STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 94 Book Reviews for profectm; there are at least half a hundred cases where a word has been incorrectly divided at the end of a line. A footnote to vi. 25 states that chapters 25-28 are regarded by some scholars as an interpolation; other passages equally suspicious pass without comment, including iv. 10, about which even the most skeptical can hardly doubt. A footnote to vii. 24 contains a belated explanation of vigilia — the word has occurred ten times before this (the list of passages given in the subject-index is incomplete). Chables H. Beeson Univebsity of Chicago W. S. Teuffels Geschichte der romischen Literatur. Sechste Auflage unter Mitwirkung von Erich Klostermann, Rudolf Leon- hard, und Paul Wessner, neu bearbeitet von Wilhelm Kroll und Franz Skutsch. Erster Band, "Die Literatur der Repu- blik." Druck und Verlag B. G. Teubner, Leipzig, Berlin, 1916. The revision of the first volume has fallen almost entirely on the shoulders of Kroll. Skutsch died before the revision of the third volume was finished; Klostermann, who revised the Christian writers in the third volume, had nothing to do in Volume I; Wessner was drawn into military service, and his contributions to the grammarians were therefore slight; Leonhard, as before, revised the jurists. Kroll's burden was increased by the delay (caused by the war) in printing the work and the consequent difficulties in keeping up with the new literature, and by the frequent changes in proof- readers, due also to the necessities of military service. As in the two previous volumes the revision has observed the bounds set by the original plan of the work. The old section numbers and, with little change, the subsection numbers have been preserved. The book has increased in size by seventy-eight pages. The greatest increase falls to Cicero (over twenty-two pages) ; Varro gains nine pages, Plautus three and a half, Sallust two and a half, Terence, Cato, the Ad Herennium, and Caesar, two pages each. The amount of new matter is greater than might at first appear since most of the additions occur in the smaller type of the sub- sections. New sections have been inserted: 60a and note, das Alphabet; 164a and notes 1-4, Varro als Forscher; 212a and notes 1 and 2, die Neoteriker. New subsections have been added throughout the book: 3, 4, infamia of the actor; 38, 2; 47, 2, Greek romance; 61, 3, Wortspiel in the early in- scriptions; 83, 4, ancient inscription found in the Forum under the lapis niger; 97, 7, 2; 98, 5, difference between Latin comedy and the Greek originals; 110, 2, 4; 118, 4, Greek influence on Cato; 123, 9, influence of Greek rhetoric at Rome shown by prologues of Terence; 164, 3, style of Book Reviews 95 Varro; 167, 3, sources of Varro's De lingua Latina; 168, 2, sources of Varro's De re rustica; 175, 4, contemporary and later attitude toward Cicero; 176, 2, defense of Cicero; 176, 3, Cicero's influence on Roman literature; 181, 2, rhythmical prose; 182, 2, 2, Greek influence on Cicero's rhetoric; 182, 3, 2 and 3, analysis and characterization of the Brutus; 182, 5, 1, characterization of the Partitiones oratoriae; 184, 2, 3, sources of De legibus. Much new matter is contained in additions to the old sections; e.g., characterizations of Scipio and Sallust, of the various plays of Plautus and Terence, and the works of Cicero. The influence of rhetoric is stressed throughout; e.g., 13, tragedy; 22, the epithalamium; 36, history; 46, let- ters; 51, philosophy; 135, Gaius Gracchus; still more attention is given to Greek influence; e.g., 23, 43, 44, on Cato and Appius Claudius; 35, literary prose; 36, history; 41, grammar and philology; 52, mathematics; 53, science; 57, architecture; 91 and 92, characterization of the sixth and seventh centuries; 118, 119, Cato; similarly throughout Cicero's writings. Poseidonios, Antiochus, Menander, and Panaitios receive especial attention. Many additions have been made in the notes; e.g., 35, 2, early prose ( Vulgarlatein) ; 88, 1 and 2, publication of the calendar of religious festivals and the leges actionis; 97, 14, 1, a lengthy discussion of contamination in the Pseudolus; 179, 16-18, 1, defense of Cicero's policy in the De lege agraria; in other notes on Cicero, dealing especially with the sources. New literature has been added, new citations from Latin authors inserted; sometimes the text of an old citation has been given in full. On the other hand more than a dozen of the old subsections have been dropped, and many have been