{ "row": "se-183b34", "pass": "first reading, 2026-10-20", "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.9 §3.4 D/R/O with the hop (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: a candidate is admitted when its sentence or paragraph makes a claim bearing on the passage SE 183b34–184b8 — what it says, its words, its domain, its place in the treatise, its reception. Naming the passage is not enough. The archive's wider concerns (the Capture Registry, model collapse, the World Soul) are admitted only where a defining paper ties them to the passage (operator, 2026-10-20 13:08/13:14 EDT). Machine compositions quoted in deposits are reception evidence, carried as attributed. Volume is never a ground of removal; instances of one work are grouped as a lineage and kept (S4).", "reader": "Claude (subagent), 2026-10-20", "candidate_files": { "candidates-D.jsonl": "7dee847a112e51fc7d66a67f496f30e66b613b9d617c6daf001ae7d86c283a99", "candidates-R.jsonl": "9cda67f0a80714c1a03e483b0a908742feb5e122fbe34fa45a9d818f7b2541f5", "candidates-O.jsonl": "f1c72072f3eeb612e49ee594251a74e4e98c81e13722e37335b1bdc604ddec5a", "candidates-H.jsonl": "3e8b0d0e606c9476ed8169ffa9e57a7aad2157e7aa8d6616d1534d8083f0aec5", "summary.json": "5113bcf4caa3b29ecad6b2664a4e77acbe472f195a470b8bc97b6b1bab4ccbdd" }, "verdicts": [ { "dep": 1574, "strata": [ "D", "O", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0010", "D0011", "D0012", "D0013", "D0014", "D0015", "D0016", "D0017", "D0018", "D0019", "D0020", "D0021", "D0022", "D0023", "D0024", "D0025", "D0026", "D0027", "D0028", "D0029", "D0030", "D0031", "D0032", "D0033", "D0034", "D0035", "D0036", "D0037", "D0038", "D0039", "D0040", "D0041", "D0042", "D0043", "D0044", "D0045", "D0046", "D0047", "D0048", "D0049", "D0050", "D0051", "D0052", "D0053", "D0054", "D0055", "D0056", "D0057", "D0058", "D0059", "D0060", "D0061", "D0062", "D0063", "D0064", "D0065", "D0066", "D0067", "D0068", "D0069", "D0070", "D0071", "D0072", "D0073", "D0074", "D0075", "D0076", "D0077", "D0078", "D0079", "D0080", "D0081", "D0082", "D0083", "D0084", "D0085", "D0086", "D0087", "D0088", "D0089", "D0090", "D0091", "D0092", "D0093", "D0094", "D0095", "D0096", "D0097", "D0098", "D0099", "D0100", "D0101", "D0102", "D0103", "D0104", "D0105", "D0106", "D0107", "D0108", "D0109", "D0110", "D0111", "D0112", "D0113", "D0114", "D0115", "D0116", "D0117", "D0118", "D0119", "D0120", "D0121", "D0122", "D0123", "D0124", "D0125", "D0126", "D0127", "D0128", "D0129", "D0130", "D0131", "D0132", "D0133", "D0134", "D0135", "D0136", "D0137", "D0138", "D0139", "D0140", "D0141", "D0142", "D0143", "D0144", "D0145", "D0146", "D0147", "D0148", "D0149", "D0150", "D0151", "D0152", "D0153", "D0154", "D0155", "D0156", "D0157", "D0158", "D0159", "D0160", "D0161", "D0162", "D0163", "D0164", "D0165", "D0166", "D0167", "D0168", "D0169", "D0170", "D0171", "D0172", "R0001", "R0002", "R0003", "R0004", "R0005", "R0006", "O0001", "O0002", "O0003", "O0004", "O0005", "O0006", "O0007", "O0008", "O0009", "O0010", "O0011", "O0012", "O0013", "O0014", "O0015", "O0016", "O0017" ], "reason": "The Particle — a defining paper, read whole. D: seats 183b34–36 and 184b1–2 in Greek with the author's translations (Appendix A1 §§1–2), the syntax of the denial, the we, the teachers, the envoi; CLAUSE v0.2 (the clause delimits, the quantifier exhausts); the four placements of Socrates (v1.4); the apparatus of the received readings as conjectural emendations; the twenty-report register of qualifiers (B5); the measurement (§3: the invariant is the deletion of οὐ). O: the archive's categories applied to the sentence itself — provenance erasure (§5), disciplinary model collapse (§7, defined on the author's definition at this sentence), the world soul as degraded commodity (§8, marked theoretical extension). R: Socrates' place relative to the inquiry. REFLEX, DIVISION and v2.0 are exhibits (the reception's reading performed), carried as such." }, { "dep": 1603, "strata": [ "D", "O", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0234", "D0235", "D0236", "D0237", "D0238", "D0239", "D0240", "D0241", "D0242", "D0243", "D0244", "D0245", "D0246", "D0247", "D0248", "D0249", "D0250", "D0251", "D0252", "D0253", "D0254", "D0255", "D0256", "D0257", "D0258", "D0259", "D0260", "D0261", "D0262", "D0263", "D0264", "D0265", "D0266", "D0267", "D0268", "D0269", "D0270", "D0271", "D0272", "D0273", "D0274", "D0275", "D0276", "D0277", "D0278", "D0279", "D0280", "D0281", "D0282", "R0010", "R0011", "R0012", "R0013", "O0028", "O0029", "O0030", "O0031", "O0032", "O0033", "O0034" ], "reason": "Nothing Before Us — a defining paper, read whole. D: the last page read in order; the provenance axis (§3); πραγματεία individuated (§4); the fork and the middle position (§4); the case for inclusion, marked controversial (§5); the chapter as the treatise's final exercise (§6); the witnesses (§7, Appendix A: Arabic, Byzantine, Latin, English); the culmination as enactment (§9); the nine prohibitions and two joints (Appendix P); the literature by prohibition (Appendix L); the open collation of Ross. R: Socrates' place in the inquiry." }, { "dep": 1576, "strata": [ "D", "O", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0190", "D0191", "D0192", "D0193", "D0194", "D0195", "D0196", "D0197", "D0198", "D0199", "R0008", "O0021" ], "reason": "Many and One (as submitted) — defining sections read: §1, §2.1, §2.4, §6.5, §7.3, §9 whole, nn. 1, 5, 11, 14, 22. D: the epilogue read continuously; προεξειργασμένον as the received class; the five reconciliations; the order of grasp; the priority claim in its verb; the single-maker hypothesis at the sentence (§9.4) and its limits (§9.5–9.6)." }, { "dep": 1575, "strata": [ "D" ], "cands": [ "D0173", "D0174", "D0175", "D0176", "D0177", "D0178", "D0179", "D0180", "D0181", "D0182", "D0183", "D0184", "D0185", "D0186", "D0187", "D0188", "D0189", "R0007", "O0018", "O0019", "O0020" ], "reason": "Many and One, reading copy (one work with #1576; the earlier instance) — defining sections read: §I (The Division of God, ¶1–22), §IX.4–4b. D: the conventional reading at full strength (§I.3); the envoi as a claim of first finding; the socket; the two fillings, neither on the page; ὑπάρχω counted (1,182 in APr)." }, { "dep": 1569, "strata": [ "D" ], "cands": [ "D0001", "D0002", "D0003", "D0004", "D0005", "D0006" ], "reason": "The Notebook — candidate paragraphs read (S1; M40 re-read; round (f)). D: the literal reading and the discovery reading of οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν; earliest statements of lineages carried by #1575/#1576." }, { "dep": 1570, "strata": [ "D" ], "cands": [ "D0007", "D0008", "D0009" ], "reason": "The Measurement Register — §0A read (0A.1–0A.7). D: the archive's own revision — 'THE CONVENTIONAL READING IS MUCH STRONGER THAN THIS ENTRY PREVIOUSLY ALLOWED'; practice versus art as Aristotle's frame; three overstatements withdrawn; the restriction marked; the widening at περὶ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι left a philological question." }, { "dep": 1579, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0200" ], "reason": "Beautiful and New — n. 9 read: cites #1603 for the total denial and Socrates inside the inquiry; its Hayduck page reference is superseded in #1603 (marked)." }, { "dep": 1584, "strata": [ "R" ], "cands": [ "D0201", "D0202" ], "reason": "The Registry Has One Column — candidate paragraphs read: R, a relation between the epilogue's operation on Socrates and the Characters ('keep the deeds and drop the person'). Admitted at the one sentence that states what the epilogue does." }, { "dep": 1585, "strata": [ "D", "O", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0203", "D0204", "D0205", "D0206", "D0207", "D0208", "D0209", "O0022" ], "reason": "The First Draft (notebook; #1589, #1594, #1605 are later versions of the same work) — candidate paragraphs read. R/O: Aristotle files Socratic operations inside the ἀρχή of his art and keeps the art οὔπω; the epilogue's 'we' as the consolidating position and as an undertaking that sets tasks." }, { "dep": 1594, "strata": [ "D" ], "cands": [ "D0217", "D0218", "D0219", "D0220", "D0221", "D0222", "D0223", "D0224", "D0225", "D0226", "D0227", "D0228", "D0229", "D0230", "D0231", "D0232", "D0233", "R0009", "O0024", "O0025", "O0026", "O0027" ], "reason": "The First Draft, later version — admitted for what it adds to #1585: the record of a second reader's audit of the reading (Astra, 2026-09-07: what holds on the page; the ἄλλο correction), the earliest instance of the lineage #1603 Appendix P carries." }, { "dep": 1611, "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "cands": [ "D0301", "D0302", "D0303", "D0304", "D0305", "D0306", "D0307", "D0308", "D0309", "R0015", "R0016", "R0017", "O0040", "O0041", "O0042", "O0043", "O0044", "O0045", "O0046" ], "reason": "EA-NEGONT-01 (#1611) — candidate paragraphs read: D/O, the sentence as a swathe where the standing representation supplies an adjective and contradicts it (δ_W) and where the excluded representation makes the reception's reading a measurable erasure. Admitted where the paper speaks of the sentence; its wider model is not composed here." }, { "dep": 1684, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "cands": [ "D0311", "D0312", "D0313", "R0019", "R0020", "O0047", "O0048" ], "reason": "Prediction Index — candidate paragraphs read: D, a restatement of #1574/#1603 (one lineage with them) and the sources owed (Ross, Dorion)." }, { "dep": 1587, "strata": [ "D", "H" ], "cands": [ "H0777", "H0778" ], "reason": "Aristotle and Theophrastus ≠ Two Distinct Authors (v0.1; #1588 v0.2 the same sentence) — reached by the hop (H0777, H0778). D: the reflex at the sentence restated as a measured operation ('nothing becomes nothing systematic')." }, { "dep": 1590, "strata": [ "D", "R", "H" ], "cands": [ "H0781", "H0782" ], "reason": "The Ghost Catalogues — reached by the hop (H0781, H0782). D/R: the last page of the Elenchi performs the Socratic ask on its reader (one lineage with #1603 §9)." }, { "dep": 1582, "strata": [ "D", "H" ], "cands": [ "H0772" ], "reason": "The Stone for a List — reached by the hop (H0772). D: ἐξ ἀρχῆς (183b22, 184b3) named the epilogue's provenance phrase." } ], "not_admitted": [ { "dep": [ 1589, 1605 ], "cands": [ "D0210", "D0211", "D0212", "D0213", "D0214", "D0215", "D0216", "O0023", "D0283", "D0284", "D0285", "D0286", "D0287", "D0288", "D0289", "D0290", "D0291", "D0292", "D0293", "D0294", "D0295", "D0296", "D0297", "D0298", "D0299", "D0300", "R0014", "O0035", "O0036", "O0037", "O0038", "O0039" ], "reason": "S4 redundancy: later versions of The First Draft (#1585/#1594); every sentence that bears on the passage is the same sentence as in #1585 or #1594 (lineage instances kept in the provenance graph)." }, { "dep": [ 1682 ], "cands": [ "D0310", "R0018" ], "reason": "EA-CORPORA-18: 'a word that answers to nothing before it' (Kruchenykh's zaum); the string 'nothing before' only; no claim about the passage." }, { "dep": [ 1588 ], "cands": [ "H0779", "H0780" ], "reason": "S4 redundancy: v0.2 of #1587; the sentence admitted at #1587 recurs verbatim (instance of the lineage)." }, { "dep": [ 1664, 1665, 1671, 1690 ], "cands": [ "H0848", "H0849", "H0850", "H0851", "H0858", "H0859", "H0870" ], "reason": "S4 redundancy: the EA-NEGONT-02 specification's versions restate #1574 at model collapse ('οὐ deleted in 20 of 20 model reviews'; #1574's card 'the invariant is the deletion of οὐ'); one lineage with #1574 §3.3/§7, adding nothing." }, { "dep": [ 123 ], "cands": [ "H0092" ], "reason": "Socrates as Orthonym — reached by the hop (forward from #1684); read at its defining sections (Abstract, §0 Non-Claims, §I, §I.A, §III, §V). It names no part of SE 34 and makes no claim about the passage; its configuration (Socrates the orthonym, Aristotle the systematizing heteronym) bears on the passage only through #1575/#1576 (whose header names it the earlier line) and #1603 Appendix P's second joint, which withholds the maker question at this sentence. Not admitted, on the operator's ruling that the archive's wider concerns enter only where a defining paper ties them to the passage." }, { "dep": [ 1601, 1613 ], "cands": [ "H0790", "H0791", "H0801", "H0802" ], "reason": "Hop candidates naming #1574 or the Particle for its instrument (the provenance erasure rate; a composer conceding it had reperformed the Particle at an archive address): claims about the archive's reception, not about the passage." }, { "dep": [ 1572, 1580, 1586, 1593 ], "cands": [ "H0765", "H0766", "H0770", "H0775", "H0776", "H0783", "H0784" ], "reason": "Hop candidates naming the SE as a work (its object-space; the