STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Griechische Mythologie. Von L. Pbelleb. Vierte Auflage erneuert von Carl Robert. Zweiter Band, Erstes Buch: Landschaftliche Sagen; Drittes Buch, erste Abteilung: Die Griechische Helden- sage: die Argonauten; der Thebanische Kreis. Berlin: Weid- mannsche Buchhandlung. 1920-21. In 1875 the second volume of Preller's Griechische Mythologie was issued in a third edition revised by Eugen Plew. The first volume, however, appeared in a fourth edition in 1894, revised by Carl Robert. Now the same scholar, a veteran in his field, but one whose skill and activity are happily unabated, gives us a revision of the first part of the second volume, that deals with Die landschaftlichen Sagen. In the thirty-eight years between the third and fourth editions of this part a vast amount of work has been done in the field of mythology and the point of view from which myths are regarded has greatly shifted. Few could be so well equipped as Robert for this work, since he adds to his thorough knowledge of the literary sources a full acquaintance with the data furnished by the monuments of every kind and a sane method of procedure. Although the outward form and arrangement at first glance seems but slightly changed, as a matter of fact we have here a new work much larger and richer than the old, brought into accord with the demands of the present day. Such a work was needed. Robert has made especial effort to trace the growth of each myth in poetry and art from the earliest form which can now be discovered, and to assign to each poet, so far as possible, the contribu- tion which he made to the development of the story. Perhaps some may regret that the author has resorted so little to etymology, but his reserve here is a happy contrast to the extremes to which would-be interpreters resorted in a past which is not yet very far away. More will wish that he had intro- duced parallels from the lore of other peoples; but Robert has restricted himself to such cases as seemed inevitable; and indeed we must recognize that if he had endeavored to quote parallel myths adequately, his work would have grown to enormous size and possibly would have been less useful in the end. The present part of the work is of especial interest to students of litera- ture, particularly to students of epic, lyric, and tragic poetry. An examina- tion of any one of his sections, as, for example, his discussion of "Peleus und Achilleus," "Medeia," or of "Orpheus" will quickly show the method and 263 264 Book Reviews worth of the book. There the reader finds in brief and clear form Robert's view of the historical growth of the myth, supported at every point by his authorities. Often the treatment will arouse dissent on special points, but nevertheless all must welcome the book and recognize its value for our studies. The third part of the second volume is given wholly to the Argonautic and Theban Cycles, the Trojan Cycle being reserved for the next instalment. The complex stories here discussed developed largely under historical influ- ences. As one part of Greece came into contact with another through trade or war, or as adventurous Greeks touched strange and barbarous shores, the quick Hellenic imagination wove tales in which were incorporated elements both old and new, and from which in time were to be made the great epics. The Ionians began the creation of these heroic sagas and then the Greek mainland followed their example. The story of the voyage of the first ship, the Argo, in its familiar form, shows the unmistakable influence of Greek trading ventures and colonizing undertakings along the shores of the Pontus Euxinus. The extant treatment of the myths in Apollonius' epic has obscured for us the older form of the story, so that the first task for the critic is to enucleate the earlier kernels of the tale from the later matter with which time and above all the learned Alexandrian involved them. According to the view which wins Robert's approval Corinth had most influence in the earlier development of the myth, for otherwise Medea's important r61e cannot be explained. Now Corinthian colonization was all in the West; there then lay the mythical land of Aea: and even Phineus, who originated in Arcadia, must have once dwelt in the West. The Odyssey tells us (//. 70) that the crashing rocks were passed by the Argo as it brought its heroes back through Oceanus by way of the passage from the unknown Pontus Euxinus into the Mediterranean once more, and not on its outward voyage. The complete reversal of the scene from West to East, Robert holds was made by Milesian poets after the founding of Cyzicus and the opening of the Euxinus. The verse in the Odyssey just referred to points to the older form of the myth; and Robert believes that this older Ionian form was used also in the lost Corinthiaca of Eumelus and in the Naupactica. Robert finds the origin of the whole myth in the union of a Thessalian story with the sacred myth of a Corinthian goddess, Medea. The details of the developed cycle he discusses through more than a hundred pages with results which are interesting if not always convincing. Points of difference cannot be handled in a brief notice, and the reviewer hesitates to oppose a scholar so learned and sane as Robert, but he cannot refrain from expressing his doubts whether it is necessary to postulate a complete reversal of the mythical geography by Milesian poets. Such violent treatment is not very probable in itself; and the somewhat incongruous elements of the complex story can surely be explained in a simplex fashion. Book Reviews 265 The Theban is the only great mythical cycle that is confined to a narrow geographical area within Greece proper. Robert holds that Oedipus was originally a "year-god" who became a Theban king; then in the developing story he grew into a patricide, a conqueror of the Sphinx, and the father of two warrior sons, whose quarrel may have a basis in historical events. The final form of the myth was created by the great tragedians of the fifth century, especially by Euripides in his Phoenissae. The details here also are discussed with the fulness and clarity that we should expect from the author of Oedipus. Clifford H. Moore Harvard University Archaeological Excavation. By J. P. Droop, M.A. Cambridge: The University Press; New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1915. 8vo. Pp. xii+80. 8 figures. $1.00. "This essay has been written chiefly with the idea of entertaining the many who by their interest and subscriptions have helped in the work of recovering the past, and partly in the hope that, if it makes even slightly for the accomplishment of better work in the future, it may not have been written in vain." It is an excellent little manual for those who are intending to excavate, written by one who, though never in full charge of an expedition, has had experience in Greece and in Egypt. Stress is laid throughout upon the duty of conducting excavations for the purpose of extracting from a site all the information it can yield and placing that information promptly before the public. Digging merely for the purpose of finding objects of special interest is properly condemned. The excavator should be in some measure a surveyor and engineer, a photographer, and a draughtsman, but above all a man of tact and sufficiently in command of the language of his workmen to understand them and be understood by them. Moreover — and this is essential — no excavation should be undertaken with an insufficient staff. The strata of the site should be carefully distinguished, and the whole site, after preliminary trenches (better than pits) have made its conditions clear, should be excavated evenly to avoid confusion of strata. All objects found should be labelled and recorded at once. Practical directions are given for the use of the dumpy level, the pick and spade, the knife for careful work, the choice of the place for dumping, and the like, as well as for encouragement of industry, efficiency, and honesty among the workmen. The book is to be recommended as interesting, practical, and sensible, well devised to guard inexperienced excavators against possible mistakes in preparation of their outfit and conduct of their digging, as well as to explain to those who contribute funds the manner in which the funds are to be spent. Harold N. Fowler