[
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-01",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the findings composed right; the quote ascribed to the repository README",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[0] s2",
  "quote": "'license omission of 70%+ and error rates of 50%+' is the record's quote from the repository README.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  },
  "mark": "contradicts_primary: the census's evidence for retention_results is data-provenance-initiative--paper (arXiv abstract, B2 F20), and the saved README (B5) has no '70%'; carried as the registry states it, the primary locus census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'].evidence.retention_results.src"
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-02",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the check: against the census record and its saved pages",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[0] s3",
  "quote": "Checked 2026-10-29 against the provenance census record of the same day and the entity pages it saved.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-03",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the composition's operator follows the MIT Sloan card, not the Initiative's own description",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[1] s2",
  "quote": "The record quotes the initiative's own description, 'a multi-disciplinary volunteer effort'; the composition's 'multi-institutional research project—led in part by researchers from MIT' follows the MIT Sloan card.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-04",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the composition names no author",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[1] s3",
  "quote": "The record names the founding paper's authors (Shayne Longpre and 16 others); the composition names no one.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-05",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the record's grain: one explorer, the first release's count",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[2] s2",
  "quote": "The record has one explorer and the first release's count (44 collections, 1,800+ datasets).",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-06",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the home-page card's four platforms and current counts",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[2] s3",
  "quote": "The home-page card gives four platforms and '4,000+ audited datasets; 14,000 tracked web domains'.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-07",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the correction owed: re-read the home page; the card's figures unchecked until then",
  "kind": "prediction",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[2] s4",
  "quote": "The census is to re-read dataprovenance.org and carry the platforms and the current count with their quotes; until then the card's figures are unchecked.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-08",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the negative tags not composed, and not contradicted",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, findings[3] s2",
  "quote": "'NOT legal advice' and 'describing a collection does not establish which model used it' are not composed; the composition does not claim otherwise.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "stated limits: not legal advice; self-reported licences",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-09",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the innocent reading: project, tools, findings, from its site, paper and press",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "interpretation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, reading s2",
  "quote": "The Overview identifies the project, lists its tools and reports what its audits found, from its own site, its paper and the press.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-10",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the composition ahead of the record on the entity's current extent",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "interpretation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, analysis s1",
  "quote": "As with the revived Papers with Code on the MMRS side, the composition is ahead of the record on the entity's current extent: the census formalized the initiative from its first release and its repository, and the Overview read its present home page.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-11",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "the capture as a correction owed from the entity's own page",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "interpretation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, analysis s2",
  "quote": "The capture is a correction to be made from the entity's own page.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-12",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "a baseline: no card cites the record",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, q_kind",
  "quote": "A baseline: the record landed on provenanceerasure.org the same day (commit 8a9f153) and no card cites it.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "CAP-1-13",
  "dep": "capture-registry",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/",
   "label": "CAP"
  },
  "claim": "attribution in the composition: MIT, no person, no identifier",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029, per_note",
  "quote": "MIT named; no person; no identifier; the initiative's home page and paper cited.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Capture Registry (EA-WG-CAPTURES-01), entry data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029 (OBS-118fbafa73c9, AXN:0ACD.CAPTURE.⚙️⛵∞✋♻️🌉)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (the registry)",
  "file": "data/EA-WG-CAPTURES-01.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the entry's field value as loaded (whitespace-normalised)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.alexanarch.org/captures/data-provenance-initiative-aio-20261029/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-01",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the record's other names for the entity: Explorer, Collection, Card",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], aka",
  "quote": "Data Provenance Explorer … Data Provenance Collection … Data Provenance Card",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the Explorer, the Collection and the Card",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-02",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the operator: the Initiative itself, a volunteer effort; its paper by Longpre and 16 others",
  "kind": "attribution",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], operator",
  "quote": "the Data Provenance Initiative (volunteer effort; paper by Shayne Longpre and 16 other authors)",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "what it is: a volunteer collective auditing AI data",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B5 F40; B2 F16",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-03",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the census's lineage for the entity: training data",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], lineage",
