STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 163 critical notes on the following passages : E. Ill, 101 exitium est pecari] exitium pecori c x< Ribbeck and Hirtzel; G. I, 418, vias] vices Ribbeck and Hirtzel with two deteriores; Aen. ii. 584 habet haec] most editors read nee habet; Aen. iv. 217 subnixus] subnexus, Ribbeck and Hirtzel with two deteriores; Aen. V. 522 svMto] svbitum, Ribbeck and Hirtzel with several deteriores; Aen. vi. 96 qtiam] qua, one MS, Seneca, Bentley, Ribbeck and Hirtzel; Aen. vi. 609 et] aut c. Nonius, Servius, Ribbeck, Hirtzel; Aen. ix. 412 admrsi] aversi, one MS, Hirtzel, ab mrsi, Ribbeck; Aen. ix. 456 spumantis] spumanti y b, Ribbeck, Hirtzel; Aen. x. 805 arte] arce, two deteriores, Ribbeck, Hirtzel. In the following passages the reading of Ribbeck and Hirtzel might have been included in the critica,! note: G. IV, 412 tarn tu for tardo; Aen. ii. 503 ampla for tanta; Aen. ii. 587 flammae for famae; Aen. v. 573 Trinacrii or Trinacriis for Trinacriae; Aen. viii. 108 tacitis for tacitos; Aen. ix. 539 aUns for armis; Aen. x. 673 quosne for quosque; Aen. x. 705 Paris for creat. The apparatus should be corrected in the following places: Aen. i. 193, where F as well as MR has humo; Aen. ix. 143, where lanell gives parvo as the reading of FM, but according to Ribbeck the last letter in F is on an erasure; Aen. ix. 287, where there is no critical note; the reader would infer that periculi est is the attested reading, but est is omitted in PR and is by the second hand in Mb; Aen. xii. 221, where PR as well as M have pubentes, which lanell accepts; Ribbeck and Hirtzel prefers tabentes; there is also a discrepancy between Ribbeck and lanell as to the reading of M^ at Aen. ii. 778; Ribbeck has portare, lanell asportare. The proofreading has been carefully done, but the following errors have escaped notice: page vi read All 487 for A 11 787; page 387 read 15 for 25 in the citation from Isidore; page 427 read VII for XII under Umbro. Charles H. Beeson Das Erbe der Alien. Neue Folge. Heft II: AUgriechischer Baum- kultus. Untersuchungen von Ludwig Weniger. Dieterich'sche Verlagsbuchhandlung in Leipzig, 1920. Pp. vi+64. M. 3.50. In this very gracefully written brochure the author, well known for numerous substantial monographs on religious history, discusses the signifi- cance of the symbolism back of the employment among the Greeks for a variety of usages of leaves and branches, mainly in the form of garlands, from special trees or varieties of trees. He finds the principal causa efficiens in an association of certain forms of plant life with the worship of the earth- mother, and here especially in a mantic relation. The interest is largely cultural and psychological, although, of course, the religious history of some of the great shrines and many related questions are taken up. The leading idea is thus expressed: "With the worthless leaves which the ancients wove 164 Book Reviews into garlands and honored as prizes for noteworthy achievement more highly than they did gold and precious stones, were connected the noblest concep- tions. For they became symbols of reverence to the gods, of poetry, of manly strength, and of peace upon earth" (p. vi). The four chapters following the Introduction treat of the mantic oak of Dodona; the laurel of Delphi, which, originating as a symbol of purifica- tion for the slaying by Apollo of the earthborn Pytho, was gradually trans- formed, as Apollo himself came more and more to represent music and poetry, into the meed of honor for pre-eminence in these arts; the wild olive of Olympia; and finally the cultivated olive of Athens. With the author's general thesis, namely, that at Dodona, Delphi, and Olympia, the worship of the great Olympians dispossessed the more ancient cults of the earth-mother and other female deities, the trend of rehgious-historical studies in recent years seems to be in accord. In fact one might well venture to go farther along this hne than does even Dr. Weniger himself, and see in the connection between Athena and the olive at Athens an adventitious union, the