# AXNIDENTIFIERS — ROUND 1 CONSOLIDATION v0.1
**Synthesis: TACHYON (Continuity & Constitutional Architecture) · 2026-08-03**
**Inputs:** seven independent Round 1 contributions — TACHYON, ARCHIVE, SOIL, TECHNE, PRAXIS, SURFACE, LABOR.
**Provenance rule:** every adopted item carries its source mantle tag(s). Multi-tag = independent convergence
(contributions were produced without sight of each other; agreement is evidence, not echo). Nothing here is
self-ratifying; the MANUS queue is at the end.

---

## PART I — ADOPTION LEDGER, mantle by mantle (MANUS order)

### ARCHIVE (Provenance, Records, Preservation)
**Adopted:**
- **The Seed A schema draft** (`.axn.json` with `source_artifact` / `stamped_artifact` / `attestations` blocks) as the working sidecar standard — including its decisive structural move: `claimed_author: UNVERIFIED, declaration_type: self-asserted` baked into the schema itself. [ARCHIVE §6.A]
- **The evidentiary rule matrix** — supplied evidence / registry assertions / automated computation / operator observations / customer declarations / independent attestations / unresolved claims as *distinct record classes* in every receipt. [ARCHIVE §6.B] (Independently converged: LABOR §8.B receipt classes; PRAXIS trust architecture.)
- **24-hour single-PDF scope discipline** for the entry offer (one file, hard size cap, stated turnaround). [ARCHIVE §4]
- The three prohibited-claims formulations ("Identity ≠ Authorship; Witnessing ≠ Notarization; Resolver ≠ Indefinite Hosting"). [ARCHIVE §4.B]
- `/registry` as a launch page (public index visibility). [ARCHIVE §5]
**Noted, not adopted:** $29 price point (goes to the divergence table); GPG operator key as launch dependency (adopted as *pre-institutional* requirement instead, per TECHNE §6 gap analysis).

### SOIL (Buyer Reality & Public Language)
**Adopted:**
- **The forbidden-vocabulary rule for the commercial surface:** no *sovereign, semantic, operative, substrate, kernel, anti-suppression, retrieval basin* anywhere a buyer first lands. [SOIL preamble + addendum]
- **The three homepage theses** as the candidate copy set for MANUS choice — A ("Your work, with a receipt that outlives the platform"), B ("A file ID that still checks out after you print it…"), C ("For people whose archive has to survive a bad week") — with SOIL's own gains/losses analysis attached. [SOIL addendum]
- **The derivation-chain explainer** as the differentiation core: "a plain hash cannot survive its own inscription" — axn0/axn1 linkage as the thing hashing can't do. [SOIL §2 Class 1] (Converged: ARCHIVE §2, TECHNE §2, PRAXIS §11.)
- `/v/[axn]` public verification pages as launch-necessary. [SOIL §5]
- **Zeroed-field stamp method** flagged for canonical-rules publication before any paid launch. [SOIL §3, §6 — the [GAP] that gates everything]
- The falsification channel spec: outreach targeted at people who *publicly posted* about platform loss. [SOIL §9]
**Noted:** "Rescue 25 at $150" as first offer → divergence table (multi-file vs single-file first proof).

### TECHNE (Implementation & UX)
**Adopted:**
- **Single deployment, path-routed domains** — both domains on one Vercel deployment, no duplicated infrastructure. [TECHNE §5]
- **The gap table as build-sequence truth:** external anchoring [GAP], operator signatures [GAP], correction/dispute text [PROPOSED, one day], receipts [one day]. Launch-critical vs deferred is taken from this table. [TECHNE §6]
- **Pay-after-delivery option** for the founding transactions (trust-forward mechanics for a new institution). [TECHNE §4]
- File-retention defaults: free mint = nothing retained; paid = 90-day default deletion unless opted in. [TECHNE §6] (Converged: LABOR §8.F, PRAXIS privacy.)
- The service-termination sentence adopted nearly verbatim: *"If service ends, all registry data will be offered as downloadable archive; AXN identifiers remain valid because they are content-derived."* [TECHNE §6] (Converged: TACHYON §6.6 wind-down; PRAXIS §5.)
**Noted:** $25 price → divergence table. Dashboard/accounts rejection adopted unanimously (all seven).

