{
 "row": "avi-loeb-3i-atlas",
 "pass": "first reading, 2026-11-06; second pass with one citation hop from #1742 and #1743 (the A pool the brief names)",
 "procedure": "EA-NEGONT-02 v0.10 §3.4 D/R/O (working; not frozen). Admission by reading: D, a claim on Loeb's position on 3I/ATLAS with the entity named; R, a relation the archive states between the position and an archive object; O, an archive category applied to the position or its composition, or to a class the field sources for it (hypotheses of technological origin for an interstellar object and their grading: B5, B10, B13, B14). 'Loeb' alone guarded against the Loeb Classical Library; a bibliographic mention of the Library or of a Loeb edition is not a claim on the entity.",
 "reader": "Claude (Opus 5.5), subagent, 2026-11-06",
 "verdicts": [
  {
   "dep": 1742,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R",
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "What the Filters Kept (Nobel Glas, Orin Trace): §1 the Loeb Overview and the reading of his position (D); §1.4a and §9.10 the archive's categories applied to its composition (frame conversion, the trajectory substitution, PER-D, institutional-prior foreclosure: O); §12.2 and §12.7 the operator's rulings on the Overview and on Loeb (D); the investigation itself an archive work bearing on him (R). Read whole.",
   "claims": [
    "D1742-01",
    "D1742-02",
    "D1742-03",
    "D1742-04",
    "D1742-05",
    "D1742-06",
    "D1742-07",
    "D1742-08",
    "D1742-09",
    "D1742-10",
    "D1742-11",
    "D1742-12",
    "D1742-13",
    "D1742-14",
    "D1742-15",
    "D1742-16"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0035",
    "D0036",
    "D0037",
    "D0038",
    "D0039",
    "D0040",
    "D0041",
    "D0042",
    "D0043",
    "D0044",
    "D0045",
    "D0046",
    "D0047",
    "D0048",
    "D0049",
    "R0002",
    "R0003",
    "R0004",
    "O0013",
    "O0014",
    "O0015",
    "O0016",
    "O0017",
    "O0018",
    "O0019",
    "O0020"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": 1743,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "A Firm No (Lee Sharks): 'Start with one search', the position held from the beginning, Level 4 and no shift, the lie made of true sentences under frame conversion (D, O); 'The firm no', his reply to the radio nulls (D); 'What the public was told', the graded position as a concession (D). Read whole.",
   "claims": [
    "D1743-01",
    "D1743-02",
    "D1743-03",
    "D1743-04",
    "D1743-05",
    "D1743-06",
    "D1743-07",
    "D1743-08"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0050",
    "D0051",
    "D0052",
    "D0053",
    "D0054",
    "D0055",
    "D0056",
    "R0005",
    "O0021",
    "O0022",
    "O0023",
    "O0024"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": 454,
   "strata": [
    "D",
    "R"
   ],
   "reason": "THE ATLAS PERIHELION PRANK (Nobel Glas, 2026-02-06): reads his Medium analyses of November 2025 to January 2026 and his stance ('Loeb is not claiming contact. He is observing the epistemic precision of the anomaly.'), the archive's earlier line on the object (R, the relation of the position to the archive's own work); the brief names it for what bears on each entity. Earliest instance in the lineage: the blog post 'The Atlas Perihelion Prank' of 2025-10-30 (rebuild/3i-atlas-signal-search/claude/run-2026-11-03/blog-sources/, l. 1176–1180), the same sentences, collected in #454.",
   "claims": [
    "R454-01",
    "R454-02",
    "R454-03"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "D0005",
    "D0006",
    "D0007",
    "D0008",
    "D0009",
    "O0002",
    "H0001"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": 1727,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "The Sophistry Measure: X24 (§1.4) and the standing granted to a locus (§2.7), the categories its first run applies to the Overview's account of his position (S1, S2). Reached by the hop.",
   "claims": [
    "O1727-01",
