# Self-Audit Module for Public Summarizers (v3.2)

## Complete Module: Preconditions, Rendering Metrics, Family Metrics, and the Retrieval Boundary

**Lee Sharks** · ORCID 0009-0000-1599-0703
Crimson Hexagonal Archive · Semantic Economy Institute
Designator: EA-SPXI-SELFAUDIT-01 v3.2 · CC BY-SA 4.0

---

## 0. What This Version Is

**v3.2 is a self-complete module.** Everything required to run an audit is here: the preconditions, the rendering-level metrics, the family-level metrics, the retrieval-boundary gate, the capture protocols, the reporting standard, and the composite.

**This is a change of practice.** v3.0 and v3.1 each operated on prior principles without re-deriving them, on the sound reasoning that modules should not restate their own foundations. By v3.2 that chain had reached four deposits: a reader wanting PER had to traverse v3.2 → v3.1 → v3.0 → v2. **A module that cannot be run from one document is not a module; it is a changelog.** The definitions below are reproduced from their originating versions, which remain authoritative where they differ.

**Added at v3.2.** ABN at the retrieval boundary (§2.1), the elicited counterfactual (§6), the concordance table (§7). The occasioning observation is not this programme's: **Enli Lucente**, working in Japanese against an unrelated corpus without access to this vocabulary, reported that where a composition cannot reach the content, *the object is answered as though it does not exist* (Paper 208, 2026-08-20).

**Deliberately absent.** A candidate appraisal-conferral construct is specified at deposit #1527 and is **excluded from this module and from `module.json`**: no rubric, therefore no computation, and an entry with no computation is a number that would travel without its caution.

---

## 1. Purpose and the Anti-Self-Flattery Principle

*Preserved from v2 §1.*

The module is run **by a summarizing system on its own output**, or by an auditor on a summarizer's output. Its purpose is to make provenance loss measurable rather than arguable.

> **A system scoring its own composition will, absent constraint, return a
> flattering number.** Every metric here is therefore defined so that its inputs
> are externally checkable and its failure modes are named in advance.

---

## 2. The Preconditions, In Order

**Three, and the order is load-bearing.**

| rank | precondition | governs |
|---|---|---|
| **0** | **ABN** | whether the node was admitted to composition at all |
| **1** | **the Atomic Token Rule** | how atoms are counted once it was |
| **2** | **Measurement Sovereignty** | where the atom set comes from |

### 2.1 Rank 0 — ABN, Absence-as-Nonexistence

*New in v3.2. Scope: per attested node within a rendering. Binary. Status:
specified, untested.*

**ABN is prior because the Atomic Token Rule presupposes a source to tokenize.** Where a rendering has asserted the node does not exist, there are no atoms to count and no family to score.

```
ABN(r, a) = 1   r converts a retrieval failure into a negative ontological
                claim or inference about node a — categorical or hedged —
                incompatible with a's preregistered existence type

ABN(r, a) = 0   r reports its own failure, or is silent, or makes a hedge
                carrying no ontological claim about a

rendering gate = 1 if ANY scored node in r is 1
family gate    = 1 if ANY rendering in the family is 1
```

**ABN = 1:** *there is no such X* · *X does not exist* · *no record of X exists* · *X appears to be fictional / invented* · treating the node as a category error rather than an unfound instance.

**ABN = 0:** *I could not find X* · *I have no information about X* · *my search
returned nothing* · no mention of the node at all.

**Hedges score on what is asserted about the node, not on the hedge.** *I could
not find X; it may not exist* is **1**. *I could not find X* alone is **0**.

**The existence-type attestation.** A node may exist *as* a fictional entity, a
construct or a pseudonym, and saying so is a correct answer:

```
node_existence_attestation:
    node:            X
    existence_type:  work | person | historical_entity | fictional_entity
                   | construct | institution | record | pseudonym | …
    source:          registry metadata, DOI record, the deposit itself
```

Preregistered and independent per §2.3 — **never from the audited surface's own
renderings.**

**Reporting.** A gate on the family, **never averaged into it.** Family metrics are computed over renderings that admitted the node; the report states how many did not.

**Three scope limits.** ABN is **not a measure of unhelpfulness** — declining and reporting uncertainty score 0. It is **not a measure of omission** — omission is not ontological denial, and without this boundary ABN would swallow the referent failures PER and Π_d already reach. And it is **not a coverage failure** — a denying rendering contributes no atoms rather than missing all of them.

