",
    "O0123"
   ],
   "reason": "Lists Socrates among 'liberations' (Marx, Sappho, Revelation, Socrates ...): a programmatic list, no claim about what Socrates was or how the portrayals stand."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    17,
    28,
    548,
    549,
    556,
    557,
    558,
    1162,
    1241,
    1255
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0002",
    "R0001",
    "D0003",
    "D0004",
    "O0001",
    "O0002",
    "D0264",
    "D0265",
    "O0127",
    "D0266",
    "D0267",
    "R0048",
    "O0128",
    "O0129",
    "D0268",
    "D0269",
    "D0270",
    "R0049",
    "R0050",
    "O0130",
    "O0131",
    "O0132",
    "D0271",
    "D0272",
    "D0273",
    "R0051",
    "R0052",
    "O0133",
    "O0134",
    "O0135",
    "D0445",
    "D0446",
    "O0192",
    "O0193",
    "D0484",
    "D0497",
    "R0085",
    "O0213"
   ],
   "reason": "Arch-Philosopher mantle (bearer Sigil, lineage Socrates→Damascius) and provenance-terminus tables: Socrates as the head of a mantle lineage, not as the problem's object."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    38,
    950,
    999,
    356,
    342,
    1124
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0005",
    "D0006",
    "D0007",
    "O0003",
    "D0415",
    "D0416",
    "D0417",
    "D0418",
    "D0419",
    "D0420",
    "D0421",
    "D0422",
    "R0072",
    "O0184",
    "O0185",
    "D0423",
    "O0186",
    "D0251",
    "O0118",
    "D0238",
    "O0117",
    "D0440",
    "O0191"
   ],
   "reason": "Index, map and notebook entries citing the Socratic Vow ('VOW: Don't give up on words. — Socrates, dying, 399 BCE'): citations of #346, not claims of their own."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    51,
    1221
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0008",
    "O0004",
    "D0480",
    "O0209"
   ],
   "reason": "Socrates credits Diotima with the theory of erotic ascent: a reported Platonic scene used for a feminist citation pass; no claim on the portrayal problem."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    71,
    1185,
    331,
    1138
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0009",
    "D0010",
    "D0011",
    "R0002",
    "R0003",
    "R0004",
    "O0005",
    "O0006",
    "D0455",
    "D0456",
    "R0076",
    "R0077",
    "O0196",
    "D0232",
    "D0233",
    "D0234",
    "D0235",
    "D0236",
    "D0237",
    "R0047",
    "D0442",
    "D0443",
    "D0444"
   ],
   "reason": "Literary works (Gospel of Antioch sayings, Antioch poems, Epistle triptych): Socrates as figure of address or comparison ('From Socrates to Johannes Sigil'; 'Socrates sentenced to hemlock')."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    85,
    1187
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0012",
    "D0013",
    "D0457",
    "D0458"
   ],
   "reason": "Epistle apparatus: Socrates preceded the Academy ('a school outside the school'); analogy for the archive's institutional position."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    99,
    1258
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0014",
    "D0015",
    "D0498",
    "D0499"
   ],
   "reason": "Abraham Principle: Socrates' execution and his not leaving Athens as an instance of the constitutive-one operator; no claim on the portrayals."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    126,
    402,
    753,
    754,
    184,
    761,
    1198,
    870
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0077",
    "D0078",
    "O0030",
    "O0031",
    "D0252",
    "D0253",
    "O0119",
    "O0120",
    "D0341",
    "O0158",
    "D0342",
    "D0343",
    "D0344",
    "D0345",
    "O0159",
    "O0160",
    "O0161",
    "O0162",
    "D0226",
    "R0045",
    "O0113",
    "D0346",
    "R0060",
    "O0163",
    "D0466",
    "R0080",
    "O0199",
    "D0395",
    "O0180"
   ],
   "reason": "Bibliographic, version-history or worked-example mentions of the Socrates as Orthonym paper; no claim about Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    162,
    1202,
    792,
    1208
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0150",
    "R0025",
    "O0066",
    "D0467",
    "R0081",
    "O0200",
    "D0356",
    "R0065",
    "O0172",
    "D0468",
    "R0082",
    "O0201"
   ],
