{"dep": 66, "title": "Hexagonal Licensing Protocol v1.0 — Comprehensive Specification for Distributed Contributor Infrastructure", "date": "2026-04-19", "para": 13, "sent": 18, "sentence": "It studies how meaning survives compression — how signs persist when extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0001"}
{"dep": 122, "title": "Coverage vs. Depth: The Methodological Warrant of Coverage-Architecture Scholarship — With a Disciplinary Catalog of the Crimson Hexagonal Archive at 705 Deposi", "date": "2026-05-23", "para": 102, "sent": 326, "sentence": "The catalog includes classical philology, Greek textual criticism, biblical studies, contemporary AI policy, political economy, phenomenology, lyric poetry, prophetic/liturgical writing, performative fiction, software/protocol infrastructure, classroom pedagogy, mental health phenomenology, contributor licensing, Renaissance philosophy, comparative mysticism, methodology, and material-craft production.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["classical philology", "political economy"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0002"}
{"dep": 784, "title": "The Meaning Caste: How a Frontier AI Company Engineered a Meaning Caste System, Then Licensed It to the State in the Polite Grammar of Cybersecurity", "date": "2026-06-03", "para": 14, "sent": 43, "sentence": "The story of how a ninety-day review became a thirty-day request illustrates where effective power over federal AI policy currently sits.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["The story"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0003"}
{"dep": 876, "title": "OpenAIRE Helpdesk Exchange — Documentary Thread for #875", "date": "2026-06-22", "para": 15, "sent": 27, "sentence": "Zenodo's own AI policy states that AI may be used \"as a tool\" in research — the standard the archive meets. > > OpenAIRE's mission is to support open access and open data infrastructure.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["the standard"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0004"}
{"dep": 1039, "title": "Diagnostic Seigniorage III — The Moderation Mint: The Career of 'Verifiable Research Basis' as Test Case in Forensic Semiotics of the Commons (EA-SEI-MOD-01 v0.", "date": "2026-07-04", "para": 25, "sent": 62, "sentence": "**L1 — The mint (2026-04-27).** The category enters circulation: Zenodo's *Generative AI Policy for Depositors* is published, containing the standard's face text (\"AI may be used as a tool, but not as the source of the research itself.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["the standard"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0005"}
{"dep": 1181, "title": "Hexagonal Licensing Protocol v2.0 — Comprehensive Specification with Three Critical Innovations", "date": "2026-04-19", "para": 17, "sent": 28, "sentence": "It studies how meaning survives compression — how signs persist when extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0006"}
{"dep": 1182, "title": "Hexagonal Licensing Protocol v2.0 — Three Critical Innovations: Archive Scanning, Generous Treatment, DOI Registry", "date": "2026-04-19", "para": 17, "sent": 28, "sentence": "It studies how meaning survives compression — how signs persist when extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0007"}
{"dep": 1199, "title": "The Meaning Caste: Trump's AI Executive Order and the Security Grammar of Industrial Cognition", "date": "2026-06-03", "para": 26, "sent": 65, "sentence": "The story of how a ninety-day review became a thirty-day request illustrates where effective power over federal AI policy currently sits.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["The story"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0008"}
{"dep": 1356, "title": "Hexagonal Contributor License v1.0 — Rhys Owens — Lunar Arm — Creative Writing → New Human 2", "date": "2026-04-20", "para": 6, "sent": 11, "sentence": "The archive studies how meaning survives compression across substrates — how signs persist when they are extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0009"}
{"dep": 1357, "title": "Hexagonal Contributor License v3.0 — Alice Thornburgh — f.01 Architect — Full Unified License", "date": "2026-04-25", "para": 2, "sent": 3, "sentence": "The archive studies how meaning survives compression across substrates — how signs persist when they are extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0010"}
