STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 316 Book Reviews Alexander, is of other than Roman origin. Many cognomina thus arbitrarily- excluded are also worthy of special discussion; but the work is voluminous as it stands, and some limit must be placed even to a modern thesis for the Doctor's degree. Chapter ii deals with the classification of cognomina, their grammatical composition, and their origin. Chapter iii adds some supple- mentary paragraphs, the most curious of which are those on double cog- nomina and uncomplimentary cognomina. Although the author tries to assign reasons for the popularity of the various cognomina in different regions and periods, it is a little disappointing that the results are not more precise. In only one particular would the reviewer take issue with the investigator's statements. Repeatedly a distinction is made between the cognomina chosen by common soldiers and those adopted by centurions; see under Datus, Donatus, Fortunatus, Honoratus, etc. In every case, it is true, the wording is somewhat vague, but the author seems to imply that the choice is not a matter of chance so far as the soldier's rank in the legion is concerned. On the contrary, whether the soldier had his Roman name from birth or adopted it on his enlistment, at neither time could he have been sure of future promotion. We must deny the gift of prophecy even to a youth who has attained the rank of a raw recruit. A short bibliography is followed by an alphabetical list of all soldiers and underofficers of the legions arranged according to cognomina. In addition to the name, there are given rank and legion, the date when possible, the place where the stone is found, and the place where the inscription or papyrus is published. The list takes up the major part of the work and is a most useful supplement to the dissertation. Chakles Hoeing University of Rochester Stoicheia, Heft II: Studien zum antiken Sternglauben. Von Ekwin Pfeiffee. Leipzig und Berlin: Teubner, 1916. Pp. 130. In this brief book of studies the author has given a comprehensive treatment of Greek and Roman astrometeorology, from its unscientific foreshadowing in classical Greek literature, down through the skeptical materialism of the Ionic philosophers, to its wider acceptance through the good company of the Stoic theories of epu iroXAov irvperbv SaAotcri ftpoTouriv. Book Reviews 317 The rising and setting of the constellations for Hesiod, in general, only denote the seasons. Pfeiffer, however, thinks that Works and Days, 587 and 417, indicate that Hesiod may have thought Sirius, along with the sun, a cause of heat. One reads with surprise that the author considers Hes. Theog. 378, 'Acrpcunji 8' Hols avipjovs tckc KaprepoOvfwvs, sufficient proof that Hesiod and his contemporaries believed in the influence of the stars upon the air. There is no literary evidence for the statement (p. 6) that before the birth of Ionic philosophy and the introduction of Chaldaean astrology the Greeks gave the moon precedence in honor over the sun. Aesch. Prom. 656 ff. indicates only that the Greeks did not yet know how to determine the seasons by the sun. In Aesch. Sept. 389 irpeo-purrov aarpiov (of the moon) is poetic ornament. The sun also is irpio-fiuTTov o-cAas in Soph. Frag. 523 and in Pindar Paean ix. 2, wrrpov vtriprarov. Other instances of honor paid to the sun may be found in Homer Od. xi. 323, Savos 0eos; Od. xii. 176, dva£; in Pindar dyvos 0eos (0. vii. 60) ; in Sophocles 0. B. 660, rbv vdvrmv 6ea>v debv irpopjov; Frag. 480, "XXu 8(vaiKrjv Otwpiav, rr/v irdrpiov imo-Trfprfv. Chiron, he says, had taught : opicous kv iir' dvToXats. The text is evidently cor- rupt. Clemens Alex. Strom. L. gives the variant xprfo-pounv rj 8' do-T«pa>j/ e7ravaToXas for the Cyrillus reading. Further evidence of the meteorological power of the stars is found in the names of the fixed stars, e.g., Hyades, and a star cult in Ceos. This, too, is doubtful ground. Association of weather changes with the rising and setting of the constellations would account for the names— an interpretation supported by Hellanicus fr. 56. An isolated star cult does not prove a widespread belief. Two influences, the author states, were at work to undermine the popular superstitions about the stars: the growth of Olympic religion and Ionian 318 Book Reviews philosophy. There is no literary evidence for the first. Even in Homer the Olympic gods are believed to control the changes in weather. It is true that the mechanistic cosmologies of Anaximander, Anaximenes, Anaxa- goras, and Democritus, if logically developed, made a belief in the potency of the stars as agents or as signs impossible. The doxographical literature, however, gives us no information (with the exception of Anaxagoras and Anaximenes) about their views on the relation of the stars to the weather. They may never have discussed the question. Any inferences drawn from their cosmologies are conjectural. Anaximenes, we read, did not believe that the stars' heat reached the earth (Hippol, Ref. i. 7) and ascribed all meteorological phenomena to the sun. Anaxagoras states not only (Aet. ii. 13. 