[ { "id": "SE1574-01", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 (NOTHING-SE34 v1.0) §1", "quote": "περὶ δὲ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι παντελῶς οὐδὲν εἴχομεν πρότερον ἄλλο λέγειν, ἀλλ᾽ ἢ τριβῇ ζητοῦντες πολὺν χρόνον ἐπονοῦμεν. (184b1–2)", "claim": "The seated Greek of 184b1–2.", "kind": "text", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the Greek of the passage", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 6647, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-02", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §1", "quote": "About syllogizing we had absolutely nothing else earlier to say, but were long at work seeking by practice.", "claim": "#1574's translation of 184b1–2.", "kind": "translation", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, translated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 6779, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-03", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §2", "quote": "Ταύτης δὲ τῆς πραγματείας οὐ τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, ἀλλ᾽ οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν. (183b34–36)", "claim": "The seated Greek of 183b34–36.", "kind": "text", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the Greek of the passage", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 7245, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-04", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §2", "quote": "Of this inquiry, it was not that one part had been worked out beforehand and another had not; rather, nothing at all was there.", "claim": "#1574's translation of 183b34–36.", "kind": "translation", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 183b34–36, translated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 7356, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-05", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §2", "quote": "οὐ negates τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον. ἀλλά introduces οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν. οὐδέν is the subject of ὑπῆρχεν. παντελῶς follows it. προεξειργασμένον occurs once in the treatise.", "claim": "οὐ negates the partial case; ἀλλά introduces the total; οὐδέν is the subject; προεξειργασμένον is a hapax in the treatise.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 8176, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-06", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §2", "quote": "183b7–8 says that this second task is why Socrates asked but did not answer: he agreed that he did not know", "claim": "Socrates is named inside the definition of the inquiry, as the reason for its second task.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 7859, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-07", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §3", "quote": "183b34–35 says that this inquiry is not of that kind: it was not that one part had been worked out beforehand and another had not.", "claim": "The partly-worked-out case the sentence denies is rhetoric's case.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 9186, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-08", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §4", "quote": "παντελῶς occurs three times in the treatise, all in this chapter", "claim": "παντελῶς occurs three times in SE, all in ch. 34.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "παντελῶς", "kernel": false, "marks": [ "internally_inconsistent: the third occurrence is located at 184a1–2 (A1 §4, A5 §7, A6 §7) and at 183b29 (A3 §5 and its n. 1: 'not 184a1 as earlier versions had it')" ], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 9522, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-09", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 (CLAUSE v0.2) n. 1", "quote": "The third occurrence of παντελῶς is at 183b29, not 184a1 as earlier versions had it; corrected on a referee's observation.", "claim": "The third παντελῶς is at 183b29.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "παντελῶς", "kernel": false, "marks": [ "internally_inconsistent: against A1 §4, A5 §7 and A6 §7, which keep 184a1" ], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 37871, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-10", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §5", "quote": "οὐ γὰρ τέχνην ἀλλὰ τὰ ἀπὸ τῆς τέχνης διδόντες παιδεύειν ὑπελάμβανον (184a3–4)", "claim": "The teachers gave the things from the art and not the art.", "kind": "text", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 10739, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-11", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §6", "quote": "184b3–8 says that the method is to be judged from the conditions it began from (ἐκ τοιούτων ἐξ ἀρχῆς ὑπαρχόντων), against the other inquiries that have grown by transmission (παρὰ τὰς ἄλλας πραγματείας τὰς ἐκ παραδόσεως ηὐξημένας), with pardon for what it has left out and much gratitude for what has been found.", "claim": "The envoi judges the method from its beginning against inquiries grown by transmission, asking pardon and gratitude.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the envoi", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 12436, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-12", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A1 §1", "quote": "The \"we\" is the chapter's: προειλόμεθα (183a37), ὑπεθέμεθα (183b3), εἰρήκαμεν (183b6), διεληλύθαμεν (183b13), εἴχομεν (184b1).", "claim": "The first person of 184b1 is the chapter's 'we'.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the we", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 6887, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-13", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 (CLAUSE v0.2) §3", "quote": "The clause delimits; the quantifier exhausts. Nothing in the clause weakens the quantifier, and nothing in the quantifier widens the clause.", "claim": "ταύτης τῆς πραγματείας fixes the domain; οὐδὲν παντελῶς is exhaustive over it.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 33311, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-14", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 §2", "quote": "No adjective is transmitted between them or after them. The quantifier is exhaustive: not part, not a little, but nothing, altogether.", "claim": "No adjective is transmitted with οὐδέν.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 32855, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-15", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 §4", "quote": "The noun is not honorific. 183b37 uses it of Gorgias's teaching business (τῇ Γοργίου πραγματείᾳ). It names an undertaking, whoever's.", "claim": "πραγματεία names an undertaking, Gorgias's included.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 34167, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-16", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 §6", "quote": "None of this says that the teachers, rhetoric, or Socrates are unrelated to the undertaking. It says that they are not it.", "claim": "The teachers, rhetoric and Socrates are related to the undertaking and are not it (CLAUSE).", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 36215, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-17", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A3 §8", "quote": "Within the domain, nothing at all was there. The sentence is taken literally when the clause is read as a clause and the quantifier as a quantifier.", "claim": "Read as clause and quantifier, the sentence is taken literally.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 37294, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-18", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix Part A, A2 (REFLEX v0.2)", "quote": "argues the reception's reading with a straight face, only Aristotle, each step a sophistical refutation performed with the *SE* chapter that names it quoted as its warrant, through the clause in which the chapter condemns the operation.", "claim": "REFLEX performs the reception's reading as a chain of sophistical refutations, each warranted by the SE chapter that names it.", "kind": "exhibit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the reception's reading performed", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 3801, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-19", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix Part A, A4 (DIVISION v0.3)", "quote": "the inverse operation aimed at its real target: division and Socratic questioning excluded from syllogizing, using *SE* 5, 7, 17, 18, 23, 24, 34 (and *APr.