STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 268 Book Reviews Pinza's theory that pozzo and fossa graves existed side by side at the same time, Miss Adams follows Modestov in explaining the change in burial rite by the coming of the Etruscans. Against this view I would particularly urge that the change of rite is most complete not on the coast but in the inland settlements of the Faliscan and Latin districts which the foreign immigrant could hardly have reached first. The discussion of the activities of the Greek and Phoenician traders at this period is especially valuable. Of great interest are the next chapters on the Etruscans in Latium. Miss Adams believes that they first seized Praeneste as a stronghold that com- manded the overland route to Campania and that the powerful rulers of that city, while maintaining communication by way of Gabii, Fidenae, and Veii with Caere and other sections of Etruria, developed their own port at Satricum. In the sixth century, she thinks, the Etruscans seized Rome which had hitherto been perhaps in a different "trade circle" and developed there an important commercial center. Well aware of the dangers of inferences from the absence of archaeological evidence, Miss Adams has made very guarded statements. Yet we may ask how Etruscan influence can have been strong enough in the eighth century in Latium to lead to a complete abandonment of cremation for inhumation, and yet have limited itself in the seventh century to Praeneste and the lines of communication with Etruria, Campania, and the sea. When in 509 the Etruscan dynasty was expelled from Rome, that city was, Miss Adams thinks, in a command- ing position which she was later unable to maintain. The first treaty with Carthage for which Miss Adams accepts Polybius' dating in the first year of the republic, shows that though the Latins had little real interest in foreign commerce there was at the time a possibility — long to remain unrealized — of Rome's becoming a commercial center. The bibliography and references are full even if the omission in many cases of page references makes the material less readily useful. The lists of important discoveries are of great service, though it is hard to see why in a study that appeared in April, 1921, the terra cottas from Veii should be said to be "still awaiting publication." Every student of early Latin history will be grateful to Miss Adams for having given meaning and sig- nificance to baffling masses of material that fill the museums of Rome. L. R. Taylor Vassar College La Legende Socratique et les Sources de Platon, Par Eugene Dupreel. Fondation Universitaire de Belgique. Bruxelles : Robert Sand, 1922. Professor Burnet's paradox that everything in Plato is Socratic was bound to conjure up to its philological anteros. Professor Dupreel's thesis is, that Socrates is a literary invention of the Socratics, and that most of Book Reviews 269 Plato's ideas and much of Aristotle's Metaphysics derive from the great Sophists of the fifth century, Gorgias, Protagoras, and especially Prodicus and Hippias, the supreme original thinkers of the age of Pericles: "A ce plus haut sommet de la pensee antique, ce n'est pas le nom de Socrate, ni celui de Platon, ni celui d'Aristote qui meritent de demeurer attaches, c'est, outre les noms perdus des penseurs qu'il faut continuer a appeler les Idealistes ou les Pythagoriciens, celui de leur emule et contradicteur Hippias." I should be sorry for more than one reason to take a purely negative attitude toward this readable and ingenious book. I am tired of the criticism of errors, though I still think it the chief need of present-day scholarship. I have read the book with interest, and I sympathize with the writer's protest against the method of combining isolated texts, and with his own better practice of analyzing the context of the passages which he cites. Nevertheless, he has not proved his thesis, and he himself admits that the three parts of the book swarm with hypotheses: "parmi lesquelles il en est d'assez aventurees." The only justification of this would be the argument that I usually reject, the consideration, namely, that only by exploiting an hypothesis to the limit can we determine its final value for "science." The negative half of Professor Dupreel's theory presents no difficulties. I can readily admit, for I have often said, that we know nothing of the historical Socrates, and that the Platonic Socrates is an ideal literary creation — too good to be true. 1 I admit also the general probability that Plato had read widely in fifth -century literature, as well as in the writings of his contemporaries, and drew many suggestions from both. Pater said as much in his Plato and Platonism, and Wilamowitz' magisterial pronouncements that Plato never read, say Thucydides, or Herodotus, are easily disproved. But the attempted specific attribution of many of Plato's and Aristotle's leading ideas to a Hippias or a Prodicus is presumptively foredoomed to failure, and neither Professor Dupreel's methods nor the particular arguments on which he relies go far to overcome this unfavorable presumption. The method is an extension of that practiced by Dummler, Joel, Dittmar, and others whom he quotes, "Parallels" between Plato and contemporary or later spurious literature are treated as evidence, not of the imitation of Plato, but of the use of a common source. This is undoubtedly a possibility. But the systematic assumption that it is always, or usually, the fact vitiates most of the source hunting and "literary feuds" literature of the past fifty years. Professor Dupreel admits that the Eryxias is a pastiche of Plato in form, but traces resemblance in substance to a common source, Prodicus. He is aware that the n-epi aperf}? reads like a trivial resume of the Meno, but will have it that it is a youthful work of Plato. He finds in the argument 1 Cf. Classical Philology, supra, p. 74; and article "Socrates" in the New Inter- national Encyclopaedia. 