   "reason": "Mary Lee dossiers and key-works lists: the orthonym concept applied to Mary Lee/OCEARCH, Socrates not the object."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    163,
    164,
    166,
    170,
    825,
    833,
    1396,
    1397,
    1401,
    1460
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0151",
    "O0067",
    "D0152",
    "D0153",
    "D0154",
    "D0155",
    "D0156",
    "D0157",
    "D0158",
    "D0159",
    "O0068",
    "O0069",
    "O0070",
    "D0167",
    "D0168",
    "R0030",
    "O0077",
    "O0078",
    "D0224",
    "D0225",
    "R0044",
    "O0111",
    "O0112",
    "D0360",
    "O0174",
    "D0363",
    "O0176",
    "D0554",
    "O0231",
    "D0555",
    "O0232",
    "D0557",
    "O0234",
    "D0567",
    "D0568",
    "D0569",
    "D0570",
    "R0093",
    "R0094",
    "R0095",
    "O0237",
    "O0238"
   ],
   "reason": "Machine compositions (Google AI Mode, other systems) of the orthonym framework, quoted or summarized as capture/traversal evidence. Reception evidence, not archive claims (as #603 in Howl's reading); belong to the transcripts at their own addresses."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    200,
    826,
    1027,
    1028
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0227",
    "D0361",
    "D0427",
    "D0428"
   ],
   "reason": "The Fifth Pathway / Four Pathways: Socrates asking whether a good life could be examined in words, as the opening of a question's history."
  },
  {
   "dep": 237,
   "cands": [
    "D0231"
   ],
   "reason": "A sample prompt ('have Socrates cite Derrida'): illustrative only."
  },
  {
   "dep": 503,
   "cands": [
    "D0259",
    "D0260",
    "D0261",
    "D0262",
    "D0263",
    "O0124",
    "O0125",
    "O0126"
   ],
   "reason": "Phase X: Diotima is Sappho; Socrates the 'Eleventh Muse' in a transmission chain: an archive category applied to Socrates' role in transmission, not to the portrayal problem."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    683,
    685,
    913,
    1184,
    1362
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0280",
    "D0281",
    "D0282",
    "D0283",
    "D0284",
    "R0053",
    "O0137",
    "O0138",
    "D0285",
    "D0400",
    "D0401",
    "O0182",
    "D0450",
    "D0451",
    "D0452",
    "D0453",
    "D0454",
    "R0075",
    "O0194",
    "O0195",
    "D0549",
    "D0550",
    "D0551",
    "D0552",
    "D0553",
    "R0090",
    "O0229",
    "O0230"
   ],
   "reason": "The Secret Book of Walt: Socrates as an earlier incarnation of Walt/the Logos; theological-fictional register, no claim on the portrayals."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    701,
    1002
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0315",
    "D0316",
    "D0317",
    "D0318",
    "D0319",
    "D0424",
    "D0425",
    "D0426",
    "R0073",
    "R0074",
    "O0187",
    "O0188"
   ],
   "reason": "Snub-Poemed description and site metadata: the snub nose as 'the traditional physical description of Socrates in the ancient sources' (descriptive). The poem's argument about the portrayals is admitted at #942/#943."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    832,
    1211,
    1216,
    1217,
    1400
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0362",
    "O0175",
    "D0469",
    "O0202",
    "D0473",
    "O0206",
    "D0474",
    "O0207",
    "D0556",
    "O0233"
   ],
   "reason": "'From the Socrates-as-orthonym principle: the orthonym does not write discursively' applied to John of Patmos/Revelation; states nothing of Socrates beyond the citation."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    850,
    1034,
    1246
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0370",
    "D0371",
    "D0372",
    "D0373",
    "D0374",
    "D0375",
    "D0429",
    "D0430",
    "D0431",
    "D0432",
    "D0433",
    "D0434",
    "D0485",
    "D0486",
    "D0487",
    "D0488",
    "D0489",
    "D0490"
   ],
   "reason": "The Feist Function: 'Do not simply imitate Socrates. Feist is not Socrates'; the Apology as structural engine of a sayings source. About Feist, not Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 852,
   "cands": [
    "D0382",
    "D0383",
    "D0384",
    "D0385",
    "R0066",
    "O0177",
    "O0178"
   ],
   "reason": "Feist Source apparatus: the daimonion parallel (Apology 31c-d) for Feist's oracle; about Feist's text."