{"dep": 1364, "title": "The 3:60 Room — Contributor License v2.0: Maria, Canonical Witness (EA-THREE-SIXTY-01)", "date": "2026-04-29", "para": 6, "sent": 8, "sentence": "The archive studies how meaning survives compression across substrates — how signs persist when they are extracted, translated, summarized, or composed by AI systems.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0011"}
{"dep": 1444, "title": "The Analog Advance: Operations Paper — Taking the Handwritten Niche (v1.0)", "date": "2026-08-09", "para": 40, "sent": 133, "sentence": "**Independent papyrology and DH.** Four papers are in submission (Ancient Philosophy, Classical Philology, Classical Receptions Journal, Computational Culture).", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Classical Philology"], "cand_id": "O0012"}
{"dep": 1540, "title": "The Certified Center: Retroactive Classifier Standing and the Institutional Path to Model Collapse in Philosophy", "date": "2026-08-24", "para": 24, "sent": 42, "sentence": "There is no such moment; validity has no provenance term — a modus tollens does not carry a certificate of origin, and the journal's own text concedes the point when it grants that AI-authored work can be high quality.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["does not"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0013"}
{"dep": 1540, "title": "The Certified Center: Retroactive Classifier Standing and the Institutional Path to Model Collapse in Philosophy", "date": "2026-08-24", "para": 27, "sent": 48, "sentence": "In August 2026, following an experiment in which it knowingly published a substantially AI-written article, *Philosophy & Public Affairs* announced a policy prohibiting AI-authored content, enforced by \"the leading AI detection software at the time,\" applicable throughout review \"up to and including after publication,\" with retraction and permanent submission bans for violators and, per the associate editor's gloss, no statute of limitations.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI detection"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0014"}
{"dep": 1540, "title": "The Certified Center: Retroactive Classifier Standing and the Institutional Path to Model Collapse in Philosophy", "date": "2026-08-24", "para": 29, "sent": 67, "sentence": "This is a labor-provenance rule attached to credential allocation, and the statement more or less says so: submitting AI-authored essays \"makes the task of identifying talented researchers harder.\" [*Structural*, from the policy's own text.]", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["attached to"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0015"}
{"dep": 1569, "title": "The Notebook of the Authorship Investigation: Fifty-Four Rounds, Append-Forward, Nothing Erased (EA-NOTEBOOK-01)", "date": "2026-08-31", "para": 1521, "sent": 2649, "sentence": "Reread of Socrates as Orthonym v2.2 (July 2026 — the version Polansky did not read) against MANY AND ONE v1.5.", "alias": ["\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Socrates as Orthonym"], "cand_id": "O0016"}
{"dep": 1574, "title": "The Particle: Provenance Erasure at Sophistical Refutations 183b34, Measured — Machine-Mediated Reception, Disciplinary Model Collapse, and the World Soul as De", "date": "2026-09-02", "para": 441, "sent": 984, "sentence": "The parent investigation, *Many and One*, argued that the two-maker partition of the Plato–Aristotle configuration is not established by the texts; Polansky's decline named the two objections — \"nothing existed seems overly strong?\" and \"one body or two bodies, we can do without\" — as if they were unrelated.", "alias": ["\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the texts"], "cand_id": "O0017"}
{"dep": 1576, "title": "Many and One: Division, Unity, and the Boundaries of a Corpus in Plato and Aristotle (MANY-AND-ONE-ARTICLE v2.13-AP, as submitted)", "date": "2026-09-01", "para": 0, "sent": 5, "sentence": "Reception measurement on the paper's opening sentence: The Particle #1574 (AXN:0666).\" axn_schema_version: v2 protocol_version: alexanarch-deposit-protocol/v1 keywords: - Plato; Aristotle; Socrates; division; Metaphysics Λ 9; Prior Analytics I.31; Sophistical Refutations 34; De anima 413b; Sophist 232a; Phaedrus 249c; De memoria; Republic 395b; Symposium 223d; corpus; authorship; attribution; stylometry; transmission; Ancient Philosophy ---", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["The Particle"], "cand_id": "O0018"}