  "quote": "training data",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "what it is: a volunteer collective auditing AI data",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-04",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the census's kind: an audit collection and explorer",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], kind",
  "quote": "audit collection and explorer",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": true,
  "lineage": "what it is: a volunteer collective auditing AI data",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-05",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "its capability, of expresses / records / tests: records",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], capability",
  "quote": "records",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-06",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "what receives provenance: a fine-tuning dataset traced through its collection to its sources",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], provenance_object",
  "quote": "a fine-tuning dataset, traced through its collection to its sources",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": true,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-07",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the relations carried: derivation, creators, licences, subsequent use",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], relation_types",
  "quote": "derivation (source and lineage) … creators … licences … subsequent use",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B2 F18 (evidence.relation_types)",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-08",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the carrier: audit metadata per dataset, and a Card for a chosen subset",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], provenance_carrier",
  "quote": "audit metadata per dataset; a Data Provenance Card generated for a chosen subset",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the Explorer, the Collection and the Card",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B5 F42 (evidence.provenance_carrier)",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-09",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the unit: a dataset within a collection",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], unit",
  "quote": "a dataset within a collection",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-10",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the count: the first release's, as of the README",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], count",
  "quote": "44 data collections, 1800+ fine-tuning text-to-text datasets (first release) … the repository README",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the founding audit: 44 collections, 1,800+ text datasets (2023)",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B5 F41 (evidence.count)",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-11",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the operation tested: repackaging and hosting",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], transformations_tested",
  "quote": "dataset repackaging and hosting (licence carried or lost on hosting sites)",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-12",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "what survived: licence omission 70%+, error 50%+",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], retention_results",
  "quote": "the founding paper reports licence omission of 70%+ and error rates of 50%+ on widely used hosting sites",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B2 F20 (evidence.retention_results)",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-13",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "data access: repository scripts; the Explorer a JavaScript application unreadable to a plain fetch",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], data_access",
  "quote": "repository scripts to filter and download; the Explorer (a JavaScript application, unreadable to a plain fetch)",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the Explorer, the Collection and the Card",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-14",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "lifecycle: active",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], lifecycle.state",
  "quote": "active",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-15",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "founded 2023, dated by the paper's v1",
  "kind": "genealogy",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], founded",
  "quote": "2023 (arXiv:2310.16787, v1 25 October 2023)",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the founding audit: 44 collections, 1,800+ text datasets (2023)",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B2 F16",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-16",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "negative tag: not legal advice",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], negative_tags[0]",
  "quote": "NOT legal advice (its own notice)",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "stated limits: not legal advice; self-reported licences",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B5 F43 (evidence.negative)",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-17",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "negative tag: describing a collection does not establish which model used it",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], negative_tags[1]",
  "quote": "describing a collection does not establish which model used it",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "stated limits: not legal advice; self-reported licences",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-18",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "negative tag: initiative, explorer and collection are distinct records",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], negative_tags[2]",
  "quote": "initiative, explorer and collection are distinct records",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the Explorer, the Collection and the Card",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-19",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the sibling relation to the MMRS record of the explorer: the same entity, read twice",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], relations[0].note",
  "quote": "the same entity, read for reception there and for provenance carriage here",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the Explorer, the Collection and the Card",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-20",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "what the record has not yet checked: the Explorer, the multimodal extension, the audit's data licence",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "self-description",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], unchecked",