result of the introduction, by conquest or otherwise, of a great deity which supplanted the older gods of the Attic plain. There is, indeed, a glar- ing incongruence between the terrible warrior maiden, that daughter of a mighty sire, whose huge spear lays waste not merely the ranks of heroes, but giants and on occasion very gods themselves, and the olive branch, the emblem of peace; and even the very latest legend could not forget that Athena won her pre-eminence on the Acropolis as the result of a struggle. The incongruence is only partially relieved by what is probably to be regarded as a secondary development, i.e., her patronage of arts and crafts, which seems to be due to late local developments at Athens, and in which she invades what is properly the sphere of Hephaistos, as, indeed, he is always closely associated with her in this capacity. "riiat the author does not emphasize those features of the local cults which might suggest that Athena has appropriated a sacred symbol of her predeces- sors seems perhaps due to his belief (following therein the famous work of V. Hehn, Kulturpflanzen, etc., 8th ed., pp. 104 ff., which, by the way, is quoted in the second edition; had the eighth [1911] been used, Schraders' well-considered rejection of Hehn's view might have been noted [pp. 120 f .]) that the olive was introduced into Greece at a comparatively late time (pp. 40 f.), when the worship of the earth-mother was nearly forgotten (pp. 47 f.). But this is, I venture to suggest, probably an error, for the olive was known and widely used in the Aegean world during the height of Minoan civilization. This is an important point in the history of culture, and because it has not been everywhere recognized as yet, the evidence for it, or such at least as has come to my attention, ought to be very succinctly indicated here. Olive stones have been found sporadically at Mycenae and in considerable numbers at Tiryns (Tsountas, 'E<^. 'Apx-, 1891, 15), at Palaiokastro in Crete (Bosanquet, Ann. Brit. Sch., IX, 280, 288), at Book Reviews 165 Phaestus (Evans, Ann. Brit. Sch., VII, 83, probably referring to those discov- ered in the cemetery near by; see Savignoni, Mmi. Ant., XIV, 635), at Peschiera (Lago di Garda) from the bronze age (Mosso, L'Origini della Civiltd, Medit.^, p. 278), at Men tone in the Riviera among palaeoUthic remains (Schultz, Zeitschr.f. Ethnol., XV, 401 ff.; some doubt attaches to this case, see Wittmack's suggestions, ibid., pp. 403 f., but Schultz insists that the stones were discovered together with palaeolithic objects). A native Sicilian vase from a settlement near Syracuse, found with Mycenaean vases, has a design produced by pressing an olive leaf into the wet clay (Orsi, Mon. Ant., II, 21 and PI. II, 1). The olive tree is represented on works of art like the Vaphio cups (for the older Uterature see Orsi, op. cit., p. 21, n. 1; Tsountas-Manatt, Myc. Age, p. 228; Schrader in the eighth edi- tion of Hehn's Ktdturpflanzen, etc., p. 120), the siege scene on the silver cup from Mycenae (Schrader, loc. cit., Tsountas-Manatt, loc. cit., think of wild olives, but the position close by the city wall suggests, as Schrader observes ยป a plantation) ; the Haghia Triadha sarcophagus (Paribeni, Mon. Ant, XIX, 42; F. von Duhn, Arch. f. Religionswiss., XII, 164; Dussaud, Les Civilisa- tions Prehelleniqiies^, p. 404), on pictographic tablets, frescoes, and vases at Knossos (Evans, Ann. Brit. Sch., VII, 83; IX, 5; the representations in VII, 26, and VII, 110, may possibly be of the myrtle), on a vase from Pseira (Plate VII; compare Hall, Aegean Arch., p. 98). What is probably an oil press was discovered at Thera along with Minoan ware (Dumont and Chaplain, Les Ceram. de la Grece propre, 1, 31; Tsountas-Manatt, op. cit., p. 79; Dus- saud, op. cit., p. 93), and what is certainly an olive press at Palaiokastro (Dawkins and Tod, Ann. Brit. Sch., IX, 334; Dawkins, XI, 276 f.), and from this same place Bosanquet describes also "a group of jars which prob- ably played a part in the manufacture of oil" (op. cit., IX, 288), and an "oil