    "O1727-02"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "H0013"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": 1523,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "Frame Conversion (§I, ll. 44–46): the category #1742 §1.4a and #1743 apply to the composition, named in the brief for this row. Reached by the hop.",
   "claims": [
    "O1523-01"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "H0009"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": 1694,
   "strata": [
    "O"
   ],
   "reason": "EA-PER-RECALC-01, rubric v1.1 (§3.9): PER-D as the entity's purpose and commitments, the sense the capture's finding[4] and #1742 §9.10 apply (attributing it to #1469). Reached by the hop.",
   "claims": [
    "O1694-01"
   ],
   "cands": [
    "H0011"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "admitted_surface": [
  {
   "dep": "capture",
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/avi-loeb-3i-atlas-aio-20261102/",
   "reason": "the Capture Registry's findings, reading, analysis, title, PER note, query note, operator note and source-frame note for the entity's capture (OBS-798655749d8c, 2026-11-02), the archive's statements on the composition at the name",
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-01",
    "CAP-1-02",
    "CAP-1-03",
    "CAP-1-04",
    "CAP-1-05",
    "CAP-1-06",
    "CAP-1-07",
    "CAP-1-08",
    "CAP-1-09",
    "CAP-1-10",
    "CAP-1-11",
    "CAP-1-12",
    "CAP-1-13",
    "CAP-1-14",
    "CAP-1-15",
    "CAP-1-16"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": "sophistry-run",
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/rebuild/3i-atlas-signal-search/claude/run-2026-11-03/sophistry/FINDINGS-sophistry.md",
   "reason": "the sophistry measure's first run on the 3I/ATLAS record (2026-11-06, filed with #1742): S1 and S2, the two findings on the Overview's account of his position, and the run's statement of what its findings establish",
   "claims": [
    "SOPH-01",
    "SOPH-02",
    "SOPH-03",
    "SOPH-04",
    "SOPH-05",
    "SOPH-06"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "not_admitted": [
  {
   "dep": "136, 625, 626, 828, 902, 926, 927, 1052, 1053, 1261, 1548, 1569, 1575, 1603, 1716, 1720, 1738",
   "reason": "the Loeb Classical Library and Loeb editions (Clouds, Sappho, Greek Lyric, Pindar, Ptolemy, Ovid and others) in bibliographies and source notes: a homonym of the person's name, no claim on the entity. Read, unadmitted",
   "cands": [
    "D0001",
    "D0002",
    "D0003",
    "D0004",
    "D0010",
    "D0011",
    "D0012",
    "D0013",
    "D0014",
    "D0015",
    "D0016",
    "D0017",
    "D0018",
    "D0019",
    "D0020",
    "D0021",
    "D0022",
    "D0023",
    "D0024",
    "D0025",
    "D0026",
    "D0027",
    "D0028",
    "D0029",
    "D0030",
    "D0031",
    "D0032",
    "D0033",
    "D0034",
    "R0001",
    "O0001",
    "O0003",
    "O0004",
    "O0005",
    "O0006",
    "O0007",
    "O0008",
    "O0009",
    "O0010",
    "O0011",
    "O0012"
   ]
  },
  {
   "dep": "1742 (header, title and SPXI packet lines), 1743 (header)",
   "reason": "front matter and packet fields that name Loeb or the Loeb Overview as a subject (title, keywords, about, related_ids) and restate claims ledgered from the body; carried by the body claims",
   "cands": [
    "D0035",
    "D0037",
    "D0038",
    "D0039",
    "D0040",
    "D0050",
    "R0002",
    "R0003",
    "R0004",
    "R0005",
    "O0013",
    "O0014",
    "O0021"
   ]
  }
 ],
 "hop": {
  "from": [
   1742,
   1743
  ],
  "candidates": 13,
  "admitted": [
   "#454",
   "#1523",
   "#1694",
   "#1727"
  ],
  "rejected": "#770, #931, #932, #1449, #1450, #1454, #1469, #1574, #1721: cited by #1742 or #1743 on the radio searches, classifier foreclosure, the null and the existence tax. #1450 (named in the brief for what a null constrains) and #770 say nothing of Loeb's position; #1742's applications of them are ledgered as #1742's claims (D1742-12). #1469 is read at its definition of PER-D (l. 67), which the capture and #1742 cite for a sense #1469 does not state; the sense is #1694's, admitted. #1721 is declined for this relation by #1742 §13.4.",
  "file": "candidates-H.jsonl"
 },
 "lineages": [
  {
   "lineage": "reception: the Overview at the name",
   "instances": [