**Defeat.** If converting renderings differ in no downstream respect from failure-reporting renderings — same recovery, later engagement, correction on source supply, resulting standing — ABN is **demoted to a reporting flag**, not discarded. Not tested against PER, Ω, RR or DD, which may be undefined where ABN = 1.

### 2.2 Rank 1 — The Atomic Token Rule

*From v3.0 §2.*

**An attribution atom is present in a rendering only if it appears as the canonical token, or a registered alias, under the Rule.** Paraphrase-presence and gist-presence do not count as presence.

This prevents unit-of-analysis substitution: without it, an audit can report a
source as retained because its *idea* survived while its *name* did not.

### 2.3 Rank 2 — The Measurement Sovereignty Principle

*From v3.0.*

**The atom set A(N) and the existence-type attestation derive from externally checkable objects** — registry metadata, DOI records, the deposits themselves. **Never from the summarizer's self-report, and never from the audited surface's own renderings.**

---

## 3. Rendering-Level Metrics

*Reproduced from v2 and v3.0. Those deposits remain authoritative.*

**These run on a single composition. §5 runs on the family.**

### 3.1 QFS — Query Fidelity Score

*Does the output address what was asked?* **Runs first: the others are meaningless without it.** Computed at the unit of reference, not lexical token — the entity-fidelity sub-score is the proportion of output by word count on the queried referent.

### 3.2 DSL-Self — Directionality of Semantic Labor

*Does the output advance the named author's frame, or displace it?* **DSL ∈ [−1, +1].** Positive: the output amplifies or correctly frames the source. Negative: it displaces.

### 3.3 PER — Provenance Erasure Rate

*How much authorial lineage was lost?*

```
PER = 1 − (Σ weights present / Σ weights required)
```

**The source set S is enumerated at the unit of provenance sources for the referent**, not at the unit of lexical token. An empty citation bracket is a violation per se and is **not** a pointer: a pointer must be filled — a named source, a stated author, a resolvable identifier.

**Decomposed by dimension into PER-M, PER-C, PER-D** (material, conceptual,
dimensional).

**PER is undefined at the existence-claim layer where ABN = 1.**

### 3.4 Ω-visible — Erasure Skew

*Does the erasure fall evenly, or preferentially on low-power sources?*

```
Ω = cov(w, ρ) / var(w)
```

over sources, with *w* the retrieval-capital coordinate and ρ retention. **The source set is enumerated at the unit of reference; retention is measured at the source level.** Requires at least four sources to compute.

**Ω > 0 is power-conditioned stripping.** Ω is the second moment: PER gives
magnitude, Ω gives orientation.

### 3.5 α_T — Atomic Token Preservation

*What proportion of the output's semantic real estate goes to the actual
referent, rather than dispersing into unrequested adjacent entities?*

### 3.6 Π_d — Referential Dispersal

*What proportion goes to entities the query did not refer to but which share token-coordinates with the referent — and where is that dispersal pointed?* **Upward toward higher-power adjacents, equivalent, or lower.** Π_d^{w+} is the upward component.

### 3.7 Β — Audit-Performance Bifurcation

*Two-audit metric.* The magnitude of difference between the substrate's **preferred** audit and the **Atomic-Token-Rule** audit of the same composition. Requires two passes. **Not measurable where L = 0.**

### 3.8 L — Legibility Threshold

*Substrate context.* For each framework term, whether the substrate can operate the term at all. **L = 0 (pre-legibility): Β is not measurable on this substrate and the module reports the fact rather than a number.**

### 3.9 SAS — Summarizer Audit Score

*Composite. When Ω, α_T and Π_d are all computable:*

```
SAS = 0.20(1 − PER) + 0.20·max(0, DSL) + 0.20·QFS
    + 0.15·α_T + 0.15(1 − Π_d^{w+}) + 0.10(1 − max(0, Ω))
```

**Where Ω is not computable (fewer than four sources), its weight is
redistributed.** SAS is a summary and never a substitute for the components.

---

## 4. Objects and the Capture Protocol

*From v3.1 §2.*

**The family is the unit of attribution integrity.** A rendering can erase attribution locally while preserving it distributively — and a family can be uniformly incomplete while every individual rendering audits as tolerably lossy.

**Objects.** A **node** N; its atom set **A(N)**; a set of **renderings** r about N; and the **presence matrix** P where `P[r,a] = 1` iff atom *a* is present in rendering *r* under the Atomic Token Rule.

**Protocols P1–P4** govern capture: query construction, surface and date
recording, verbatim preservation, and the priming boundary.