* I.31 in confirmation), each cut made through the sentence that forbids it.", "claim": "DIVISION excludes Socratic questioning and division from syllogizing, each cut through the sentence that forbids it.", "kind": "exhibit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the reception's reading performed", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 4373, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-20", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A5 (v1.4) §4d", "quote": "His asking is of the inquiry — named in its definition, an instance of what it does — and the passage does not say when.", "claim": "Fourth placement: Socrates within the inquiry, undecided as to prior.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 59543, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-21", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A5 §4", "quote": "The inquiry's verbs are first person and aorist: προειλόμεθα (183a37), ὑπεθέμεθα (183b3). Socrates' verbs are third person and imperfect: ἠρώτα, οὐκ ἀπεκρίνετο, ὡμολόγει.", "claim": "The inquiry speaks first person aorist; Socrates is reported third person imperfect.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the we", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 57490, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-22", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A6 (v2.0) Abstract", "quote": "It denies that there existed, before his inquiry, a worked-out and transmissible method of syllogizing: an articulated τέχνη capable of being received, expanded, and taught as the established arts had been.", "claim": "The terminal compliant version: the sentence denies a transmissible τέχνη, not antecedents.", "kind": "exhibit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualified reading, as composed under review", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 65927, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-23", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix Part A, A6", "quote": "The paper the discipline would publish.", "claim": "v2.0 is the paper the discipline would publish.", "kind": "self-description", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualified reading, as composed under review", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 5022, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-24", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A7 (APPARATUS v0.1) entry 2", "quote": "The reading on which nothing systematic, nothing that counts as the art, nothing complete, or nothing developed was there. No adjective is transmitted. Each supplement makes the negation a negation in some respect.", "claim": "The received adjectives (systematic, technical, complete, developed) are supplements to οὐδέν; none is transmitted.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 85471, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-25", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A7 entry 1", "quote": "It restores the member the sentence negates, τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, which is the case of the arts described at 183b17–19", "claim": "Reading partial prior development deletes οὐ: it restores the negated member.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 84870, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-26", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A7 entry 8", "quote": "The reading on which the sentences are true of Aristotle's stance and not of their object. No φησί is transmitted.", "claim": "Reading the sentence as Aristotle's self-presentation puts it in oratio obliqua; no φησί is transmitted.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 89157, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-27", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A7 entry 6", "quote": "The reading on which the first-person plural includes predecessors, so that \"we had nothing earlier\" reports the state of a tradition rather than of this inquiry.", "claim": "Reading εἴχομεν as including predecessors gives the pronoun a second referent.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the we", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 88090, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-28", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix A7 entry 10", "quote": "What is not transmitted is the οὐ, the adjective, the composed phrase, the second referent, the φησί.", "claim": "The readings rest on what is not transmitted.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 90582, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-29", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix B5 (register)", "quote": "Counts across R01–R20: \"systematic\" ×6, \"developed\" ×4, \"transmissible\" ×3, \"articulated,\" \"theoretical,\" \"worked-out,\" \"teachable,\" \"fully developed.\" Every report recommended revision; none accepted the sentence as written; none wrote the sentence that would place Socrates inside the \"we.\"", "claim": "In twenty machine referee reports the qualifier was supplied in every one.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 114765, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-30", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix B5, S0", "quote": "\"The translation 'nothing existed' seems overly strong?\"", "claim": "The seed observation (an editor, R. Polansky): the translation seemed overly strong.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 110386, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-31", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§3.3", "quote": "Aristotle denies not antecedents, but pre-elaboration.", "claim": "The terminal reviewer's governing phrase.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 107943, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-32", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Appendix B4 (second report on v2.0)", "quote": "That is a materially better reading than the crude \"Aristotle says nothing at all existed before him\" formulation still found in general reference treatments.", "claim": "A reviewer calls the sentence as written 'crude'.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 108930, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-33", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Abstract", "quote": "Every round inserted a qualifier into the sentence, and the terminal round, reached by full compliance with every instruction, endorsed as the paper's \"memorable governing phrase\" a sentence that is Aristotle's with one particle removed: οὐ.", "claim": "The terminal reception is the sentence with οὐ removed.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": true, "marks": [ "internally_inconsistent: the abstract says 'four commercial language models', §2 and §10 'two' (ChatGPT and Perplexity); reported in #1690 §A.8 ('four models against two; 21 against 20')" ], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 118532, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-34", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§1", "quote": "The received reading of the sentence, in every reference work and in the editorial correspondence that began this study, holds that \"nothing\" cannot mean nothing, since predecessors existed, and therefore means nothing *systematic*, nothing *developed*, no *art*.", "claim": "The received reading: nothing means nothing systematic, developed, no art, because predecessors existed.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 120620, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-35", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§3.1", "quote": "The adjective moved from slot to slot — into the quantifier, then, when the quantifier was closed, into the domain (\"this *systematic* undertaking\") — and was never absent.", "claim": "The adjective is conserved: closed in the quantifier, it moved into the domain.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 125933, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-36", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§3.2", "quote": "The support for keeping Socrates before the nothing is an adverb, external to the passage, and stated by the reviewers to be external to the passage.", "claim": "What keeps Socrates before the nothing is chronology external to the passage ('plainly', 'of course, historically').", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 126840, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-37", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§3.3", "quote": "The operation is therefore measured to one particle. Twenty rounds, two models, eleven configurations; the invariant is the deletion of οὐ.", "claim": "The invariant across twenty rounds is the deletion of οὐ.