STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 108 Book Reviews P. Cornelii Taciti Dialogus de Oratoribus. Mit Prolegomena, Text und Adnotatio Critica, exegetischem und kritischem Kom- mentar, Bibliographic, und Index Nominum et Rerum von Alfred Gudeman. Zweite vollig neubearbeitete Auflage. Leip- zig: B. G. Teubner, 1914. Pp. viii+528. M. 14 (16, bound). This completely remodeled edition of the Dialogus was issued at the beginning of July, 1914, on the eve of a far more momentous struggle than that which once divided the world of scholars over the authorship of the little work now adjudged beyond any reasonable doubt to the historian. The first edition, published in English in this country just twenty years earlier, has long been an indispensable tool to every Tacitus scholar. It will now be still more warmly welcomed as the mature product of intensive cultivation in a field in which these have not been lean years. Many opinions have been modified in response to criticism, but the main contentions of the first edition remain, strengthened by more exact statement and gradually accumulated evidence. Outwardly the book has not grown conspicuously in size, but a larger page and smaller type alone have kept growth within bounds. Text and critical notes, which formerly claimed 55 pages out of 585, now fill but 43 out of 528, while the commentary (allowing for the different page) has been increased by perhaps 60 of the new pages. In the Prolegomena there is a great gain in point of clear arrangement, and in added chapters. The question of authorship, time of writing, dramatic date of the dialogue, plan and technique of composition, the interlocutors, the two lacunae and the speakers of 36-40. 4, the fictitious character of the dialogue, literary sources, matters grammatical and rhetorical, the manu- scripts — all these subjects are fully treated in the Prolegomena. The history of the controversy is given with much detail, and the arguments for Tacitean authorship marshaled with rare skill. It is safe to say that the ghost of anonymity or heteronymity conjured up by Beatus Rhenanus and Justus Lipsius has finally been laid. With regard to the date of composition, the newer view of Leo, Norden, and Wilamowitz, that the Dialogus was a tour de force in a style dictated by the subject-matter, and therefore may, or must, have been written after the Agricola and Germania, is critically exam- ined and duly rejected, along with other arguments for a date after Domitian. The chapter on the dramatic date will probably win no less general assent, except in a passage (pp. 61 f.) concerning the magnus annus and Censorinus, where one may feel that the unknown quantities are more numerous than the equations available for their solution. The chapter on the two lacunae and the speakers of 35-40. 4 strongly defends the theory, already maintained in 1894, of a lacuna at the latter point, involving the loss of the conclusion of Secundus' speech and the beginning of that of Maternus. But much new matter is of course added, including a careful revision of the calculations printed in Classical Philology, VII (1912), 412-16. The summa summarum Book Reviews 109 is that that part of the dialogue between the long lacuna of 35 fin. and the shorter lacuna at 40. 4 would fill just four pages of the lost Hersfeldensis — lost except for eight leaves of the Agricola (cod. Aesinus), which furnish the basis for the computation. Of course opinions will differ as to the substantial value of calculations of this kind, in which Teubner lines are compared with those of a lost portion of a codex, that a lacuna, otherwise suspected on internal evidence, may gain external support also, if it can be made probable that precisely one leaf, beginning and ending with a com- plete sentence, was lost at this point. 1 Prominence is deservedly given to Sabbadini's discovery (1901) of Decembrio's detailed description of the Hersfeldensis as he collated it in 1455. Decembrio counted 14 folia of the Dialogus up to the great lacuna, and 2\ thereafter. In his addenda Gudeman supplements this (pp. 135 ff.) by a similar but less minute description found at the close of a manuscript of the philosophical works of Cicero and known since 1913. This is from an inventory made by Niccoli of manuscripts in convent and other libraries of Germany. The description goes back to 1425. It omits Decembrio's "Cornelii Taciti," and gives the folia of the Dialogus as 18. Thus Gudeman finds full confirmation of his theory of a lost leaf at 40. 