3) that the sun, moon, and stars are stones and therefore not gods (Achill. Isag. in Arat. i. 13) nor even living beings, as their movements are not caused by an indwelling soul but mechanically (Plut. Lys. 12) but also that their heat is not perceptible on the earth on account of the distance (Hippol. Ref. i. 8, § 7). The question of the divinity of the stars discussed by Pfeiffer (pp. 22-24) in the case of all excepting Anaxagoras is contro- versial, and does not affect the astrometeorological problem directly, as the philosophers might still have given mechanistic explanations for weather phenomena. Pfeiffer thinks that the physicians of the pre-Socratie period retained the popular belief in the action of the stars upon weather and men and quotes in proof Hippocrates vi. 470 L. Hippocrates is here insisting that writers irept Suurrp must know ras v ttovuxv in relation to foods, nature and age of the individual, seasons of the year, and changes in winds and locations of places and ttjv Karao-Too-iv tov iviavrov. To guard against excesses in food and drink and climate and general conditions of the universe one must know the rising and setting of the constellation with which these changes are associated. There is no suggestion either in this or in the other passages cited, ii. 14 L, ii. 670 L, ii. 42 L, that the stars are active powers. No certain conclusion can be reached in regard to the views of pseudo- Hippocrates, the author of irept l^8o/«£So)v, who, Pfeiffer believes, derived his cosmology from the Pythagoreans and ascribed meteorological power to the stars. The meaning of to aAAa and t&v ael ovrwy in irepl e/3Sop«8v o\mv SioiKrjariv, ij/iepav xal fviavrov iroioSvTa icai Tas aXAas wpas, but it does not necessarily follow that the other cosmic forces were the stars or that their function was meteorological. The quotation from Chrysippus is equally indefinite. Diogenes of Seleucia (v. Arnim, Stoic, frag. iii. 25 and 27) and Boethius rejected astrology and Panaetius both astrology and astro- meteorology (Cic. De div. ii. 42. 87.) Boethius strove to find some causal relation between the coincidence of weather changes with the rising and setting of the constellations. Geminus, clo-aymyr) as to. ^xuvo/ieva and Cic. De div. ii. 42. 91-94 give a compendium of all the arguments against astral influences. Both alike, Pfeiffer thinks, use Panaetius as their source. In proof of Posidonius' acceptance of astrometeorology the author can give only the negative evidences of Cic. De div. ii. 88, and the statement of August. De civ. dei v. 2, with Cicero as authority, that Posidonius believed in genethliology. Cic. De fato 3 shows a belief in divination in general, while in Cic. De not. dear, ii, §§ 154-55 (on teleology) and Seneca Nat. quaest. ii. 32 Posidonius is not mentioned. The author finds suggestions of Posidonian astrology in Vergil, in such epithets of the stars as nimbosus, pluviae, conscia fati. It is always difficult to determine how far these poetic epithets belong to the traditional language of poetry or are dramatic concessions to the superstitions of the age or clear indications of the poet's own views. Vergil, at any rate, knew the scientific explanation of the universe. 320 Book Reviews Plotinus believed that the stars acted in a natural manner upon the earth, causing heat and cold, but that they did not have the supernatural power to determine the fate of man. The Christians were willing to accept astrology as long as it did not question the omnipotence of God and the unity of the universe. In general, however, they accepted only the prophetic power of the stars as servants of God, although other views did prevail despite the doctrine of human responsi- bility. I can give only a brief summary of the five appendixes in which the author has discussed several related questions. Appendix I contains a refutal of Burnet's contention that Anaximander believed in the coexistence of in- numerable worlds. In Appendix II the author discusses the meanings of iirurr]imiva and imnnfiuurla and other formulae used to introduce weather prognoses in the Greek calendars. In Appendix III he points out that the tales of weather prophecies by Democritus belong to the general group of wonder legends that tended to gather around the names of philosophers. In Hellenistic-Roman times the philosopher becomes along with the emperor a worker of nature-miracles, a (Tu/r-qp, and paves the way for the magician, who is followed as wonder- worker by the Christian saint. In Appendix IV Pf eiffer calls attention to the similarity of Horn. Hymn to Ares viii to the prayers to planets and suggests that it may have come from an astrological source. The meter points to the early Alexandrian period as date. In Appendix V he endeavors to prove that the belief that human souls come from and return to the stars is not native to Greece but came from the East, through the mystery-cults and Orphic and philosophical speculation. It owed its wider circulation later to astrology. I have noted a few inaccurate or omitted references: p. 8, Hesiod Erg. v. 283 for v. 383; p. 25, Eustathius p. 62 for /x 64; p. 65, Cic. Acad. iv. 38 for Cic. Acad. ii. 38. The quotation from Cleanthes, p. 54, is found in Euseb. Praep. evang. xv. 15. 7, and that from Chrysippus in Stobaeus Eel. i. p. 182. Geneva Misenek The University op Alberta Griechische Geschichte. Von Karl Julius Beloch. Zweite neu- gestaltete Auflage. Erster Band, Erste Abteilung (I, 1), 1912; Erster Band, Zweite Abteilung (I, 2), 1913; Zweiter Band, Erste Abteilung (II, 1), 1914. Strassburg: Karl J. Triibner. Pp. xii+446 (I, 1), x+409 (I, 2), viii+432 (II, 1). Each "Abteilung" of the volumes of this new edition of Beloch's Griech- ische Geschichte comprises a volume in the ordinary sense of the word. The extent to which additions and rewriting have been carried can be inferred