STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 99 by Kroll in the next line, contains a list of 119 MSS (including a few that contain only fragments). A few minor errors may be noted; the number in the running title at the top of page 13 should be 8 instead of 7; page 224 (top), the number of the subsection has been omitted; 182, 6, 1, the cross-reference 184, 2, 3 should be 184, 2, 4; the cross-reference in 184, 3, 2, 184, 7, 3 and 184, 9, 2 should be 183, 6 instead of 183, 7; page 450, the subsection number 6 should be 7; page 74 (bottom), read "Cremer" for "Cremrr." The index (about 4 pages) has been much condensed, many subject titles and a few unimportant names being omitted. Charles H. Beeson University op Chicago VEta delle Guerre Puniche. {Storia del Romani, Vol. III.) By Gaetano de Sanctis. Turin: Fratelli Bocca. Pt. I, pp. ix+ 432; Pt. II, pp. 727. Price of the two parts, lire 30. In the volumes before us Professor Gaetano de Sanctis carries his ambi- tious Storia del Romani to the close of the Punic Wars. His readers will have been prepared by his earlier work to expect a scholarly and exhaustive treatment of each period, and their expectations will be fully realized in the present generous instalment, which consists of more than eleven hundred medium octavo pages. Our author's plan is to give an unbroken chapter of historical exposition with essential notes at the foot of the page, and then to give an appendix to the chapter containing a thoroughgoing treatment of special points. In comparison with the earlier volumes the present shows a much fuller discussion of sources and critical problems. As one views carefully this vivid depiction of the struggle for the Mediter- ranean one finds a surprising number of suggestive contacts across the cen- turies. One is almost tempted to acquiesce in the contention of Benedetto Croce that there is no difference between contemporaneous and non- contemporaneous history. In fact, for a student with a philosophic trend the dictum is sound. However, it is exactly these contacts and suggestions that classically trained readers will feel and follow for themselves, so a reviewer is robbed of his most pleasant function. Accordingly he must content himself with considering a few of the questions one always puts to a historian of this period. To begin with, Professor de Sanctis is an extreme admirer of Polybius. It is true that he occasionally tempers his praise, but his strictures are of the mildest. His detailed studies such as Composizione ed economia delle Storie di Polibio will be regarded by the serious student as among the most accept- able features of the volumes. Toward Livy he is not overgenerous; but he 100 Book Reviews is reasonable and he appreciates the unquestionable dramatic power of the Patavian as well as his desire to write instructively and reliably. Toward the smaller fry he is ruthless. In dealing with modern writers he holds a level balance, escaping alike the perils of a narrow nationalism and of undue deference to his great predecessors in other lands. Moreover, his range is enviably comprehensive. Some specialist in this field could doubtless point out a few studies missed by our historian, but they would be neither numerous nor important. As to Roman "imperialism," he agrees with many other writers in thinking that the first steps in the direction of empire were unconscious, but he does not go too far in the "absent-minded" theory. To the political acumen of the powerful commercial and landed-property classes he is more generous than most historians, and herein he is surely right. We have been so blinded by the illiberality and stupidity of these classes in social problems that we have failed to do justice to their_brains when working in other fields. They simply could not have been as persistently and impenetrably unin- telligent as we are often told. At any rate, it was not long after 250 that the pathway to dominion grew fairly clear to some of the leaders, and it is nonsense to talk as though they were not alive to its possibilities. On the vexed question of cavalry tactics our author throws little light. The more one delves into the Punic Wars, the more stress one lays on the fleet and the cavalry. It is thoroughly provoking that we must still grope in puzzled eagerness for any adequate knowledge of the methods whereby the horsemen, particularly the Numidians, were so effectively handled. Even today we do not get far beyond a general impression of decisive weight thrown into one battle after another by this arm of the service. Turning to the question that was a joy even in our high-school and Freshman days, we are assured unreservedly that Hannibal crossed by Mont Genevre. Indeed, Professor de Sanctis has no patience with any other view. However, this tempting line of review is leading us to intolerable length, and we must content ourselves with saying that not even the most exacting reader will fail to find his questions answered one way or another. Our author is always keen for a difficulty and a discussion. We have no disposition to attempt to pick flaws in such a work. One feels that the military side of history is here made very prominent, but our author has discussed this question most sanely in his preface. The possi- bility of criticism seems to lie in another direction, and we find ourselves asking whether constructive imagination has been allowed as much play as might have been desirable. Perhaps in the past we have been so prone to talk of the warmth and glow of the "meridional" that our distinguished Italian has been holding himself in check deliberately; but if this is true we could wish he had allowed himself more freedom. If we may refer once more to a great contemporary and compatriot of our author, we may recall Croce's doctrine that there is not an essential difference in kind between the intuitive Book Reviews 101 imagination of the student and of the artist. The ultimately great historian will so suffuse his painfully sought knowledge with the vivifying power of his artistic imagination that the past is brought compellingly, or even irre- sistibly, into the general active interest of our life and thought. In this way is achieved the historian's lofty ambition worded so unforgettably by Thucydides. It would ill become a modest reviewer to venture any pre- diction as to how near Professor de Sanctis will come to this final goal; but one is sure that if the Fates will vouchsafe the completing of his work, he will leave a notable and abiding monument. As a very business-like conclusion one ought to state that in addition to the extensive notes and appendixes mentioned above there will be found a good index and a chronological table. Not the least praiseworthy feature is the series of very usable plans and maps at the close of the second volume. Most of the typographical slips have been caught up in the list of errata, so one has little to complain about under this head. It will be nice to bind the volumes in old-fashioned heavy calf, if such luxuries ever become accessible again. F. B. R. Hellems University op Colorado The Doctrine of Literary Forms. By Roy Kenneth Hack. Har- vard Studies in Classical Philology, Vol. XXVII, 1916, pp. 65. The reprint before us contains a better-executed piece of work than is suggested by the rather awkward sentence in which the writer summarizes his project: Hence the subject which I wish to investigate in this paper is the doctrine of forms in its application to criticism: first, to sketch the history of the criticism of the Ars Poetica of Horace, then to show that there is a basic error in the critical method which has commonly been followed, and lastly to trace that error to its source and to indicate the necessity of a change in critical procedure. Mr. Hack believes there has been altogether too much stress upon "genres" in the study of Latin literature; and his onslaught upon the representatives of this mistaken emphasis upon etSij and yevrj is marked by a thoroughness that is both whole-hearted and effective. On this point one will congratulate the author most heartily; the only question is whether the critics of this misguided type were worth the expenditure of wide-ranging scholarship and protestant energy he has devoted to them, since even some years ago their malignant influence seemed to be on the decline. Perhaps, however, it was worth while dealing them this vigorous downward thrust. In the second part of his study Mr. Hack attempts to prove that Plato is responsible for the erroneous method of literary criticism that is based upon the "doctrine of propriety" found in Cicero and Horace. Plato's doctrine of imitation implies that we must judge a thing "by the degree in