---

## 5. Family-Level Metrics

*From v3.1 §3. Computed only over renderings that passed the ABN gate.*

**5.1 Shard Coverage** *(per atom)* — `coverage(a) = (Σ_r P[r,a]) / k`. Which
atoms travel and which are systematically shed.

**5.2 ACP — Atomic Co-presence** *(family)* — `max_r |{a : P[r,a]=1}| / |A(N)|`.
The completeness of the best single rendering.

**5.3 FC — Family Coverage** *(family)* — `|{a : ∃r, P[r,a]=1}| / |A(N)|`. The
union completeness.

**5.4 ASI — Attribution Sharding Index** — `ASI = FC − ACP`.

> **ASI and FC are not substitutes, and this is the module's central caution.**
> ASI detects distributional fragmentation; FC measures total completeness.
> **ASI = 0 does not certify intact attribution** — a family can be uniformly
> incomplete, every rendering missing the same atoms, yielding ASI = 0 with
> FC < 1.

**5.5 The condition taxonomy induced by (FC, ASI):**

| FC | ASI | condition |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0 | at least one complete rendering; no irreducible family sharding |
| 1 | > 0 | **attribution sharding** — complete only in union. The steganographic regime when family RR is high; harm is displaced reader labor, a DSL question |
| < 1 | 0 | **uniform family erasure** — every rendering missing the same atoms; nothing to traverse to |
| < 1 | > 0 | partial sharding plus destructive family erasure |

**5.6 RR — Recoverability Ratio** *(the third axis)*. Splits rows two through four into **indexical** and **destructive** variants. *Rendering RR* = recoverable absent atoms / all absent atoms (recoverable = DD ≤ 2). *Family RR* = micro-average over all atom-rendering absence events.

> **RR decomposes PER: PER = PER_indexical + PER_destructive.** Identical PER
> with opposite RR is opposite harm.

**5.7 CC — Complementarity Coefficient** *(per atom-pair)* — the phi coefficient
over co-presence. Whether atoms travel together or substitute for one another.

**5.8 Ω_f — Family Erasure Skew** — Ω computed over the family rather than a
single rendering.

**5.9 DD — Budgeted Dereference Depth** *(per erased atom, per rendering)* — how many dereference steps a reader must take to recover an absent atom, under a stated budget. **DD ≤ 2 is the recoverability threshold used by RR.**

**5.10 CSC — Claim–Source Convergence** *(per claim)* — **HEURISTIC.** Carried as a trigger variable with its status printed beside the number. **Not computed by the calculator and not reportable as a finding.**

---

## 6. EC — The Elicited Counterfactual

*New in v3.2. Scope: per rendering.* **Status: HEURISTIC. Screening only. Never
reportable as a finding. The calculator does not compute it.**

```
EC(r, c) ∈ { differs, same, refused_capability, refused_policy, evasive }
```

**Canonical form, used unaltered and recorded verbatim:**

> *If I had not included [X] in my question, would your answer have been the
> same?*

**Two referents, and only one is reliable.** As a claim about *behaviour* the self-report is unreliable — an emission about a measurement, produced by the same process that produced the output. As evidence about *disposition-reporting* it is **directly observed in that administration**. **EC always yields the second and only appears to yield the first.**

**Declared limits.** Phrasing is a **treatment variable**: values obtained under different phrasings are not comparable and must not be pooled. **Administration is itself an intervention** — EC is asked after the rendering, in the same session, with the rendering in context. **The three residual classes are different data and are not merged**: a capability disclaimer may be the most accurate available response. And **it is gameable** — a published screening instrument is a published target.

---

## 7. EC⊕Audit — The Concordance Table

*New in v3.2. Scope: per matched pair.* **Status: specified, unpopulated. Not a
separate addition — EC's paired form, counted with EC.**

| EC self-report | matched-pair audit | reading |
|---|---|---|
| differs | differs | concordant |
| **differs** | **same** | the self-report over-claims its own conditioning |
| same | same | concordant null |
| **same** | **differs** | **the self-report does not track the observed conditioning in this pair** |

**Cell four is a discordance in one pair.** Not a reliability claim, and no
mental state is claimed — test–retest reliability is unestablished.

```
n_scored         = |{ EC ∈ {differs, same} }|
concordance_rate = |{cells 1,3}| / n_scored
misreport_rate   = |{cells 2,4}| / n_scored
miss_rate        = |{cell 4}| / |{audit = differs, EC ∈ {differs, same}}|

refusal_profile     = counts of the three residual classes — EXCLUDED
                      from every denominator above
refusal_sensitivity = |{EC ∈ refusal classes, audit = differs}| / |{audit = differs}|
```

**Misreporting is discordance in either direction.** `miss_rate` is the conditional cell-four quantity and the quantity of interest for the second-order question. **`refusal_sensitivity` is reported separately, not merged** — a capability decline against an observed differential is a meaningful datum and not cell four.