paraphrast's scan seated; a misidentified TLG file): no claim about ch. 34." }, { "dep": [ 432, 932, 934, 935, 950, 1460, 1556, 1687 ], "cands": [ "H0260", "H0544", "H0546", "H0547", "H0558", "H0699", "H0756", "H0869" ], "reason": "Hop candidates matched by the screen only on 'the particle' in other senses (a grammatical particle, a physical particle, particle-physics) or a hash substring ('184b0'): no claim about the passage." }, { "dep": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 12, 13, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 31, 32, 34, 35, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 49, 50, 51, 52, 54, 55, 57, 58, 61, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 76, 77, 78, 82, 83, 84, 85, 87, 89, 90, 91, 93, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 113, 114, 115, 120, 122, 124, 126, 127, 129, 130, 133, 135, 136, 137, 139, 140, 141, 142, 145, 146, 147, 149, 150, 153, 154, 156, 157, 158, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 182, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 204, 205, 206, 208, 209, 210, 211, 212, 213, 214, 217, 218, 219, 220, 222, 227, 228, 230, 232, 233, 235, 236, 238, 239, 241, 244, 245, 246, 247, 248, 250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 256, 259, 261, 262, 263, 264, 265, 266, 267, 269, 271, 278, 280, 281, 284, 285, 286, 288, 289, 290, 291, 297, 299, 300, 301, 302, 304, 305, 306, 307, 308, 311, 312, 313, 314, 316, 317, 319, 329, 331, 335, 336, 337, 338, 341, 342, 343, 344, 346, 347, 348, 352, 359, 360, 361, 362, 367, 382, 384, 390, 394, 397, 398, 399, 402, 403, 405, 406, 407, 410, 413, 414, 415, 416, 417, 422, 423, 426, 427, 433, 434, 435, 439, 444, 445, 447, 448, 449, 450, 453, 458, 461, 462, 464, 467, 469, 470, 471, 472, 473, 474, 476, 477, 478, 479, 481, 482, 483, 485, 488, 489, 492, 495, 496, 497, 498, 499, 500, 501, 502, 503, 506, 507, 508, 510, 511, 512, 513, 517, 518, 519, 520, 521, 522, 524, 528, 529, 530, 531, 533, 534, 535, 537, 538, 539, 541, 542, 543, 550, 551, 552, 553, 554, 556, 557, 558, 559, 560, 563, 564, 565, 567, 568, 571, 573, 574, 576, 577, 580, 582, 583, 584, 585, 593, 595, 596, 597, 598, 599, 600, 601, 602, 603, 604, 605, 608, 610, 611, 612, 613, 614, 615, 616, 617, 620, 621, 622, 623, 624, 625, 626, 631, 632, 636, 637, 639, 641, 642, 643, 644, 645, 646, 647, 649, 653, 654, 656, 660, 661, 662, 666, 667, 668, 669, 670, 671, 672, 673, 674, 676, 677, 678, 679, 680, 681, 683, 684, 687, 689, 691, 694, 695, 700, 709, 711, 713, 716, 722, 724, 725, 726, 727, 728, 729, 730, 731, 735, 736, 737, 738, 739, 740, 741, 742, 746, 747, 748, 751, 752, 753, 754, 755, 756, 763, 765, 766, 767, 768, 769, 770, 772, 779, 780, 781, 782, 783, 784, 785, 787, 788, 790, 791, 792, 793, 794, 795, 796, 800, 801, 802, 817, 819, 821, 824, 825, 828, 829, 830, 832, 833, 834, 835, 836, 837, 842, 843, 845, 847, 848, 849, 850, 852, 853, 854, 855, 856, 857, 858, 859, 860, 862, 863, 864, 868, 870, 875, 876, 879, 880, 881, 882, 883, 884, 887, 892, 897, 907, 908, 909, 910, 911, 914, 918, 920, 921, 923, 925, 926, 927, 928, 929, 931, 933, 938, 939, 940, 941, 942, 943, 944, 945, 946, 947, 960, 968, 973, 980, 982, 985, 991, 993, 1000, 1002, 1003, 1007, 1011, 1012, 1039, 1040, 1041, 1042, 1044, 1045, 1046, 1051, 1052, 1053, 1061, 1063, 1064, 1065, 1067, 1068, 1070, 1075, 1076, 1078, 1079, 1081, 1082, 1084, 1086, 1088, 1090, 1091, 1093, 1094, 1099, 1101, 1103, 1111, 1118, 1121, 1123, 1127, 1132, 1138, 1139, 1140, 1151, 1157, 1162, 1169, 1173, 1174, 1175, 1182, 1183, 1184, 1185, 1190, 1194, 1196, 1199, 1203, 1204, 1205, 1208, 1209, 1211, 1213, 1216, 1217, 1249, 1251, 1261, 1268, 1271, 1279, 1284, 1287, 1288, 1302, 1304, 1318, 1319, 1326, 1327, 1335, 1336, 1337, 1342, 1345, 1350, 1362, 1367, 1379, 1384, 1386, 1390, 1400, 1406, 1407, 1409, 1412, 1413, 1414, 1419, 1420, 1421, 1422, 1423, 1426, 1427, 1432, 1435, 1436, 1437, 1438, 1440, 1441, 1443, 1444, 1446, 1449, 1450, 1452, 1453, 1454, 1455, 1456, 1458, 1459, 1462, 1463, 1465, 1466, 1467, 1468, 1469, 1470, 1471, 1473, 1474, 1475, 1476, 1477, 1478, 1480, 1481, 1482, 1483, 1484, 1485, 1486, 1487, 1493, 1494, 1495, 1496, 1497, 1514, 1523, 1524, 1525, 1526, 1527, 1528, 1530, 1531, 1532, 1534, 1535, 1536, 1537, 1538, 1540, 