STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. May 19, 1919] THE CLASSICAL WEEKLY 215 work. The author, we happen to know, has had The Unwilling Vestal on his mind for some thirty years and writes out of a fulness of knowledge that may well lead him to dissent from some of the reviewer's con- clusions. Our final suggestion may be unacceptable to Mr. White after writing sq charmingly and without the slightest taint of pedantry a book intended pri- marily to entertain: The Unwilling Vestal could profitably be assigned to young Latinists to review for class-room purposes, or to a Classical Club of undergraduates for an evening of discussion, or to an advanced class in Private Life or Roman Religion for serious analysis and verification upon the basis of our ancient authorities. We plan to commit several of these sins ourselves. University of Pennsylvania. Walton Brooks McDaniel. Essais d' Etymologie et de Critique Verbale Latines; Recueil de Travaux Publies par la Faculty des Lettres de 1' University de Neuchatel, Septieme Fascicule. Par Max Niedermann. Paris and Neuchatel: Attinger Freres (1918). Pp.119. At the close of his Preface, dated July 31, 191 8, Professor Niedermann thanks his faculty and La Society Academique de Neuchatel for having made possible the publication of his book "en depit des difficulty de 1' heure actuelle". Honor to the Swiss University which carried on the cause of scholarship even in dark days! These pages contain a miscellany of etymologies and elucidations of difficult passages in certain epi- graphic and Vulgar Latin texts. The whole book is tied together by a single method — a method as sound as it is uncommon. In matters of etymology Niedermann is particularly concerned to gather all possible light from the resources of Latin itself and from a pains- taking study of the semantic problems involved. In textual matters he calls in the help of scientific gram- mar. In short, Niedermann has given us a brief demonstration of the interdependence of the study of Latin texts and the study of the Latin language. Possibly the most interesting of the etymological articles is that on parma (pages 36-45). After examin- ing and rejecting the previously suggested etymologies, not one of which really has anything in its favor except phonetic possibility, and some not even that, our author suggests that palma, in its original sense of 'hand' (Greek iraXd^r;), formed a diminutive palmula, which was changed by dissimulation to parmula. Many examples are cited from various languages of 'diminutives' in form but not in sense; e.g. armitta, 'bracelet', from armus, 'arm', and manicula, 'handle of the plough', from manus, 'hand' ; in a similar fashion parmula came to me,an 'shield'. Professor Petersen's monograph on Greek Diminutives in -tar, particularly 98 ff., might have suggested that parmula was not a true diminutive at all, but contained some earlier meaning of the suffix; at any rate, the meaning of the derivative seems to be parallel with that of armitta and manicula. Parma, then, is a retrograde derivative of parmula, just as pugna cones from pugnare, which is itself a derivative of pugnus, 'fist'. On pages 55 f . there is a discussion of an epigraphical dedication to Priapus, C. I. L. 5. 28o3=Carmina Epi- graphica 861 : Villicus aerari quondam, nunc cultor agelli, haec tibi perspectus templa Priape dico. Perspeclus, in the sense of probatus, is to be taken with Priape. There are many Latin examples of the vocative in -us, as Audi tu, populus Albanus (Livy 1.24.7); but for exact parallels to our passage Nieder- mann goes to tj>l\os S> Mer4\ae (II. 4.189), oCXos Sretpe (sic, II. 2.8), and the Lithuanian adjectives, which differ from the nouns in having lost the vocative form. Of particular interest to grammarians is a footnote on pages 31 f., concerning Indo-European dh. The new hypothesis has the advantage of making the second consonant of medius from *medhios and of ruber from *rudhros a voiced sound from the earliest times, instead of assuming an interval of voicelessness in the Italic period. Columbia University. E. H. STURTEVANT. HARVARD STUDIES IN CLASSICAL PHILOLOGY, VOLUME XXIX Volume XXIX of Harvard Studies in Classical Philology contains three papers: Plato's View of Poetry, 1-75, by William Chase Greene; Collations of the Manuscripts of Aristophanes' Aves, by John Williams White and Earnest Cary, 77-131; Joseph Scaliger's Estimates of Greek and Latin Authors, by George W. Robinson (133-176). A page in the volume is dedicated to a brief record of Professor White's service at Harvard. Mr. Greene's essay is a revision of his doctoral dissertation, Quid de Poetis Plato Censuerit, presented to Harvard University in 1 91 7. The study is carefully documented, by references to Plato and other Greek writers, and to modern scholars who have written about Plato. He sums up on pages 73-75. We must not hope, he says, to find in Plato's writings a definite formula that shall represent Plato's views. Mr. Robinson regards Joseph Scaliger as "the great- est scholar of modern times — if not indeed of all times", and feels that, therefore, a peculiar value attaches to his estimates of the classical writers. A few of these estimates had been collected and arranged in Sir Thomas Blount's Censura Celebriorum Authorum (1690), but most of them had been uncollected, till Mr. Robinson • himself read through the huge bulk of Scaliger's writings, and presented the results in the present paper. Mr. Robinson has also included the Scaligerana, memoranda of Scaliger's informal conver- 216 THE CLASSICAL WEEKLY [Vol. XII, No. 27, Whole No. 341 sations jotted down, for the years 1 574-1 593, by Franciscus Vertunianus, and for the years 1603-1606 