STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 161 stroke that was mistaken for i) seems unlikely; such an abbreviation for quam would be an anomaly; q with an abbreviating stroke through the tail was probably the cause of the error. In the majority of cases where our editor is in doubt whether a correction in the Thuaneus is to be attributed to T 2 , or to T 1 or T 3 , I agree with Dianu in attributing it to T 2 ; in some cases the reference mark makes the attribution almost certain. The com- pendium in IX, 44, 2, if correctly printed, stands for est, not et. There is no index and the reader will still find use for his Teubner text. Charles H. Bbeson P. Vergili Maronis opera post Ribbeckium tertium recognovit Gual- therus Ianell. Editio Maior. lipsiae in aedibus B. G. Teubneri, MCMXX. Pp. xxviii+428. Ribbeck's great critical edition of Virgil has undergone a gradual process of contraction. His first edition required three good-sized volumes for the text, the second (1894, 1895) was reduced by more than a third, and the present volume contains only about half as many pages as the second edition; the format has been reduced to that of the ordinary Teubner text. The Appendix Vergiliana has been omitted, the testimonia have disappeared, and the apparatus has shrunk, in some places almost to the vanishing point of usefulness. In the first ten pages of the Preface the editor states the principles he has followed in constituting the text and apparatus. His announced purpose is to free the text from Ribbeck's often reckless changes and restore the tradition. He has made no new examination of the M3S previously used; the readings of M, which he regards as the "best" MS, are taken from Hoffman's collation; those of F, which he classes as second in value, are derived from the Vatican reproduction. He cites occasionally readings from a Codex Rehdigeranus, a MS of the twelfth century, which he collated at Norden's suggestion. He has examined the external evidence also, including the centones, which Ribbeck disregarded. In matters of orthography the editor has not attempted to reproduce the variations of spelling of the MSS; hence -om after u and » everywhere; following Gellius he spells ahenus everywhere. A few innovations occur, e.g., Aepytus for Epylus, Elymus for Helymus, Heruium for Ertdum, Hortinae for Ortinae, Mevius for Maerius, Mezzentius for Mezentius and Pthia for Phthia; the spelling with g instead of c has been adopted in such forms as Agmon, Agragas, Cygnus, Gnosus, Ognus, Progne, Pyragmon. In punctua- tion the Codex Mediceus has been followed as far as practicable. The Preface also contains the text of the Vita Donatiana, based on eight MSS, the Serviana, based on eight MSS, and the Vita Probi, based on four MSS. Three pages are devoted to the testimonia. 162 Book Reviews In printing the text the editor has indicated at the top of the page the capital-letter MSS involved; there are a number of discrepancies with Ribbeck's statements, but in each case only one or two lines are in question; e.g., G does not contain Aen. iii. 208, 209, 227 (except traces of one word), 228, 531, 532; similarly, Aen. xi. 691, 692 are not found in P; on p. 250 the MSS for Aen. vii. 482-485 are MRV not MPV. The critical apparatus contains only those variants which in the opinion of the editor are "graviore momento vel memorabiles"; the deteriores are cited only when they agree with one or more of the best MSS. It is of more importance to have the evidence of the deteriores where they support a reading admitted to the text against the consensus of the majuscule MSS; the same principle holds for the external evidence. This material could have been included without greatly increasing the bulk of the apparatus, since the conservatism of the editor has reduced considerably the number of such cases; e.g., E. Ill, 38, no evidence is given for facili, the accepted reading; Servius is quoted for facilis, " Donatus sic legit," but the rest of the citation which, with the MSS y ir, is the only support iorfacili, is omitted, "legitur tamen et 'torno facili'"; E. IV, 26 and 33, the readings of R, the only majuscule MS for this part of the poem, are given, but not the evidence for the readings admitted into the text; there is no critical note on flavescet, v. 26, and one might infer that flavescet is the form vouched for by the MSS; in point of fact R y 1 b 1 have flavescit; E. IV, 62 is one of the few cases where the editor admits an