{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 0, "sent": 3, "sentence": "The implementation (SPXI-gnΩsis 0.9.1) was written and tested in session; its model passes ran in replay, labelled as such, and no payment has settled.\" version: v1.0 related_ids: \"#137 (The Semantic Commodity Form); #1617 (Substrate Sovereignty); #1618 (Money Writes the Claim); #1625 (Mammonic Transmission Engineering); #1631 (Monetary Dark Matter); #1634 (Ontological Economy); #1613 (EA-MIRROR-01); #1690 (The Negative of the Negative v0.9); #1694 (EA-PER-RECALC-01); #1574 (SE 34); #1603; #1629; /non row se-183b34; implementation https://github.com/leesharks000/spxignosis (commit bdbe2c815eff62116fd65a132384b1712b77b75d)\" axn_schema_version: v2 protocol_version: alexanarch-deposit-protocol/v1 keywords: - entity - ontological commodity form - semantic fetish - Wikipedia - Wikidata - verifiability - no original research - attributization - operation and attribute - recognition and reconst", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0001"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 4, "sent": 8, "sentence": "**v0.2 round log.** Folds in the operator's proposition of 2026-10-20 (\"maybe the ontological problem is 'the entity' itself. the entity is the ontological commodity form in which the operation is obscured\") as §1, and re-founds §§2–5 on it: the algorithm's unit becomes the operation, with the entity as index; S3 gains the attributization test.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0002"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 5, "sent": 12, "sentence": "Adopted: the governing test is material persistence without operative authority, and attributization is recorded with the relations that survive it and their authority to revise (ChatGPT); §§1.3 and 3.4 restated so that the substitution rule permits operative loss and the protocol's own reconstruction remains possible (ChatGPT); the specimen's textual finding separated from its policy verdict, against NOR's own paraphrase clause, which reads \"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source) is not original research\" (ChatGPT, DeepSeek); applicable, documented and inferred governance kept apart in the tuple (ChatGPT); unresolved integrity states and the split between a documented rejection and an uncited available source (ChatGPT); P2's falsifier corrected and matching criteria", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0003"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 67, "sent": 317, "sentence": "Its row composes the operator as the subject: what it does, on what domain, where it is performed, which entities it speaks through (each attributization of S3(c) an instance), and where it stops.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0004"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 70, "sent": 331, "sentence": "*(c) Attributization.* Does the source perform an act that the sentence states as a property of the entity?", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0005"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 72, "sent": 345, "sentence": "The build emits the support, paraphrase and attributization classes with their spans and loci; the elements it does not compute (∼_W, K_W, B_W, C_W, λ) and the S4 ledger are named unimplemented in the evidence record until supplied.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0006"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 92, "sent": 423, "sentence": "*(c) Attributization:* ω = a first-person count over a stated domain ending in a total negation (\"nothing at all\"; \"absolutely nothing else\"); attribute = primacy of a work.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0007"}
{"dep": 1696, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-22", "para": 116, "sent": 486, "sentence": "**P1 (entity form).** Attributization with loss of operative authority (S3(c)) occurs at a higher rate on entity pages than on work and method pages.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0008"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 4, "sent": 8, "sentence": "**v0.2 round log.** Folds in the operator's proposition of 2026-10-20 (\"maybe the ontological problem is 'the entity' itself. the entity is the ontological commodity form in which the operation is obscured\") as §1, and re-founds §§2–5 on it: the algorithm's unit becomes the operation, with the entity as index; S3 gains the attributization test.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0009"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 5, "sent": 12, "sentence": "Adopted: the governing test is material persistence without operative authority, and attributization is recorded with the relations that survive it and their authority to revise (ChatGPT); §§1.3 and 3.4 restated so that the substitution rule permits operative loss and the protocol's own reconstruction remains possible (ChatGPT); the specimen's textual finding separated from its policy verdict, against NOR's own paraphrase clause, which reads \"Describing the information from cited material in one's own words while retaining the substance (i.e., not introducing ideas or arguments absent from the source) is not original research\" (ChatGPT, DeepSeek); applicable, documented and inferred governance kept apart in the tuple (ChatGPT); unresolved integrity states and the split between a documented rejection and an uncited available source (ChatGPT); P2's falsifier corrected and matching criteria", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0010"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 22, "sent": 145, "sentence": "Kept prominent, as asked: the reproduction of source-fidelity findings and the failure of attributization to transfer (§0.6).", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0011"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 30, "sent": 179, "sentence": "On attributization they do not: asked whether a source's act is restated as a property, they answer no nearly everywhere the session answered yes.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0012"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 30, "sent": 180, "sentence": "The reading step transfers; the session's attributization did not, and that is the instrument's measured open problem.