{ "row": "orcid", "pass": "first reading 2026-11-01; second pass with one citation hop from the 30 deposits admitted at the first reading", "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.10 (#1726) §3.4 D/R/O (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: D, a claim on ORCID with the name; R, a relation the archive states between ORCID and an archive object (its iD, its heteronyms, the archive); O, an archive category applied to ORCID or to a class the field and the census source for it (persistent identifiers for persons; author name disambiguation) or the archive alone sources (civil-name attribution: the census's ls_reading and does_not_answer). #940 and #1722, the census's anchors, read at the passages that bear on name authorities, pseudonyms and heteronyms and the existence tax. A bare mention (the iD in a byline, a metadata field, a JSON-LD block, a list of surfaces) is not a claim.", "reader": "Claude (Opus 5.5), subagent, 2026-11-01", "counts": { "D_sentences": 2175, "D_deposits": 969, "R_sentences": 1616, "R_deposits": 858, "O_direct": 1733, "O_class": 288, "O_deposits": 961, "H_candidates": 301 }, "verdicts": [ { "dep": 940, "strata": [ "D", "O", "R" ], "reason": "The civil-name regime ¶1 (line 79): the civil name as the atomic unit of attribution in the systems of scholarly legitimacy; §2, the critical refinement (line 114): a heteronym attributable through the civil bearer without reduction to that bearer; what heteronymy does (line 126): collapse into single-civil-identity ownership registers as loss; cases: Mary Lee Sharks (line 166): a heteronymic entity shares an ORCID identifier for cross-attribution; the ORCID's normative implications left open", "claims": [ "O940-01", "O940-02", "O940-03", "R940-04" ], "cands": [ "D0928", "D0929", "D0930", "O0829", "O0830", "O0831", "O0832", "O0833", "O0834", "O0835", "O0836", "O0837" ] }, { "dep": 1722, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "Part One ¶3 (line 55): an Overview at the author's name found the ORCID among the record and denied none of it; Part One ¶5 (line 65): an ORCID record cited as evidence that the name is real, and the Overview siding with the other answer", "claims": [ "R1722-01", "R1722-02" ], "cands": [ "D2162", "D2163", "D2164", "D2165", "O2006", "O2007", "R1607", "R1608", "R1609" ] }, { "dep": 1009, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "Prerequisite A (line 156): the account belongs to the legal identity; a heteronym has an alternate-name presence within it, the pattern by which Lee Sharks operates on 0009-0000-1599-0703; Prerequisite A (line 156): the mechanism is ORCID's 'Other names' / 'Also known as', on ORCID's own documentation, which the procedure defers to; public declaration (line 439): the alternate-name registration makes the relation visible on the profile", "claims": [ "D1009-01", "D1009-02", "D1009-03" ], "cands": [ "D1056", "D1057", "D1058", "D1059", "D1060", "D1061", "D1062", "D1063", "D1064", "D1065", "D1066", "D1067" ] }, { "dep": 135, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "Anchor 3 (line 319): the earlier instance of #1009's anchor: one ORCID, the heteronym an alternate published name, never a separate ORCID", "claims": [ "D135-01" ], "cands": [ "D0271", "D0272", "D0273", "D0274", "D0275", "D0276", "D0277", "D0278", "D0279", "D0280", "D0281", "D0282" ] }, { "dep": 1446, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "§11, sameAs (lines 180–184): sameAs to the orthonym's ORCID asserts the heteronym is the orthonym: the collapse; §11, rule (lines 182–184): the archive's ORCID belongs in the deposit record and not in a heteronym's identity graph", "claims": [ "D1446-01", "D1446-02" ], "cands": [ "D1768", "D1769", "D1770", "D1771", "O1636", "O1637", "R1325", "R1326", "R1327" ] }, { "dep": 928, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "witness identity (lines 99–102): the heteronym's ORCID anchors the witness; no civil identity stored", "claims": [ "D928-01" ], "cands": [ "D0903", "D0904", "D0905", "D0906", "D0907", "D0908", "D0909", "D0910", "D0911", "D0912", "D0913", "D0914" ] }, { "dep": 794, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "opening (line 23): the heteronym Lee Sharks has