STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 176 Book Reviews of contraries, the cycle of life and death, and the logos, which Goethe might have picked up from Giordano Bruno, the Stoics, Cicero's philosophical works, and Lucretius, but also in all poetic and dialectic developments of "pantheism." Thus Spinoza and Hegel contribute to Goethe's Hera- cliteanism, and Herbert Spencer would have done so, if Goethe had known him. Newer and more useful to the present reviewer is the compact little essay on Goethe's archeologische Arbeiten, which assembles facts not given by Keller or Maass, and much more significant for Goethe's intellectual life than the extremely vague parallels with Heraclitus. The chapters on Goethe and Euripides and Goethe and the homerische Frage contain less matter than the corresponding sections in Keller. But with the guidance of Wilamowitz Bapp offers a more critical treat- ment of Goethe's attempted restoration of the Phaethon. Paul Shohey Bronzi Arcaici e Ceramica Geometrica ?iel Museo di Bari. By Michele Gekvasio. Bari, 1921. 8vo., pp. xii+371, 18 pis., 84 figures in the text. 40 Italian lire. This work forms Vol. XVI of the Documenti e Monografie brought out under the direction of the "Commissione Provinciale di Archeologia e Storia Patria." It is excellently produced, the type is clear and accurate, the figures in the text happily chosen to illustrate special points, and the plates are admirable, especially the two in color, which give an excellent impression of the unusual group of ceramics treated in this monograph. The majority of the objects were found on the slopes of Monte Sannace in an archaic necropolis where the graves differed in character according to the level at which they were found. Some were rectangular trenches cut in the bare soil with large stones at each corner to sustain a heavy stone slab. At a slightly greater depth the graves were hollowed out in the tufa, and they also were covered by the slab. But more frequent is the tomb made of a large monolithic tufa sarcophagus, buried at a depth of 1 m. 50. These sarcophagi are often found in the district, and are used by the peas- ants as water troughs for their cattle. The funereal objects are usually discovered, not in the sarcophagus, but piled outside at the head of the coffin. When uncovered the bodies were often found wrapped in mantles woven with gold and silver thread which instantly crumbled away upon exposure to the air. The ceramics of the archaic necropolis may be divided into two groups, indigenous and imported. The co-existence of Corinthian products with certain Ionic elements is confirmed by two most important specimens, a Corinthian crater and a Book Reviews 177 stamnos Ionicising in style. The crater is of the usual shape, the body divided into two zones. The narrow lower zone is decorated with five grazing gazelles, five leopards and a solitary waterfowl. In the middle of the broad upper zone are three winged horses galloping to. left, each mounted by a rider whose body is completely hidden by his steed's wings; only their beardless faces protrude, and their hands grasping the reins and a trident. These riders are labeled in archaic Greek lettering "Poseidon," and the crater furnishes important evidence for the diffusion of his cult through- out Apulia. The stamnos is an uncommon shape; the shoulder is adorned with stars and palmettes and the body illustrates two scenes. In one Herakles lies asleep on the ground with his club, bow, and quiver at his feet; from the right a Satyr advances with furtive steps, intent upon stealing the club of the sleeping hero. In the second scene a large amphora stands on the ground beside a table on which are three smaller vessels. In the middle of the scene two Satyrs are grouped around a brazier over which one of them holds a jar containing some substance which boils or dissolves in the heat. A third Satyr bends over a bowl placed upon a high stand. The author here sees the caricature of a potter's workshop; one Satyr kneads the clay for the pots, the other two melt the varnish, and to right are the finished speci- mens of their work. This attractive theory is not wholly convincing, but both scenes are treated in the spirit of caricature which we only find again in the Kabeiroi vases. The stamnos may be dated towards the middle of the sixth century B.C. Various isolated tombs and smaller necropoles are described, and then the author discusses the rich tomb discovered at Noicattaro. Here the vases, Corinthian and local geometric in type, were found outside the monolithic sarcophagus, heaped around the head and covered with a bronze shield. The bronze objects consisted of an oinochoe, shield, belt, and a pair of long narrow strips with the design beaten out, consisting of metope-like scenes which depict heraldic sphinxes, Achilles and Penthesilea, Herakles and the lion, Theseus and the Minotaur, and heraldic lions. The strips were finished off at each end by a palmette, recalling the finial surmounting early stelae. The author compares these strips with the similar ones found at Olympia, Aegina, Gela, and other sites and concludes that they are Argive-Corinthian, and that they probably decorated scabbards, because they are long, narrow, and applied with little nails more suitable to penetrate a leather foundation than to pierce a wooden core as would be necessary if they adorned a coffer or throne. However, the clean cut through both strips, made without regard to the metopes thus disfigured, suggests that they were wrought without precise destination, and were afterwards cut to the required length. Strips of this type may be dated at the end of the seventh century. The belt is also ornamented with a beaten pattern of six quadrigae racing to right. Under the horses' feet a boar or dog is placed alternately. 