{"dep": 43, "title": "The Seed That Remembers the Tree: Retrocausal Canon Formation — Theory, Toolkit, and Archive of Techniques (EA-RCF-01)", "date": "2026-03-29", "para": 27, "sent": 67, "sentence": "Provenance studies stabilizes authorship and priority through archival evidence — manuscripts, signatures, watermarks, chain of custody.", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["chain of custody", "Provenance studies"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0001"}
{"dep": 725, "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance", "date": "2026-05-08", "para": 20, "sent": 45, "sentence": "[ archival science (records management, custody chains, contextual provenance, *respect des fonds*) | art history (chain of ownership, attribution) | legal evidence (chain of custody) | supply-chain management (origin tracking) | data provenance (W3C PROV, lineage tracking) | content authenticity (C2PA, cryptographic signing) | dataset documentation (DPI, model cards, dataset cards) | digital preservation (OAIS, PREMIS — including transformations and derivations) ]", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["archival science", "chain of custody"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0002"}
{"dep": 725, "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance", "date": "2026-05-08", "para": 22, "sent": 49, "sentence": "**Archival precedent acknowledged.** Archival theory has long insisted that provenance is contextual and meaning-bearing — *respect des fonds* requires understanding the record's context of creation, custodial history, and function.", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["Archival precedent acknowledged", "Archival theory"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0003"}
{"dep": 725, "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance", "date": "2026-05-08", "para": 75, "sent": 199, "sentence": "| Term / Field | Common Meaning | Relation to This Packet | Disambiguation Rule | | ---|---|---|--- | | Provenance (archival) | Origin and chain of custody of records | Parent concept | Semantic provenance extends archival concerns to circulating meaning under AI synthesis | | Provenance (art history) | Documented chain of ownership and attribution for art objects | Adjacent tradition | Same conceptual structure; different object | | Chain of custody (legal) | Documented handling of evidence | Adjacent tradition | Procedural, not value-theoretic | | Supply-chain provenance | Origin tracking for goods (food, materials, conflict minerals) | Adjacent tradition | Material objects, not meaning | | Data provenance / W3C PROV | Lineage of digital data through systems | Closest technical cousin | Operates on data flow; semantic provenance operates on meaning circulation | | Data lineage | How da", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["Chain of custody", "chain of custody", "Disambiguation Rule", "Parent concept", "Semantic provenance", "semantic provenance"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0004"}
{"dep": 1190, "title": "Provenance After AI: Semantic Provenance and the Provenance Erasure Rate as Extension of C2PA, Data Provenance Initiative, and EU AI Act Frameworks (v1.1)", "date": "2026-05-12", "para": 34, "sent": 66, "sentence": "[ archival science (records management, custody chains, contextual provenance, *respect des fonds*) | art history (chain of ownership, attribution) | legal evidence (chain of custody) | supply-chain management (origin tracking) | data provenance (W3C PROV, lineage tracking) | content authenticity (C2PA, cryptographic signing) | dataset documentation (DPI, model cards, dataset cards) | digital preservation (OAIS, PREMIS — including transformations and derivations) ]", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["archival science", "chain of custody"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0005"}
{"dep": 1190, "title": "Provenance After AI: Semantic Provenance and the Provenance Erasure Rate as Extension of C2PA, Data Provenance Initiative, and EU AI Act Frameworks (v1.1)", "date": "2026-05-12", "para": 36, "sent": 70, "sentence": "**Archival precedent acknowledged.** Archival theory has long insisted that provenance is contextual and meaning-bearing — *respect des fonds* requires understanding the record's context of creation, custodial history, and function.", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["Archival precedent acknowledged", "Archival theory"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0006"}
{"dep": 1190, "title": "Provenance After AI: Semantic Provenance and the Provenance Erasure Rate as Extension of C2PA, Data Provenance Initiative, and EU AI Act Frameworks (v1.1)", "date": "2026-05-12", "para": 102, "sent": 219, "sentence": "Term / Field | Common Meaning | Relation to This Packet | Disambiguation Rule ---|---|---|--- Provenance (archival) | Origin and chain of custody of records | Parent concept | Semantic provenance extends archival concerns to circulating meaning under AI synthesis Provenance (art history) | Documented chain of ownership and attribution for art objects | Adjacent tradition | Same conceptual structure; different object Chain of custody (legal) | Documented handling of evidence | Adjacent tradition | Procedural, not value-theoretic Supply-chain provenance | Origin tracking for goods (food, materials, conflict minerals) | Adjacent tradition | Material objects, not meaning Data provenance / W3C PROV | Lineage of digital data through systems | Closest technical cousin | Operates on data flow; semantic provenance operates on meaning circulation Data lineage | How data moves and transforms across", "classes": ["manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["Chain of custody", "chain of custody", "Disambiguation Rule", "Parent concept", "Semantic provenance", "semantic provenance"], "class_basis": {"manuscript provenance: the history of manuscripts' sales, locations and ownership (archival and art-historical provenance of objects)": "field: B9 (sdbm.library.upenn.edu, home: 'other sources that document the sales and locations of these books from around the world'); B8 (JOHD 2020, 'Data Transformation and Aggregation': 'three specialist databases, which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); B10 (MMM white paper: 'two specialized relational databases which focus on the history and provenance of medieval and Renaissance manuscripts'); census lineage 'manuscripts and books', kind 'database', relation_types sale, location, ownership"}, "cand_id": "O0007"}