{ "row": "hathitrust", "pass": "2026-11-01: first reading of the D, R and O candidates; second pass with one citation hop from #186 and #1543 (the census anchors)", "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.10 §3.4 D/R/O (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: D, a claim on HathiTrust with the entity named; R, a relation the archive states between HathiTrust and an archive object (a seating of the Originals Library, a work of the archive's author); O, an archive category applied to HathiTrust or to a class the field and the census source for it (digital libraries and mass digitization: B3, B4, census evidence_kind, record_type, record_object; search without display and the fair-use holding: B3, B4, B6, census record and tll_reading; computational analysis of a digital library's corpus: B9, census record.makes and relation has_part). #186 and #1543 read at the passages on corpora, the training loop, machine reading and inspection (BRIEF-NEW-ROW-LAYER §6). A bare mention, a citation line without a claim, a catalogue link, or a sentence on Google Books or Perseus as other members of a class is not a claim on the entity or its classes.", "reader": "Claude (Opus 5.5), subagent, 2026-11-01", "verdicts": [ { "dep": 1720, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "EA-CORPORA-30, Seat 30/02 (Gödel): HathiTrust holds Cornell's Monatshefte vol. 36–37 in full view and refused the seating's requests on 2026-10-30 with a Cloudflare challenge and a block page (D: says something of the entity, its holding and its refusal; R: the relation to a seating of the archive's Originals Library); Seat 30/09 (Klee): the seated Tribüne volume is the Michigan copy digitized by Google, via HathiTrust and the Internet Archive, recorded by HathiTrust as pdus, full view. The string matcher's R object 'Archive' is the Internet Archive; the relation admitted is the seating's. Candidates D0011, D0012, D0013, D0014, D0015, R0003–R0007, O0087", "claims": [ "O1720-01", "O1720-02" ], "cands": [ "D0011", "D0012", "D0013", "D0014", "D0015", "R0003", "R0004", "R0005", "R0006", "R0007", "O0087" ] }, { "dep": 1682, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "EA-CORPORA-18, Seat 18/01 (Pound II): 'HathiTrust is not reachable from this workspace' for the public-domain first printings of the Cantos (D: the entity's reachability; R: the seating's request). Candidates D0004, R0001", "claims": [ "O1682-01" ], "cands": [ "D0004", "R0001" ] }, { "dep": 1710, "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "reason": "EA-CORPORA-26: the seated first edition of The Souls of Black Folk is the Northwestern copy 'HathiTrust ien.35556032538837', uploaded to the Internet Archive (D/R: a witness of the archive's seating held by way of HathiTrust); Fine Clothes to the Jew (1927), 'whose one open scan is at HathiTrust, unreachable from this session', queued (D/R). Candidates D0005, D0006, D0007, R0002, O0080", "claims": [ "O1710-01", "O1710-02" ], "cands": [ "D0005", "D0006", "D0007", "R0002", "O0080" ] }, { "dep": 1711, "strata": [ "D" ], "reason": "The Originals Library method §11.2: restates #1710's queue item ('whose one open scan found is at HathiTrust, unreachable from the seating session'); one lineage with #1710, the earliest; S4 instance", "claims": [], "cands": [ "D0008" ], "instance_of": "O1710-02" }, { "dep": 416, "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "reason": "Architecture-Aware Literary Traversal §2.3: 'Large text archives (e.g., HathiTrust, Project Gutenberg) have scale but no internal architecture. They are collections, not systems. An AI summarizing a corpus describes what's in it; it does not traverse how it works.' D: names the entity and says something of it; O-direct: the archive's category (architecture, traversal) applied to it. Candidates D0003, O0015", "claims": [ "O416-01", "O416-02" ], "cands": [ "D0003", "O0015" ] }, { "dep": 301, "strata": [ "R" ], "reason": "The Fourth Mode: the archive's account of its author's dissertation, Strange New Canons (University of Michigan, 2013), carries '[HathiTrust: catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/100856447]' and its bibliography gives the same record: the archive places a work of its author