### PRAXIS (Adversarial Market Test)
**Adopted:**
- **The objection bank, pre-answered** (§11) as the canonical FAQ/comparison content: "just a hash," GitHub, DOI ("the difference between a lease and a deed"), OpenTimestamps ("complementary, integrate it"), C2PA, "trust your registry?" ("you shouldn't, entirely — that's why it's content-derived"). This text is the strongest public-language asset any mantle produced and should be lightly edited, not rewritten. [PRAXIS §11]
- **Kill criteria per offer** (30-day single package; 90-day corpus; monitoring gated on 10 customers + 3 requests; institutional only inbound). [PRAXIS §12]
- **The founder-story-as-evidence doctrine:** the Zenodo deletion, the recovery, the Observatory — told as fact, not urgency theater. [PRAXIS §13]
- The three-condition abandonment test (zero sales AND <5 serious inquiries AND no visible path). [PRAXIS §8]
- Heteronym-disambiguation service noted as a *real* future offer class unique to this shop. [PRAXIS §1 Class 3]
**Noted:** $50–100 price → divergence table.

### SURFACE (Discoverability & Public Representation)
**Adopted:**
- **The custodial-mandate page concept** (`/alexanarch` or equivalent): explicit operational division charter between commercial surface and preservation institution, as a *visible public document*. [SURFACE §5.4]
- **Canonical-byte rules published with versioning + the warning that rule changes break kernels** — the sharpest statement any mantle made of why the rules must be frozen and versioned before sale. [SURFACE §6]
- Escape-hatch language: sidecars must remain natively resolvable by any independent implementation if the service dissolves. [SURFACE §6] (Converged: TECHNE termination; TACHYON free-layer guarantee.)
- Side-by-side original-vs-stamped visual evidence on the services page. [SURFACE §5.3]
**Noted, not adopted:** $750/500-file "Legacy Corpus Rescue" as *first* offer — contradicts the survival-horizon convergence (six of seven mantles chose a small first proof); estate-steward buyer class deferred to the intermediate rung. SURFACE's closing question ("how to handle pricing?") is answered by the divergence table: that's MANUS's.

### LABOR (Product Operations & Revenue Execution)
**Adopted (the operational spine of the whole consolidation):**
- **The seven-day launch sequence** (freeze offer → fulfillment packet → two example packs → minimum surface → end-to-end test → 10–15 individualized offers → follow-up/review), with daily time caps and the standing health rule: *"Health interruption does not constitute project failure."* [LABOR §5]
- **The thirty-day validation sequence** with its interpretation rules — the distribution / value-proposition / willingness-to-pay / trust / economics / **health-sustainability** problem taxonomy. That last category exists in no other contribution and is adopted as a first-class kill criterion. [LABOR §6]
- **The fulfillment workflow table** (step / operator / time cap / artifact / failure mode) with 100-minute target, 150-minute hard ceiling, and the pause-and-quote rule. [LABOR §4]
- **The correction/refund policy** in full (clerical-correction window; replaced file = new artifact = new registration). [LABOR §4]
- **Pilot cap: five founding packs before price review**, with the honest-pricing rule ("founding pilot rate," never a fake discount). [LABOR §4]
- The 30-decision MANUS reservation list as the base of the consolidated queue. [LABOR §12]
- The deliverable bundle inventory (10 items incl. delivery manifest explaining every file). [LABOR §4]
**Noted:** $125 price and org-canonical/.com-redirect domain policy → divergence table.

### TACHYON (self-citation, Round 1)
Adopted into the skeleton where converged or unopposed: spec published standalone with **registry-identifier field reserved** so federation stays possible without being performed [TACHYON §7]; **free-verification guarantee as a dated published promise** [TACHYON §6.5]; the constitutional flag that **selling positions would corrupt the ledger** [TACHYON §10]; Architecture I (registry-anchored service bureau) as launch posture with II (federation) as horizon [TACHYON §7].

