STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 184 Book Reviews ment of his thought with Plato's. We may perhaps wish that he had chosen to devote more consideration to Philo's place in the history of Platonic interpretation. Roger Miller Jones University of California De Ciceronis Libro Consolationis Scripsit Iacobus Van Wageningen. Groningae: Heredes P. Noordhoff, 1916. M. 3.50. The universal mourning by which he was surrounded led the author's thoughts to Cicero's lost Consolatio. He believes that the chief and virtually the only source of this was Crantor's essay de luctu. This document in turn he thinks can be recovered by comparing the order of treatment of the parts of the various consolations that have come down to us, particularly parts of the Tusculans and Ps.-Plutarch, Consolatio ad Apollonium. In these and other similar works he finds an order of treatment so similar that he concludes that all of them come from the single source. He therefore analyzes the Consolatio ad Apollonium into the following parts: (a) "Exordium"; (b)"Devita"; (c) " De morte" ; (d) " De immortalitate animi." The salient parts of the text are given in one column and parallel to these, passages from the Tusculans, Ambrosius de excessu fratris liber II, Hieronymus Epistle lx, and similar documents. The result is the reconstructed Con- solatio of Cicero, with many additional fragments. It reads very much as we might expect certain parts of the real Consolatio to read. But several grounds for suspension of judgment at once appear. First, the process of reconstruction is too simple. Second, we have no real assurance that Cicero followed Crantor as closely as Plutarch is assumed by the author (following Pohlenz) to have done. Pliny (N.H. pref. 22) quotes from the Consolatio the words "Crantorem sequor" and the statement is echoed by Hieronymus (Ep. lx. 5; Migne i. 592). This statement must be read in the light of De off. ii. 60: "Panaetius, quem multum in his libris secutus sum, non interpretatus, " and De off. iii. 7 : " Panaetius quem .... secuti sumus." The use of sequor does not then imply any unwavering adherence to the source. Compare also Ad. Att. xii. 21. 5; xii. 14. 3; Tusc. iii. 76. When Cicero's eclecticism is taken into consideration, it seems dangerous to think that any particular idea can be traced to any particular source so easily and certainly. Third, Crantor was only one of many philos- ophers and rhetoricians who said practically ,the same thing in practically the same way. Consolatory literature is a mass of commonplaces that inevitably linked themselves together in natural groupings. Thus it becomes almost impossible to say that one passage is certainly the source of another. The consolatory topics were part of the common stock, and generations of philosophers and rhetoricians had handled and rehandled them, so that the natural order of treatment and the natural selection of ideas had become Book Reviews 185 also the conventional order and selection. It is therefore again dangerous to infer that similarity of form of expression or order is proof of relationship. Fourth, this customary order (followed, according to the author, by Plutarch) required that exempla follow praecepta, and this was the doctrine of the schools. But the scheme of arrangement requires now that a long list of exempla (Tusc. i. 113-14, 115, 116) fall into division (c) "Demorte." Cicero (Tusc. i. 112) expressly describes this section as an epilogus rhetorum, and this is confirmed by Seneca (Cons, ad Marc. 2. 1). Such a dislocation is sufficient to shake our confidence. This reconstructed Consolatio is plausible as to contents, less so as to arrangement, and still less so as to spirit. It is far too artificial and impersonal. The author reveals a thorough mastery of the material and much ingenuity in treatment and interpretation. I wish his purpose had allowed him to study the spurious document which goes under Cicero's name (see my Pseudo-Ciceronian Consolatio). He has given us, as he hopes, an "imago, quamvis non expressa, at tamen adumbrata, Consolationis Tulhanae." That he could do no more is the fault of the material rather than of the author. University of Pittsburgh Evan T. Sage Libanii Opera. Recensuit Richardus Foerstek. Vol. X, Epistulae 1-839. Leipzig: Teubner, 1921. Pp. 761. In 1914 Foerster published Volume VIII of his edition of Libanius. In spite of the interruption of the war he has practically completed the three final volumes and in his brief preface to Volume X he promises that Volume IX shall appear sine mora. For that volume he reserves his Prolegomena to the Letters and all discussion of the MSS and previous editions and com- mentaries. The present volume contains the first instalment of the Letters and a conspectus siglorum for the MSS, editions, and commentaries cited. Not until Volume IX with the Prolegomena is accessible will it be possible to give any account of Foerster's text or of his use of Sievers, or of Seeck whose work Die Briefe des Libanius, published in 1906, in some respects super- seded and in others supplemented Sievers as a biographical handbook for the sophists and officials of the fourth century a.d. Volume XI, which is in the press, will contain the remainder of the Letters, the Apocrypha, and certain pieces which are, says Foerster, the work of Choricius of Gaza, though they have come down to us under the name of Libanius. Foerster gives Wolf's numbering of the Letters in the margin of his edition, his own arrangement being independent of Wolf after Letter 218, Wilmer Cave Wright Bryn Mawb College