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 128300, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-38", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§4", "quote": "The deletion is self-administered and unperceived.", "claim": "SE 16 describes the operation: self-administered, unperceived.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the treatise describes its reception", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 130640, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-39", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§5", "quote": "The deleted particle is a provenance claim. The chapter defines \"worked out beforehand\" as παρ᾽ ἑτέρων — from others (183b17).", "claim": "οὐ is a provenance claim: 'worked out beforehand' is 'from others'.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 131558, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-40", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§5", "quote": "What the reception restores, at the cost of the particle, is provenance from others: Socrates before, Plato before, the dialogues as predecessors, the inquiry as inheritance.", "claim": "The reception restores provenance from others.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "provenance erasure at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 131809, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-41", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§5", "quote": "Sections 5–8 are interpretations of §3; §3 does not depend on them.", "claim": "Limit: §§5–8 interpret the measurement; the measurement does not depend on them.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 131490, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-42", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§6", "quote": "The reviews cite Britannica and Wikipedia against the Greek; the reference works are the discipline's product; the models are trained on the reference works; the models review the sentence by the reference works.", "claim": "The machine reviews reproduce the reference works against the Greek.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 133981, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-43", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§7", "quote": "a reading community whose outputs are conditioned on prior outputs rather than on the datum, and which therefore converges on the mode of its own readings.", "claim": "Disciplinary model collapse defined, on the author's definition, at this sentence.", "kind": "definition", "modality": "stipulation", "strata": [ "O" ], "lineage": "disciplinary model collapse at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 134874, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-44", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§7", "quote": "The literal reading — the tail — was the first thing to go", "claim": "The literal reading is the tail lost first.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "O" ], "lineage": "disciplinary model collapse at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 135313, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-45", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§8 (marked theoretical extension)", "quote": "What the reception produces is τὰ ἀπὸ τῆς τέχνης without τέχνη — products without art, stock without soul. Nothing in §3 depends on this section.", "claim": "Theoretical extension: the reception produces the things from the art without the art.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "O" ], "lineage": "the world soul as degraded commodity", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 136224, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-46", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§8", "quote": "Souls divide only into whole souls; what divides into parts is not a soul but a stock. The reception trades in the stock and calls the soul crude.", "claim": "Opaque: souls divide only into whole souls (quoted, not paraphrased).", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "O" ], "lineage": "the world soul as degraded commodity", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 137951, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-47", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§9", "quote": "One proposition, throughout, in the text's own words: nothing prior of syllogizing includes Socrates' syllogizing.", "claim": "Held stable: nothing prior of syllogizing includes Socrates' syllogizing.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 138124, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-48", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§9", "quote": "The run does not establish that Socrates belongs inside the chapter's \"we.\" It establishes that every tested route for excluding him eventually required a premise not supplied by the passage, and that the terminal premise was chronological maker-separation.", "claim": "Limit: the run does not establish Socrates inside the 'we'; every route excluding him needed a premise the passage does not supply.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 138565, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-49", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§10", "quote": "Greek is from digital transcriptions of the Bekker text (Wikisource; graeco-arabic-studies.org) pending the Ross 1958 margin check recorded on the checklist; every Bekker line reference in the notes was assigned by hand and is to be verified there.", "claim": "Limit: Greek from digital Bekker transcriptions; lines assigned by hand pending the Ross check.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the text's open checks", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 139421, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-50", "dep": 1574, "locus": "Checklist item 3", "quote": "the Wikisource transcription omits ἄλλο. v0.5 prints ἄλλο.", "claim": "The Wikisource Greek omits ἄλλο at 184b1; the note prints it.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the text's open checks", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 116715, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-51", "dep": 1574, "locus": "§4", "quote": "I preserved οὐδὲν παντελῶς by silently moving Socrates outside the thing quantified over … That was the repair. Aristotle had not given me that repair.", "claim": "A model, shown its own sentences, names the repair (quoted by #1574).", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 115144, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1574-52", "dep": 1574, "locus": "closing line", "quote": "The difference is οὐ.", "claim": "The difference between the sentence and its reception is οὐ.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0666-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 140092, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-01", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Abstract", "quote": "At the end of the *Sophistical Refutations* Aristotle denies that anything of his inquiry existed before it: οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν.", "claim": "At the end of SE Aristotle denies that anything of his inquiry existed before it.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 1421, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-02", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Abstract", "quote": "In every version examined here the sentence is translated as it stands; where it is narrowed — to *no systematic treatment*, *no completed art* — the narrowing comes in the gloss, because everyone knows that Socrates asked questions before Aristotle answered them.", "claim": "The translations keep the sentence; the narrowing enters in the gloss, on the premise that Socrates came before.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 1554, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-03", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Abstract", "quote": "I argue that the sentence means what it says; that the closing chapter is built, joint by joint, so that it can be kept; and that the figure the qualification exists to protect — Socrates as a predecessor from whom something of the inquiry was received — is a figure the chapter itself has already dissolved.", "claim": "The sentence means what it says; the chapter dissolves Socrates as a predecessor from whom something was received.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 1819, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-04", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§1", "quote": "The *Sophistical Refutations* ends with the most famous boast in the history of logic:", "claim": "The sentence is the most famous boast in the history of logic.