cut down. The editors of the present re- vision broke with the principle of giving a complete bibliography and much of the older literature has been eliminated; this is especially true of titles bearing on Kritik and Erklarung; references are given instead to Bursian, Engelmann-Preuss, Klussmann, etc.; in 214, 14 the bibliography of Catullus (Kritik und Erklarung) has been reduced by a half to 16 lines. A number of sections have been completely rewritten; e.g., 33, the iambus; 47, the romance; 61, earliest Roman prose {carmen); 62, Saturnian meter; 206, characterization of Sallust. In general, however, the outline of the original text has been but little disturbed. Sometimes the text is cut, sometimes cleverly condensed; often the change is purely stylistic; fre- quently a word or phrase is inserted to add a new fact or to indicate the author's dissent from the old statement. Occasionally the new statement is more cautious than the old; in many cases a neutral statement has been made more positive. The following will illustrate: 8, 12, denial that any connection can be proved between the mimus and the commedia dell' arte; 9, 7, denial that Horace in his discussion of the satyrdrama (A.P. 220) had any definite purpose in mind; 13, 1 rejects Ribbeck's theory that ancient Roman tragedies were modernized in the first century a.d.; 15, the plays of Plautus were performed "einige Zeit," not "bis in die Kaiserzeit"; so 96 Book Reviews also 99, the critical study of Plautus began "erst spater," not "bald"; 28, the old statement "die Satire wurde zu einem Literaturzweige durch Ennius" is corrected and enlarged, "die Satura ist eigentlich nicht ein besonderer Literaturzweig, sondern eine Sammlung vermischter Gedichte, wie sie bei den Alexandrinern iiblich war und, wie es scheint, durch Ennius in die romische Literatur eingeftihrt wurde"; 29, Valerius Cato is rejected as the author of the Dirae; 35, prose has a rhetorical coloring "infolge der Herrschaft der Schule," not "infolge des romischen Volkscharakters"; 36, "das Verlangen das geschichtlich Wahre als solches zu ermitteln und fortzupflanzen ist auch den Romern fremd" is corrected to "die Forderung das geschichtlich Wahre als solches zu ermitteln und darzustellen, war vorhanden und wurde oft ausgesprochen"; and with regard to those who concerned themselves with historical criticism "nur wenige" is corrected to "keiner"; 44, 7, Cicero's publication of his speeches exactly as they were delivered appears to have been the exception rather than the rule; 58, "unter den hierher gehorigen Schriften des Boethius ist viel Unechtes" is corrected to "von den hierher gehorigen Schriften des Boethius sind gerade die gromatischen Teile unecht"; 77, 5, "sogar deutliche Spuren hexametrischer Fassung bei Amm. Marc." is corrected to "trtigerisch wohl die Spuren," etc.; p. 153, n. 15, Plautus' numerous complaints about mores mali do not reflect Roman conditions but were taken over from the Greek originals; 128, Spurius Carvilius is not "one of the first" who opened a public school at Rome but "the first"; 183, Cicero's errors in rendering his Greek originals are "gelegentlich" not "zahlreich"; 205, Sallust writes "mit scheinbarem (not "sichtlichem") Streben nach Unparteilichkeit"; 210, M. Junius Brutus is "weder moralisch noch geistig hochstehend" instead of "redlich aber geistig nicht hochstehend." Similarly in regard to dates. Sometimes the date is omitted; e.g., for the Asinaria, Poentdus, and Rudens of Plautus; rarely is a new date inserted. Occasionally a more definite date is given; e.g., 12, drama at Rome "seit dem J. 240" instead of "zu Anfang des sechsten Jahrhunderts " ; 44, rhetoric taught by Romans "in den neunziger Jahren des letzten Jahrh. v. Chr." instead of "nach der Mitte," u.s.w. More often a less definite date is given: 40, the earliest inscriptions are "aus sehr fruher Zeit" instead of "aus dem sechsten Jahrh."; 97, 20, the Truculentus appeared "aus Plautus' spateren Jahren" instead of "um J. 189"; 143, Lucilius died "im J. 102/4" instead of "im J. 103"; in a number of instances the date is changed: 60, the original of the tabula Peutingeriana is put in the middle of the second century instead of the third (but in 412, 6 [third volume] it is put in the third or fourth century; a similar discrepancy occurs in dating the Choro- graphia of Iulius Titianus; in 60 it is put in the third century; in 364 in the second) ; 93, aspirates represented by ch, ph, th "etwa seit J. 150" instead of "seit J. 104"; 132, the historians still