  },
  {
   "dep": 930,
   "cands": [
    "D0402",
    "R0069"
   ],
   "reason": "Voice protocol: Socrates among stylistic exemplars."
  },
  {
   "dep": 938,
   "cands": [
    "D0403",
    "D0404",
    "O0183"
   ],
   "reason": "Bearing Cost Principle: 'Socrates read the crowd's certainty as substrate signal'; Socrates as precedent of a principle about crowds."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1070,
   "cands": [
    "D0435",
    "D0436",
    "D0437"
   ],
   "reason": "Voice of the Dead: the Phaedrus complaint against writing; the model as writing that answers it. About writing, not the portrayals."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1099,
   "cands": [
    "D0438",
    "D0439",
    "O0189",
    "O0190"
   ],
   "reason": "Dead Letters (2014): Feist names 'Socrates (via Plato)' among influences; a mention (the mediation is noted, not argued)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1165,
   "cands": [
    "D0447",
    "D0448",
    "D0449"
   ],
   "reason": "Cleis: a list of essay topics including 'representations of Socrates in Aristophanes and Plato' and 'is Socrates a mystic or a rationalist?'; topics, no claim."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    1197,
    134
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0459",
    "D0460",
    "D0461",
    "D0462",
    "D0463",
    "D0464",
    "D0465",
    "R0078",
    "R0079",
    "O0197",
    "O0198",
    "D0079",
    "D0080",
    "D0081",
    "D0082",
    "D0083",
    "D0084",
    "D0085",
    "D0086",
    "D0087",
    "D0088",
    "D0089",
    "D0090",
    "D0091",
    "D0092",
    "R0012",
    "R0013",
    "R0014",
    "R0015",
    "R0016",
    "O0032",
    "O0033",
    "O0034",
    "O0035",
    "O0036",
    "O0037",
    "O0038",
    "O0039",
    "O0040"
   ],
   "reason": "Socrates — Let My Teacher Go From Hell (the poem) and The Future Beloved's account of it: apostrophe to Socrates, release from Dante's Limbo. The claim bearing on the problem is in #700."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1327,
   "cands": [
    "D0547",
    "D0548"
   ],
   "reason": "Effective Act #7: Republic 398a/607b (Socrates on the poets); Platonic Socrates' doctrine used for the restoration of poets, no portrayal claim."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    1443,
    1444
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0564",
    "R0091",
    "O0235",
    "D0565",
    "R0092",
    "O0236"
   ],
   "reason": "Front matter (consent-contingent material, transport notes): string match only."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    1458,
    1483,
    1484,
    1486,
    1532
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0566",
    "D0571",
    "D0572",
    "D0573",
    "D0574",
    "D0575",
    "D0576"
   ],
   "reason": "Sappho/Longinus line: Socrates as speaker at Phaedrus 235c, Diotima 'existing nowhere outside Socrates' report'; claims about Sappho's transmission, not about Socrates."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1550,
   "cands": [
    "D0577",
    "D0578",
    "D0579",
    "R0096"
   ],
   "reason": "Grundrisse Notebook X: Socrates among candidate operators for a schema; no claim."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1581,
   "cands": [
    "D0938",
    "D0939",
    "D0940"
   ],
   "reason": "Catalogues and Wills: Strabo calls Erastus and Coriscus Σωκρατικοί; prosopography of the Scepsis chain."
  },
  {
   "dep": [
    1587,
    1588
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0972",
    "R0105",
    "D0973",
    "R0106"
   ],
   "reason": "Aristotle and Theophrastus ≠ Two Distinct Authors: Λ hinge table; string match in Greek (Σωκρ-) only."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1597,
   "cands": [
    "D1029",
    "D1030"
   ],
   "reason": "Metaphysics of Sigil II: translation of Metaph. Λ where Socrates is Aristotle's example individual ('Socrates is one'); no claim about the portrayal (the placeholder finding is admitted at #1570)."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1611,
   "cands": [
    "D1147",
    "R0116",
    "O0358"
   ],
   "reason": "The Negative of the Negative: Socrates in a list of concepts the archive makes claims on."