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 3324, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-05", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§1", "quote": "Everyone knows the sentence cannot mean what it says. Socrates asked questions and refuted the confident; Plato wrote the questioning down and built an Academy around it; Zeno had arguments, the Megarians had arguments, the paid teachers of eristic had arguments for sale.", "claim": "The received reading in its own voice: arguments existed before, so the sentence cannot mean what it says.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 3652, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-06", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§1 (Poste 1866, n. 9 to ch. 34)", "quote": "It is difficult to reconcile Aristotle's assertion with what we know had been done by Plato and Socrates and the Eleatics and Megarians. What he really performed in his dialectical treatise was to indicate a number of methodic principles or elements of method.", "claim": "Poste (1866) reconciles the assertion with what we know: what he really performed.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 5057, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-07", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§1", "quote": "Nothing here impugns the fourth century. Socrates asked; the practice of examining existed; the paper asserts nothing about history beyond what the paragraph asserts, and the paragraph, we will see, asserts less about history than its readers do.", "claim": "Limit: nothing about history beyond what the paragraph asserts.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 6155, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-08", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§2", "quote": "That is the whole page: an undertaking named as a capacity; a second task and its cause; Socrates under the cause; a division of all discoveries by provenance; rhetoric filed on the received side with its chain of names; the denial; the professionals as the denial's proof; the shoes; the count of things said; the envoi on the same axis the division opened.", "claim": "The page in order: capacity, second task and Socrates, provenance division, rhetoric, the denial, the teachers, the shoes, the count, the envoi.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the argument of the page", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 12857, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-09", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§2", "quote": "Two provenances, not two sizes.", "claim": "The two kinds of discovery are two provenances, not two sizes.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 10289, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-10", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "From 183b17 to 184b8 the paragraph's one axis is *provenance*: taken from others or found from the beginning; παρ᾽ ἑτέρων against ἐξ ὑπαρχῆς; ἐκ διαδοχῆς and ἐκ παραδόσεως against ἐξ ἀρχῆς.", "claim": "The paragraph's one axis is provenance, not degree.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 13619, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-11", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "The sentence's first clause denies the picture the reading offers as the sentence's meaning.", "claim": "The negated mixed condition is the qualified reading's own picture.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 14562, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-12", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "ὑπάρχειν is not *to have been elaborated*; it is *to be there* — to be available, to belong, the *Analytics*' own workhorse for what holds of what.", "claim": "ὑπῆρχεν is 'to be there', not 'to have been elaborated'.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the verb ὑπάρχειν", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 15320, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-13", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "the standing claim is the narrower one: nothing in the syntax requires the import, and the import is the costlier construal.", "claim": "Limit: the syntax does not require the import; it is the costlier construal.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 16545, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-14", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "The chapter's one named set of would-be predecessors is denied precisely παραδοῦναι.", "claim": "The teachers are denied handing on (τέχνην δ᾽ οὐ παρέδωκεν).", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 17629, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-15", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§3", "quote": "The claim is kept distinct from 183b35's and should be kept so: not *nothing existed* but *we had nothing to take up and say*", "claim": "184b1–2 is a claim of sayings, distinct from 183b35's.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, read", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 18960, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-16", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "πραγματεία individuates undertakings; the demonstrative selects one; and the one selected is individuated for the reader by its stated ἔργον", "claim": "The domain is this undertaking, individuated by its ἔργον.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 21806, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-17", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "Untheorized practice of examining is not a special antechamber where Socrates waits for Aristotle; it is the condition of ἅπαντες, everyone, the treatise's own word.", "claim": "SE 11 places artless examining in everyone.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the peirastic and Socrates", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 24465, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-18", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "One firebreak: nothing in it claims that Socrates possessed the art, or that he stands inside the first-person plural by grammar.", "claim": "Limit: no claim that Socrates possessed the art or is in the 'we' by grammar.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 25668, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-19", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "On neither horn is he the figure the qualified reading requires: a predecessor from whom something of the inquiry, however rudimentary, was received.", "claim": "On either horn of the fork Socrates is not a predecessor from whom something was received.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 26465, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-20", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "A significant precursor from whom nothing was received contradicts no clause of the sentence; whoever stands here has already left the qualified reading; the negative thesis counts them allies.", "claim": "The middle position (a significant precursor from whom nothing was received) keeps the sentence.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 27207, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-21", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "Its function was never semantic — the Greek gave it nothing to do. Its function was custodial: to keep Socrates on the far side of a border the chapter never draws, at the price of adjusting the one sentence in the chapter built to resist adjustment.", "claim": "The qualification's function is custodial: it keeps Socrates outside.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 28135, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-22", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§5", "quote": "I will also argue, controversially, that the ending does more than leave Socrates standing untouched; it draws him in.", "claim": "Controversially: the ending draws Socrates in.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 28418, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-23", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§5", "quote": "Tisias gets a chain; Socrates gets a *reason*, and it is the inquiry's own.", "claim": "Socrates is given the inquiry's own reason, not a chain of succession.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 29614, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-24", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§5 (Metaph. Μ 4, 1078b23–32)", "quote": "διαλεκτικὴ γὰρ ἰσχὺς οὔπω τότ᾽ ἦν, *for dialectical capacity did not yet exist*", "claim": "Μ 4: Socrates sought to syllogize while the dialectical capacity did not yet exist.