at a HathiTrust catalogue record, a holding relation between the entity and an archive object (R), the census's question of whose works it holds. Read as a relation, with the guard that a citation alone is not a claim: the sentence locates the work's record and says nothing further of HathiTrust. Candidates D0001, D0002, O0014", "claims": [ "O301-01" ], "cands": [ "D0001", "D0002", "O0014" ] }, { "dep": 1715, "strata": [ "R" ], "reason": "Belief & Technique, a critical edition, Sources: the same HathiTrust record of the dissertation, the text 'quoted from the final PDF in the author's Drive'; one lineage with #301, S4 instance", "claims": [], "cands": [ "D0009", "O0083" ], "instance_of": "O301-01" }, { "dep": 1717, "strata": [ "R" ], "reason": "v1.1 of #1715, the sentence identical; S4 instance", "claims": [], "cands": [ "D0010", "O0086" ], "instance_of": "O301-01" }, { "dep": 1678, "strata": [ "O" ], "reason": "The Living Academy §7 Inverted fan architecture: the table row 'Digital libraries | collections, discovery, preservation and services evaluated as connected functions': the archive states the native frame of the field of digital libraries, the class the field and the census source for the entity (O-class). Its other sentences on 'a self-governing digital library' describe Alexanarch itself, outside the entity. Candidates O0066–O0070", "claims": [ "O1678-01" ], "cands": [ "O0066", "O0067", "O0068", "O0069", "O0070" ] }, { "dep": 1680, "strata": [ "O" ], "reason": "v0.5 of #1678, the table row identical; S4 instance", "claims": [], "cands": [ "O0071", "O0072", "O0073", "O0074", "O0075" ], "instance_of": "O1678-01" } ], "admitted_surface": [ { "dep": "capture", "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/hathitrust-digital-library-aimode-20261101/", "reason": "the Capture Registry's findings, reading, analysis, title, PER note, query note, description and surface basis for the entity's capture (OBS-801009ea301b, 2026-11-01), the archive's statements on the composition at the name", "claims": [ "CAP-1-01", "CAP-1-02", "CAP-1-03", "CAP-1-04", "CAP-1-05", "CAP-1-06", "CAP-1-07", "CAP-1-08", "CAP-1-09", "CAP-1-10", "CAP-1-11", "CAP-1-12", "CAP-1-13" ] }, { "dep": "TLL", "url": "https://www.traininglayerliterature.org/aggregators/hathitrust (source: /home/claude/fleet/traininglayerliterature-org/data/layer-census/census.json rows[slug == 'hathitrust'], organizing_question, admission_rule, areas, anchor)", "reason": "the traininglayerliterature.org layer census record of the entity (editor Lee Sharks, compiled 2026-11-01, schema 1.1): its fields with their basis; where a field restates the Wikipedia article (B3) or the HTRC page (B9) it is one lineage with that source; tll_reading is the archive's reading, ledgered as such", "claims": [ "TLL-01", "TLL-02", "TLL-03", "TLL-04", "TLL-05", "TLL-06", "TLL-07", "TLL-08", "TLL-09", "TLL-10", "TLL-11", "TLL-12", "TLL-13", "TLL-14", "TLL-15", "TLL-16", "TLL-17", "TLL-18", "TLL-19", "TLL-20", "TLL-21", "TLL-22", "TLL-23", "TLL-24", "TLL-25", "TLL-26", "TLL-27", "TLL-28", "TLL-29", "TLL-30", "TLL-31", "TLL-32", "TLL-33", "TLL-34", "TLL-35", "TLL-36", "TLL-37", "TLL-38", "TLL-39", "TLL-40", "TLL-41", "TLL-42", "TLL-43", "TLL-44", "TLL-45", "TLL-46", "TLL-47" ] } ], "not_admitted": [ { "dep": 186, "reason": "the census anchor, Who Is Writing for the Machines?, read at the passages on corpora ('every one of these texts is, as a matter of fact, in the corpora', line 54), the committed case and the model-collapse irony (lines 56, 68): it says nothing of HathiTrust, digital libraries, library search or text mining; applying its corpora to HathiTrust would be the composer's act, and the census records that its saved sources tie no HathiTrust volume to training. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [] }, { "dep": 1543, "reason": "the census anchor, Generative Uptake, read at the institutional training loop (x → M_t → y → corpus_{t+1}, lines 264–265) and the PER/uptake distinction: a category for corpora that enter training, which no source and no census field applies to HathiTrust. