STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 105 The initial chapter contains a historical sketch of the study of palaeog- raphy, a discussion of the names of the various scripts and the theories as to their origin, with full citations of the literature. The second chapter (pp. 21-31) deals with the epigraphical material. Here the alphabets are treated collectively. The third chapter (pp. 32-224), dealing with the papyri and ostraka, forms the bulk of the book. The documents (about 150) are arranged generally in chronological order, though of course the date is often only approximate or tentative. Under each papyrus the author gives, where pos- sible, a description of the document, its provenance, the contents, and a bibliography. The abbreviations and ligatures are listed and the alphabet is described. This description is supplemented by 18 plates containing 41 alphabets interspersed through the chapter. Chapter iv (pp. 225-241) contains an excellent summary of the history of the cursive alphabet. There are three appendixes. The first gives a list (incomplete) of Greek papyri that contain Latin subscriptions. The second contains the bibliog- raphy (also incomplete). The third gives a list of abbreviations found in Latin papyri that can be dated. This is an extract from the Transactions of the American Philological Association, XLV (1913). Four plates A-D give tables of alphabets of the epigraphical material, and six more contain alphabets of various papyri. Reference is constantly made to the plates in the body of the book. In the bibliography one misses Kopp's great work, Palaeographia critica, and the publications of the New Palaeographical Society; Wattenbach's Scriftwesen should be cited in the third edition and Amdt-Tangl in the fourth — the fourth edition is referred to in a footnote on p. 17. A few items consist of an author's name alone, without the name of the work, the date or place of publication. Charles H. Beeson University op Chicago T. Lucretius Carus. Of the Nature of Things. A metrical transla- tion. By William Ellery Leonard. London [1917]. Almost any translation of a classical author may be praised or blamed according to the critic's desire; for a translation of a literary masterpiece is an impossibility. Thus in the opening words of this version of Lucretius — Mother of Rome, delight of Gods and men Dear Venus that beneath the gliding stars Makest to teem the many-voyaged main And fruitful lands — a Latinist might question the italicized words, for if they were translated back into the Latin it is improbable that the retranslator would hit on the 106 Book Reviews Lucre tian words; and yet those very Latin words are integral parts of the poem. The distinction between mater and genetrix, Roma and Aeneadae, cara and alma, signa and stellae, is almost the difference between prose and poetry, and the Latin words taken together strike a peculiar stylistic note. One may adequately translate a simple statement of fact like Macrobius' triplicabis septem et faciunt viginti unum, but even statements of fact have frequently set a trap, in which, by reason of the ambiguity of English words, the unwary reader is caught. Thus in a recent magazine article Aristotle's remark that money is "barren" is given an entirely false gloss. Translation and interpretation must go together, and the most direct path to correct interpretation lies in the knowledge of the original language from which the translation has been made. Yet those who are ignorant of foreign languages ought not to be debarred wholly from a knowledge of foreign literature; but let them not think for a moment that they are getting the real thing. The present vogue of translations and the efforts to multiply them may in the end weaken the reputation of classical literature or give a false conception of the value of the second-rate authors. Munro's translation of Lucretius is a condensed commentary and quite unreadable. Bailey's is a fine example of academic English; the earlier English renderings for one reason and another do not at present merit con- sideration. Professor Leonard's version is noteworthy in many respects; he uses clear-cut English for faded Latin metaphors — "untangle" for expe- diam; homely phrasing — "puts the fat on goats and quails"; archaisms — "to dure and dreer the mighty forces"; and there are many examples of boldness and simplicity, of roughness of meter and ruggedness, and he has often been happy in imitating the sweep of the hexameter — all of which are Lucretian qualities. On the other hand, at times his verse lacks the stateli- ness and sublimity of the original; he is too literally etymological, as "in these my country's leaves" (chartis), and repeatedly, as might be expected, he adds to the Lucretian thought, as "telluric soil" for tellus, and "curst Lucanian oxen" where "curst" is not in the Latin. Intruded metaphors are not uncommon: "vain dingdong" for sonitus, "blue deep of heaven" for caerula caeli. Actual errors are few and some perhaps debatable, such as "navy's admiral" in v. 1227, "shining" for nitentibus in i. 372. Perhaps he has overshot the mark in "ether's skiey coasts," "pell-mell horses," and "fire ball" for faces. But there are many happy turns and some strong lines: "a weary while to tell the whole," "by the prodigious reaches of the sky," "interstices and paths, coherencies," "the lack-speech years," "of mighty menacings forevermore." The close of the fourth book gives the only close translation and interpretation in English of an important part of the poem that has been neglected for obvious reasons. The first three hundred lines of Book v are very well done. It is to be regretted that Giussani's text has been followed with its numer- ous and generally unaccepted transpositions. The book may be commended Book Reviews 107 to Latinists and the general public. It is unquestionably the best metrical translation of Lucretius into English that has yet appeared. W. A. Merrill University of California The Diamond. A Study in Chinese and Hellenistic Folk-Lore. By Bebthold Laufer. Field Museum of Natural History, Publi- cation 184, Anthropological Series, Vol. XV, No. 1. Chicago, 1915. Pp. 75. The first fifteen pages of this learned study are the ones of chief interest to students of the classics. In the Memoirs of the Four Worthies or Lords of the Liang Dynasty, written by Chang Yue (667-730 a.d.), a story is told about an island in the Western Sea (Mediterranean) where there is an inaccessible ravine in which precious stones he. The inhabitants throw flesh into this ravine. Birds pick up the flesh in their beaks and as they fly, they drop the precious stones. The men of the country are clever workers of gems, which are called Fu-lin after the name of the country. Fu-lin is the Chinese name for some part of the Roman Empire, probably Syria. A legend similar in all its essential features is found in Epiphanius, bishop of Constantia in Cyprus in the fourth century. Dr. Laufer points out the close likeness of this legend to the story of the Arabians and their curious method of obtaining cinnamon told by Herodotus iii. Ill, and to a somewhat similar tale in Pliny N.H . xxxviii. 33, but prudently refrains from attempting to link them closely. The source of the legend he finds in the Hellenistic Orient. To one already impressed with the fact that Hellenistic artistic motives influenced early Chinese and even Japanese art in a marked degree, the thesis is in itself reasonable, and Dr. Laufer's proofs are con- vincing. There are two further points of interest in this study for the classicist and archaeologist. The author is convinced (pp. 42-46) that the adamas of the ancients was actually the diamond, but concludes that ancient gem- workers did not understand the process of cutting and polishing diamonds to add to their luster (pp. 46-50). The study contains other information which will be attractive chiefly to Sinologists and to those interested in the history of the diamond. In this pamphlet Dr. Laufer has presented another useful link of the broken chain of evidence which connects Hellenistic-Roman civilization with the Far East. Curiously enough the classical archaeologist and the classicist seem to regard the evidence upon this new sphere of Greek influ- ence either with suspicion or with apathy. W. L. Westermann University of Wisconsin