4, arguing that the leaf was still extant and counted by Niccoli, but had been lost before Decem- brio thirty years later counted but 14+2J folia. Some have no doubt scented a possible error in a Roman numeral, but to most scholars not already committed to another theory the assumption of a second lacuna, two pages in length, must now appear all but completely demonstrated. Of the full description and comparison of the manuscripts it will suffice to say that as a result the value of A and B is somewhat lowered, and that the new stemma assigns E and V to a parent Z, a copy of the Hersfeldensis distinct from those (X and Y) from which the other manuscripts descend. The text is much more conservative, ut fit, than in the first edition, many conjectures of the editor or his predecessors now appearing in the critical notes only, while an obelus in the text bids the reader seek enlighten- ment from below. In many cases Gudeman still favors the same conjecture, but does not admit it to the text. In not a few others readings of 1894 are silently discarded. Table I gives the changes which may be mentioned here. 1 Some curiosity on this matter prompted the reviewer to compare each successive group of four pages in the first Medici codex with Andresen's text of 1913, through the first book of the Annals, making careful allowance for all short lines and indented lines of Teubner as compared with solid text in the facsimile. With this correction it was found that, while four pages of this manuscript may mean only 86 Teubner lines, or as much as 101 lines, on the other hand 11 out of the 15 blocks of four pages examined run between 91 and 96 — a very fair degree of uniformity, though perhaps not all that might be expected of a manuscript of the first order of calligraphy, with solid pages and no short lines, such as add another element of uncertainty in the Aesinus. 110 Book Reviews table I 1914 1894 1, line 12. 1, 13 2, 14 4, 9 5, 3 5, 10 5, 11 5, 21 5, 25 6, 7 6, 23 6,24. 7, 9. . 8, 3. . 8, 20. . 10, 4. . 10, 18.. 10, 29 . . 10, 30. . 10, 33. . 10,34. 12, 13.. 13, 3. 13, 21. 13, 22. 14, 4. 14, 10. 14, 12. 15, 4. 15, 5. 15, 12. 16, 19. 16, 29. 17, 18. 18, 5. 18, 15. 18, 21 . 19, 2. 19, 10. 20, 2. 20, 6. 20, 10. 21, 3. 21, 28. 21, 34. 22, 11. 22, 13. 22, 19. 23, 4. 23, 20. 24, 9. 25, 12. 25, 18. 25, 23. 25, 28. 26, 15. 27, 11. 28, 13. 29, 4. 30, 22. 32, 2. 32,24. 33, 3. 33, 15. 34, 18. 34, 21 . 35, 17. 36, 2. 36, 21 . accepl maiorem colam cognitionibus tinveniri apud feos ferat(?} praesidium venire plerumque Ingenlo alia( ?) serantur elaborentur gratiora in |alio tminus ipsis rarissimarum summa adeptus( ?) taut f[ex his] adsensus privatas maior ad tenim veniat ( ?)statuarque( ?) consilium et audentior(?) sermo ipse tantiquis eo Gratis utrique sed ffama tet quidem imitatus pro Catone adtritum Cassiumf narrationi8( ?) fere invitatus Boscii tquique (in the corrigenda) orationibus tviderimus topt .... paries et olentia voc[ab]ant( ?) permittitur( ?) tnostris sic ferunt livere non exigit tvis qua gremio tet virides tteneri statim et rudes oratoris autem rhetorum, sed quibus .... tot taut reconditas tarn varias tsed suis quidquid clarescit quin e excepi maiorem quam colam solam cognitionibus se non inveni apud nos feras quae est praesidium plerumque venire in ingenio quae [alia] serantur elaborantur grata, gratiora in alvo minores et ipsis vel rarissimarum max summa adeptus [aut] adsensus privatas causas [expressis] maior erat vel ad [enim] veniet statuarlque] consilium aut ardentior sermo ille [antiquis] eoque G-raecis huic utrique sed etiam aeque idem miraius Porcio Catone aridum Cassium Severum narrationum omnia fere [in]vitt'atus Q. Boscii quosque in orationibus videmus enim apte .... paries est obsoleta vociiant permittit veteribus sic et f->rae se ferunt ivore id non exigit bilis a qua in gremio [et] virides statim et teneri [rudesl orationis enim ex rhetorum officinis, sed ex quibus artibus tot tam varias ae reconditas sic in suis quidquid aliud c[l]atescit qui quin Book Reviews TABLE I — Continued 111 1914 1894 37, 16 37, 24 37, 27 37,34 38, 2 38, 16 39, 11 40, 3 40, 9 expilatis aut expilatis fuft(?) fuerit exstitit( ?) existit velint .... velint, periculosa extollant test ita erit ^extiterit maximal ?) (see corrigenda) maxime tpatronus praetor Sulla L. Sulla vocabant( ?) vociVant In 7. 