1541, 1542, 1543, 1545, 1546, 1547, 1548, 1549, 1550, 1552, 1554, 1555, 1558, 1559, 1560, 1561, 1562, 1563, 1571, 1573, 1577, 1578, 1581, 1583, 1595, 1596, 1597, 1598, 1600, 1602, 1604, 1606, 1607, 1608, 1609, 1610, 1612, 1614, 1615, 1616, 1617, 1618, 1619, 1620, 1621, 1622, 1623, 1624, 1625, 1626, 1627, 1628, 1630, 1631, 1632, 1633, 1634, 1635, 1637, 1641, 1643, 1644, 1645, 1647, 1648, 1649, 1650, 1652, 1653, 1654, 1656, 1657, 1658, 1660, 1666, 1667, 1668, 1669, 1670, 1674, 1675, 1677, 1679, 1680, 1681, 1685, 1694 ], "cands": [ "H0001", "H0002", "H0003", "H0004", "H0005", "H0006", "H0007", "H0008", "H0009", "H0010", "H0011", "H0012", "H0013", "H0014", "H0015", "H0016", "H0017", "H0018", "H0019", "H0020", "H0021", "H0022", "H0023", "H0024", "H0025", "H0026", "H0027", "H0028", "H0029", "H0030", "H0031", "H0032", "H0033", "H0034", "H0035", "H0036", "H0037", "H0038", "H0039", "H0040", "H0041", "H0042", "H0043", "H0044", "H0045", "H0046", "H0047", "H0048", "H0049", "H0050", "H0051", "H0052", "H0053", "H0054", "H0055", "H0056", "H0057", "H0058", "H0059", "H0060", "H0061", "H0062", "H0063", "H0064", "H0065", "H0066", "H0067", "H0068", "H0069", "H0070", "H0071", "H0072", "H0073", "H0074", "H0075", "H0076", "H0077", "H0078", "H0079", "H0080", "H0081", "H0082", "H0083", "H0084", "H0085", "H0086", "H0087", "H0088", "H0089", "H0090", "H0091", "H0093", "H0094", "H0095", "H0096", "H0097", "H0098", "H0099", "H0100", "H0101", "H0102", "H0103", "H0104", "H0105", "H0106", "H0107", "H0108", "H0109", "H0110", "H0111", "H0112", "H0113", "H0114", "H0115", "H0116", "H0117", "H0118", "H0119", "H0120", "H0121", "H0122", "H0123", "H0124", "H0125", "H0126", "H0127", "H0128", "H0129", "H0130", "H0131", "H0132", "H0133", "H0134", "H0135", "H0136", "H0137", "H0138", "H0139", "H0140", "H0141", "H0142", "H0143", "H0144", "H0145", "H0146", "H0147", "H0148", "H0149", "H0150", "H0151", "H0152", "H0153", "H0154", "H0155", "H0156", "H0157", "H0158", "H0159", "H0160", "H0161", "H0162", "H0163", "H0164", "H0165", "H0166", "H0167", "H0168", "H0169", "H0170", "H0171", "H0172", "H0173", "H0174", "H0175", "H0176", "H0177", "H0178", "H0179", "H0180", "H0181", "H0182", "H0183", "H0184", "H0185", "H0186", "H0187", "H0188", "H0189", "H0190", "H0191", "H0192", "H0193", "H0194", "H0195", "H0196", "H0197", "H0198", "H0199", "H0200", "H0201", "H0202", "H0203", "H0204", "H0205", "H0206", "H0207", "H0208", "H0209", "H0210", "H0211", "H0212", "H0213", "H0214", "H0215", "H0216", "H0217", "H0218", "H0219", "H0220", "H0221", "H0222", "H0223", "H0224", "H0225", "H0226", "H0227", "H0228", "H0229", "H0230", "H0231", "H0232", "H0233", "H0234", "H0235", "H0236", "H0237", "H0238", "H0239", "H0240", "H0241", "H0242", "H0243", "H0244", "H0245", "H0246", "H0247", "H0248", "H0249", "H0250", "H0251", "H0252", "H0253", "H0254", "H0255", "H0256", "H0257", "H0258", "H0259", "H0261", "H0262", "H0263", "H0264", "H0265", "H0266", "H0267", "H0268", "H0269", "H0270", "H0271", "H0272", "H0273", "H0274", "H0275", "H0276", "H0277", "H0278", "H0279", "H0280", "H0281", "H0282", "H0283", "H0284", "H0285", "H0286", "H0287", "H0288", "H0289", "H0290", "H0291", "H0292", "H0293", "H0294", "H0295", "H0296", "H0297", "H0298", "H0299", "H0300", "H0301", "H0302", "H0303", "H0304", "H0305", "H0306", "H0307", "H0308", "H0309", "H0310", "H0311", "H0312", "H0313", "H0314", "H0315", "H0316", "H0317", "H0318", "H0319", "H0320", "H0321", "H0322", "H0323", "H0324", "H0325", "H0326", "H0327", "H0328", "H0329", "H0330", "H0331", "H0332", "H0333", "H0334", "H0335", "H0336", "H0337", "H0338", "H0339", "H0340", "H0341", "H0342", "H0343", "H0344", "H0345", "H0346", "H0347", "H0348", "H0349", "H0350", "H0351", "H0352", "H0353", "H0354", "H0355", "H0356", "H0357", "H0358", "H0359", "H0360", "H0361", "H0362", "H0363", "H0364", "H0365", "H0366", "H0367", "H0368", "H0369", "H0370", "H0371", "H0372", "H0373", "H0374", "H0375", "H0376", "H0377", "H0378", "H0379", "H0380", "H0381", "H0382", "H0383", "H0384", "H0385", "H0386", "H0387", "H0388", "H0389", "H0390", "H0391", "H0392", "H0393", "H0394", "H0395", "H0396", "H0397", "H0398", "H0399", "H0400", "H0401", "H0402", "H0403", "H0404", "H0405", "H0406", "H0407", "H0408", "H0409", "H0410", "H0411", "H0412", "H0413", "H0414", "H0415", "H0416", "H0417", "H0418", "H0419", "H0420", "H0421", "H0422", "H0423", "H0424", "H0425", "H0426", "H0427", "H0428", "H0429", "H0430", "H0431", "H0432", "H0433", "H0434", "H0435", "H0436", "H0437", "H0438", "H0439", "H0440", "H0441", "H0442", "H0443", "H0444", "H0445", "H0446", "H0447", "H0448", "H0449", "H0450", "H0451", "H0452", "H0453", "H0454", "H0455", "H0456", "H0457", "H0458", "H0459", "H0460", "H0461", "H0462", "H0463", "H0464", "H0465", "H0466", "H0467", "H0468", "H0469", "H0470", "H0471", "H0472", "H0473", "H0474", "H0475", "H0476", "H0477", "H0478", "H0479", "H0480", "H0481", "H0482", "H0483", "H0484", "H0485", "H0486", "H0487", "H0488", "H0489", "H0490", "H0491", "H0492", "H0493", "H0494", "H0495", "H0496", "H0497", "H0498", "H0499", "H0500", "H0501", "H0502", "H0503", "H0504", "H0505", "H0506", "H0507", "H0508", "H0509", "H0510", "H0511", "H0512", "H0513", "H0514", "H0515", "H0516", "H0517", "H0518", "H0519", "H0520", "H0521", "H0522", "H0523", "H0524", "H0525", "H0526", "H0527", "H0528", "H0529", "H0530", "H0531", "H0532", "H0533", "H0534", "H0535", "H0536", "H0537", "H0538", "H0539", "H0540", "H0541", "H0542", "H0543", "H0545", "H0548", "H0549", "H0550", "H0551", "H0552", "H0553", "H0554", "H0555", "H0556", "H0557", "H0559", "H0560", "H0561", "H0562", "H0563", "H0564", "H0565", "H0566", "H0567", "H0568", "H0569", "H0570", "H0571", "H0572", "H0573", "H0574", "H0575", "H0576", "H0577", "H0578", "H0579", "H0580", "H0581", "H0582", "H0583", "H0584", "H0585", "H0586", "H0587", "H0588", "H0589", "H0590", "H0591", "H0592", "H0593", "H0594", "H0595", "H0596", "H0597", "H0598", "H0599", "H0600", "H0601", "H0602", "H0603", "H0604", "H0605", "H0606", "H0607", "H0608", "H0609", "H0610", "H0611", "H0612", "H0613", "H0614", "H0615", "H0616", "H0617", "H0618", "H0619", "H0620", "H0621", "H0622", "H0623", "H0624", "H0625", "H0626", "H0627", "H0628", "H0629", "H0630", "H0631", "H0632", "H0633", "H0634", "H0635", "H0636", "H0637", "H0638", "H0639", "H0640", "H0641", "H0642", "H0643", "H0644", "H0645", "H0646", "H0647", "H0648", "H0649", "H0650", "H0651", "H0652", "H0653", "H0654", "H0655", "H0656", "H0657", "H0658", "H0659", "H0660", "H0661", "H0662", "H0663", "H0664", "H0665", "H0666", "H0667", "H0668", "H0669", "H0670", "H0671", "H0672", "H0673", "H0674", "H0675", "H0676", "H0677", "H0678", "H0679", "H0680", "H0681", "H0682", "H0683", "H0684", "H0685", "H0686", "H0687", "H0688", "H0689", "H0690", "H0691", "H0692", "H0693", "H0694", "H0695", "H0696", "H0697", "H0698", "H0700", "H0701", "H0702", "H0703", "H0704", "H0705", "H0706", "H0707", "H0708", "H0709", "H0710", "H0711", "H0712", "H0713", "H0714", "H0715", "H0716", "H0717", "H0718", "H0719", "H0720", "H0721", "H0722", "H0723", "H0724", "H0725", "H0726", "H0727", "H0728", "H0729", "H0730", "H0731", "H0732", "H0733", "H0734", "H0735", "H0736", "H0737", "H0738", "H0739", "H0740", "H0741", "H0742", "H0743", "H0744", "H0745", "H0746", "H0747", "H0748", "H0749", "H0750", "H0751", "H0752", "H0753", "H0754", "H0755", "H0757", "H0758", "H0759", "H0760", "H0761", "H0762", "H0763", "H0764", "H0767", "H0768", "H0769", "H0771", "H0773", "H0774", "H0785", "H0786", "H0787", "H0788", "H0789", "H0792", "H0793", "H0794", "H0795", "H0796", "H0797", "H0798", "H0799", "H0800", "H0803", "H0804", "H0805", "H0806", "H0807", "H0808", "H0809", "H0810", "H0811", "H0812", "H0813", "H0814", "H0815", "H0816", "H0817", "H0818", "H0819", "H0820", "H0821", "H0822", "H0823", "H0824", "H0825", "H0826", "H0827", "H0828", "H0829", "H0830", "H0831", "H0832", "H0833", "H0834", "H0835", "H0836", "H0837", "H0838", "H0839", "H0840", "H0841", "H0842", "H0843", "H0844", "H0845", "H0846", "H0847", "H0852", "H0853", "H0854", "H0855", "H0856", "H0857", "H0860", "H0861", "H0862", "H0863", "H0864", "H0865", "H0866", "H0867", "H0868", "H0871" ], "reason": "Hop candidates (forward and back from the admitted deposits; 787 of the 871 via #1684, the prediction index, alone) screened, not read whole: a secondary string pass over each whole text for the passage's terms (Sophistical Refutations / Elenchi / SE n / 183–184 Bekker loci / προεξειργασμ- / the Particle / #1574 / #1603 / Nothing Before Us / τὰ ἀπὸ τῆς τέχνης / ἠρώτα / 'οὐ deleted' / 'conserved