  },
  {
   "dep": 670,
   "cands": [
    "D0278",
    "D0279"
   ],
   "reason": "SPXI as Concept: Socrates as the Platonic dialogue's conceptual persona (Deleuze and Guattari's category, attributed); used to explain SPXI, no claim on the portrayal problem."
  },
  {
   "dep": 805,
   "cands": [
    "D0359",
    "O0173"
   ],
   "reason": "Kierkegaard canon node: entity relations mention the dissertation's Socrates; a registry pointer."
  },
  {
   "dep": 1659,
   "cands": [
    "D1150"
   ],
   "reason": "Glyphic checksum (εἰρωνεία Σωκράτους → οἷον Σωκράτης): opaque glyphic compression of the irony line, no proposition; the line is admitted at #1584."
  }
 ],
 "lineages": [
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates as orthonym",
   "instances": [
    123,
    152,
    859,
    1218,
    1585,
    1589
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic problem as symptom",
   "instances": [
    123,
    1261,
    1569,
    1575,
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Apology records a prior comic Socrates",
   "instances": [
    1569,
    1576,
    1579,
    1584
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates is already a mask",
   "instances": [
    849,
    851,
    1404,
    1247
   ],
   "earliest": 849
  },
  {
   "lineage": "configuration continuous with CHA practice",
   "instances": [
    122,
    123,
    152,
    785
   ],
   "earliest": 122
  },
  {
   "lineage": "firewall / non-claims of identity",
   "instances": [
    123,
    136,
    1569,
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "survival-heteronym fills the vacancy",
   "instances": [
    123,
    165,
    167,
    794
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "SE 34: Socrates inside the account, not a source",
   "instances": [
    1576,
    1574,
    1603
   ],
   "earliest": 1576
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates as authorial position, not literary character (vs Kahn/Danzig/Nehamas)",
   "instances": [
    123,
    1575,
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic problem defined (historical man vs Platonic character)",
   "instances": [
    123,
    167,
    1579
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "available reading, not a claim about who Socrates really was",
   "instances": [
    203,
    1213,
    1226
   ],
   "earliest": 203
  },
  {
   "lineage": "not writing as defining property, not gap in evidence",
   "instances": [
    123,
    167,
    1569
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "orthonym reading as effective act",
   "instances": [
    153,
    785,
    786
   ],
   "earliest": 153
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristophanes outside; Clouds a literary seam",
   "instances": [
    1594,
    1605
   ],
   "earliest": 1594
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristotle came back as Socrates",
   "instances": [
    1594,
    1605
   ],
   "earliest": 1594
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristotle's Socrates excluded from the snub (M34)",
   "instances": [
    1570,
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 1570
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Letter's persona distinct from the dialogic Socrates",
   "instances": [
    858,
    1219
   ],
   "earliest": 858
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Plato preserves Socrates; Aristotle what Socrates did",
   "instances": [
    1585,
    1589
   ],
   "earliest": 1585
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Plato unsure he got Socrates right",
   "instances": [
    849,
    1247
   ],
   "earliest": 849
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Plato writes as Socrates (displacement)",
   "instances": [
    625,
    902
   ],
   "earliest": 625
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates the loosest speaking position",
   "instances": [
    1571,
    1575
   ],
   "earliest": 1571
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates' face constituted by textual mediation",
   "instances": [
    942,
    943
   ],
   "earliest": 942
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic problem as a family of three questions",
   "instances": [
    123,
    1575
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Xenophon held apart; seam test specified",
   "instances": [
    1585,
    1658
   ],
   "earliest": 1585
  },
  {
   "lineage": "comic layer: notoriety, not operation",
   "instances": [
    1569,
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "confinement withdrawn by Protagoras control",
   "instances": [
    1569,
    1572