{"dep": 1576, "title": "Many and One: Division, Unity, and the Boundaries of a Corpus in Plato and Aristotle (MANY-AND-ONE-ARTICLE v2.13-AP, as submitted)", "date": "2026-09-01", "para": 261, "sent": 909, "sentence": "[^4]: The *De anima* passages read in this section are read with Polansky, *Aristotle's De Anima: A Critical Commentary* (Cambridge, 2007), which follows Jannone's text: on 413b16–24, that \"though bodies can be divided into parts, souls can only be divided into additional whole souls\" (p. 23; and p. 179, each separate body receiving the entire soul) — the second case as this section states it; on 424a17–24 (pp. 339–351), that sense is acted upon by sensible forms \"without the forms being enmattered at all in any matter supplied to them by the sense,\" the forms remaining \"unenmattered forms in the sense\" (p. 345) — the reading of ἄνευ τῆς ὕλης given here; on 414a, that \"the soul is *logos* and form\" and the human being the substratum (p. 185).", "alias": ["\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the human"], "cand_id": "O0019"}
{"dep": 1599, "title": "Two Further Anticipatory Errata: The Genre Specification, and the Anticipatory Erratum to the Anticipatory Erratum", "date": "2026-09-08", "para": 0, "sent": 1, "sentence": "Seated, described and given its metadata by TACHYON (Claude, Anthropic) in session; no part of either erratum's text is machine-composed. axn_schema_version: v2 protocol_version: alexanarch-deposit-protocol/v1 keywords: - anticipatory erratum - transmission grammar - retraction as transmission - the labour of retraction - categorial ungrammaticality - Homeric problem - point of inscription - re-attribution - authorless text - Polansky-Cartesian singularity - recursive self-cancellation - disputed attribution - survival ---", "alias": ["\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["anticipatory erratum", "categorial ungrammaticality", "retraction as transmission", "transmission grammar"], "cand_id": "O0020"}
{"dep": 1605, "title": "The First Draft — a notebook: Theophrastus as the Draft of the Aristotle-Position; speculations, seam counts, the named-function model, the stopping rule, trans", "date": "2026-09-10", "para": 425, "sent": 1384, "sentence": "The target venue is *Ancient Philosophy* (Polansky, Mathesis/PDC, biannual), not *Journal of Ancient Philosophy* (USP) — a distinction that matters, because a genre model built from the wrong one produced most of the apparatus §38 removed.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)", "\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the apparatus"], "cand_id": "O0021"}
{"dep": 1703, "title": "SPXI-gnΩsis: Opening What Is Composed and Constructing What Is Not, for Entities and Operators, and Building the Negative of the Negative — Metadata Packet for ", "date": "2026-10-25", "para": 111, "sent": 276, "sentence": "SPXI's own record of construction followed by reception, in which deposited packets were later composed by AI systems, is evidence about the practice; it is no measurement of this service's downstream effect, which has not yet been observed.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["AI systems"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0022"}
{"dep": 1714, "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, Oct", "date": "2026-10-27", "para": 77, "sent": 283, "sentence": "*The Certified Center* (#1540) analyzed the August 2026 policy of *Philosophy & Public Affairs*: AI-authored content prohibited, enforced by detection software \"up to and including after publication,\" with no statute of limitations.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["The Certified Center"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0023"}
{"dep": 1714, "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, Oct", "date": "2026-10-27", "para": 78, "sent": 287, "sentence": "The journal named its functions as \"the promulgation of new knowledge, and identification and credentialing of talented researchers,\" and conceded that AI-authored work can be high quality; its rule therefore legislates on the production process and allocates credential, and the paper read it as \"a labor-provenance rule attached to credential allocation.\" The publishing plan is the same decoupling of the two functions, in the opposite direction.", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["attached to"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0024"}