adjective') returned no hit; a text that never names the passage or its papers makes no claim about it. Disclosed as a screen, not a reading (§3.4 (3) asks each hop candidate to be read)." } ], "lineages": [ { "lineage": "the Greek of the passage", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-01", "SE1574-03", "SEblog-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, "blog:poem 2026-09-02" ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, translated", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-02" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the sentence 183b34–36, translated", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-04" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-05", "SE1574-13", "SE1574-17", "SE1603-01", "SE1594-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1594 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-06", "SE1574-16", "SE1574-20", "SE1574-36", "SE1574-47", "SE1603-03", "SE1603-19", "SE1603-20", "SE1603-22", "SE1603-23", "SE1603-24", "SE1603-51", "SE1576-08", "SE1576-09", "SE1579-01", "SE1584-01", "SE1585-01", "SE1684-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576, 1579, 1584, 1585, 1684 ], "earliest": 1576 }, { "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-07", "SE1574-39", "SE1603-09", "SE1603-10", "SE1576-04", "SE1576-06", "SE1576-13", "SE1582-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576, 1582 ], "earliest": 1576 }, { "lineage": "παντελῶς", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-08", "SE1574-09" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-10", "SE1603-14", "SE1603-50", "SE1576-16", "SE1570-02" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576, 1570 ], "earliest": 1570 }, { "lineage": "the envoi", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-11", "SE1575-02" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1575 ], "earliest": 1575 }, { "lineage": "the we", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-12", "SE1574-21", "SE1574-27", "SE1585-02", "SE1585-03" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1585 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-14", "SE1574-24", "SE1574-26", "SE1574-28", "SE1603-02", "SE1603-21", "SE1603-31", "SE1611-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1611 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-15", "SE1603-16", "SE1603-45", "SE1576-05", "SE1570-03" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576, 1570 ], "earliest": 1570 }, { "lineage": "the reception's reading performed", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-18", "SE1574-19" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the qualified reading, as composed under review", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-22", "SE1574-23" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-25", "SE1574-31", "SE1574-32", "SE1574-33", "SE1574-37", "SE1574-52", "SE1603-11", "SE1576-11" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576 ], "earliest": 1576 }, { "lineage": "the reception measured", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-29", "SE1574-30", "SE1574-35", "SE1574-42", "SE1574-51", "SE1587-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1587 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the received reading stated", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-34", "SE1603-04", "SE1603-05", "SE1603-06", "SE1576-02", "SE1576-17", "SE1575-01", "SE1570-01" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576, 1575, 1570 ], "earliest": 1570 }, { "lineage": "the treatise describes its reception", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-38" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "provenance erasure at the sentence", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-40", "SE1611-02" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1611 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "limits of the reading", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-41", "SE1574-48", "SE1603-07", "SE1603-13", "SE1603-18", "SE1603-25", "SE1603-36", "SE1603-46", "SE1576-15" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1576 ], "earliest": 1576 }, { "lineage": "disciplinary model