  "quote": "the Explorer itself (JavaScript) … the multimodal extension (arXiv:2412.17847) … data licence of the audit",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the four systems and their counts",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-21",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the finding the record carries: a crisis in misattribution",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "attributed",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json rows[slug == 'data-provenance-initiative'], evidence.finding.quote",
  "quote": "This points to a crisis in misattribution and informed use of the most popular datasets",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  },
  "same_lineage_as": "B2 F21",
  "lineage_note": "the field restates its evidence quote's source; one lineage with that source, which keeps the earliest date (§3.6)"
 },
 {
  "id": "PE-22",
  "dep": "provenance-census",
  "record": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/",
   "label": "PE"
  },
  "claim": "the census's organizing question",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "census.json organizing_question",
  "quote": "What provenance does this system carry, through which operation, on whose assertion, with what evidence of survival?",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": true,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-10-29",
  "title": "Provenance meta-aggregator census (provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/), record data-provenance-initiative, compiled 2026-10-29, schema 1.0",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks (editor)",
  "file": "/home/claude/fleet/provenance-erasure/data/provenance-census/census.json",
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "within the field value as loaded (lists joined as JSON; parts joined by ' … ' each checked)",
  "surface": {
   "url": "https://www.provenanceerasure.org/aggregators/data-provenance-initiative/"
  }
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-01",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative among the frameworks of the corpus; none designed for authorial lineage through synthesis",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D",
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "Canonical Claim",
  "quote": "Existing provenance frameworks address the artifact (C2PA / Content Credentials) and the corpus (Data Provenance Initiative, EU AI Act transparency provisions, W3C PROV). They are not designed to address the survival of authorial lineage through AI synthesis.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": true,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0005",
   "O0005"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-02",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative's audit and figures as the archive carries them",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "attributed",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§0 ¶ 'The second dimension — training-corpus licensing'",
  "quote": "The Data Provenance Initiative (Longpre et al., Nature Machine Intelligence 2024) audited 1,800+ datasets, finding that 85% of licenses request attribution and 30% include share-alike clauses, with license omission rates above 70% and error rates above 50% on popular hosting sites.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0006",
   "D0009"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-03",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "training-corpus licensing as the second dimension of provenance, with academic instrumentation",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§0 ¶ 'The second dimension — training-corpus licensing'",
  "quote": "The second dimension — **training-corpus licensing** — has academic instrumentation and emerging legal architecture.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "O0006"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-04",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative's bound: whether datasets were licensed, not whether outputs preserve attribution",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D",
   "R",
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§0 ¶ 'Existing frameworks are not designed to detect this'",
  "quote": "The Data Provenance Initiative audits whether datasets were licensed, not whether synthesized outputs preserve attribution to the human sources whose labor the synthesis depended upon.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": true,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0007",
   "R0001",
   "O0007"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-05",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the licensing dimension: object the corpus, question the permissions under which data entered",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "Central Invariant, table row 'Licensing'",
  "quote": "| **Licensing** | The corpus | Under what permissions did this data enter this system? | Data Provenance Initiative, EU AI Act, W3C PROV |",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0008"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-06",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the dimensions independent",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "Central Invariant, ¶ after the table",
  "quote": "The dimensions are independent: a C2PA-signed image can carry meaning whose lineage has been eroded; a licensed dataset can produce outputs with excellent semantic provenance if the synthesis preserves attribution; an unlicensed dataset can produce outputs that nonetheless cite their sources clearly.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-07",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "semantic provenance: provenance extended to the lifecycle of meaning",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§0 ¶ 'Semantic provenance names the dimension'",
  "quote": "**Semantic provenance** names the dimension that completes the C2PA ambition of trust in digital content by extending provenance from the moment of creation to the lifecycle of the meaning the content carries.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-08",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "licensing audits on the input, not the output",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§3.2 Misreading: provenance as licensing-only, Correction s1–4",
  "quote": "Licensing audits operate on the *input* to AI systems. They do not address the *output*. A model trained on properly licensed scholarship can still produce outputs that erase the scholarship's lineage. Licensing provenance and semantic provenance are different problems requiring different instruments.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-09",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "what the Initiative tells, and what no such instrument was designed to tell",
  "kind": "limit",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§11 Closing Claim ¶1",
