STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 154 THE CLASSICAL WEEKLY THE NEW CLASSICAL PHILOLOdY 1 I derive the title of my paper by analogy from "the new theology". We, who were brought up in the theology of our fathers and have since kept up with recent developments in theological thought, recognize that the new theology is merely the adaptation of the old truths of religion to the life and forms of thought of to-day. It is a shaking off of the shackles of eighteenth century statements of biblical doctrines, and an endeavor to preserve the old wine of divine truth in the new bottles of modern science and philosophy. There is a great contrast between the 'Zeit- geist' of the early nineteenth and that of the early twentieth century, brought about by the changes of economic conditions, the development of science and the broadening of knowledge of man and the uni- verse. The spirit of the former period was essen- tially intellectual and cultural, of the latter social and utilitarian. A century ago the standard of effi- ciency was, "What does he know?"; to-day it is "What can he do?" The old theology aimed to make a man good and to fit him for heaven; the new theology aims to make a man .good for something and to fit him for the life of to-day. Similarly in education a century ago the culture ideal prevailed; to-day the service ideal is dominant. A century ago, the man of thought was held highest in honor; to-day the man of action wins more general esteem. A century ago the three learned professions — of the preacher, the lawyer, the doctor — were paramount; to-day their place is taken by the captain of industry, the banker and the engineer. In the light of this change in the spirit of the times, we must investigate the development of clas- sical studies, in order fully to appreciate their pres- ent status and to mark out the path whereby they may once more attain to pre-eminence in the educa- tional system of the future. The evolution of classical studies in the last hun- dred years aptly illustrates Hegel's well-known aphorism that truth in its development is the media- tion between two opposites evolved through three successive stages, viz. : thesis, or the dogmatic stage ; antithesis, or the stage of opposition and contradic- tion; and synthesis, or the stage of reconciliation and final adjustment. During the first half of the nineteenth century classicism of the Oxford type dominated the college and university curriculum. This was the pabulum that produced great statesmen, profound lawyers and eloquent preachers. They assimilated the spirit of the Greeks and Romans, found in ancient writers principles of action to meet contemporary problems, and brought the wisdom of the ancients to bear on the affairs of modern life. Humanism, or the aes- thetic culture inherent in the Classics, was the mark 1 This paper was read at the Second Annual Meeting of the Classical Association of the Atlantic States at Washington, D. C, April ij, 1908. of the gentleman; clear and accurate thinking, re- fined diction, a knowledge of belles lettres, history, philosophy, and ability to quote the great masters of Greece and Rome, were the tests of scholarship. By degrees, however, the great strides made by physical science won attention and the great benefits conferred by science introduced a new standard of educational efficiency. The scientific, in contrast to the humanistic spirit, dominated the intellectual field. The expanding university life of Germany brought in new ideals of educational fitness, by emphasizing erudition rather than culture. Herbert Spencer as- sailed the traditional humanistic ideal and "sternly required every branch of learning to say what it could do for its possessor toward the ends of self- preservation and the continuation of the species". Thus was ushered in a period of antithesis, the con- test of conflicting ideals in education. The new sciences with their utilitarian bias demanded recog- nition, and it devolved on the Classics to conform to the scientific standard of efficiency that rapidly be- came dominant. The response of the Classics was the development of philology as a science, the endeavor to treat lan- guage by methods similar to those found in the chemical and biological laboratories. In their eager- ness to demonstrate the scientific character of classi- cal study, however, classical teachers lost sight too frequently of the essentially humanistic nature of the material they had to deal with. The masterpiece of classical literature was ofttimes regarded as merely a cadaver for scientific dissection to establish the laws of language and to train the mind of students in scientific method. The value of the Classics as a mental discipline and the position of classical phil- ology as a science were established, yet there is no telling how much was lost to mankind in the sacri- fice of spirit to letter, of content to form. By enter- ing into friendly rivalry with physical science on its own ground, classical philology has gained recog- nition as a member of the republic of sciences, yet in the period of antithesis, the value of humanism as an educational force has become obscured, and thus the Classics have lost somewhat the bloom of their peculiar excellence. Fortunately, we have now entered upon the third period, synthesis, the stage of reconciliation and final adjustment, and our leading university presi- dents, especially Schurman and Wilson, are urging the need of a revival of the spirit of humanism puri- fied by the fiery trial it has passed through, and its recognition as the twin sister of the scientific spirit. Higher education in America has entered upon a new phase of vast significance. We are witnessing the union of the spirit of science with that of hu- manism and the emergence of a new ideal of personal efficiency, which combines liberal culture with tech- nical training. The