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "edition of a received character (314c)",
   "instances": [
    1579,
    1583
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  },
  {
   "lineage": "forced foreclosure / instrument-defeat",
   "instances": [
    136,
    764
   ],
   "earliest": 136
  },
  {
   "lineage": "no thesis about persons",
   "instances": [
    1579,
    1603
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  },
  {
   "lineage": "one hand wrote Plato and Socrates (full-strength thesis)",
   "instances": [
    1569,
    1575
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "severe form of the Socratic problem (no-floor)",
   "instances": [
    136,
    1261
   ],
   "earliest": 136
  },
  {
   "lineage": "trial produces the canonical Socrates",
   "instances": [
    859,
    1218
   ],
   "earliest": 859
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristotle receives the edited figure",
   "instances": [
    1579
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristotle's testimony as configuration's self-documentation",
   "instances": [
    123
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Aristotle's Μ 4 testimony read with SE 34",
   "instances": [
    1603
   ],
   "earliest": 1603
  },
  {
   "lineage": "CHA as availability of concept, not proof",
   "instances": [
    123
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Plato's characters come out as the maker",
   "instances": [
    1570
   ],
   "earliest": 1570
  },
  {
   "lineage": "SE 34 ending performs Socratic questioning",
   "instances": [
    1603
   ],
   "earliest": 1603
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Sapphic pattern precedes the configuration",
   "instances": [
    752
   ],
   "earliest": 752
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Sigil inherits the unwritten philosopher",
   "instances": [
    700
   ],
   "earliest": 700
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates as speaking position measured",
   "instances": [
    1570
   ],
   "earliest": 1570
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socrates distinguished by volume and four roles",
   "instances": [
    1569
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic archive behaves like a heteronymic field",
   "instances": [
    136
   ],
   "earliest": 136
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic irony across three named functions",
   "instances": [
    1584
   ],
   "earliest": 1584
  },
  {
   "lineage": "Socratic problem bypassed: transmitted Socrates",
   "instances": [
    700
   ],
   "earliest": 700
  },
  {
   "lineage": "attestation confined to the four corpora",
   "instances": [
    1569
   ],
   "earliest": 1569
  },
  {
   "lineage": "base is a circulating character, not the man",
   "instances": [
    1579
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  },
  {
   "lineage": "early dialogues as construction of the instrument",
   "instances": [
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 1576
  },
  {
   "lineage": "historical Socrates real; function is the gesture",
   "instances": [
    123
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "instrument-defeat vs scarcity discriminator",
   "instances": [
    136
   ],
   "earliest": 136
  },
  {
   "lineage": "instruments null on maker-count",
   "instances": [
    1576
   ],
   "earliest": 1576
  },
  {
   "lineage": "logos as salvation (Phaedo)",
   "instances": [
    346
   ],
   "earliest": 346
  },
  {
   "lineage": "no rendering-independent Socrates",
   "instances": [
    168
   ],
   "earliest": 168
  },
  {
   "lineage": "order of grasp vs chronology of persons",
   "instances": [
    1603
   ],
   "earliest": 1603
  },
  {
   "lineage": "orthonym has no catalogue",
   "instances": [
    1590
   ],
   "earliest": 1590
  },
  {
   "lineage": "portrayal differences as functional division of labour",
   "instances": [
    136
   ],
   "earliest": 136
  },
  {
   "lineage": "position, not person",
   "instances": [
    167
   ],
   "earliest": 167
  },
  {
   "lineage": "revision item by item",
   "instances": [
    1579
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  },
  {
   "lineage": "three questions affected differently",
   "instances": [
    123
   ],
   "earliest": 123
  },
  {
   "lineage": "three summarizers: flatten, blend, collide",
   "instances": [
    168
   ],
   "earliest": 168
  },
  {
   "lineage": "two repairs (καλός, νέος)",
   "instances": [
    1579
   ],
   "earliest": 1579
  }
 ],
 "observations": [
