STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS L. Annaei Senecae Dialogorum Liber xii., Ad Helviam Matrem de Consolatione. Par Charles Favez. Lausanne-Paris : Libr. Payot et Cie., 1918. Pp. lxix+109. It is cheering to note the appearance of this useful edition of an important Senecan essay, especially at the present time. Its contents will mean more to those exiles of the last half-decade who have suffered and endured; there wiU be new life in the old words: "nee secunda sapientem evehimt nee adversa demittunt; laboravit enim semper ut in se plurimiun poneret, ut a se omne gaudium peteret" (v. 2). One also notes with interest that M. Favez signs his preface at Clarens, the haunt of Rousseau, that Senecan admirer whose jfirst essay reproduced much of the style and many of the ideas of the Roman philosopher. The text is based almost entirely upon Gertz. The editor deviates only in a few cases, such, for example, as xi. 6, page 64, where he rejects the faecis of the Danish scholar for the luis of EUis, which is textually sounder, though it may not keep up so well the metaphor of the preceding sincerus aninvus. M. Favez is also completer in his critical notes than was Mr. Duff in his edition of 1915; but this is natural in an edition devoted wholly to one essay instead of three. Exsaniari, page 9, and Imdissimum, page 43, are cases in point. The Introduction does not contribute anything especially new, except the passage from StDpo, quoted by Teles, p. xlviii. There is unnecessary repetition with regard to the casa Romuli, pp. Ixii and Ixiv. The twofold cause of Seneca's exile is attractively set forth, with a lenient interpretation of Seneca's relations with Julia Livilla, based rather upon the two rival court parties of Messalina and Agrippina than upon any clear case against the philosopher. We cannot help feeling that 8 B.C. is a few years too early to place Seneca's birth; and we are disappointed, after an announcement that the Consolatio will be thoroughly discussed as a type, to find little more real information than we found in Siun- mers' (1910) foreword to the sixty-third epistle of Seneca, which is a consolatio in miniatiu-e. The general commentary, however, is delightfully clear and copious, as indeed is the essay itself, "de tons les ouvrages de S6n6que le mieux compost peut-ltre." It is not devoted so much to translational helps as to exposition of the argument, the style, and the matter. Rhetorical points, with compari- sons from the Elder Seneca, are woven into the notes in harmonious sequence, bringing out the idea that the piece is more of an essay than an address. There 89 90 Book Reviews is more of value here than in the Introduction. This is exemplified by M. Favez' note on the second person of cogitas, xiii. 3, p. 74, indicating that in certain remarks "il ne s'addresse pas k elle ici, mais k cet adversaire fictif qu'U fait parler au 1." Vicos, ix. 2, p. 42, is certainly to be interpreted as a "block of houses" rather than as a "street." The notes, for example, to page 14 are a model of penetrating clearness. To sum up, this makes the Consolatio ad Helviam accessible in French as well as in English, a fact which will be of service to a better imderstanding of an Empire prose artist who has in the past been taken for granted without being suflBciently understood. RiCHABD M. GUMMEBE The Penn Charter School, Philadelphia Zur Geschichte der gymnischen Agone an griechischen Festen. By Theophil Klee. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1918. This is the dissertation of a young Swiss scholar published after his death by the piety of friends. Its chief contribution is the first publication of about thirteen pages of inscriptions from Cos which their discoverer. Pro- fessor R. Herzog (Archaeolog. Ameiger, 1909, p. 190; 1905-11), turned over to the author to edit. The fragmentary inscriptions are lists of the victors at the Coan Asclepieia, dated ca. 250-178 B.C. (p. 18). Taking these as his text or pretext the author discusses in successive chapters the programs and the order of events, the age classes, the festival dates, and the lists of victors for the four great games of the periodos, the seven other games of Pan-Hellenic significance for which we have inscrip- tions, and several local and minor contests. Without being able to solve finally the many technical problems that still remain in doubt, he re-collects the evidence and weighs the opinions of Forster, Hyde, Juthner, Gardiner, Paton and Hicks, and others. His book will be indispensable to the special student of the subject, and, as Professor Herzog says in his Nachruf, it will also be a useful and convenient work of reference for Greek chronology by reason of its lists of dated names. To the student of Pindar and of Greek literature its chief service is the more vivid realization it brings of the place held in Greek life by these con- tests and of the minuteness and particularity of their arrangements and classifications. The editors of Pindar comment rarely or slightly on dyci/eioi (O. 8. 54, 9. 89.), and many students doubtless are left with the impression that it is a mere sjmonym for "boy" or "youth." It was technical for the class between boy and man, and Klee discusses the recognition or non-recognition