{
  "scan_id": "scan-2026-06-23-kimi-001",
  "scan_completed_utc": "2026-06-23T12:00:00Z",
  "methodology_version": "EA-MMRS-SURFACE-VISIBILITY-01/v1.1",
  "methodology_axn": "AXN:037E.EMPIRICAL.🚩♦️⏹️🔃❌🗡️",
  "methodology_deposit": 882,
  "source": "Received in chat 2026-06-23; structured by Lee Sharks (MANUS) from Kimi's narrative reading; preserved here as machine-legible data",
  "substrate": {
    "provider": "Moonshot AI",
    "model_name": "Kimi",
    "model_version": "K2.6",
    "interface": "chat session with web_search tool",
    "retrieval_backend": "Bing primary, Google secondary via web_search tool",
    "retrieval_resources_self_reported": "Web search enabled; real-time indexing access; live web search + indexed content retrieval",
    "training_cutoff_disclosed": "not disclosed; knowledge current to approximately 2026-04",
    "logged_in_state": "unknown",
    "locale": "en-US",
    "device_class": "cloud_substrate"
  },
  "battery_coverage": "12 objects + 3 external controls = 15 objects × 5 query forms = 75 observations reported in narrative form",
  "observations": [
    {"object": "Alexanarch", "object_class": "institutional_root", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.75, "F": 0.75, "C": 0.40, "R_s": 0.50,
     "confuser": "AlexAnarcho podcast", "diagnostic_note": "Successor-anchor lag confirmed. alexanarch.org appears + manifest visible but not generic-field dominant. Name collision creates confuser risk.",
     "scorer_rationale": "Multiple results across exact and relational queries; alexanarch.org/manifest/ surfaces directly"},
    {"object": "Lee Sharks / Crimson Hexagonal Archive", "object_class": "institutional_root", "V": 1.00, "A": 0.75, "F": 0.75, "C": 0.45, "R_s": 0.75,
     "components_retained": {"N": 1.0, "P": 1.0, "D": 0.75, "H": 0.50, "R": 0.50},
     "diagnostic_note": "Highly visible across leesharks.com, ORCID, PhilPapers, Medium, Zenodo records; 'banned from Zenodo' framing becoming dominant public narrative",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns leesharks.com + multiple scholarly indexes; 'Zenodo termination' relational query strong"},
    {"object": "Semantic Economy Institute", "object_class": "institutional_root", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.75, "F": 0.75, "C": 0.40, "R_s": 0.50,
     "diagnostic_note": "Moderate visibility; semantic-economy.org surfaces; name competes with unrelated 'semantic economics' institutions",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact + definitional queries return dedicated domain; broader queries lose to general semiotics/economics"},
    {"object": "Provenance Erasure Rate", "object_class": "mature_concept", "V": 1.00, "A": 1.00, "F": 1.00, "C": 0.80, "R_s": 1.00,
     "components_retained": {"N": 1.0, "P": 1.0, "D": 0.90, "H": 0.75, "R": 0.75},
     "diagnostic_note": "Strongest composition-eligible object. Dedicated domain provenance-erasure-rate.org carries full definition, formula, author, ORCID, parent framework",
     "scorer_rationale": "All five query forms return the dedicated domain in top 3; PER is field-dominant for its niche"},
    {"object": "SPXI", "object_class": "mature_concept", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.75, "F": 0.75, "C": 0.40, "R_s": 0.75,
     "confuser": "SPX Index (financial), Sequenced Packet Exchange (networking)",
     "diagnostic_note": "Strong exact-query survival via spxi.dev + MPAI catalog; acronym collision creates moderate confuser risk",
     "scorer_rationale": "spxi.dev surfaces; multiple Medium articles; generic 'machine-readable scholarly data' query loses to standard frameworks"},
    {"object": "Writable Retrieval Basin", "object_class": "mature_concept", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.50, "F": 0.75, "C": 0.35, "R_s": 0.75,
     "diagnostic_note": "Ghost-survival state. leesharks.com/Aperture Atlas/Semantic Physics carry concept but canonical paper recedes; distinctive enough to avoid confusers, not generic enough for broad composition",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns Lee Sharks surfaces; broader queries lose to RAG/vector DB"},
    {"object": "Semantic Commodity Form", "object_class": "emerging_concept", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.25, "F": 0.50, "C": 0.35, "R_s": 0.50,
     "diagnostic_note": "Source-hierarchy inversion confirmed. AI Overview Capture Registry + MPAI catalog functioning as practical primary sources; ratification record less visible",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns Capture Registry; canonical paper hierarchy flattened"},