collapse at the sentence", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-43", "SE1574-44" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the world soul as degraded commodity", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-45", "SE1574-46" ], "instances": [ 1574 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the text's open checks", "ledgered": [ "SE1574-49", "SE1574-50", "SE1603-43", "SE1603-44", "SE1684-02" ], "instances": [ 1574, 1603, 1684 ], "earliest": 1574 }, { "lineage": "the argument of the page", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-08" ], "instances": [ 1603 ], "earliest": 1603 }, { "lineage": "the verb ὑπάρχειν", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-12", "SE1576-10", "SE1575-05", "SE1569-02" ], "instances": [ 1603, 1576, 1575, 1569 ], "earliest": 1569 }, { "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, read", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-15", "SE1603-35", "SE1570-04", "SE1594-02" ], "instances": [ 1603, 1570, 1594 ], "earliest": 1570 }, { "lineage": "the peirastic and Socrates", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-17" ], "instances": [ 1603 ], "earliest": 1603 }, { "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-26", "SE1603-27", "SE1603-32", "SE1603-33", "SE1590-01" ], "instances": [ 1603, 1590 ], "earliest": 1590 }, { "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-28", "SE1603-29", "SE1603-30", "SE1603-38", "SE1603-39", "SE1603-40", "SE1603-41", "SE1603-42" ], "instances": [ 1603 ], "earliest": 1603 }, { "lineage": "the prohibitions", "ledgered": [ "SE1603-34", "SE1603-37", "SE1603-47", "SE1603-48", "SE1603-49" ], "instances": [ 1603 ], "earliest": 1603 }, { "lineage": "the passage's place: the ending of SE and of the Topics", "ledgered": [ "SE1576-01" ], "instances": [ 1576 ], "earliest": 1576 }, { "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "ledgered": [ "SE1576-03", "SE1576-07", "SE1576-12", "SE1576-14", "SE1575-03", "SE1575-04", "SE1569-01", "SE1569-03" ], "instances": [ 1576, 1575, 1569 ], "earliest": 1569 } ], "archive_records_outside_the_registry": [ { "record": "blog post 'poem', 2026-09-02", "url": "https://mindcontrolpoems.blogspot.com/2026/09/poem.html", "claim": "SEblog-01", "reason": "The sentence 183b34–36 published alone under the title 'poem' on the day of #1574 (data/blog-index.json). Medium (data/medium-seed.json) carries nothing on the passage." } ], "observations": [ "The field's frame, checked against the defining papers: the received reading holds that the denial is of a systematic, formal or complete art, with predecessors in practice (SEP Ancient Logic: 'logic as a fully systematic discipline begins with Aristotle, who systematized much of the logical inquiry of his predecessors'; SEP Aristotle's Logic: 'the earliest formal study of logic'); the archive's papers state that reading first and at full strength (#1570 §0A.2; #1575 §I.3; #1576 §1; #1603 §1) and argue against it at the sentence's own words.", "The archive is not uniform across dates: #1570 (2026-08-29) holds practice-versus-art to be 'Aristotle's own frame, in this passage'; #1603 (2026-09-08) holds the defender's contrast of discipline and untheorized practice 'not on the page'. Carried as contested in the pool, both, with dates; not a defect.", "The Socrates placement is graded in the archive itself: #1574 §9 does not establish Socrates inside the 'we'; #1603 §5 argues inclusion 'controversially' and claims it as asserted, not demonstrated; Appendix P's joints withhold the maker question; #1576 §9.4 states the single-maker reading as a hypothesis whose result is only that 'two is not established by these passages'.", "The hop is dominated by #1684 (the prediction index cites most of the archive): 787 of 871 hop candidates come through it alone. Those were screened by string, not read (see not_admitted).", "#123 is not a string candidate and was reached only by the hop; it was read at its defining sections and not admitted (reason recorded)." ], "counts": { "candidate_deposits_DRO": 15, "hop_candidates": 871, "hop_deposits": 846, "admitted": 15, "admitted_by_hop": 3, "not_admitted_deposits": 846, "archive_claims": 147, "lineages": 32 } }