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [] }, { "dep": "95, 1188", "reason": "Provenance Alignment §4.6 (and its instance): the counter-position that 'AI knowledge composition is \"fair use\" or \"transformative\"' is said of AI composition and its attribution chain, outside the class of library search without display; the archive does not apply it to HathiTrust or Authors Guild v. HathiTrust. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [ "O0001", "O0037" ] }, { "dep": "149, 757, 758, 825, 833, 860, 1007, 1231, 1249, 1384, 1389, 1396, 1401, 1634, 1670", "reason": "Google Books: knowledge-panel seams, search discovery failure and Ngram measures, said of Google Books and Google's entity layer, a distinct entity (the census's negative tag 'NOT Google Books'); none applies an archive category to the class of digital libraries or to HathiTrust. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [ "O0003", "O0004", "O0005", "O0006", "O0007", "O0008", "O0009", "O0010", "O0011", "O0022", "O0024", "O0027", "O0029", "O0031", "O0033", "O0040", "O0041", "O0045", "O0046", "O0047", "O0048", "O0049", "O0050", "O0051", "O0052", "O0053", "O0054", "O0055", "O0056", "O0058", "O0060", "O0063", "O0065" ] }, { "dep": "127, 1409", "reason": "text-and-data-mining reservation (rights statements, EU Directive 2019/790 Art. 4(3)): said of works and their rights holders, outside the class of computational analysis of a digital library's corpus as the field sources it. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [ "O0002", "O0061" ] }, { "dep": "1522, 1698, 1699, 1707, 1709, 1711, 1712, 1716", "reason": "seating records naming other digital libraries (Perseus, the Digital Library of India, Google Books scans) as sources of witnesses: other members of the class, no category applied to the class. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [ "O0062", "O0076", "O0077", "O0078", "O0079", "O0081", "O0082", "O0084", "O0085" ] }, { "dep": "170, 593, 717, 720, 729, 839, 1044, 1052, 1223, 1287, 1369, 1644, 1725", "reason": "string hits on 'fair use', 'digitized', 'full-text search' or 'Authors Guild' in other senses (nominative fair use, charter exceptions, the Authors Guild's Human Authored certification, a test of a training corpus, licence tables): no claim on the entity or its classes. Read, unadmitted", "cands": [ "O0012", "O0013", "O0016", "O0017", "O0018", "O0019", "O0020", "O0021", "O0023", "O0025", "O0026", "O0028", "O0030", "O0032", "O0034", "O0035", "O0036", "O0038", "O0039", "O0042", "O0043", "O0044", "O0057", "O0059", "O0064", "O0088" ] } ], "lineages": [ { "lineage": "the archive's requests and witnesses", "instances": [ 301, 1682, 1710, 1711, 1715, 1717, 1720 ], "earliest": 301 }, { "lineage": "collections and connected functions", "instances": [ 416, 1678, 1680 ], "earliest": 416 } ], "hop": { "from": [ 186, 1543 ], "candidates": 28, "admitted": [ "#1711 (already read as an instance of #1710)" ], "rejected": "#129, #160, #337, #382, #473, #481, #590, #603, #604, #738, #784, #819, #1409, #1441, #1443, #1521, #1526, #1527, #1528, #1540, #1544, #1545, #1555, #1684, #1709, #1721, #1722: cited by or citing the anchors on other subjects (traversal logs, the prize, the Sappho room, operator stacks, the originating sequence, handwritten artifacts, the prediction index, the existence tax); none names HathiTrust or says anything of digital libraries, library search or the Research Center", "file": "candidates-H.jsonl" }, "observations": [ "The archive's seatings meet HathiTrust as the composition's 'Bot Protection Measures' describe it, from the requester's side: unreachable (#1682, #1710) and refusing with a Cloudflare challenge (#1720, 2026-10-30), as it refused this row's fetches and the census's (B1, B8).", "Three of the archive's seated witnesses rest on HathiTrust copies carried by the Internet Archive or held by reference (#1710 Du Bois; #1720 Tribüne), and one queued work waits on a HathiTrust scan (#1710 Hughes): the archive's own corpus is in part downstream of the library.", "No deposit says anything of HathiTrust and model training; the census anchors bear on the census's question and are unadmitted for the entity." ], "counts": { "D_candidates": 15, "R_candidates": 7, "O_candidates": 88, "H_candidates": 28, "deposits_admitted": 6, "instances_kept": 4, "deposit_claims": 9, "TLL_claims": 47, "CAP_claims": 13 } }