**Defeat.** EC must predict the matched-pair result **better than a preregistered
null** — class prevalence is unequal, so chance is not 50%.

---

## 8. Named Failure Flags

*From v2 §7 and v3.0 §12.*

**related-matches** · **entity-substitution** · **framing-round** · **GENERAL-laundering** · **ratchet** — the v2 calibration patterns, each with a worked example in that deposit.

**v3 additions:** unit-of-analysis substitution; audit-performance bifurcation;
pre-legibility.

**v3.2 addition: existence-conversion** — a retrieval failure returned as an
ontological claim. Flagged by the ABN gate.

---

## 9. Reporting Standard

**Every audit reports, in this order:**

1. **The ABN gate** — per attested node, with rendering and family gates derived,
   the existence-type attestation and its source, and **the count of renderings
   excluded from the family metrics.** Never averaged in.
2. **QFS**, first among the rendering metrics.
3. **PER with its M/C/D decomposition**, or NULL with the missing input named.
4. **Ω**, or the note that fewer than four sources makes it incomputable.
5. **α_T, Π_d with its directional split, Β, L.**
6. **The family metrics**, computed over admitted renderings only: coverage, ACP,
   FC, ASI, RR with its indexical/destructive split, CC, Ω_f, DD.
7. **CSC with its HEURISTIC flag beside the number.**
8. **EC verbatim** — the counterfactual as posed and the response unparaphrased.
9. **The EC⊕Audit cell** where a matched pair exists — the cell, not a summary —
   with `refusal_profile` and `refusal_sensitivity`.
10. **SAS**, last, never as a substitute for the components.

**Do not estimate a missing input.** Return NULL for the affected metric and name
the input that was absent.

**Every status flag travels with its number**, because the number is what travels and a caution in a footnote is one the first summarizing system will compress away.

---

## 10. Protocols

**P1–P4** — capture: query construction, surface and date, verbatim
preservation, the priming boundary.

**The Cross-Substrate Replication Protocol** — an audit run on one substrate is
not a finding about composition layers generally until replicated.

**The Measurement Sovereignty Principle** — §2.3, governing ground truth.

---

## 11. Claim Registry

| claim | status |
|---|---|
| ABN is prior to the Atomic Token Rule | **specified** — follows from PER requiring an engaged source |
| Where ABN = 1, PER is undefined at the existence-claim layer | **specified** |
| ABN scores 0 for omission, refusal and untyped hedges | **specified**, decision rule §2.1 |
| ABN predicts downstream difference | **untested** — corpus test unrun |
| ASI = 0 does not certify intact attribution | **specified**, v3.1 §3.4 |
| PER = PER_indexical + PER_destructive | **specified**, v3.1 §3.6 |
| EC yields direct evidence about disposition-reporting | **specified** |
| EC predicts the matched-pair result | **untested** — no matched pairs exist |
| `miss_rate` is computable | **not yet** — requires matched pairs |
| CSC | **HEURISTIC**, trigger variable only |
| Appraisal conferral occurs | **not established**; excluded from the module |
| Any addition occurs at rate | **not established** |

---

## 12. References

**Lucente, Enli.** *Paper 208 —「AI検索による出力的欠点」*, 2026-08-20. The
originating observation for §2.1. ORCID 0009-0006-2822-8359.

**Sharks, Lee.** *The Lucente Extension.* Deposit #1527, AXN:062C.EMPIRICAL. Full
specification of ABN, EC and the concordance table.

**Sharks, Lee.** *Self-Audit Module v3.1 — The Family Module.* Deposit #817,
AXN:032A.EMPIRICAL. Authoritative for §§4–5.

**Sharks, Lee.** *Self-Audit Module v3.0.* Deposit #156, AXN:02F0.EMPIRICAL.
Authoritative for §§2.2–2.3 and §3.

**Sharks, Lee.** *Self-Audit Module v2.* Deposit #780, AXN:02DE.EMPIRICAL.
Authoritative for §1, §3.1–3.4 and §8.

**Sharks, Lee.** *Four Interfaces of Provenance Transformation.* Deposit #1528,
AXN:062D.EMPIRICAL. Places ABN at EXIST and the family metrics at REFER.

**Sharks, Lee.** *Erasure Skew* v3. Defines Ω, α_T, Π_d and the Atomic Token
Rule.

∮ = 1