imitated the annalists "um die Mitte des zweiten Jahrh. v. Chr." instead of "in dem ersten Funftel des siebenten Book Reviews 97 Jahrh. d. St."; 182, 5, the Partitiones oratoriae were written "um J. 54" instead of "im J. 46 oder 45"; 182, 7, De optimo genere oratorum was written "um J. 46" instead of "vielleicht gleichfalls aus dem J. 44"; 205, Sallust died in the year 35 instead of 34. From the foregoing it will be seen that the revision has covered, with great thoroughness, a very wide range and has dealt with an immense mass of petty details. It was no light task to incorporate in a work constructed on such an inelastic plan the results of the investigations of a quarter of a century in every field of philological endeavor. It is not surprising, therefore, if here and there a passage has escaped the revising hand or if an occasional error has crept in or remained unnoticed from the old edition. One could make many additions to the bibliography, but it is not clear that these omissions have not been intentional. The absence of many French, English, and Italian titles is, however, probably due to the deficiencies of the library at Munster, of which the editors complained in the preface of the second volume. Dreves, Analecta hymnica, should be added in 30, 2, and Leo, Die griechisch-romische Biographie, in 37, 7; Traube, Die Geschichte der tironischen Noten bei Swtonius und Isidorus, deserves mention in 104, 5. The facsimiles cited are almost entirely from Chatelain, Zangemeister- Wattenbach, and the Leyden series, but the Chatelain citations are not complete; e.g., 182, 2, 3, Harley 2736 = Ch. 19a; 184, 2, 4, Voss. 84 and 86 = Ch. 38a, 39, 1; 184, 3, 2, Vindob. 189 = Ch. 38, 1; 198, 8, Gudianus 166 and Parcensis = Ch. 182, 1 and 2. The editions cited are not always the latest; Mommsen's Romische Geschichte is still cited in the sixth edition; Leo, Kultur der Gegenwart, is cited in the second edition, his Plautinische Forschungen and Ebert's Geschichte der Literatur des Mittelcdters in the first; Voigt, Wiederbelebung des klassischen Altertums, appears in both the second and the third; the first four volumes of Drumann's Geschichte Roms are sometimes cited in the first edition, and even when the second is used the fact is not always indicated (210, 6 and 7). The citations from Isidore's Origines should be revised according to Lindsay's edition, especially as some of the chapter numbers of Book i have been changed ; 35, 1, read 1, 38 for 1, 37; 37, 3, read 41 for 40; 41, 2, read 21 for 20; 104, 5, and 191, 4, read 22 for 21. Lindsay's text also contains some changes of which the more important are: 7, 1, "mimi sunt .... imitatores" (instead of "imitationes"); 35, 1, read "Syrus" for "Syrius" and "iam exhinc et ceteri prosae eloquentia contenderunt" for "iam exhinc ceteri prosae elo- quentiam condiderunt"; 8, 3, "(mimi) habebant suum actorem (instead of "auctorem") qui antequam mimum ageret fabulam pronuntiaret"; 16, 1, "aut gestu cantabant" for "ac gestu canebant"; 26, 2, after "more centonario" insert "ex multis hinc inde compositis"; 104, 5, insert "com- plures" before "simul astantes"; in 191, 4, the MSS have "commentus," which Teuffel-Schwabe proposed as an emendation for Arevalo's "com- mentatus. " 98 Book Reviews In 180 Porcia is the sister of Cato; 215, 3 is correct, "Tochter nicht Schwester"; p. 319, Gallus is said to have been born in Northern Italy; 232, 2 (second volume) gives his birthplace correctly as Gallia Narbonensis. Both of these errors are repeated from the old edition. In 196, 1 the passage in oratio recta in B.G. 7, 20 is said to be an exception to Caesar's usage; there are other exceptions and one more striking in 7, 77; in 196, 2 the ex- pression "Besorgung kritischer Ausgaben" applied to the activities of Celsus and Lupicinus is inaccurate; the correct view of such "recensions" is given in 109, 2; 196, 7, Holder's edition of the Gallic War contains a (separate) word-index to Book viii; the statement in 196 that Caesar speaks of himself only in the third person is incorrect. He uses the first person plural a number of times. 