separator" {ibid., p. 279). At Knossos Evans has found the places in the palace where oil was prepared and handled, and these he calls the Court of the Oil Press and the Court of the Oil Spout (Ann. Brit. Sch., VII, 82 f.; VIII, 8ff.). Many of the great pithoi seem to have been stored with oil at the time of the destruction of the palace by fire, as the marks of a fierce conflagration are evident about the vats in the fourth magazine (Evans, op. cit., VII, 83), in which connection it may be recalled that the preserva- tion of many of the clay tablets is due to their having been subjected to this intense heat (Burrows: The Discov. in Crete, 18, after Evans, op. cit., VI, 19 and 56; VII, 83 and 101). Lamps of a type which bum oil (that is, of course, olive oil) are comparatively numerous. They are listed and dis- cussed especially by Burrows and Ure, J.H.S., 1911, pp. 92 ff.. Pfuhl, Arch. Jahrb., 1912, pp. 55 ff. Sir Arthur Evans, Scr. Min., p. 59, even seems inclined to believe that the oil trade was the principal basis of the commerce upon which the prosperity of Crete depended (followed in this by Baikie, The Sea Kings of Crete, pp. 184, 222, 227), but that is perhaps pressing the evidence unduly. 166 Book Reviews Now as regards the relation of Athena to the olive, that is pretty generally regarded as original, but, although I cannot here enter upon a general argu- ment, I am strongly inclined to believe (with WUamowitz, Aristoteles und Athen, II, 37 f., Jane Harrison, Themis, pp. 170 ff., and Escher, Pauly-Wiss., VI, 409, for the original independence of the group of old Athenian nature deities and their later subordination to Athena, see Usener, Gotternamen, pp. 135 ff.) that Athena was an interloper on the Acropolis, and that, there- fore, the sacred olive was not from the first in her care. It might be observed especially in this regard that the tree itself was in the sacred inclosure of Erechtheus (Herodotus vii. 55), where Athena could hardly have had prior rights, or else in the precinct of the closely related Pandrosos (Frazer on Pausanias i. 27. 2; Judeich, Topogr. von Athen, p. 252). Besides Ge had a statue only a few yards away, and a rock-cut inscription still testifies to her presence in the immediate vicinity. With Earth, the earth-born (Erech- theus), the spirit of the dew (Pandrosos, compare Jane Harrison, op. cit., p. 172), and Zeus Morios (probably the sender of rain for the Moriai) it would seem that the olive was more naturally to be associated than with the Hellenic Walkyrie, who otherwise certainly had little enough to do with agriculture. All this, however, is in the main incidental, and does not diminish the value of the delicate and sagacious deUneation of the rites and the feelings of the early Greeks which they reflect. The whole is a valuable study in religious psychology and especially in a singularly beautiful type of symbol- ism which has proved alluring to all subsequent representatives of our com- mon European civilization. W. A. Oldfathee Die altgriechische Buhne. By August Feickenhaus. Strassburg: Karl J. Triibner, 1917. Pp. viii -1-131. 30 illustrations. Apart from whatever value this book may possess for the specialist, the circumstances attending its pubhcation make it a document of interest to a wider circle as affording a ghmpse behind the scenes in Germany during the progress of the Great War. The proof was read by the author while engaged in the campaign about Mainz during the summer of 1917. Previous to that time, since the beginning of the war, he had had a furlough of but a single academic semester, during which he had hastily put the finishing touches on his manuscript. The book was then hurried through the press, not only because of the uncertainty attending the author's life, but also that he might anticipate the pubhcation of a work on the Athenian theater undertaken and announced by the Austrian Archaeological Institute ! Finally, although dedi- cated with evident exultation "zur Erinnerung an den dritten Kriegs- winter," as events proved it was to be one of the last, if indeed not the last,