9, while the text reads si non in falio oritur, the former reading si non in alvo oritur is even more stoutly defended than before. No attempt is made to meet Baehrens' obvious objection that mains in alvo would be expected. The passages cited from Accius and from Pro Cluentio 34, in which a woman is in both cases the subject of the sentence, do not support in alvo without matris here. The same is true of De div. ii. 39, alvo continent (not cited by Gudeman). And why, in the search for an antithesis to the dussere Vergunstigungen, should one reject the perfectly general in alio and dwell with exclusive emphasis upon the idea of heredity, as though application and experience had nothing to do with the case and would not be quite as likely to be mentioned here ? The excellent authority for de alio, ex alio, and alio furnished by the Thesaurus may perhaps impress some who have been skeptical about in alio. In 10. 18 the unhappy mox before summa adeptus is now dropped, but reluctantly, as we may infer from the commentary in which Gudeman still speaks of the "analogy" of Hist. ii. 82, egregios viros et mox summa adeptos. But in that case the historian is allowing himself an anticipation to which there can be no parallel in adeptus here. It is clear enough that the antithesis of levioribus must be found in summa, which then has no reference to fame or outward rewards — no more than Seneca's summa adeptum of the sage {Ep. 109. 1). A glance at any part of the commentary suffices to show what a mass of material has been added in one form or another. Suppression has often made fresh insertions possible, or matter has been transferred to another context. The result is an encyclopedic commentary on the largest scale and of great value as a general work of reference, for which purpose it is made available by an adequate index. It is unnecessary here to cite instances of the learning accumulated ovpavuov Sow in these 326 solid pages. The most appreciative critic will sometimes feel that too much has been included, as when discarded readings are still more or less half-heartedly defended. Thus on pp. 308-9 imitatus esset (18. 5), though accepted in the text (in lieu of miratus esset, 1894), is found a hard nut to crack. Too much is made of a "direct contradiction" between Aper's own words at 22 init. ([Cicero] suorum temporum eloquentiam anteponebat) and the wish (18, §2) that Calvus 112 Book Reviews Caelius, and even Cicero had not imitated the antiqui. For there Aper is speaking of general tendencies and everything in the large, here in all prob- ability of incidental and perhaps rare expressions. If Seneca (Ap. Gell. xii. 2. 6ff.) could find fault with such Ennian words in Cicero as suaviloquens and breviloquentia, what certainty have we that Aper could not claim to find imitations of older orators in Cicero ? The hearers might be horrified, as was Gellius, but the truth may still be on the side of the merciless critic. Cicero's acknowledged obligations to the old orators and Quintilian's recommendation that they be judiciously studied (x. 1. 40) become perfectly meaningless, if they did not have in mind at least occasional imitation. That Aper meant anything more than this does not appear; hence direkt falsch or stark uber- trieben seem much overdrawn. To most readers miratus would seem to involve some degree of imitation and to be only a little less explicit than imitatus. But it is ungracious to look for rare flaws in so sound and admirable a piece of work. The excellent Index nominum et rerum has already been mentioned. A copious Index locorum in the first edition has not been reproduced, no doubt for lack of space, since it would now be much larger. Frank Gaednee Moobe Columbia University