STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 275 scholarly reviews, the odium scholasticum refusing to be drowned even by war's alarums. The bitterest hater of Germany cannot but pay his tribute of amazement to the manner in which the German scholarly machine kept grinding on, regardless of the fact that sky and solid earth were crashing above and beneath it. The volumes themselves are, however, disappointing. Their title-pages seem to promise something for which we have long been looking, a fresh treatment of the constitutional evolution of the Roman Empire. That promise is not redeemed. The first volume is simply an incomplete summary of the familiar views of Mommsen regarding the Augustan Principate. The author vaunts himself a heretic and proclaims his liberation from the yoke of the master's authority. But his dissent is confined practically to one point. He fastens upon the passage in the Siaatsrecht (IP, 842-44) in which Mommsen sets forth the doctrine that both the army and the Senate had a constitutional right to set up an emperor; and urges the more sensible view that legally a Princeps received his authority from the Senate and that the military acclamation, however influential in actuality, had no constitutional force until confirmed by decree of the Senate and people. The two volumes together are nothing but a polemic in support of this thesis. With true German thoroughness all the evidence upon the question is assembled, quoted, and discussed. In portentous German periods the inevitable con- clusion — whose accuracy common sense must recognize as soon as it is stated — is ponderously set forth again and again. The really valuable part of the work is the collection of materials in the second volume, and the last chapter in the same volume, in which certain obscure survivals in the third century of characteristic features of the Augustan Principate are noted. The constitutional theory that the Princeps derives his authority from the Senate disappears, according to Schulz, with the accession of Carus in 282, not with that of Diocletian in 284. Donald McFayden University of Nebraska Vergil. A Biography. By Tenney Frank. New York: Henry Holt & Co., 1922. Pp. vi+200. Professor Frank's absorption for many years in the social and economic history of Rome indicates what we may expect and welcome in his recent sallies into the field of literary interpretation and of literary history. He is manifestly engaged in the task of relating the literature of the pre-Augustan and Augustan periods to the social, political, and intellectual environment of the age from which it came. By careful study of the contacts, personal, social, and political, of various individuals he has often been able to deepen or clarify our knowledge of the developments in the first century b.c. In 276 Book Reviews large terms the result may be described as emphasizing the purely Roman or Italian factors and serving as a perhaps desirable antidote to prevalent views of Greek and particularly Hellenistic influence, the importance of which Mr. Frank fully recognizes. In this remedial process the antidote may be too severe a dose but the corrective is often sanely applied. Sound judgment and historical knowledge lead the author in his first chapter to a discriminating dismissal of various theories of Vergil's racial origin and to a proper estimate of the significance of biographical details such as the report that his father was a potter. Subsequent chapters are based on the poems of the Vergilian Appendix. The author evidently thinks that the authenticity of most of these poems may now be granted and proceeds on this basis. The book, therefore, may fairly be considered as addressed to the lay reader, not the scholar, and the interest of the scholar is rather in the assumption than in the consequent vivid picture of Vergil's formative years. With this assumpton one may easily quarrel, however sympathetic he may be toward the efforts in recent years to establish it as more than an assumption. And I think it worth while to raise the question, for the sake of conservative criticism, whether anything has resulted from these efforts but the conclusion, pedantically expressed in a double negative, that it is now difficult to prove that many of these poems are not Vergil's. It still remains the fact, in my opinion, that it is equally difficult to prove that they are Vergil's, although in the case of the Culex and many epigrams of the Catalepton the argument for authenticity is quite valid. And even if the Ciris is Vergilian, I must protest that Cecropius hortulus is not easily applicable to the group of young Augustans who, in the neighborhood of Naples, certainly did study under Siro and Philodemus, and that both this term and the reference to the "four ancient heirs" in verse 15, not to speak of the description of the Panathenaic peplus, point to study at Athens, not at Naples. In that environment Messalla belongs. In the Culex Mr. Frank finds echoes from the Roman schoolroom, rather than any immediate transcript of a Hellenistic original. The mythology is the issue of schoolroom elucidation at Rome of Greek poetry; the meta- morphosed trees are from Vergil's lecture notes on the rhetorician Epidius. Mr. Frank works Epidius pretty hard. Epidius wrote a book on meta- morphosed trees, we are told, and Pliny's Natural History is referred to as evidence. Pliny says, in the midst of a passage dealing with the theme of talking trees, that there were commentarii of Epidius in which certain trees reperiuntur locutae. The facts are that the Culex describes a grove composed of trees metamorphosed from human beings, but not talking, that Pliny does not say