STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS The Fragments of Sophocles. Edited with additional notes from the papers of Sir R. C. Jebb and Dr. W. G. Headlam by A. C. Pearson. Cambridge: University Press, 1917. The completion of Jebb's Sophocles by these three volumes on the frag- ments with a comprehensive index would be a notable achievement of scholar- ship in any year. In the year 1917 it is particularly impressive. Students of Mr. Pearson's Fragments of Zeno and Cleanthes and of his excellent editions of the Helena and the Heraclidae expected him to prove equal to the burden which the deaths of Jebb and of Headlam imposed upon him. They will not be disappointed. He has made use of and given credit to the Adversaria of Headlam and the lecture notes of Jebb. But the work as it stands is essentially his. And the student will pass to it and back again to the plays with no sense of inequality. A great monument of English scholarship is worthily completed. These three volumes are something more than a sufficient critical and exegetical commentary on the entire body of Sophoclean fragments — though they are eminently that. They will remain one of the works to which the wise student frequently recurs both as storehouses of knowledge and as illustrations of sound method. Mr. Pearson's annotation combines the best traditions of English virtuosity with the patient industry that leaves few German or American monographs unexplored. He has a sound feeling for Greek idiom and the niceties of Greek usage, and he has one advantage even over Jebb in his familiarity with the ideas and the vocabulary of Greek philosophy. His commentary does not stop with the indispensable minimum of exegesis but often goes on to illustrate and illuminate the principle of language involved or sketch the history of an idea or sentiment. I may instance the notes on Xcvktjv ■qp.ipav, fr. 6, on oi rvpawoi, 14, on orepvo/uatTis, 59, on irivorriprfi, 113, on ve/uiv and airovcfitiv, 144, on crapSanos yeAo)?, 160, on Plouton and Ploutos, 273, on the trick of the Polypus, 307, on ovou crxta, 331, on avraiov, 334, on the "third to the Saviour," 425, on 7ro&ords, 453, on irapa ofiovfj.ev

v ti/wo/acvcov is not "nowhere honored " but that p.i)8ap.ov is felt as genitive of price is a hard saying. Surely there are parallels to the idiomatic use of "nowhere," nvllo loco habere, etc., in many languages. 116: dyvwrai for the supposed meaning "destroy." Mr. Pearson refers to Headlam (Classical Review, XVI, 438), on Anth. Pal. 7. 49, v/yvurt rav Bvarav vaparos loropiav, "destroyed the inscription which described Euripides as mortal." But the first two lines of the epigram distinctly say that Euripides himself was killed by the lightning stroke, and something like Bury's amparoi appMvtav is the more plausible reading. 96 Book Reviews 181 : dx/oaos &v is PpSxriv aXkovs i£epivdt,us \6yw. It is true that Athenaeus in Eustathius says impoifuaxov 8k avro to vor/pa ofioiov T<3 dircu'8evros 6pS>vra, k&v e&o Siktjs j(v dv&raiTo sufficed (Theoc. 26. 38; Soph. Elect. 1422-23; Aesch. Choeph. 830 and 900). 287: In Schol. Ar. Plvi. 590 6 8e dveXev&oos kokul Traprnvopao-Tat rrj avckcvOepioTTjTi there is probably no intention to affirm that avtXtvOepos is derived from aveXtvOepiorrji. The meaning is that the one word is in the Aristotelian terminology a "paronym" of the other so that you may argue from the meaning of the one to that of the other. 314.34: €vXoy<{>. The idiom which Mr. Pearson illustrates by Phil. 319, iv Aoyois, "unjustly suspected," is further exemplified by Aesch. Eumen. 21, hi Aoyois irpio-fltvtTai, which is often wrongly pressed into explicit antithesis with the preceding iv evxio-6ai. But need this be anything more than Aristides' development of Plato's irayyeXoiov yovv es. 568: /Siov fipaxvv UrOpov. This "remarkable figure" might be further illustrated by Pope's "Placed on this isthmus of a middle state," and Moore's "This narrow isthmus twixt two boundless seas." 591 : tv xpovy irdpirXovTov o\[$ov Saipovos kokov SoVis, oTav jueraorjj nal Oeciis Sony TaSt. The objection to the apparent tautology is perhaps lessened if iv fipax" is felt rather as a mere idiomatic prepositional phrase. Cf. O.C. 586, fr. 771. 3 kAv fipaxtt Siooo-koAov, and the collections of Miss Emily Dutton in "Greek Prepositional Phrases" (Chicago dissertation), p. 171 and p. 187; also Pindar, Pyth. 8. 98, where the effect of the omission of XP° V V i s better felt in Myer's "in a little moment" than in Sandys' "short is the space of time." I think Mr. Pearson reads too much into Scujuopos ko.kov 600-ts when he sees in it the expression of belief in mysterious and destructive powers, etc. It is virtually equivalent to 6Ws Sokj? i-dSt in the following line. From Homer down Saipmv is a convenient and often interchangeable synonym of 0eo S . There is no difficulty in Soais; cf. Theognis 134 with 165, 442-46, 516, 591, 1033, and indeed Greek literature passim. 665: aicmv 8' apapriov ovtis avdpmirwv kclkos. Mr. Pearson still takes seriously the paradox of Hippias Minor 371 E ff. Socrates himself with obvious irony tells Hippias that he sometimes does and sometimes doesn't believe it; just now he has an attack of belief and wishes to be refuted by Hippias. 98 Book Reviews 682: nuOwv 8' aaurros tov tv^JJ Aeya. I don't think that the iradaiv 8e re v»;irios eyrw parallels are quite in point. The thought is rather that of Pindar Nem. 4. 91, often misunderstood: TO 8' OVTOS 3.V TIS ISr), ekircTal tis ocao-Tos e£oxdo-8ai. Note the coincidence in «a Aoyou is not quite pertinent. It alludes not to the quasi-legal meaning, but to the well-known proverb about excepting the gods. 809: "The conception of Fortune as a goddess of incalculable chance as contrasted with foresight is comparatively late." In view of Pindar, O. 12, 1 do not see how we can deny it to Sophocles. There Pindar passes directly from the invocation of Fortune to the uncertainty of all things and the failure of all human forecasts. 828: eh amdvTrjcnv. In view of Photius' <5>s iv rrj crwqdtia tfrnp-iv, it may be worth noting that the phrase is frequent in the Septuagint. 831: ipyov 8k fl-avTos, t}v tis ap^rfrai KaAfis, k$ ^xuv. The list of "the beginning is half or more than half" parallels including Plato Rep. 377 A; and Leges 753 E is less pertinent than is another series often overlooked. The apter Platonic parallel is Rep. 453 A: op' ofy outws av xaAAioTa tis apx6/i*vos & to ebcos k