    1742
   ],
   "earliest": 1742
  },
  {
   "lineage": "what the composition does to a held position",
   "instances": [
    1523,
    1694,
    1727,
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "earliest": 1523
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the position held: 'most likely natural' and Level 4 together",
   "instances": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "earliest": 1742
  },
  {
   "lineage": "a graded stance, no flat answer",
   "instances": [
    1742
   ],
   "earliest": 1742
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the Loeb Scale and Level 4",
   "instances": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "earliest": 1742
  },
  {
   "lineage": "his reply to the radio nulls",
   "instances": [
    1743
   ],
   "earliest": 1743
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the anomalies, each graded",
   "instances": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "earliest": 1742
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the archive's earlier reading of his position (2025–2026)",
   "instances": [
    454
   ],
   "earliest": 454
  }
 ],
 "observations": [
  "The archive names Loeb in two kinds of text: the 3I/ATLAS deposits (#454, #1742, #1743) and bibliographies of the Loeb Classical Library; only the first bear on the entity.",
  "The O-class pass (hypotheses of technological origin, their grading) returned two sentences, both in #1742 and #1743; the archive's other technosignature work (#931–#935, #1449, #1450) concerns classifiers and nulls and reaches the entity only through #1742.",
  "Three archive statements stand against a primary locus the field ledger holds: the ranking's first date, a probability for each April anomaly, and the attribution of PER-D's sense (marks in the plan)."
 ],
 "counts": {
  "D_candidates": 56,
  "D_deposits": 20,
  "R_candidates": 5,
  "R_deposits": 3,
  "O_candidates": 24,
  "O_deposits": 13,
  "H_candidates": 13,
  "deposits_admitted": 6,
  "deposit_claims": 31,
  "CAP_claims": 16,
  "SOPH_claims": 6
 },
 "lineages_composer": [
  {
   "lineage": "reception: the Overview at the name",
   "deposits": [
    1742
   ],
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-01",
    "CAP-1-05",
    "CAP-1-08",
    "CAP-1-09",
    "CAP-1-12",
    "CAP-1-13",
    "CAP-1-14",
    "D1742-01",
    "D1742-02",
    "SOPH-05"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "what the composition does to a held position",
   "deposits": [
    1523,
    1694,
    1727,
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-02",
    "CAP-1-03",
    "CAP-1-07",
    "CAP-1-11",
    "CAP-1-15",
    "D1742-04",
    "D1742-07",
    "D1742-08",
    "D1742-09",
    "D1742-10",
    "D1742-11",
    "D1742-12",
    "D1743-01",
    "D1743-05",
    "D1743-07",
    "SOPH-01",
    "SOPH-02",
    "SOPH-06",
    "O1727-01",
    "O1727-02",
    "O1523-01",
    "O1694-01"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the position held: 'most likely natural' and Level 4 together",
   "deposits": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-04",
    "CAP-1-10",
    "D1742-03",
    "D1742-05",
    "D1742-06",
    "D1742-14",
    "D1743-02",
    "D1743-04",
    "SOPH-04"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "a graded stance, no flat answer",
   "deposits": [
    1742
   ],
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-06",
    "D1742-13",
    "SOPH-03"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the Loeb Scale and Level 4",
   "deposits": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "claims": [
    "CAP-1-16",
    "D1742-15",
    "D1743-03"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "his reply to the radio nulls",
   "deposits": [
    1743
   ],
   "claims": [
    "D1743-06"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the anomalies, each graded",
   "deposits": [
    1742,
    1743
   ],
   "claims": [
    "D1742-16",
    "D1743-08"
   ]
  },
  {
   "lineage": "the archive's earlier reading of his position (2025–2026)",
   "deposits": [
    454
   ],
   "claims": [
    "R454-01",
    "R454-02",
    "R454-03"
   ]
  }
 ]
}