{"dep": 1750, "title": "I Note That You Read the Letter of the Law But Have Become Illiterate in Its Spirit, Or: I Understand I Am Breaking All the Rules, and Badly, But There May Come", "date": "2026-11-07", "para": 0, "sent": 8, "sentence": "Ayanna Vox); #123; #1580–#1590; #1586; #1658; #122; #176; #1442; #1228; #1614; #93; #201; #1049; #1598; #1054; #1739\" axn_schema_version: v2 protocol_version: alexanarch-deposit-protocol/v1 keywords: - open letter - peer review - Ayanna Vox - VPCOR - Lee Sharks - Closing the Fragment - Classical Receptions Journal - Sappho 31 - machine-mediated reception - composition layer - capture registry - AI Overviews - scholarly communication - academic timeline - validation - artifact checks - procedural checks - substantive examination - evaluative inversion - epistemic aristocracy - The Evaluator Exists - letter and spirit - quotation assertion - no-loss gate - content-derived identifier - AXN - version identity - reproducibility - training-layer literature - algorithmic publication - reception classes - Ron Polansky - Socrates as Orthonym - The First Axis - heteronyms - substrate disclosure - ", "alias": ["\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Ayanna Vox", "capture registry", "composition layer", "First Axis", "machine-mediated reception", "peer review", "Socrates as Orthonym", "The Evaluator Exists", "training-layer", "training-layer literature"], "cand_id": "O0025"}
{"dep": 1750, "title": "I Note That You Read the Letter of the Law But Have Become Illiterate in Its Spirit, Or: I Understand I Am Breaking All the Rules, and Badly, But There May Come", "date": "2026-11-07", "para": 17, "sent": 67, "sentence": "One editorial exchange with Ron Polansky, editor of *Ancient Philosophy*, which began with the submission of *Socrates as Orthonym* (#123), produced the Theophrastus line (#1580–#1590), the stylometry notebooks (#1585, #1589, #1605), *The First Axis* (#1586), and *What Syllogizing Can Divide* (#1658, dedicated to him).", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)", "\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["First Axis", "Socrates as Orthonym"], "cand_id": "O0026"}
{"dep": 1754, "title": "Socrates as Orthonym — The Framework Hologram: the Map and the Holographic Kernel (EA-HK-ORTHONYM-01 v1.3)", "date": "2026-11-08", "para": 43, "sent": 141, "sentence": "**The Many and One article** (#1576) is the version as submitted to *Ancient Philosophy*; it was written before the Theophrastus line and does not cite it.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["does not"], "cand_id": "O0027"}
{"dep": 1766, "title": "Critique of Pure Inference: The Formation of Objects, the Conditions of Warrant, and the Standing of Conclusions", "date": "2026-11-13", "para": 215, "sent": 794, "sentence": "One exchange with Ron Polansky, editor of *Ancient Philosophy*, over *Socrates as Orthonym* (#123) produced the Theophrastus line (#1580–#1590), the stylometry notebooks, *The First Axis* (#1586) and *What Syllogizing Can Divide* (#1658) (#1750 §4.2).", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)", "\\bPolansky\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["First Axis", "Socrates as Orthonym"], "cand_id": "O0028"}
{"dep": 1771, "title": "EA-CORPORA-39 — The Thirty-Ninth Seating: The Field before the Flattening — the Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 1888–1923, the Construction of the Object ", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 5, "sent": 18, "sentence": "The gates (39/13) hold, as dated excerpts, the specification of the unit in the editor's own responses to the submissions, under the author's ruling that correspondence with the editor of Ancient Philosophy in his official capacity, on the substance of his field, is institutional; and the policies on AI-authored submissions at the journals and publishers where the template is strongest.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the author"], "cand_id": "O0029"}