life of the spirit is asserting it- self as of at least equal importance with material welfare, and the need of the Classics is being felt THE CLASSICAL WEEKLY 155 most keenly in localities where technical education has received its highest development. Out of the struggle of the past fifty years is emerging the netv classical philology which adapts its message and its methods of teaching to the life of to-day. Let us point out briefly how this new utili- tarian classicism contrasts in some respects with the humanistic classicism of the dogmatic stage and the scientific classicism of the antithetic stage. Classical philology, in the broad definition of Boeckh, is the reconstruction of classical antiquity in all its essential manifestations — life, language, litera- ture, art — by the scientific interpretation of all exist- ing phenomena. Or, in the language of K. O. Miillcr, it "does not strive to establish isolated facts or to get an acquaintance with abstract forms, but to grasp the ancient spirit in its broadest meaning, in its works of reason, of feeling and of imagina- tion". The new classical philology is realizing this broad ideal, it seems to me, by placing the emphasis on aspects of antiquity that have not received full rec- ognition in the period of antithesis. Let me briefly call attention to the most important of these. (1) The new classical philology lays stress rather on the subject matter of ancient literature than on language and style. The study of ancient times is pursued in a more historic spirit and is directed more to fact and reality than to words. It recognizes that far more important than language and style is the assimilation by the student of the spirit and the content of Greek and Roman literature, that they may become a possession for ever, giving him deeper insight into the problems of life and wisdom to meet them. John Stuart Mill, in his inaugural address, delivered to the University of St. Andrews, February 1, 1867, calls attention "to the treasure which they (the ancients) accumulated of what may be called the wisdom of life; the rich store of experience of human nature and conduct, which the observing minds of those ages, aided in their observations by the greater simplicity of manners and life, consigned to their writings and most of which retains its value. The speeches in Thucydides; the Rhetoric, Ethics and Politics of Aristotle; the Dialogues of Plato; the Orations of Demosthenes; the Satires and es- pecially the Epistles of Horace; all the writings of Tacitus; the great work of Quintilian, a repertory of the best thoughts of the ancient world on all sub- jects pertaining to education; and, in a less formal manner, all that is left to us of the ancient histo- rians, orators, philosophers, and even dramatists, are replete with remarks and maxims of singular good sense and penetration, applicable both to politi- cal and to private life : and the actual truths we find in them are even surpassed in value by the encour- agement and help they give us in the pursuit of truth". (2) The study of ancient life and art is now re- garded as of equal significance with the study of language and literature. The growth of classical archaeology has shown that the study of the mate- rial remains must go hand in hand with the study of literature, if we would restore the picture of an- tiquity with any degree of completeness. Just at the time when too exclusive attention to philology and grammar were causing the Classics to lose their grip on the American people, the American Schools at Athens and in Rome brought to our classrooms a number of teachers who had got in close touch with the life of antiquity through a study of the monu- ments. The result has usually been that courses in archaeology have attracted students who would not otherwise be brought in contact with the spirit of Greece and Rome, and have kept alive a popular in- terest in the cultured public who might otherwise have become alienated from the Classics. We must induce all the students we can to take and to keep up the study of Greek and Latin. But it falls to us as classical teachers to awaken an interest in an- tiquity through the study of Greek and Roman art, antiquities and politics in students who may not have had the privilege of studying the languages of Greece and Rome. (3) The Classics must be advocated as the funda- mental study, as the basis of modern education. If we insist on this point and accommodate our meth- ods to proving its truth, we shall have a firmer foundation for the new classical philology. It is not difficult to demonstrate that the study of an- tiquity is the best preparation for the life of the present, by taking advantage of the scientific recog- nition of the doctrine of evolution and the impor- tance of origins. We make a mistake if we insist merely on the value of the study of Greek and Latin as a whet- stone on which to sharpen youthful minds. No ade- quate substitute has yet been found for the study of the Classics in this respect, but we must show a positive value attaching to classical studies in them- selves. The basis of modern European civilization is es- sentially classical. "Modern Christianity is not more directly connected with the Founder and His Disci- ples than is modern culture with the ancient civili- zation of Hellas". Rome was the great reservoir into which poured the culture of Greece and the Orient, and out of Rome issued the streams which have made France, Germany, England and America what we now find them. Hence, to understand our language, our literature, our institutions, our art, we must have a knowledge of the ancient Classics. The danger of each nation selecting its own language as the basis of education on patriotic grounds lies in the serious evil that would result from dividing up the common basis of European education, which is clas- sical. (4) We must meet our