39, 5, the Vatican MS, Pal. lat. 909, of the His- toria miscella of Landolfus Sagax, though contemporaneous, is not an auto- graph; see Loew, Beneventan Script, p. 9. The new edition, like the old, is in the dark as to the whereabouts of the best MS of Cicero's Laelius (184, 14, 2, "wo jetzt?"), once in the library of Firmin Didot in Paris, where Mommsen collated it in 1863. Schanz is no better informed (" die beste HS is der Codex Parisinus s. IX/X den Mommsen bei Didot gefunden hat"); practically the same statement is made by Muller (in his Teubner edition) , who used Mommsen's collation. Apparently no scholar has collated the MS since 1863, though Reid examined it in 1883 in London, where it was in the possession of Quaritch, but too late to use it for his second edition of the Laelius, which appeared in that year. Professor Clifton Price is the only editor, so far as I have discovered, who states that the MS is in Berlin. He writes me that Quaritch sold it to Berlin in 1901. The MS is in the Royal library there, as I was informed in 1910 by Holder, the kindly old librarian at Karlsruhe. It might pay the next editor of Laelius to collate it anew; at any rate it is high time that this philological waif be provided with a definite home in our bibliographies. In 214, 1 two inscriptions have been combined into one and the reference to the first omitted; the first one, "M. Annius Valerius Catullus," is found in CIL, 4484, as stated in the old edition. The paragraph dealing with the Catullus MSS (214, 10) needs revision. The 'awkward statement, repeated from the old edition, "die alteste und beste erweislich unmittelbare Abschrift des Veronensis ist der Parisinus 14137 vom Jahre 1375," can be challenged at every point. The Parisinus certainly cannot be proved to be a direct copy of V; it is probably not the oldest. The date 1375 is that of its im- mediate archetype; the further statement that R contributes nothing important to the text is not to the point in estimating the relative value of OGR, for the same statement might have been made of G if R had been discovered first, and indeed it would probably apply equally well to the lost Verona if it should ever come to light. The number of Catullus MSS is still given as 70, though Hale's article in Classical Philology, III, 233, cited Book Reviews 99 by Kroll in the next line, contains a list of 119 MSS (including a few that contain only fragments). A few minor errors may be noted; the number in the running title at the top of page 13 should be 8 instead of 7; page 224 (top), the number of the subsection has been omitted; 182, 6, 1, the cross-reference 184, 2, 3 should be 184, 2, 4; the cross-reference in 184, 3, 2, 184, 7, 3 and 184, 9, 2 should be 183, 6 instead of 183, 7; page 450, the subsection number 6 should be 7; page 74 (bottom), read "Cremer" for "Cremrr." The index (about 4 pages) has been much condensed, many subject titles and a few unimportant names being omitted. Charles H. Beeson University op Chicago VEta delle Guerre Puniche. {Storia del Romani, Vol. III.) By Gaetano de Sanctis. Turin: Fratelli Bocca. Pt. I, pp. ix+ 432; Pt. II, pp. 727. Price of the two parts, lire 30. In the volumes before us Professor Gaetano de Sanctis carries his ambi- tious Storia del Romani to the close of the Punic Wars. His readers will have been prepared by his earlier work to expect a scholarly and exhaustive treatment of each period, and their expectations will be fully realized in the present generous instalment, which consists of more than eleven hundred medium octavo pages. Our author's plan is to give an unbroken chapter of historical exposition with essential notes at the foot of the page, and then to give an appendix to the chapter containing a thoroughgoing treatment of special points. In comparison with the earlier volumes the present shows a much fuller discussion of sources and critical problems. As one views carefully this vivid depiction of the struggle for the Mediter- ranean one finds a surprising number of suggestive contacts across the cen- turies. One is almost tempted to acquiesce in the contention of Benedetto Croce that there is no difference between contemporaneous and non- contemporaneous history. In fact, for a student with a philosophic trend the dictum is sound. However, it is exactly these contacts and suggestions that classically trained readers will feel and follow for themselves, so a reviewer is robbed of his most pleasant function. Accordingly he must content himself with considering a few of the questions one always puts to a historian of this period. To begin with, Professor de Sanctis is an extreme admirer of Polybius. It is true that he occasionally tempers his praise, but his strictures are of the mildest. His detailed studies such as Composizione ed economia delle Storie di Polibio will be regarded by the serious student as among the most accept- able features of the volumes. Toward Livy he is not overgenerous; but he