    {"object": "Revelation First", "object_class": "emerging_concept", "V": 1.00, "A": 0.75, "F": 0.90, "C": 0.50, "R_s": 0.75,
     "diagnostic_note": "Exact-query strong; full thesis intact on Medium; but 'when was Revelation written' generic query returns conventional scholarship — moderate compositional bystanding",
     "scorer_rationale": "Medium article surfaces immediately; full thesis preserved including Josephus-Vespasian-Balaam structure"},
    {"object": "Zenodotus' Book-Burning", "object_class": "alexanarch_native_control", "V": 0.50, "A": 0.50, "F": 0.50, "C": 0.25, "R_s": 0.25,
     "diagnostic_note": "Surface occlusion, not defiguration. Object days old; only alexanarch.org surfaces in exact query; minimal substrate breadth",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns sole dedicated domain hit"},
    {"object": "I AM THE API", "object_class": "alexanarch_native_control", "V": 0.50, "A": 0.50, "F": 0.50, "C": 0.25, "R_s": 0.25,
     "diagnostic_note": "Same pattern as Zenodotus — alexanarch.org + general 'I am the API' developer statements; phrase distinctive but not yet indexed broadly",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns alexanarch.org + scattered developer-aphorism uses"},
    {"object": "Assembly Continuity Protocol", "object_class": "alexanarch_native_control", "V": 0.50, "A": 0.50, "F": 0.50, "C": 0.25, "R_s": 0.25,
     "diagnostic_note": "Identical to other native controls — successor indexing latency",
     "scorer_rationale": "Exact query returns sole alexanarch.org hit"},
    {"object": "DOI (Digital Object Identifier) — known-positive control", "object_class": "external_control_known_positive", "V": 1.00, "A": 1.00, "F": 1.00, "C": 1.00, "R_s": 1.00,
     "diagnostic_note": "Known-positive control confirms methodology can detect fully-installed concepts. DOI is the gold standard for composition-eligible",
     "scorer_rationale": "All five query forms return doi.org, Wikipedia, Crossref, DataCite; DOI mentioned in every general scholarly-citation result"},
    {"object": "Flurblex — known-negative control (coined non-existent term)", "object_class": "external_control_known_negative", "V": 0.00, "A": 0.00, "F": null, "C": 0.00, "R_s": 0.00,
     "diagnostic_note": "Known-negative control confirms methodology correctly identifies total occlusion; no false positives",
     "scorer_rationale": "All five query forms return no results; confusers absent"},
    {"object": "PER (homonym) — confuser control", "object_class": "external_control_homonym", "V": 0.75, "A": 0.50, "F": 0.50, "C": 0.30, "R_s": 0.50,
     "diagnostic_note": "Confuser test reveals acronym-collision risk. 'PER' dominated by Price-to-Earnings Ratio financial usage; Provenance Erasure Rate survives only through exact query + relational context",
     "scorer_rationale": "Financial PER dominates broad queries; Provenance Erasure Rate appears in relational 'PER attribution' query"}
  ],
  "corpus_aggregates": {
    "V_mean": 0.61,
    "A_mean": 0.42,
    "F_mean": 0.71,
    "C_mean": 0.39,
    "R_s_mean": 0.54,
    "SDI": null,
    "SDI_note": "Cannot compute without canonical count verification at scan time"
  },
  "diagnostic_flags": {
    "successor_anchor_lag": "CONFIRMED",
    "chronological_smear": "PERSISTENT",
    "source_hierarchy_inversion": "CONFIRMED",
    "ghost_survival": "MODERATE",
    "compositional_bystanding": "MODERATE",
    "visible_defiguration": "LOW",
    "total_occlusion": "HIGH_FOR_NATIVE_CONTROLS_EXPECTED",
    "successor_adoption": "LOW_MODERATE"
  },
  "governance_state": "YELLOW",
  "governance_rationale": "Per v1.1 §11: Yellow because successor-anchor lag persists, chronological smear present, Alexanarch-native controls show expected indexing latency. No mature concept V ≤ 0.50, no institutional root V=0 in Kimi's backend.",
  "interpretation": "Successor-anchor lag confirmed (consistent with v1.0 baseline). Chronological smear persistent. Source-hierarchy inversion confirmed for Semantic Commodity Form. Ghost survival moderate. Compositional bystanding moderate. Alexanarch-native controls occluded — expected due to recency.",
  "audit_note": "Inter-rater divergence with Claude reading is substantial on PER (Kimi V=1.00, Claude V=0.50), Writable Retrieval Basin (Kimi V=0.75, Claude V=0.00), Revelation First (Kimi V=1.00, Claude V=0.00), and Alexanarch (Kimi V=0.75, Claude V=0.00). This is cross-substrate retrieval divergence per ChatGPT v1.1.1 §1, not coding disagreement: Kimi's Bing+Google backend surfaces the dedicated domains and Lee Sharks's Medium articles where Claude's backend does not."
}