by the brothers Vassan. They contain, says Mr. Robinson, much that is of value, a value that is, at times, increased by their very informality. The arrangement of the Estimates is alphabetical, usually by authors, occasionally by groups of authors (in the latter case the necessary cross-references are inserted.) The actual citations 'from Scaliger cover pages 137-176. Though the footnotes, which give references to the place in which Scaliger expressed the particular judgment, take up a certain amount of every page; the actual bulk of these citations is very great, and the range of authors of whom Scaliger speaks is enormous. The major part of the authors, Greek and Latin both, lie far outside the reading, I should say, of most classical scholars. Comments on the more familiar authors — e.g. Aristophanes, Plautus, Horace, Terence, take up little space. The Appendix Vergiliana receives much more attention than the unquestioned works of Vergil. Many of the comments are brief, of the sort that one might make even without any careful, first-hand knowledge of the authors, but it is abundantly clear, after all, that Scaliger knew the authors, Greek and Latin, as few men have known them. One cannot help thinking, as he turns over Mr. Robin- son's pages, of the wonderful knowledge of orators, Greek and Roman, Cicero displays in his Brutus. In both cases, Scaliger's and Cicero's, the knowledge is of the sort that the Germans once were fond of charac- terizing by the word Autopsie'. c. K. THE PHILADELPHIA SOCIETY FOR THE PROMOTION OF LIBERAL STUDIES The Philadelphia Society for the Promotion of Liberal Studies held its Sixth Annual Meeting in Houston Hall, of the University of Pennsylvania, on Saturday, March 22. The following officers were elected: President, Professor George Depue Hadzsits, University of Pennsylvania; Vice-Presidents, Mr. Harvey Watts, of the Public Ledger, and Dr. Laura Carnell, of Temple University; Secretary, Miss Bessie R. Burchett, South Philadelphia High School for Girls; Treasurer, Mr. Fred. J. Doolittle, The Episcopal Academy. Miss Florence A. Fonda, of the West Chester High School, presented a paper on Vitality versus Mortality in High School Latin. Miss Fonda described plays, games, etc., by means of which she stimulates interest in Latin. The figures which she gave show the success of her methods, for almost half of the pupils in the School elect Latin. Dr. Mary C. Burchinal, of the West Philadelphia High School for Girls, gave a paper on How to Make the Teaching of the Classics Vital. Dr. Burchinal pre- sented different phases of the vitality of Latin, and read some of the answers to a questionnaire in which her pupils had been asked to tell why they liked Latin. Professor Lane Cooper, of Cornell University, in a paper abounding in interest and wit as well as in learn- ing, to which this short review can not do justice, pleaded the cause of the Classics. He compared the spirit of ancient, medieval, and modern literature, and urged that young people in their formative years should study Latin and Greek authors for the sake of the standard of good taste to be found there. He very forcefully advocated a revision of the classical course, making it include a minimum of syntax, and a great amount of reading. Ovid and Plato are the authors he thinks most fruitful, both because of their influence upon English literature and thought, and because of the ideas to be obtained from these ancient sources. One suggestion of his is both an encouragement and a warning: that both teachers and pupils should read more widely in ancient literature. He says that it is possible for pupils to acquire the habit of reading Latin and Greek rapidly, just as they acquire that of reading modern languages rapidly; but, in order to train their students to this, teachers themselves must read widely, for it is impossible to impart a habit which one does not possess. The President, Dr. W. W. Comfort, President of Haverford College, in his annual report reviewed a prosperous year for the Society. Of the first meeting of the year, held on November 8, a report appeared in The Classical Weekly 12.62-63. The addresses delivered there have been published in pamphlet form by the University of Pennsylvania (The Classical Weekly 12.160). The second meeting was held in Witherspoon Hall. The general subject was Liberal Studies and their Relation to Citizenship and Patriotism. The speakers were Mr. Walter George Smith, Miss Agnes Repplier, and Dr. Henry Van Dyke. The third meeting was concerned with Educational Reconstruction. Dr. Francis B. Brandt, Dean Wil- liam McClellan, Dr. John P. Garber, President Joseph Swain, Professor William I. Hull, Professor Elihu Grant, and Rev. John A. MacCallum took part in this discussion. The Society feels that the fact that so many eminent men and women have spoken in Philadelphia for the value of the Classics can not fail to influence public opinion. In addition to the public meetings, the Society, through Miss Jessie E. Allen, Chairman of the Lecture- ship Committee, has arranged for free lectures which were delivered in Schools in Philadelphia and the vicinity (The Classical Weekly 12.128). Bessie R. Burchett, Secretary. QUERY CONCERNING THE TOGA PRAETEXTA Can anyone supply pertinent facts in answer to the question, How did the Romans make the red stripe in the toga? To this question I have had various answers: "They sewed on a piece of ribbon or cloth. There was no seam"; "They wove it in the fabic of the toga"; "Such a stripe cannot be woven in such a whole piece of cloth"; "They cut the toga and sewed in a colored strip". None of these answers seems to me satisfactory; some of them must be wrong. Franklin A. Dakin Haverford School.