178 Book Reviews The use of quadrigae is one of the strongest reasons for excluding the belt from the cycle of Ionic art. Moreover the charioteers hold a goad, not a whip, and all the details of the chariots point to the Mainland rather than to the Ionic type. By a painstaking analysis of the Apulian geometric style the author has been enabled to make a definite classification of the types of vases found. Those painted in two colors show a dull black and a purplish red which tends to become violet. Of the two colors red prevails on the archaic shapes whilst it is sparingly used on the later examples. Yet it is probable that originally Apulian geometric followed the simplest path and made use of one color, black, only; later red also was added. For a time monochrome and vases in two colors were manufactured contemporaneously; in a later phase, the potters abandoned the use of red, most likely for technical reasons, since the red color was not very fast and did not incorporate satisfactorily with the clay. A design of single, double, or even triple reversed semicircles seems to go back to the late Mycenaean period, as do the spirals and complete circles, whereas the tongue patterns derive from Corinthian ware. The earliest instances of the meander show its derivation from recurring spirals, for the angles are still somewhat rounded and the whole design is set aslant, but it gradually usurps greater importance until in some cases it forms the chief ornament on the body of the vase. Still more prevalent is the swastika; indeed it is one of the characteristic motives of Apulian pottery. The human figure, although of rare occurrence, is rendered by an opaque silhouette of two triangles after the fashion of Dipylon ware, but one can trace the simplification of the design until it becomes a mere broken meander. Similarly the zones of water birds lose more and more of their natural form and degenerate into conventional signs. The author concludes that the streams of Greek influence found a fruit- ful soil in Apulia where the Bronze Age had left the tradition of well-made pottery adorned with an extensive repertory of designs. He believes that the geometric style was diffused throughout Apulia by means of the Proto- Corinthian and perhaps the Argive geometric. Although the first attempts may go back even to the eighth century B.C., yet the greatest development of the Apulian geometric may be fixed from the middle of the seventh to the middle of the sixth century; it gradually yielded before the invasion of Attic r.-f. vases, and entirely disappeared in the beginning of the fifth century with the rise of the Italiot fabrics, amongst the most celebrated of which were those of Ruvo and Ceglie. The author has co-ordinated and classified the results of his investiga- tions and has not only enriched the museum of Bari with the important fruits of his careful excavations but has enlarged our knowledge of this complicated subject by his admirable analysis of the material so acquired. Book Reviews 179 The book is written in such an agreeable style that we only dimly realize the long research and painstaking study which enabled the author to draw such illuminating comparisons and present what might have been a dry subject in such a lucid and attractive form. E. Douglas Van Buren Rome The Platonism of Philo Judaeus. By Thomas H. Billings. Uni- versity of Chicago Dissertation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1919. Pp. viii+105. In his first chapter Dr. Billings gives a clear and concise survey of the history of Philonic interpretation. It is interesting to note that he is not convinced by the arguments of the scholars who try to show that Philo is largely dependent upon Posidonius. At the end of this chapter Billings states his own point of view: Philo's thought is essentially Platonic, though he frequently adopts the terminology of other schools, and at times assumes a syncretistic attitude, as, for example, in identifying the Platonic Ideas, the Stoic logoi, the angels of the Old Testament, and the Greek demons. In the second chapter, on Philo's conception of the ultimate reality, Billings points out Philo's agreement with Plato and opposition to the Stoics in teaching a dualistic theory of the universe. Philo has been accused of two inconsistencies in his doctrine of God. "On the one hand it is said that while he regards the ultimate reality as an impersonal principle, the supreme genus comprehending in itself all the multiplicity of the species, he puts alongside of this the Jewish conception of a living, personal God. Others point out that while he insists that God absolutely transcends the universe he is equally insistent on the Stoic doctrine that the universe is created, filled, and governed by him." But these inconsistencies are already present, fully developed, in Plato. Zeller is wrong in asserting that Philo's use of owrla. for matter means that he adopts a Stoic point of view opposed to that of Plato. Billings rejects, after Shorey, the identification of Plato's God with the Idea of Good, but he adds: "Whether we make this identification or not, God is still for Plato beyond the world of ideas." Billings makes no attempt to prove this assertion, and I think it is quite impossible to prove it. Further, the identification of God and to ov is a mere reconstruction. Neither Sophist 249 A, which can hardly be called "an eloquent digression," nor Timaeus 38 AB really identifies the two, though, of course, to ov includes God. But it is highly probable, as Billings says, that Philo regarded to ov, especially in the Parmenides, as a philosophical term for God.