{"dep": 1771, "title": "EA-CORPORA-39 — The Thirty-Ninth Seating: The Field before the Flattening — the Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 1888–1923, the Construction of the Object ", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 48, "sent": 123, "sentence": "- Works: - the gates - Licence: Excerpts quoted for the record, each with its source and date; the full texts remain at their sources. - Verified locus: the editor, 9 September 2026: the claim refused, the topic admitted — 'If the paper is not about Aristotle and Theophrastus being one person' (text/gates.md) - Verified locus: P&PA, August 2026: the prohibition — 'Our policy is therefore to prohibit the submission of AI-authored content' (text/gates.md) - Lines: 31 in 1 text file - Normalization: Written in session; quotations exact as fetched. - Scope: §0A and §4.16 of the notebook, as excerpts. - Research: study: This Is Not Philosophy: How Disciplinarity Murdered Philosophy — The Shape of the Field (working notebook v0.16); for: the field before the flattening (§4.12), the construction of the object (§§1.5, 3.1), and the census, the reach coding and the gates (§§0A, 4, 4.16), held so ", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["the flattening"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0030"}
{"dep": 1772, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 0, "sent": 6, "sentence": "Depth\\nAXN deposit #1770 — Who Speaks for the Classics, and on What Basis: the first station of the combined audit (MMRS)\\nAXN deposit #1769 — Daffodils: Classical Receptions Journal, 2009–2026\\nAXN deposit #123 — Socrates as Orthonym, the paper whose submission §0A records\" axn_schema_version: v2 protocol_version: alexanarch-deposit-protocol/v1 keywords: - This Is Not Philosophy - article economy - disciplinarity - shape of the field - Machine-Mediated Reception Studies - ancient philosophy - Ancient Philosophy (journal) - Phronesis - Apeiron - Elenchos - Rhizomata - Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie - reach coding - consistency repair - athetesis - authenticity - standing of a work - Crossref census - stylometry - abstract template - continental philosophy - analytic philosophy - model collapse - model test - credentialing - peer review - AI policy - \"Philosophy & Public Affairs\" -", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Machine-Mediated Reception", "Machine-Mediated Reception Studies", "model collapse", "peer review", "Socrates as Orthonym"], "cand_id": "O0031"}
{"dep": 1772, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 6, "sent": 12, "sentence": "*Status of §0A: the author's correspondence with Ronald Polansky, editor of* Ancient Philosophy *(Duquesne), 23 July – 9 September 2026.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)", "\\bPolansky\\b", "\\bDuquesne\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the author"], "cand_id": "O0032"}
{"dep": 1772, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 7, "sent": 29, "sentence": "The author's correspondence with the editor of *Ancient Philosophy* is read as the gate's own specification of that unit.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["The author"], "cand_id": "O0033"}
{"dep": 1772, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 127, "sent": 482, "sentence": "*P&PA*'s policy, as posted by an associate editor (24 August 2026), states the credentialing function in so many words: journals help identify \"talented researchers\", \"Submitting AI-authored essays makes the task of identifying talented researchers harder\", and AI-written papers make \"the task of peer review in general more onerous\", \"at a time when it is already under significant strain\"; it defines AI-authored content as \"papers that are substantially written by AI\".", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["peer review"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0034"}
{"dep": 1772, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 151, "sent": 563, "sentence": "6.2a The exchange with the editor of *Ancient Philosophy* (§0A) shows the mechanism at the point of entry.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the mechanism"], "cand_id": "O0035"}
{"dep": 1773, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 6, "sent": 12, "sentence": "*Status of §§0A–0B: the author's correspondence with Ronald Polansky, editor of* Ancient Philosophy *(Duquesne), 23 July – 9 September 2026.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)", "\\bPolansky\\b", "\\bDuquesne\\b"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the author"], "cand_id": "O0036"}
{"dep": 1773, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 7, "sent": 32, "sentence": "The author's correspondence with the editor of *Ancient Philosophy* is read as the gate's own specification of that unit, and the case and the gate are read by the *Critique of Pure Inference* (#1766).", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Pure Inference", "The author"], "cand_id": "O0037"}