270 Book Reviews of the Dialexeis that he who knows justice will know injustice a parallel to the infinitely subtler and finer statement of the dependence of rhetoric on dialectic in the Phaedrus, which again, he thinks, points to a common source. And in similar comparisons throughout the book he neglects the principle of sound criticism, that the mere crude hint and suggestion of an idea counts for very little. Doubtless some approximation to almost any notion can be found in Euripides, and if we had their texts, could be found in the Greek Sophists. What sets Plato apart and makes him unique is a mastery of ideas, a subtlety of coherent and nicely qualified reasoning, which cannot be found in any of his predecessors, and which his modern critics will never understand until they analyze the contexts and secondary intentions of their quotations much more critically than even Professor Dupreel has tried to do. What, then, are his proofs that Hippias towers above Plato and Aristotle on the summit of fifth-century thought ? Assuming the greater Hippias to be genuine, he treats all that Socrates there says of the definition as a defense of the theory of ideas. I am not concerned to refute that exaggeration of a theory of my own. For in the unity of Plato's thought the terminology of the definition may always imply the theory of ideas. Serious fallacy begins with Professor Dupreel's confusion of Hippias' incapacity to comprehend the nature of a definition with a reasoned rejection of the theory of ideas from the standpoint of a conscious Nominalism. There is plainly nothing of the kind in the dialogue. Hippias' inability to distinguish a definition of beauty from a pretty girl is precisely that of Meno and many other inter- locutors, whom Socrates initiates into the elements of logic. If there were any independent evidence that Hippias had ever thought seriously, or was capable of serious thought about the nature of universals, it would be competent to argue that Plato's caricature misrepresented as incapacity for logic what was really a rational rejection of the theory of ideas by a philo- sophic Nominalist. As it is, the assumption has nothing to support it except a misunderstanding of one of the funniest passages of the dialogue, that in which Hippias, like a modern professor of education, bitterly complains of the atrophizing accuracy and the cheese-paring scholastic abstract logic by which Socrates breaks up and renders static the continuous flux of the concrete, dynamic entities of life and integral experience. Professor Dupreel sees in this delicious parody a conscientious citation of Hippias' philosophic repudiation of the theory of ideas in favor of an Aristotelian doctrine of the indissoluble unity of matter and form in substance. And in the succession of blundering and tentative definitions of the kalon, he discovers the outlines of an entire treatise on the beautiful which he attributes to Hippias. By means of the word TrvfrvKora, which is all they have in common, he identifies the thought of this passage of the Hippias Maior (301. B) with a totally disparate idea in Cratylus (386.D-E), in order to confirm his theory that the "pre-Aristotelianism" of the Cratylus is due to Hippias. The Cratylus, Book Reviews 271 without doubt, anticipates and is perhaps one source of the Aristotelian doctrine of matter and form, as others have perceived. But there is not one iota of evidence that it in turn is derived from Hippias. All over-ingenious books are protected against critical reviewing by the fact that a really critical review would occupy as much space as the book itself. The general method of the rehabilitation of Prodicus is to attribute to him everything in the argument of the dialogues that mention him that can be associated with any of the passages in which Socrates playfully alludes to his discrimination of synonyms. Thus Laches' indignation at the sophistic distinction between "brave" and "fearless" is used to refer to Prodicus as source the whole theory of bravery set forth by Nicias. Many scholars and pragmatist philosophers have anticipated M. Dupreel in the employment of similar methods for restoration of the true Protagorean philosophy. Once more I am sorry to seem to take a purely negative position toward what is after all a well-written, laborious, stimulating, thought-provoking piece of work, which every Platonic library should possess. But how is Platonic scholarship to progress if diametrically opposed interpretations are all favorably reviewed and allowed to stand side by side with no attempt to settle the issues that they raise ? Wilamowitz, Dupreel, Burnet ignore one another. A negative attitude toward all of them will have at least a 50 per cent chance of being right. And a scholar who translates ixtra \6yov "apres le raisonnement " (p. 347) surely invites scrutiny of his arguments. Paul Shokey Philostratus and Eunapius, The Lives of the Sophists. With an English translation by Wilmeb Cave Wright. Loeb Classical Library. London: William Heinemann; New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1922. Mrs. Wright's studies of Julian and her familiarity with the later Greek rhetoric designated her as the Loeb translator of Philostratus and Eunapius. She writes a fluent and idiomatic English which follows closely the thought of the Greek, yet does not read like a translation. Well-written introductions supply all the information that the modern reader will need for the intelligence of these biographies and a helpful glossary of Greek rhetorical terms and an index complete what will prove one of the most useful and instructive volumes of the series. There are very few oversights. In Lives of the Sophists 585 I think Rohde is right in taking hrvnr'iX,ovro figuratively. Herodes, perhaps, does not "expound with copious comments a hundred verses," but speaks for a time measured by a hundred verses. In 5.87 a-Kiprriixa is not, I think, "a boisterous Greek dance" but is used metaphorically as in Stob. Flor. 68.37: i^oi\tTai to v€OTrj