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0013"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 75, "sent": 361, "sentence": "Its row composes the operator as the subject: what it does, on what domain, where it is performed, which entities it speaks through (each attributization of S3(c) an instance), and where it stops.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0014"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 78, "sent": 382, "sentence": "*(c) Attributization.* Does the source perform an act that the sentence states as a property of the entity?", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0015"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 80, "sent": 396, "sentence": "The build emits the support, paraphrase and attributization classes with their spans and loci; the elements it does not compute (∼_W, K_W, B_W, C_W, λ) and the S4 ledger are named unimplemented in the evidence record until supplied.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0016"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 95, "sent": 468, "sentence": "| Case | Cited at the sentence | S3(a) support | S3(c) attributization | λ | |---|---|---|---|---| | W1, lead: \"identified twelve or thirteen fallacies\" | no | partially supported: thirteen by Krabbe (article-internal); twelve unsourced | partial: \"identified\" keeps the act; the completeness claim is lost | 4 | | W2, lead: \"the first work to treat the subject of deductive reasoning in ancient Greece\" | primary pointer only | priority claim supported as attributed; gloss interpretive, entered from the field's translation convention (article-internal, uncited); qualifier added | yes, by inversion: the verdict SE 34 hands to its hearers (184b3–8) becomes Aristotle's assertion of primacy in a modern subject, bounded to a region | 4 (where the gloss entered), 5 (the archive's reading) | | W3, lead: \"a pattern of sound and genuine reasoning\" | no | partially supported by the translation and Kr", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0017"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 103, "sent": 522, "sentence": "*(c) Attributization, by inversion.* ω = a verdict held open.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0018"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 112, "sent": 605, "sentence": "Attributization: yes, a stated criterion becomes membership in a later taxonomy.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0019"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 113, "sent": 619, "sentence": "No attributization: the operation survives.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0020"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 129, "sent": 698, "sentence": "Attributization: no.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0021"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 129, "sent": 702, "sentence": "Attributization: no.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0022"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 130, "sent": 707, "sentence": "That is the calibration property §5.4 asks for: an instrument run on operation-carrying pages returns \"no attributization\", and it keeps its resolution for smaller losses.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0023"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 141, "sent": 736, "sentence": "**P1 (entity form).** Attributization with loss of operative authority (S3(c)) occurs at a higher rate on entity pages than on work and method pages.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0024"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 190, "sent": 1043, "sentence": "The procedure is S3 as v1.1 states it: the innocent reading first, then support, the paraphrase comparison, attributization, λ, the alternative reading, the correction pathway and a confidence.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0025"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 198, "sent": 1076, "sentence": "The field table, for the two JSON replies, against the session (attributization; λ): SR-W1 partial / yes / partial; SR-W2 partial / yes / yes; SR-W3 yes / yes / yes; SR-W4-6 no / no / no; SR-W7-8 yes / yes / yes; TH-1 (the judgment the source's) / partial / no; TH-2 (the field's subordination) / yes / no; IW-1 no / no / no; EB-1 no / no / no; AC-1 recognition / no / no; λ 4 throughout, 2 for AC-1.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0026"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 198, "sent": 1077, "sentence": "The positive controls (SR-W4-6, IW-1, EB-1) return \"no attributization\" from every reader.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0027"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 204, "sent": 1108, "sentence": "*Where the session stands alone.* (1) Attributization.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0028"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 208, "sent": 1131, "sentence": "On operative retention, the session's attributization findings do not reproduce.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0029"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 209, "sent": 1138, "sentence": "Attributization: yes on SR-W2, partial on SR-W1 and SR-W7-8, no elsewhere; the nearest of the four to the session, from a context that is not blind.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0030"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 213, "sent": 1164, "sentence": "*Attributization.* DeepSeek answered yes on PA-1 (\"converts a priority claim about logic into a credential of the work\") and AR-1; ChatGPT partial on PA-1, NE-1, CA-1 and OR-1; Gemini no throughout.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0031"}
{"dep": 1697, "title": "Opening the Encyclopedia: The Entity as Ontological Commodity Form, and a Translation Protocol from Encyclopedic Grammar to the Meaning Layer (EA-WIKI-OPEN-01 v", "date": "2026-10-23", "para": 213, "sent": 1165, "sentence": "On the new cases the readers find attributization where a priority or founder noun is the predicate, which is where round 02's Messages 1 and 2 placed the concept's reach.", "alias": ["\\battributization\\b"], "cand_id": "D0032"}