the ORCID", "claims": [ "D794-01" ], "cands": [ "D0692", "D0693", "O0593", "O0594", "R0447", "R0448" ] }, { "dep": 922, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "personal-name protection (line 68): the ORCID documents identity continuity without naming the civil identity", "claims": [ "D922-01" ], "cands": [ "D0896", "D0897", "D0898", "O0800", "O0801", "R0619" ] }, { "dep": 162, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "accepted rulings (para 65): a ruling of 2026-06-08: the ORCID belongs to Lee Sharks and is not assigned to Mary Lee", "claims": [ "D162-01" ], "cands": [ "D0345", "D0346", "D0347", "O0294", "O0295", "O0296", "R0200", "R0201" ] }, { "dep": 823, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "statement of the petitioner (line 21): a heteronym holds publications of record under its own creator name on the shared ORCID", "claims": [ "R823-01" ], "cands": [ "D0720", "D0721", "O0644", "O0645", "R0475", "R0476" ] }, { "dep": 1210, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "statement (line 96): the petition's later instance: four publications regularized under 'Sharks, Mary Lee' on the shared ORCID", "claims": [ "R1210-01" ], "cands": [ "D1449", "D1450", "D1451", "O1340", "O1341", "O1342", "R1041", "R1042", "R1043" ] }, { "dep": 1429, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "CP-2 (line 146): the registry's rule: a heteronym creator carries the shared ORCID; CP-R2 (line 158): open: whether OAI records expose the shared ORCID on heteronym creators", "claims": [ "D1429-01", "D1429-02" ], "cands": [ "D1743", "D1744", "D1745", "D1746", "O1613", "O1614", "O1615", "O1616", "R1306", "R1307", "R1308" ] }, { "dep": 1377, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "FAQ JSON-LD (line 646): a heteronym and the accountable author both attributed under the one ORCID", "claims": [ "R1377-01" ], "cands": [ "D1631", "D1632", "D1633", "D1634", "D1635", "D1636", "D1637", "D1638", "D1639", "O1514", "O1515", "O1516" ] }, { "dep": 195, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "Conclusion, preceding ¶ (line 122): the operator carries the ORCID as Editor on a work bylined to heteronyms: the aperture", "claims": [ "R195-01" ], "cands": [ "D0386", "D0387", "O0332", "R0234" ] }, { "dep": 196, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "the institution (line 57): one ORCID under many names, read as the corpus's remarking machine", "claims": [ "R196-01" ], "cands": [ "D0388", "D0389", "O0333", "R0235", "R0236" ] }, { "dep": 126, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "ORCID inscription (para 87): the ORCID as the operator's persistent inscription", "claims": [ "D126-01" ], "cands": [ "D0199", "D0200", "D0201", "D0202", "D0203", "D0204", "D0205", "D0206", "D0207", "D0208", "D0209", "D0210" ] }, { "dep": 868, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "§3 (line 85): a DataCite sweep: 399 DOIs by ORCID, 307 more by heteronym creator names", "claims": [ "D868-01" ], "cands": [ "D0804", "D0805", "D0806", "D0807", "O0735", "O0736", "O0737", "R0545", "R0546", "R0547", "R0548" ] }, { "dep": 1075, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "Appendix A note (line 91): the backup queried by ORCID and by each heteronym creator name", "claims": [ "D1075-01" ], "cands": [ "D1179", "D1180", "D1181", "D1182", "D1183", "O1091", "O1092", "R0818", "R0819", "R0820", "R0821" ] }, { "dep": 147, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "the substitution (line 23): ORCID record updates did not correct an entity substitution at the name", "claims": [ "D147-01" ], "cands": [ "D0321", "D0322", "D0323", "D0324", "D0325", "D0326", "O0278", "O0279", "R0182", "R0183", "R0184" ] }, { "dep": 79, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "§1 (line 42): ORCID records attachable to any self-asserted identity; markers mistaken for provenance; alias capture (lines 173, 271): an ORCID cannot make an alias true (the Satoshi claimant with two ORCID records)", "claims": [ "D79-01", "D79-02" ], "cands": [ "D0084", "D0085", "D0086", "D0087", "D0088", "D0089", "D0090", "D0091", "D0092", "D0093", "D0094", "D0095" ] }, { "dep": 703, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "verification_level