opponents on their own ground and show the utilitarian value of classical stud- ies. The Gassical Conferences of the Michigan School- 156 THE CLASSICAL WEEKLY masters' Club have for a number of years been di- recting attention to this aspect of classical study. Thus at the conference of 1906, there was a sympo- sium upon the value of humanistic, especially clas- sical studies, as a preparation for the study of medi- cine and engineering ; at the conference of 1907, there was a similar symposium upon the value of human- istic, particularly classical studies, as a preparation for the study of law; again, at the conference of March, 1908, the symposium considered the value of humanistic, particularly classical, studies as a prepa- ration for the study of theology; and at the classical conference of 1909, there will be a symposium on the value of the study of Latin and Greek as a preparation for practical life. President Woodrow Wilson, in his presidential ad- dress before the Association of Colleges and High Schools in November, 1907, emphasized Latin as the fundamental study for a knowledge of English and other modern languages, thus: "It happens that La- tin is the medium, so to say the background — al- most the substance — of so many modern languages, that it is in a sense indispensable. Let him choose one language besides the Latin — let it be Greek or let it be Spanish ; it does not make any difference whether it is a modern language or an ancient lan- guage, but one language besides Latin — let him swim from first to last in the atmosphere of Latin, and then let him choose one language besides Latin". Similarly, it is easy to show that Latin is the fundamental study for a knowledge of the political sciences. "No study of the development of Euro- pean institutions is possible without a knowledge of Latin, for in it are contained the records of the development of law, religion, literature and thought". (5) The great need of modern America is an im- pulse away from materialism, and toward higher standards of living, moral, intellectual and spiritual. Hence, the new classical philology seeks to restore the spirit of humanism to our educational system, to introduce into our fretful modern life "the sweet- ness and light" of the Greek spirit and the strength and fortitude of the Roman spirit. President Schur- man sometime ago asserted that Athenian culture is America's need. He had taken to heart the contrast between American culture of to-day and the culture of the ancient Greeks. He says that "While as a people, we are wonderfully energetic, industrious, in- ventive and well-informed, we are, in comparison with the ancient Athenians, little more than half- developed on the side of our highest rational and artistic impulses", and he concludes as follows: "Our work in the nineteenth century was largely of the utilitarian order; in the twentieth century we are summoned to conquer and make our own the ideal realms of truth and beauty and excellence which far more than material victories constitute the true greatness of nations". Hence, it becomes us as classical teachers to rec- ognize that our strongest weapon in this material age is the fact that we stand for humanism and all that the term implies far more than does any other branch of knowledge. We must respond to the call for the discipline of cultured manhood. The aim of education is not to make a living but to make a life, not the accumulation of material wealth, but the growth of the spirit. Next to the religion of the Man of Nazareth, nothing contributes so much to this end as the study of Greek and Roman literature and art. We have in Pericles the incarnation of the Greek love for reason and beauty at its best, in Julius Caesar the highest manifestation of the Ro- man practical sense, mastery of men, grasp of social problems and science of government. What our own age needs to meet the demands of the day is a double portion of the spirits of Pericles and of Julius Caesar. For this, it must look to the classrooms where Greek and Latin are taught. In conclusion, we must adapt our methods of in- struction to the ideals which we have before us. While the languages must be mastered, yet forms and syntax and rhetorical analysis must be regarded as merely means to an end — namely, the understand- ing of the thought and the assimilation of the spirit of the author read. I feel that from the very be- ginning of a Greek or Latin course the teacher should strive to impart as much as possible of the spirit of Greece and Rome and of a knowledge of Greek and Roman life and art. The first two years of a college course should be devoted to the study of the literature, and to the acquirement of an accurate and ready reading knowledge of Greek and Latin, while at the same time the bearing of ancient life on the life of to-day should be emphasized in season and out of season. Then, in the later years, there should be offered to the student a variety of courses according to his special bent, and the profession he expects to pursue. Some will want philology and literary criticism, especially those who are preparing to be teachers, authors, preachers or journalists. Others will prefer archaeology and art, especially prospective artists, architects and engineers, others ancient history, courses in private and public life, Greek political science and Roman law, especially young men who hope to be lawyers or to enter the public service. By thus contributing to the needs of the student according to the demands of the day, we shall make the public realize that the Classics are valuable to the student, not merely as a whetstone on which to sharpen his wits and give him a command of lan- guage necessary in every walk of life, but also as an essential part of the student's equipment to give him adequate preparation for his work in the world. Mitchell Carroll Thb Gborgb Washington University.