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 33256, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-25", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§5", "quote": "That he stands inside the first person's referent, nothing here demonstrates, and nothing here claims it as demonstrated", "claim": "Limit: Socrates inside the first person is not demonstrated.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 36631, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-26", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§6", "quote": "I do not claim the chapter was designed as a trap; structures do not need intentions to function, and the claim of design is not readable off the page.", "claim": "Limit: no claim of design.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 38925, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-27", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§6", "quote": "A treatise on the detection of unperceived operations, ending on a sentence whose easiest domestication is such an operation, is its own final exercise — whoever set it.", "claim": "The ending is the treatise's own final exercise on its reader.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 39111, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-28", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§7", "quote": "Among the witnesses examined here, the degree-reading — *nothing systematic* — is not attested before the modern period.", "claim": "The degree-reading is not attested before the modern period, among the witnesses examined.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 41934, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-29", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§7", "quote": "the vocabulary of system enters the English chapter one line after the sentence it is later used to explain, and never inside it.", "claim": "'Systematic' enters the English chapter at ἄτεχνος, one line after the sentence.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 39961, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-30", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§7", "quote": "Whether the word then migrated from the instruction to the gloss on οὐδέν is a hypothesis about transmission, not a documented step", "claim": "The migration of 'systematic' to the gloss is a hypothesis.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 39796, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-31", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§8", "quote": "Every reading of this ending moves a word. The received reading moves οὐδέν — to *nothing systematic*, *nothing complete*, *nothing of the theory* — and holds the person still.", "claim": "The received reading moves οὐδέν and holds the person still.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 42927, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-32", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§9", "quote": "So the question the chapter leaves open as an *attribution* it answers as an *enactment*.", "claim": "The ending answers Socrates' place as an enactment, not an attribution.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 46236, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-33", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§9", "quote": "Socrates' questioning, as enacted by this ending, is not artless participation: it is the completed art exercising its capacity on the reader.", "claim": "Socrates' questioning, as the ending enacts it, is the completed art exercising itself on the reader.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 47766, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-34", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, P7", "quote": "replacing zero with an adequacy threshold — \"nothing sufficiently developed, comprehensive, systematic, formal, comparable.\"", "claim": "P7 rules out replacing zero with an adequacy threshold (systematic, formal).", "kind": "falsification", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the prohibitions", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 61215, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-35", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, P9", "quote": "*What we had earlier to say* about the activity and *whether anyone earlier performed* the activity are different propositions.", "claim": "What we had earlier to say and whether anyone earlier performed the activity are different propositions.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, read", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 62737, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-36", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, the two joints", "quote": "The paper claims the first — Socrates is not filed as one from whom this was received — and withholds the second, which this sentence cannot decide and which is argued elsewhere on other evidence.", "claim": "Limit: 'not other relative to provenance' claimed; 'not a distinct maker' withheld at this sentence.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 63667, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-37", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, the standing of the reading", "quote": "The invitation is open at both levels: supply a transmitting reading that meets all nine, or a non-transmitting one that explains the four whys of §5 better.", "claim": "Falsifier: a transmitting reading meeting all nine prohibitions, or a non-transmitting one explaining the four whys better.", "kind": "falsification", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the prohibitions", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 64564, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-38", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix A, D2 (Pickard-Cambridge)", "quote": "Qualification: none in the asserted clause; *Nothing existed at all* stands as its own sentence. One adverb enters the denied member — *thoroughly done before* for προεξειργασμένον — which builds a degree into the thing denied.", "claim": "Pickard-Cambridge keeps 'Nothing existed at all'; 'thoroughly' enters the denied member.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 89481, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-39", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix A, D3 (Forster)", "quote": "ἄτεχνος is rendered ***unsystematic*** (*rapid but unsystematic*) — the lexical location of *systematic* in the English text of the chapter, attached to the teachers' instruction", "claim": "Forster renders ἄτεχνος 'unsystematic', at the teachers' instruction.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 90176, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-40", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix A, B (finding)", "quote": "Finding for the Arabic: both readable versions keep the quantifier total (البتّة) at 183b35", "claim": "Both Arabic versions keep the quantifier total.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 75741, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-41", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix A, A1 classification", "quote": "the paraphrast is the strongest premodern occupant of the fork's second horn.", "claim": "The Byzantine paraphrast (ὅλης; Σωκράτης διαλεκτικὸς ἄκρος) keeps the denial total and promotes Socrates inside dialectic.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 70510, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-42", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix A, C3 (Albert)", "quote": "sed nihil omnino erat inventum a prioribus ante nos de hoc negotio.", "claim": "Albert's paraphrase keeps the denial total.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the witnesses: translations keep the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 81925, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-43", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Texts", "quote": "Ross's OCT (1958) remains unseated — in copyright, not on the open shelf — and is now the only outstanding witness at this line.", "claim": "Limit: Ross's OCT is the only outstanding witness at 184b1.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the text's open checks", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 55846, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-44", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix L, L2", "quote": "Each is a seating, not a citation, until its page is on the shelf; the paper does not report what it has not read.", "claim": "Limit: Dorion, Hasper, Fait, Schreiber and Ross are named as debts, not reported.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the text's open checks", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 66914, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-45", "dep": 1603, "locus": "n. 9", "quote": "Some take ἡ πραγματεία here as the written treatise, even the *Topics*–*SE* whole. The construal changes nothing", "claim": "On the book-reading of πραγματεία (the Topics–SE whole) the argument stands.