Epidius wrote a book on metamorphosed trees but that certain trees talked in Epidius' commentarii. Is it captious, or in the interest of care- ful handling of evidence, to question Mr. Frank's reasoning here ? Is not the intervention of the Roman schoolroom much less likely than the direct Book Reviews 277 intrusion of a Hellenistic original ? And similarly, is it inevitably the case that sancte and venerande in the dedication of the Culex, if patiently and thoroughly interpreted, are "a clear reference" to young Octavius' election to the pontificate ? In spite of the trend of current opinion Octavius Musa seems to me still eligible as the person addressed. The Copa, like the Culex, Mr. Frank relates to Italy and finds in it memories of the Neopolitan Bay, in spite of its Grecised diction and its manifest fusion of Theocritean coloring and Greek setting, suggested by A.P. vii. 223. One fancies that Philodemus, rather than the Neopolitan Bay, inspired it. In general, it seems to me that these doubtful poems of the Appendix may rightly be used as evidence of the influences at work in determining the themes and technique of poets during Vergil's formative period, but to accept them as Vergil's, to date them precisely, and then to construct upon them a precise account of Vergil's development is still unnecessary and unwise, particularly if it is the lay reader, not the scholar, who is addressed. Regarding the Eclogues and Georgics the author has less to contribute, though some details are interesting suggestions. Naturally he is disposed to stress the Servian interpretation of the sixth eclogue and to relate it to Vergil's studies at Naples under Siro, in opposition to Skutsch's view of it as merely an example of "catalogue poetry." Here his method seems to me faulty. One can easily discriminate in the Roman interpreters of the Eclogues from the earliest times, even before the fourth century, a radical and conservative school. The conservatives insist that there is no allegory except in so far as in some places Vergil has transferred his own experiences, in connection with the confiscation of his property, to certain herdsmen in the poems. The radical school, on the other hand, admits all sorts of double meanings, and gets wilder and wilder as the centuries go on. From this radical group, therefore, comes probably the view in the Servian commentary that Silenus is Siro and all that results from that identification, a view easily prompted by the Epicurean passage in the poem. I am not saying that the radicals are wrong but I suggest. that any scientific procedure must reckon with these ascertainable facts of the allegorical tradition. Only so can a modern critic avoid the danger of accepting the Servian interpretation of the sixth eclogue and, contrariwise, though quite rightly, dismissing Servius as "irrepressible" when he says that the fourth book of the Aeneid was lifted from Apollonius (p. 177). We must not accept Servius when he agrees with us, and reject him when he does not accord with our theories, and we should better eliminate Servius as an individual and analyze the Servian commentary as a corpus which represents conflicting schools of criticism that developed before Servius' time. On the Aeneid, too, Mr. Frank has many new and stimulating ideas. His conviction that Vergil is a consistent Epicurean is reiterated in spite of the protest of Professor Pease. He develops the evidence that points to an early conception of the plan of the epic. In this evidence he strangely 278 Book Reviews uses Catalepton ix. 2 (p. 68), in which patrio carmine represents the poet's ambition to write a national poem according to Mr. Frank. But the unity of thought in the elegiac couplet makes it quite clear that the author of Catalep- ton ix is hoping to be a Roman Callimachus, and certainly Graios sales would find little place in an epic. The Roman elements in the story of Dido are heavily stressed. "Vergil's first and fourth books are as unthinkable in Greek dress as is the sixth." This remark is an obvious contrast to Heinze's view that the story of Dido is a Hellenistic epyllium. Here Mr. Frank's antidote is severely applied, though his picture of the difference between Greek and Roman social life is valid and suggestive. And there is a mark of hasty thought when he uses Aeneid v. 5-6 to strengthen an opinion that an un-Greek notion of chivalrous love gives a Roman coloring to the story. " The confession of Aeneas, as he departs, that in heeding Heaven's command he has blasphemed against love — pollute amore — how strange a thought for the pius Aeneas!" But the passage does not convey this force. It says simply that the Trojans, not Aeneas, did not know why Carthage was in flames, but they did guess from experience the cruel pangs that come from outraged love, and the capacity of a desperate woman. How can this be twisted into a confession of Aeneas that he has blasphemed against love, and what "quality of purest Romance" rests in this passage? Such interpreta- tions are disquieting. More pardonable are slight inaccuracies such as the quotation of Tacitus Dial. 13 to prove that the Eclogues were set to music and sung in the concert halls; the reference should be to the Vita by Donatus. Tacitus refers merely to recitation. It would be a more gracious task to list the many suggestive lines of thought by which Mr. Frank endeavors to co-ordinate Vergilian poetry with contemporary history and politics. Herein lies his main contribution. The book is forcefully and interestingly written. Misprints are few, but glaring: concensus (p. 29), Vellius (p. 30, n. 1), the Greek type on pages 52-53, Calaeno (p. 70). Henry W. Prescott University of Chicago