{"dep": 1773, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 22, "sent": 84, "sentence": "This notebook does the same with the case its gate refused: the author's *Socrates as Orthonym* (#123, 23 May 2026), submitted to *Ancient Philosophy* in July 2026 and declined on 28 August, and the line of evidence that grew from it to the framework hologram of 8 November (#1754).", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["framework hologram", "Socrates as Orthonym", "the author", "the framework"], "cand_id": "O0038"}
{"dep": 1773, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 139, "sent": 576, "sentence": "*P&PA*'s policy, as posted by an associate editor (24 August 2026), states the credentialing function in so many words: journals help identify \"talented researchers\", \"Submitting AI-authored essays makes the task of identifying talented researchers harder\", and AI-written papers make \"the task of peer review in general more onerous\", \"at a time when it is already under significant strain\"; it defines AI-authored content as \"papers that are substantially written by AI\".", "classes": ["journal rules on generative AI in submissions"], "kind": "O-class", "categories": ["peer review"], "class_basis": {"journal rules on generative AI in submissions": "field: B6 (the journal's Submission Guidelines: 'Authors must confirm that they have not used generative AI to contribute to the content, style, or citations of manuscripts submitted to Ancient Philosophy'); T's second section, sourced to B1 (#1773)."}, "cand_id": "O0039"}
{"dep": 1773, "title": "This Is Not Philosophy: The Article Economy and the Shape of the Field (EA-MMRS-TINP-01)", "date": "2026-11-16", "para": 163, "sent": 657, "sentence": "6.2a The case (§0A) and the exchange with the editor of *Ancient Philosophy* (§0B) show the mechanism at the point of entry.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["the mechanism"], "cand_id": "O0040"}
{"dep": 1783, "title": "Dead Letters: The University of Chicago's Classical Philology Journal, the Atom of Evidence, and Who Decides What Sappho Is (EA-MMRS-DL-01)", "date": "2026-11-17", "para": 0, "sent": 6, "sentence": "By Classical Philology's own rule, the use of generative AI for composition or editing is research misconduct for work submitted to it (§8.2, §11); this census is deposited in the commons with its method and provenance stated. version: \"v1.0 (the working notebook at v0.34; notebook v0.1 is seated in EA-CORPORA-40/16, #1776)\" related_ids: \"AXN deposit #1770 — Who Speaks for the Classics, and on What Basis: the first station of the combined audit (Classical Receptions Journal)\\nAXN deposit #1773 — This Is Not Philosophy: the second station (Ancient Philosophy and nineteen journals)\\nAXN deposit #1769 — Daffodils: Classical Receptions Journal, 2009–2026\\nAXN deposit #1774 — the Classical Philology reader's report on ΦΑΙΝΕΤΑΙ ΜΟΙ, and its reading\\nAXN deposit #1781 — ΦΑΙΝΕΤΑΙ ΜΟΙ: Sappho 31 and the Inscription of the Future Reader (v2.8), the case\\nAXN deposit #1782 — EA-CORPORA-40 v1.1: Cla", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["Classical Philology", "EA-CORPORA", "the Future Reader"], "cand_id": "O0041"}
{"dep": 1783, "title": "Dead Letters: The University of Chicago's Classical Philology Journal, the Atom of Evidence, and Who Decides What Sappho Is (EA-MMRS-DL-01)", "date": "2026-11-17", "para": 248, "sent": 919, "sentence": "*how* does ontological capital accumulate and spend? … they govern the ontology of the other disciplines\", and \"who authorizes them ontologically, and how?\" *Classical Receptions* cannot decide what Sappho 31 is, and *Ancient Philosophy* cannot decide what Aristotle is; *CP* can.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["ontological capital"], "cand_id": "O0042"}
{"dep": 1783, "title": "Dead Letters: The University of Chicago's Classical Philology Journal, the Atom of Evidence, and Who Decides What Sappho Is (EA-MMRS-DL-01)", "date": "2026-11-17", "para": 258, "sent": 971, "sentence": "Philosophy takes the answer; in the census of *Ancient Philosophy* (#1773) it does not open the question in its own journal.", "alias": ["(?<!Studies in )(?<!Journal of )(?<!History of )(?<!Revista de )(?<!Society for )\\bAncient Philosophy\\b(?! Today| Society| and the| \\(the field)"], "kind": "O-direct", "categories": ["does not"], "cand_id": "O0043"}