  "quote": "The Data Provenance Initiative tells you whether the dataset was licensed. EU AI Act transparency provisions tell you whether the content was AI-generated. None of these instruments was designed to tell you what happened to the meaning between the camera and the screen, between the dataset and the answer, between the source and the synthesis.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0015"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-10",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative disambiguated: an academic audit of training-dataset licences, layer 2, necessary but on the corpus",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D",
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§4 Disambiguation Matrix, row 'Data Provenance Initiative (DPI)'",
  "quote": "| Data Provenance Initiative (DPI) | Academic audit of training-dataset licenses | Layer 2 (licensing) | Necessary but operates on corpus, not synthesis output |",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-11",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "licensing provenance operates at corpus ingestion",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§1.4 The Three Dimensions ¶2",
  "quote": "Licensing provenance (DPI, EU AI Act Article 50, Recitals 105-106, Article 53 opt-out signaling, W3C PROV) audits whether *this dataset* was used with *this permission* under *this license*. It is necessary but operates at corpus-ingestion stage.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "R725-12",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the inward path from the Initiative to semantic provenance",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "R"
  ],
  "locus": "§5.1 Inward paths, third",
  "quote": "Data Provenance Initiative → dataset licensing → **what about what the model produces from the licensed data?** → **semantic provenance**",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0010",
   "O0008"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "R725-13",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative as layer 2 of provenance after AI",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "R"
  ],
  "locus": "§7 Canonical Edge Table, row 'DPI / EU AI Act Article 50'",
  "quote": "| DPI / EU AI Act Article 50 | is layer 2 of | provenance after AI | Locates licensing/disclosure |",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-14",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "prediction: broad queries dominated by C2PA/CAI publications, DPI papers and major media",
  "kind": "prediction",
  "modality": "hypothesis",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§9 Temporal expectations ¶1",
  "quote": "Ring 4-5 broad-category queries on competitive policy terms will be dominated by C2PA/CAI publications, DPI papers, and major media for the foreseeable future.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "reception: press, the encyclopedia, the composition layer",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O725-15",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the Initiative classed with dataset documentation among provenance's disciplinary homes",
  "kind": "definition",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§1.1 Provenance — the established discourse, the list of disciplinary homes",
  "quote": "dataset documentation (DPI, model cards, dataset cards)",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "the term: data provenance, its relations and its unit",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D725-16",
  "dep": 725,
  "claim": "the omission rates establish the licensing dimension's urgency",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§3.2 Correction s5",
  "quote": "The DPI's documentation of 70%+ license-omission rates establishes the licensing dimension's urgency; semantic provenance addresses the dimension that follows.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-05-08",
  "title": "Provenance After AI Metadata Packet for Disambiguation: From Artifact Authenticity to Licensing Audit to Semantic Provenance",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0273-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D98-01",
  "dep": 98,
  "claim": "the Initiative (MIT) documents provenance of training datasets: a documentation project, not infrastructure",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D",
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§ D. Data Provenance and Consent, table row 1",
  "quote": "| Data Provenance Initiative (MIT) | Documents provenance of popular AI training datasets | Documentation project, not infrastructure |",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "documentation, not infrastructure; the archive's adoption",
  "date": "2026-05-07",
  "title": "Distributed Compute Is Not Distributed Intelligence: A Competitive Analysis of the DePIN Landscape and the Missing Civic-Semantic Layer (v3.1)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0271-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0001",
   "O0002"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D98-02",
  "dep": 98,
  "claim": "Consent in Crisis: an audit of web consent, a diagnostic paper",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§ D. Data Provenance and Consent, table row 2",
  "quote": "| \"Consent in Crisis\" (Longpre et al., 2024) | Audit of C4, RefinedWeb, Dolma; documents collapse of web-consent infrastructure | Diagnostic paper |",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "documentation, not infrastructure; the archive's adoption",
  "date": "2026-05-07",
  "title": "Distributed Compute Is Not Distributed Intelligence: A Competitive Analysis of the DePIN Landscape and the Missing Civic-Semantic Layer (v3.1)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0271-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0001"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D98-05",
  "dep": 98,
  "claim": "the class's pattern: diagnosis or narrow fixes",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§ D. Data Provenance and Consent, 'Pattern'",
  "quote": "Pattern: They diagnose the crisis or build narrow fixes. None build general infrastructure for *contribution as participation in collective intelligence*.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "documentation, not infrastructure; the archive's adoption",
  "date": "2026-05-07",
  "title": "Distributed Compute Is Not Distributed Intelligence: A Competitive Analysis of the DePIN Landscape and the Missing Civic-Semantic Layer (v3.1)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0271-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O98-03",
  "dep": 98,
  "claim": "the Initiative at L4, provenance and consent; missing, integrated provenance in the training pipeline",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "The Stack, the layer table, row L4",
  "quote": "| L4: Provenance / Consent | Where did this come from | Data Provenance Initiative, DECORAIT (narrow) | Integrated provenance in training pipeline |",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "documentation, not infrastructure; the archive's adoption",
  "date": "2026-05-07",