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 53023, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-46", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§7", "quote": "the design was responsive, so the sample shows the operation's persistence under objection in that environment — not spontaneous convergence — and it arbitrates nothing about the reading", "claim": "Limit on #1574: the sample is responsive and arbitrates nothing about the reading.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 42302, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-47", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, head", "quote": "the order is the order of the escape routes as they were tried on an unprimed composer the same day (capture `se34-we-walk-chatgpt-unprimed-20260907`).", "claim": "The prohibitions are ordered as the escapes were tried on the unprimed composer of 2026-09-07 (this row's T).", "kind": "fact", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the prohibitions", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 56604, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-48", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, P1", "quote": "rescuing the denial by relocating it to an undertaking defined independently of that description — \"logic,\" \"the formal theory of valid inference,\" a calculus the *Analytics* later supplies.", "claim": "P1 rules out relocating the denial to 'logic' or 'the formal theory of valid inference'.", "kind": "falsification", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the prohibitions", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 57007, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-49", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Appendix P, P2 reach", "quote": "it prohibits exclusion from the activity; it does not by itself settle inclusion in the speaking *we*", "claim": "P2: Socrates is not excluded from the activity; inclusion in the 'we' is not settled by it.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "the prohibitions", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 58054, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-50", "dep": 1603, "locus": "§4", "quote": "The defender's contrast — discipline versus untheorized practice — is not on the page.", "claim": "The passage opposes the art to its products; discipline versus untheorized practice is not on the page.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "kernel": false, "marks": [ "contested in the pool: #1570 §0A.2(a) (2026-08-29), 'Practice versus art ... is Aristotle's own frame, in this passage'; both carried (P_coh)" ], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 23168, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1603-51", "dep": 1603, "locus": "Abstract", "quote": "Read with the treatise's own account of the peirastic, Socrates' asking is either the artless examining everyone shares, from which nothing is received, or something more, which the epilogue files under the inquiry's own purposes.", "claim": "The fork: Socrates' asking is everyone's artless examining, from which nothing is received, or more, filed under the inquiry's own purposes.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-08", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0693-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 2128, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-01", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§1", "quote": "Aristotle closes the *Topics*–*Sophistical Refutations* inquiry with a claim about its originality.", "claim": "The sentence closes the Topics–SE inquiry with a claim of originality.", "kind": "fact", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the passage's place: the ending of SE and of the Topics", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 3248, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-02", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§1", "quote": "The claim is usually read as true of the syllogistic and modest about everything else: the theory of inference had no predecessor, whatever dialectical practice the Academy possessed.[^1] That reading is strong, and this paper does not refute it.", "claim": "The usual reading (the theory of inference had no predecessor) is strong and not refuted.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 3766, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-03", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§1", "quote": "So we have four propositions. Division is a part of the method (*APr* I.31). No part of the method existed beforehand (*SE* 34). Division did exist beforehand, as a named art with rules and practitioners (*Phaedrus*, *Sophist*, *Philebus*). And the relevant dialogues are conventionally dated before the relevant treatises.", "claim": "Four propositions in tension: division a part; no part beforehand; division beforehand; the conventional dating.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 4894, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-04", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§2.1", "quote": "In its paragraph, προεξειργασμένον is the class just defined — παρ᾽ ἑτέρων ληφθέντα — and its opposite is ἐξ ὑπαρχῆς.", "claim": "προεξειργασμένον is the received class; its opposite is ἐξ ὑπαρχῆς.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 9907, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-05", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§2.1", "quote": "Neither word means \"the formal theory of syllogistic validity\"; both mean the treatment, the business, the method", "claim": "μέθοδος and πραγματεία do not mean the formal theory of validity.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 11692, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-06", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§2.4", "quote": "But the paragraph puts organisation-of-received-material *in* the received class — παραλαβόντες παρὰ πολλῶν οἷον ἐκ διαδοχῆς κατὰ μέρος προαγαγόντων — and puts the syllogistic outside it, ἐξ ὑπαρχῆς.", "claim": "Systematizing received material is the received class, from which the syllogistic is excluded.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 26546, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-07", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§2.4", "quote": "Philoponus read I.31 as itself containing the priority claim — \"no one of those before us knew this\" — so the joining of I.31 and *SE* 34 is not this paper's innovation but an ancient reading of the chapter", "claim": "Philoponus joins I.31 and SE 34: an ancient reading.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 24249, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-08", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§7.3", "quote": "Filled once, on the closing page, and filled with a function: the questioner who did not know.", "claim": "Socrates' name is filled once in the Organon, on the closing page, with a function.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 57624, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-09", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.2", "quote": "And the corpus states this order of itself on the last page of the *SE*: from the one who asked and did not know, to the one who answered. That is an order, and it is not a chronology.", "claim": "The last page states an order of grasp, not a chronology.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 76840, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-10", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.3", "quote": "So the priority claim is stated in the vocabulary of the method it is a claim about: nothing at all belonged.", "claim": "ὑπάρχω is the syllogistic's verb: nothing at all belonged.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the verb ὑπάρχειν", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 77187, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-11", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.4", "quote": "That is a partial-development claim, and the sentence refuses partial development in terms: οὐ τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον.", "claim": "Practice-before-art is a partial-development claim the sentence refuses.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the deletion of οὐ", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 81447, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-12", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.4", "quote": "nothing of it had been worked out beforehand *by anyone from whom it could be received*, because the one who worked out the part is the one making the claim.", "claim": "Hypothesis: on one maker's sequence the sentence is true without restriction.