description (line 98): ORCID does not verify authorship claims", "claims": [ "D703-01" ], "cands": [ "D0525", "D0526", "D0527", "D0528", "D0529", "D0530", "D0531", "D0532", "D0533", "O0453", "O0454", "O0455" ] }, { "dep": 84, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "identity nodes (line 363): two ORCIDs for one person make two identity nodes", "claims": [ "D84-01" ], "cands": [ "D0106", "D0107", "D0108", "D0109", "D0110", "D0111", "D0112", "D0113", "D0114", "D0115", "D0116", "D0117" ] }, { "dep": 1073, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "subsidiary defects (line 27): ORCID iDs issued to individual natural persons only, against an office that said otherwise", "claims": [ "D1073-01" ], "cands": [ "D1171", "D1172", "D1173", "D1174", "D1175", "D1176", "D1177", "O1089", "O1090", "R0815", "R0816" ] }, { "dep": 49, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "Heteronymic Distribution (line 2201): distinct ORCID identifiers per heteronym would read as a community", "claims": [ "R49-01" ], "cands": [ "D0009", "D0010", "O0011", "O0012", "R0006" ] }, { "dep": 115, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "named positions (lines 561–565): do not collapse the heteronyms into Lee's ORCID unless intentional", "claims": [ "D115-01" ], "cands": [ "D0173", "D0174", "D0175", "D0176", "D0177", "D0178", "D0179", "D0180", "D0181", "O0154", "O0155", "O0156" ] }, { "dep": 754, "strata": [ "O", "R" ], "reason": "heteronymic handle support (line 220): each heteronym an ORCID-equivalent inscription chain; the civil identity protected", "claims": [ "O754-01" ], "cands": [ "D0610", "D0611", "D0612", "D0613", "D0614", "O0520", "O0521", "O0522", "O0523", "O0524", "O0525", "O0526" ] }, { "dep": 996, "strata": [ "O" ], "reason": "the Orthonym Inversion: infrastructure built on the legal name as the real person", "claims": [ "O996-01" ], "cands": [ "D1029", "O0935", "O0936", "O0937", "O0938", "O0939", "O0940", "O0941", "O0942", "O0943", "O0944", "O0945" ] }, { "dep": 1183, "strata": [ "O" ], "reason": "the Armature fields: the archive's own record of a named position carries a declared civil-name relation", "claims": [ "O1183-01" ], "cands": [ "D1343", "D1344", "D1345", "D1346", "H0238", "O1243", "O1244", "O1245", "O1246", "O1247", "O1248", "O1249" ] } ], "rejected": { "rule": "every other candidate: the iD or the name as a bare mention (byline, metadata, schema, surface list), or a sentence that says nothing of ORCID or of a sourced class; the O-direct candidates (1733) are sentences that name ORCID beside an archive category without applying it to ORCID; the 301 hop candidates were read by title and by the string-pass sentences each holds, and none adds a claim beyond those admitted except #1183 (O-class), admitted with its instance #68", "reading_note": "the 2175 D sentences were first reduced to the 757 that use the name beyond the iD and then to 674 outside JSON-LD and schema blocks; these were read through a predicate filter (ORCID with a verb of being, holding, verifying, belonging or anchoring, or with heteronym, alternate name, civil or legal identity) and then by eye at their paragraphs. The filter is recorded as a reading aid; it is no ground of removal (§3.4 S4)" }, "not_admitted": [ { "cands": "rule", "reason": "every other candidate: the iD or the name as a bare mention (byline, metadata, schema, surface list), or a sentence that says nothing of ORCID or of a sourced class; the O-direct candidates (1733) are sentences that name ORCID beside an archive category without applying it to ORCID; the 301 hop candidates were read by title and by the string-pass sentences each holds, and none adds a claim beyond those admitted except #1183 (O-class), admitted with its instance #68" }, { "cands": "reading_note", "reason": "the 2175 D sentences were first reduced to the 757 that use the name beyond the iD and then to 674 outside JSON-LD and schema blocks; these were read through a predicate filter (ORCID with a verb of being, holding, verifying, belonging or anchoring, or with heteronym, alternate name, civil or legal identity) and then by eye at their paragraphs. The filter is recorded as a reading aid; it is no ground of removal (§3.4 S4)" } ] }