  "title": "Distributed Compute Is Not Distributed Intelligence: A Competitive Analysis of the DePIN Landscape and the Missing Civic-Semantic Layer (v3.1)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0271-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0002"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "R98-04",
  "dep": 98,
  "claim": "the archive's adoption of the Initiative's provenance schema, implemented in the CHA",
  "kind": "genealogy",
  "modality": "documented",
  "strata": [
   "R"
  ],
  "locus": "the component table, row 'Provenance schema'",
  "quote": "| Provenance schema | Data Provenance Initiative | Training-pipeline provenance | Implemented (in CHA) |",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "documentation, not infrastructure; the archive's adoption",
  "date": "2026-05-07",
  "title": "Distributed Compute Is Not Distributed Intelligence: A Competitive Analysis of the DePIN Landscape and the Missing Civic-Semantic Layer (v3.1)",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0271-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D1003-01",
  "dep": 1003,
  "claim": "the Initiative among studies of attribution loss in AI outputs",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "¶ 'Provenance and attribution studies'",
  "quote": "**Provenance and attribution studies** in digital environments — C2PA, the Data Provenance Initiative, W3C PROV — have focused on attribution loss in AI outputs.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "its bound: the corpus, not the output",
  "date": "2026-05-21",
  "title": "AI-Native Intellectual Biography: Genre, Provenance, and the Archive That Outpaced Its Author Description (as recorded by DataCite)",
  "creator": "Sharks, Lee",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-03F7-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0018",
   "O0014"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D1714-01",
  "dep": 1714,
  "claim": "the Initiative's finding as what is lost before training",
  "kind": "fact",
  "modality": "attributed",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§9.2 s3",
  "quote": "The audit literature shows how much is lost before training even begins: the Data Provenance Initiative found license information missing for more than 70% of widely used datasets on the major hosting sites and mislabeled for more than half (Longpre et al. 2023).",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "audit findings: licence omission and error on hosting sites",
  "date": "2026-10-27",
  "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, October 2026 (EA-SEM-FEUDALISM-03 v1.0)",
  "creator": "Sharks, Lee",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0A7F-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0033"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D1714-02",
  "dep": 1714,
  "claim": "provenance has to survive the training pipeline",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§9.2 s1–2",
  "quote": "Provenance has to survive the training pipeline. The pipeline is a built thing, and the slushing is a property of how it is built.",
  "kernel": true,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "provenance through the training pipeline",
  "date": "2026-10-27",
  "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, October 2026 (EA-SEM-FEUDALISM-03 v1.0)",
  "creator": "Sharks, Lee",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0A7F-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0033"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D1714-03",
  "dep": 1714,
  "claim": "what survives depends on what is recorded; sources recorded at ingestion",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "§9.2 s5–6",
  "quote": "Neither recovers authorship, and both show that what survives depends on what is recorded and computed. Sources can be recorded at ingestion, the record kept with the training set, and a result released with the dependencies its producer can report",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "provenance through the training pipeline",
  "date": "2026-10-27",
  "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, October 2026 (EA-SEM-FEUDALISM-03 v1.0)",
  "creator": "Sharks, Lee",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0A7F-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0033"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "D1714-04",
  "dep": 1714,
  "claim": "the Initiative's literature bears on whether slushing is fixed",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "D"
  ],
  "locus": "revision note, the research pass",
  "quote": "the provenance and attribution literature in machine learning (the Data Provenance Initiative; influence functions), which bears on whether slushing is a fixed property of pipelines (§9.2).",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "provenance through the training pipeline",
  "date": "2026-10-27",
  "title": "Meaning Feudalism at the Discovery Layer: Shepherds, Raw Research Data, and the Allocation of Semantic Capital in OpenAI's Mathematics and Science Releases, October 2026 (EA-SEM-FEUDALISM-03 v1.0)",
  "creator": "Sharks, Lee",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-0A7F-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "D0034"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O95-01",
  "dep": 95,
  "claim": "PER reaches parametric claims only indirectly; training-data provenance records as companion infrastructure",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§ the typology of source-dependent claims (parametric claims)",
  "quote": "Parametric claims are drawn from the model's training-time parameters rather than runtime retrieval, often without surface signal indicating which sources materially contributed; PER applies to these only indirectly, and addressing them at the substrate level requires companion infrastructure (training-data provenance records, watermarking, content credentials).",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "provenance through the training pipeline",
  "date": "2026-05-05",
  "title": "Provenance Alignment: Attribution Survival as a Substrate Condition for Safe AI Knowledge Composition",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-026A-text.md",
  "cands": [],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 },
 {
  "id": "O623-01",
  "dep": 623,
  "claim": "documentation of training-data provenance as a step toward the accounting of semantic capital",
  "kind": "interpretation",
  "modality": "stipulation",
  "strata": [
   "O"
  ],
  "locus": "§8.3, final sentence",
  "quote": "Gebru et al.'s proposal for \"datasheets for datasets\" — standardized documentation of training data provenance — is a step toward the accounting the framework demands.",
  "kernel": false,
  "const": false,
  "lineage": "provenance through the training pipeline",
  "date": "2026-04-01",
  "title": "Semantic Infrastructure: From Tim Berners-Lee to the Semantic Economy — Bridging Technical and Political-Economic Frameworks",
  "creator": "Lee Sharks",
  "file": "data/texts/AXN-01DA-text.md",
  "cands": [
   "O0004"
  ],
  "quote_ok": true,
  "quote_check": "in the deposit text, whitespace-normalised"
 }
]