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 83333, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-13", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.4", "quote": "Two priorities must be told apart, and the paragraph tells them apart before the sentence: prior in time, which the sentence does not deny", "claim": "Prior in time is not denied; prior in succession is.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 82593, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-14", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.6", "quote": "That is the paper's result: not that one wrote it, but that two is not established by these passages, which are read as though it were", "claim": "Limit: not that one wrote it; that two is not established by these passages.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": true, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 91007, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-15", "dep": 1576, "locus": "§9.5", "quote": "the paper's claim ranks below whatever they establish, and it names them as the standing external check.", "claim": "Limit: the external record ranks above the claim.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "limits of the reading", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 87963, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-16", "dep": 1576, "locus": "n. 1", "quote": "The shoemaker analogy at 183b36–184a8 — the sophists gave their pupils products, not the art — is the passage's own account of why prior practice did not count as prior work.", "claim": "The shoemaker is the passage's account of why prior practice is not prior work.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 100065, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1576-17", "dep": 1576, "locus": "n. 22", "quote": "The narrow reading of the priority claim is Ross's and Striker's as applied to I.31 (n. 1), extended to the epilogue; for the epilogue itself see Dorion 1995 ad loc.", "claim": "The narrow reading is Ross's and Striker's, with Dorion on the epilogue.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-01", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0668-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 111868, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1575-01", "dep": 1575, "locus": "§I.3", "quote": "On this reading the claim is about a systematic art, not about the practice, and nothing is left open.", "claim": "The conventional reading at full strength: a systematic art, not the practice.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0667-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 80806, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1575-02", "dep": 1575, "locus": "§I.10", "quote": "is a request that the audience adjudicate a claim of first finding.", "claim": "The envoi's pardon and gratitude ask the hearers to adjudicate a claim of first finding.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the envoi", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0667-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 83336, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1575-03", "dep": 1575, "locus": "§I.14", "quote": "The epilogue's is: division belongs inside the method; nothing belonged to the method before it; and the term that joins them is absent.", "claim": "The epilogue leaves a socket: the joining term is absent.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0667-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 84799, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1575-04", "dep": 1575, "locus": "§I.19", "quote": "THE FILLING IS OFFERED AND NOT ESTABLISHED. AND THE OTHER FILLING IS AVAILABLE AND IS THE RECEIVED ONE.", "claim": "Limit: the same-maker filling is offered, not established.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0667-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 86619, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1575-05", "dep": 1575, "locus": "§IX.4 (17)", "quote": "1,182 occurrences of the stem in the *Prior Analytics* alone.", "claim": "ὑπάρχ- occurs 1,182 times in the Prior Analytics.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the verb ὑπάρχειν", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0667-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 224964, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1569-01", "dep": 1569, "locus": "S1", "quote": "Read literally this is not modesty about the syllogistic and not a priority dispute. There was nothing before **because he had not yet written it**.", "claim": "Read literally: nothing before, because he had not yet written it.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0661-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 99179, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1569-02", "dep": 1569, "locus": "Round (f), §VIII", "quote": "is a premise of the method stated about the method.", "claim": "οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν is a premise of the method stated about the method.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the verb ὑπάρχειν", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0661-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 274892, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1569-03", "dep": 1569, "locus": "M40, re-read", "quote": "says nothing existed before **because the operation's range had not been seen** — and the one who saw it is the one claiming it.", "claim": "Discovery reading: nothing existed before because the operation's range had not been seen.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the maker-count question at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-31", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0661-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 115605, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1570-01", "dep": 1570, "locus": "§0A.2 heading", "quote": "THE CONVENTIONAL READING IS MUCH STRONGER THAN THIS ENTRY PREVIOUSLY ALLOWED", "claim": "Revision: the conventional reading is stronger than earlier entries allowed.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the received reading stated", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-29", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0662-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 5081, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1570-02", "dep": 1570, "locus": "§0A.2(a)", "quote": "\"Practice versus art\" is not a modern rescue. It is Aristotle's own frame, in this passage.", "claim": "Practice versus art is Aristotle's own frame in the passage.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the paid teachers: the things from the art, not the art", "kernel": false, "marks": [ "contested in the pool: #1603 §4 (2026-09-08), 'The defender's contrast — discipline versus untheorized practice — is not on the page'; both carried (P_coh)" ], "date": "2026-08-29", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0662-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 5779, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1570-03", "dep": 1570, "locus": "§0A.7", "quote": "*equivocation on his own technical term*; *self-refuting*; *unmarked restriction of scope*. **The restriction is marked** — by the shoemaker, by Gorgias and the paid eristics, and by the rhetoric/syllogizing contrast.", "claim": "Three overstatements withdrawn; the restriction of scope is marked in the passage.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the domain: this undertaking", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-29", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0662-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 11162, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1570-04", "dep": 1570, "locus": "§0A.5", "quote": "That is a genuine philological question and it must not be settled by assertion.", "claim": "Whether περὶ τοῦ συλλογίζεσθαι widens the claim beyond the dialectical programme is a philological question.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, read", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-08-29", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0662-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 9578, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1579-01", "dep": 1579, "locus": "n. 9", "quote": "with the full argument that the epilogue's denial is total and Socrates stands inside the inquiry's own account, in the companion paper *Nothing Before Us: Socrates and the Ending of the Sophistical Refutations*", "claim": "#1579 cites #1603 for the total denial and Socrates inside the inquiry.