emendation, that of Birt; the version of Quintilian, qui non risere parenti, approved by Crusius and adopted by Hirzel, might well have been included in the apparatus; G. I, 383, the evidence for et quae, •ybc and Servius, is not given; G.I, 461, the text has vehat; the readings of M 1 R (ferat) and M 2 (verat) are given, but the deterimes, which have vehat or veat, are not mentioned; G. IV, 148 has no critical note and one might infer that MP have me, whereas these MSS as well as y a omit it; the only evidence for me is found in x b; v. 241 has suffire; the apparatus reads suffere, M(P)R omitting the evidence for suffire (y be and Priscian); Aen. II. 398 has no critical note; the text has demittimus but the MSS (except the second hand in some of the deteriores) have dimitlimus; the editor has done better at v. 734 where he gives the evidence for dispiciunt and despiciunt, Aen.vi. 20, be -ir should be mentioned as well as r; Aen. vi. 617 has no critical note though practically all the MSS have destricti, not districti; Aen. vii. 740 has Abellae, with no critical note; the MSS have bellae, except a Vienna MS quoted by Ribbeck in his Prolegomena, page 353; the reading Abellae was known to Servius, who, however, prefers bellae; Aen. ix. 455, the evidence for tepida, the accepted reading, is omitted; similarly the manuscript evidence (y be) for levabat in Aen. x. 834. The apparatus would have been more useful if the editor had included the evidence on the more important passages where he has reverted to the MSS, rejecting readings long established in our text; e.g., there are no Book Reviews 163 critical notes on the following passages : E. Ill, 101 exitium est pecori] exitium pecori c x< Ribbeck and Hirtzel; G. I, 418, vias] vices Ribbeck and Hirtzel with two deteriores; Aen. ii. 584 habet haec] most editors read nee habet; Aen. iv. 217 subnixus] subnexus, Ribbeck and Hirtzel with two deteriores; Aen. v. 522 subito] subitum, Ribbeck and Hirtzel with several deteriores; Aen. vi. 96 quam] qua, one MS, Seneca, Bentley, Ribbeck and Hirtzel; Aen. vi. 609 et] aut c, Nonius, Servius, Ribbeck, Hirtzel; Aen. ix. 412 adversi] aversi, one MS, Hirtzel, ab versi, Ribbeck; Aen. ix. 456 spumantis] spumanti y b, Ribbeck, Hirtzel; Aen. x. 805 arte] arce, two deteriores, Ribbeck, Hirtzel. In the following passages the reading of Ribbeck and Hirtzel might have been included in the critical note: G. IV, 412 tarn tu for tanto; Aen. ii. 503 ampla for tanta; Aen. ii. 587 flammae for famae; Aen. v. 573 Trinacrii or Trinacriis for Trinacriae; Aen. viii. 108 tacitis for tacitos; Aen. ix. 539 albis for armis; Aen. x. 673 quosne for quosque; Aen. x. 705 Paris for creat. The apparatus should be corrected in the following places: Aen. i. 193, where F as well as MR has humo; Aen. ix. 143, where Ianell gives parvo as the reading of FM, but according to Ribbeck the last letter in F is on an erasure; Aen. ix. 287, where there is no critical note; the reader would infer that periculi est is the attested reading, but est is omitted in PR and is by the second hand in Mb; Aen. xii. 221, where PR as well as M have pubentes, which Ianell accepts; Ribbeck and Hirtzel prefers tabentes; there is also a discrepancy between Ribbeck and Ianell as to the reading of M 2 at Aen. ii. 778; Ribbeck has portare, Ianell asportare. The proofreading has been carefully done, but the following errors have escaped notice: page vi read All 487 for A 11 787; page 387 read 15 for 25 in the citation from Isidore; page 427 read VII for XII under Umbro. Charles H. Beeson Das Erbe der Alten. Neue Folge. Heft II: Altgriechischer Baum- kultus. Untersuchungen von Ludwig Weniger. Dieterich'sche Verlagsbuchhandlung in Leipzig, 1920. Pp. vi+64. M. 3.50. In this very gracefully written brochure the author, well known for numerous substantial monographs on religious history, discusses the signifi- cance of the symbolism back of the employment among the Greeks for a variety of usages of leaves and branches, mainly in the form of garlands, from special trees or varieties of trees. He finds the principal causa efficiens in an association of certain forms of plant life with the worship of the earth- mother, and here especially in a mantic relation. The interest is largely cultural and psychological, although, of course, the religious history of some of the great shrines and many related questions are taken up. The leading idea is thus expressed: "With the worthless leaves which the ancients wove