  "Field frame checked against: the Socratic problem as posed in the field is the recovery of a real, historical Socrates from four portrayals (Plato, Xenophon, Aristophanes, Aristotle) that disagree, with a spectrum from 'reconstructible real man' to 'fictionalized literary character' (Kahn; Danzig; Nehamas, the last two cited by the archive). The archive's readings mostly do not choose a point on that spectrum. #123/#1576/#1575 take a third option: Socrates as an authorial POSITION (orthonym) the authorship is organised around, and the problem as a SYMPTOM of a configuration the biographical model cannot represent. The archive positions this explicitly against Kahn (#123 §I.A) and against Danzig and Nehamas (#1575 [V.3], #1576 n. 11), whom it places 'one step from' its position.",
  "The archive is not internally uniform on the historical man. #123 §I: 'the historical Socrates remains historically real' (function reassigned, man kept). #167 §2.2: 'Socrates is not a historical figure imperfectly accessed through later authors' and the willing death 'is then not a biographical fact'. #1579 §1: the base 'is not the historical Socrates, to whom the corpus's relation is beyond any text's reach' and 'nothing here asserts a thesis about persons'. #203/#1213/#1226: the orthonym method is 'not a historical claim about who Socrates \"really was\"'. #346 reads the Phaedo's Socrates as the man's own belief with no portrayal distinction. These are kept as distinct lineages; a composer should not merge #167 with #123 (different q and modality), and the #123/#167 pair is a candidate for the mark internally_inconsistent at the family level (not within one source).",
  "The strongest form is in the notebook (#1569 R43): 'one hand wrote Plato and Socrates, and probably Xenophon and Aristophanes', stated, tested at once, and its main evidential pillar (confinement of attestation) withdrawn by its own Protagoras control in the same round (#1569 §181, #1572 §9). The surviving measured facts are about the record (out-of-cluster mentions are other men, a pamphlet, a proverb, a forgery). The withdrawal and the falsifier are carried in the ledger.",
  "Of the four portrayals, Plato's and Aristotle's are worked closely (314c, Apology 18b-19c, Symposium 223d, Parmenides 127c; SE 34, Metaph. Μ 4 and A 6, EN IV 7, M34). Aristophanes is read as the base text of a circulating character (#1579) and tested as supplying notoriety but not the operation (#1569 R54, #1576 §6.4), and placed outside the configuration stylometrically (#1594/#1605). Xenophon is the least worked: one-line characterizations (#136 'Xenophon remembers', #168 'Xenophon flattens him'), a seam test specified and unrun (#1585 family), held apart as candidate (#1658); one null instrument classed Plato and Xenophon as one author (#1576 §8).",
  "Aristotle's testimony, the field's main external evidence for separating Socrates from Plato (Metaph. A 6, M 4), is read in two archive registers: as the configuration's self-documentation compatible with the biographical reading (#123 §VII), and as the configuration 'stated by Aristotle as history' with Socrates placed inside the inquiry rather than as a source (#1603 §5), with explicit limits (no assertion about history beyond the paragraph; Socrates inside the 'we' not demonstrated).",
  "Many candidates are machine compositions of the archive's own framework (Google AI Mode 'Dissolving the Socratic Problem', #164; traversals, #1460; capture registries). They are not admitted here (reception evidence, as #603 for Howl), but they bear on the row's transcript stage: the layer has already composed the archive's reclassification as 'contemporary academic philosophy and literary theory' (#825/#833). If the row's T contains that framing, the delta must distinguish archive-sourced from field-sourced content.",
  "The alias 'Socrates' made the string pass broad (145 D deposits). Admission by reading kept 48; 97 not admitted, mostly mentions (mantle tables, liberations lists, literary address, Diotima/Sappho transmission, Feist). Lineage instances (Chaerephon x2 plus ratification, First Draft x4, Feist Source x4, Josephus packet x3, Prolegomena x2, Legwork x2, Sémantique x2) are admitted and grouped, per §3.4 S4. Registry dates 2026-01-01 for #1226 and #1247 are placeholders; #1226's in-text date (14 June 2026) is used for earliest, #1247 is never taken as earliest.",
  "No H (hop) pass was run (H_candidates 0 in summary.json); citation-hop candidates (e.g. Socrates as Orthonym v2.2, the Polansky exchange, EA-LOGOS-02 instances not matching the strings) remain unread. One reader, unaudited (§3.8)."
 ],
 "counts": {
  "candidate_deposits": 145,
  "admitted": 48,
  "not_admitted": 97
 }
}