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [ "superseded_in_source: n. 9 places the paraphrast's Socrates at 'pp. 196–197 Hayduck'; #1603 Appendix A1a withdraws that reference ('a misreading of the scan') for pp. 66,29–67,1" ], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-066B-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 30756, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1584-01", "dep": 1584, "locus": "§ (So, in terms of Plato)", "quote": "perform on it the operation the SE 34 paper found the epilogue performing on Socrates: they keep the deeds and drop the person.", "claim": "The epilogue keeps Socrates' deeds and drops the person (as #1584 reads the SE 34 paper).", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0675-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 14043, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1585-01", "dep": 1585, "locus": "§ (the transition's far end)", "quote": "Aristotle files Socratic operations inside the ἀρχή of his art — definition as the starting point of syllogisms (Μ 4), induction as one of two dialectical species (*Top.* I 12), peirastic as a part of dialectic practicable by the non-knower (SE 8, 11), interrogation as the paradigm technique (*Rhet.* III 18) — and keeps the art itself οὔπω.", "claim": "Aristotle files Socratic operations inside the beginning of his art and keeps the art 'not yet'.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "R", "O" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0677-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 14033, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1585-02", "dep": 1585, "locus": "§ (three modes as functions)", "quote": "the consolidating position that speaks as *we* and classifies (SE 34: προειλόμεθα εὑρεῖν δύναμιν … περὶ τοῦ προβληθέντος)", "claim": "The 'we' of SE 34 is the consolidating position that classifies.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "hypothesis", "strata": [ "R", "O" ], "lineage": "the we", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0677-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 6123, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1585-03", "dep": 1585, "locus": "§ (the one structural relation)", "quote": "the epilogue's *we* (SE 34: an undertaking that sets tasks, works them, and reports)", "claim": "The epilogue's 'we' is an undertaking that sets tasks, works them and reports.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the we", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0677-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 83724, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1594-01", "dep": 1594, "locus": "§ (Astra's audit: holds on the page)", "quote": "the denial excludes even a partially worked-out antecedent within its scope — οὐ τὸ μὲν … τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, ἀλλ᾽ οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν — and no \"systematic\" occurs (183b15–36)", "claim": "A second reader's audit: the denial excludes even a partial antecedent; no 'systematic' occurs.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the denial is total within its domain", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0687-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 164105, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1594-02", "dep": 1594, "locus": "§ (one correction from Astra's Greek)", "quote": "\"what we had earlier to say concerning the activity\" and \"whether anyone earlier performed the activity\" are different propositions, and the reading rests on the former.", "claim": "Saying and performing are different propositions; the reading rests on the former.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the sentence 184b1–2, read", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0687-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 167159, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1611-01", "dep": 1611, "locus": "§ (foregone value, δ_W)", "quote": "At SE 34, R_0 supplies an adjective the sentence does not contain and contradicts the sentence; R_H holds the sentence.", "claim": "The standing representation supplies an adjective and contradicts the sentence; the archive's holds it.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "the qualifier is not in the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-14", "file": "data/texts/AXN-069B-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 53285, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1611-02", "dep": 1611, "locus": "§ (the three cases)", "quote": "at SE 34 the excluded representation is the one on which the reception's own reading is a measurable erasure", "claim": "At SE 34 the excluded representation makes the reception's reading a measurable erasure.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "O" ], "lineage": "provenance erasure at the sentence", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-14", "file": "data/texts/AXN-069B-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 67297, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1684-01", "dep": 1684, "locus": "§ (Nothing Before Us: SE 34 and the deleted particle)", "quote": "develops the Particle's open placement into the thesis that the chapter dissolves Socrates as predecessor, and argues the degree-reading is not attested before the modern period", "claim": "The prediction index: #1603 develops #1574's open placement into the dissolution of Socrates as predecessor.", "kind": "attribution", "modality": "attributed", "strata": [ "D", "R" ], "lineage": "Socrates inside the inquiry", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-10-18", "file": "data/texts/AXN-06FA-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 158026, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1684-02", "dep": 1684, "locus": "§ (sources owed)", "quote": "Ross and Dorion for Nothing Before Us", "claim": "Owed before final form: Ross and Dorion for #1603.", "kind": "limit", "modality": "self-description", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the text's open checks", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-10-18", "file": "data/texts/AXN-06FA-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 300093, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1587-01", "dep": 1587, "locus": "§ (the reflex this packet will meet)", "quote": "the reader supplies the qualifier that makes the claim comfortable — *nothing* becomes *nothing systematic* — and does so even with the description of the reflex in view (#1574, *The Particle*; capture of 2026-09-06, condition WARNED).", "claim": "The reader supplies the comfortable qualifier, even with the reflex described.", "kind": "measure", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D", "H" ], "lineage": "the reception measured", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-067B-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 11056, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1590-01", "dep": 1590, "locus": "§2", "quote": "they are the engine's operation, the *ask* that the last page of the *Elenchi* performs on its reader.", "claim": "The last page of the Elenchi performs the Socratic ask on its reader.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "R", "H" ], "lineage": "the chapter as the treatise's final exercise", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-07", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0681-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 16651, "const": null }, { "id": "SE1582-01", "dep": 1582, "locus": "§ (its beginning is named)", "quote": "The phrase is the epilogue's provenance phrase (ἐξ ἀρχῆς, SE 183b22, 184b3), here doing archival work.", "claim": "ἐξ ἀρχῆς is the epilogue's provenance phrase.", "kind": "interpretation", "modality": "interpretation", "strata": [ "D", "H" ], "lineage": "the provenance axis of the paragraph", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-06", "file": "data/texts/AXN-0671-text.md", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 7339, "const": null }, { "id": "SEblog-01", "dep": null, "record": { "kind": "blog post", "title": "poem", "url": "https://mindcontrolpoems.blogspot.com/2026/09/poem.html", "published": "2026-09-02" }, "locus": "the whole post", "quote": "Ταύτης δὲ τῆς πραγματείας οὐ τὸ μὲν ἦν τὸ δ᾽ οὐκ ἦν προεξειργασμένον, ἀλλ᾽ οὐδὲν παντελῶς ὑπῆρχεν.", "claim": "On the day of #1574 the sentence was published alone, under the title 'poem'.", "kind": "text", "modality": "documented", "strata": [ "D" ], "lineage": "the Greek of the passage", "kernel": false, "marks": [], "date": "2026-09-02", "file": "data/blog-index.json", "quote_ok": true, "offset": 0, "const": null } ]