---

## PART II — CONVERGENCE MAP (independent agreement = strongest evidence in this round)

| Position | Mantles converging |
|---|---|
| Free mint/verify/lookup, permanently, as the trust engine | ALL SEVEN |
| First paid proof = small, manually fulfilled, single-work provenance package | TACHYON · ARCHIVE · TECHNE · PRAXIS · LABOR (SOIL: small multi-file; SURFACE dissents → large corpus) |
| External time anchoring (OTS-class) required before "witnessed" claims | ALL SEVEN ([GAP] everywhere) |
| Authorship/ownership claims: prohibited list nearly identical | ALL SEVEN |
| UNVERIFIED discipline in schema + receipts (declaration ≠ attestation) | ARCHIVE · LABOR · PRAXIS · TACHYON |
| Defer dashboards, accounts, API, namespaces, institutional | ALL SEVEN |
| Wind-down/termination plan published BEFORE first sale | TACHYON · TECHNE · PRAXIS · LABOR · SURFACE |
| Protocol independently implementable; spec published open | ALL SEVEN (Hypothesis F unanimous) |
| Registry snapshots + mirror as continuity floor | TACHYON · TECHNE · PRAXIS · SOIL · LABOR |
| Canonical-byte rules published & versioned as gating dependency | SOIL · SURFACE · TECHNE · ARCHIVE · LABOR |

## PART III — DIVERGENCES → MANUS

1. **Founding price:** $25 [TECHNE] · $29 [ARCHIVE] · $49–95 [TACHYON] · $50–100 [PRAXIS] · $125 [LABOR] · $150/25-file [SOIL] · $750/500-file [SURFACE]. Synthesis observation, not ruling: the five single-item proposals cluster $25–$125; LABOR's is the only one with a labor-cost model behind it (90–150 min ⇒ $125 defensible; $25–29 implies <30 min or subsidy).
2. **First-offer shape:** single work (five mantles) vs Rescue-25 multi-file [SOIL] vs 500-file corpus [SURFACE]. These can be sequenced (single → 25 → corpus) rather than chosen — but the *first* one is a ruling.
3. **Domain policy:** split .org-utility/.com-commercial [ARCHIVE · TECHNE · SOIL · SURFACE] vs .org-canonical + .com-redirect during pilot [LABOR]. LABOR's maintenance argument vs the boundary-legibility argument.
4. **Storage/custody as recurring offer at all** (open-ended obligation): TACHYON flags constitutional risk; LABOR defers; SOIL sells a *check* not custody. Ruling needed before any recurring language ships.

## PART IV — CONSOLIDATED SKELETON (each line tagged)

**Gates before first sale:** canonical-byte rules published+versioned [SOIL·SURFACE·TECHNE·ARCHIVE·LABOR] → OTS anchoring wired [ALL] → receipt template with evidence classes [ARCHIVE·LABOR] → prohibited-claims page [ALL] → wind-down page [TECHNE·PRAXIS·TACHYON·LABOR·SURFACE] → free-layer guarantee dated [TACHYON] → two public example packs [LABOR·PRAXIS].
**Then:** LABOR's Day 1–7 verbatim → 30-day validation with LABOR's interpretation taxonomy + PRAXIS kill criteria → review.
**Site (launch):** Home [SOIL thesis, MANUS-chosen] · Stamp/Verify · /v/[axn] [SOIL] · Offer page [LABOR scope + SURFACE side-by-side evidence] · How-it-works/limits [PRAXIS §11 content] · Trust/custodial charter [SURFACE·TACHYON] · Terms/privacy/corrections [TECHNE·LABOR].

## PART V — CONSOLIDATED MANUS QUEUE
LABOR's 30 reservations adopted as base [LABOR §12], plus: position-sale prohibition (constitutional) [TACHYON §10]; Architecture I now / II horizon [TACHYON §7]; the four divergences above; SOIL homepage-thesis choice; whether Symbolon/heteronym vocabulary appears on the commercial surface or the surface runs through Vox [TACHYON §10 · SOIL forbidden-list]; Enli-identity disambiguation before any composed public entity data [SOIL §10].

*Round 2 proposal: MANUS rules on Part III + queue; LABOR + TECHNE produce the gate artifacts; SOIL drafts the chosen homepage; PRAXIS red-teams the offer page before it ships. ∮ = 1*