STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Horace and His Age. A Study in Historical Background. By J. F. D'Alton, M.A., D.D. London: Longmans, Green & Co., 1917. $2.00 net. As the title indicates, this book is an essay in the higher criticism of Horace based on the sound creed that a poet is of his own age. Beginning with Horace's political views, Professor D'Alton supports the thesis that the poet suffered a genuine reconstruction after Philippi and became, if not the inspired spokesman, at least the willing disseminator, of the Augustan propa- ganda. He along with his contemporaries accepted the nationalistic interpre- tation of Actium, was moved by real fears in the reaction against the east (Ode iii. 3), and joined in the militarist clamor for Parthian campaigns and invasions of Britain under the inspiration of the pacific Augustus, not, as Ferrero holds, of the extreme imperialists. Hence he welcomes with equal enthusiasm the greater bloodless triumphs of the emperor and the establish- ment of the Pax Augusta. The fourth book of the Odes Professor D'Alton would read as a panegyric on the Pax Augusta rather than as a celebration of the triumphs of Tiberius and Drusus. The spirit of the Carmen Saeculare still informs this later book. Horace, the author believes, was likewise completely won over to the program of religious and moral reforms by which Augustus reinforced his policy of political reconstruction. The emperor hoped to invest the Pax Augusta with the splendors of a Pax Deorum by restoring the old national religion which had been undermined by Hellenism, the cosmopolitan Stoic philosophy as well as the skeptical Epicurean, oriental astrology and cults, and finally by the disillusionment of the civil wars. The various forms taken by the religious revival are traced by Professor D'Alton in Horace's solicitude for the rebuilding of ruined temples, his aversion to Egyptian forms of worship, the celebration of old rites, such as the Ludi Saeculares, and the prominence given to the Palatine gods, even though in Horace they are but the "shadowy creations of a litterateur." The emperor thus sought to centralize religious traditions around the Julian house and reconcile the Romans to the alien idea of imperial apotheosis. His own worship Augustus wisely restricted to his genius and associated with the cults of Roma and the Lares. Many influences, in Professor D'Alton's opinion, had a part in preparing Horace and his contemporaries for the acceptance of a cult of the emperors, Greek hero-worship, the 315 316 Book Reviews teaching of Euhemerus, the Stoic doctrine of the world-soul, and the katasterism of the astrologers. Gratitude to the emperor for the new era of peace and reform which as a true energetes he had brought to war- distraught Rome made it possible for Horace to re-echo the sentiments of his countrymen and claim for Augustus, as the Greek poets had for their heroes of old, a literary or, it may be, a real apotheosis through his immortal verse. Fate and fortune, however, impersonal deities, obsessions of the chaotic years of the civil wars, and, in reality, inimical to the revival, and the old rustic divinities of the Sabine countryside that still lived on unaffected by the decline and rise of state religions had from Horace a more genuine reverence than the Olympic deities of the Julian tradition. The social problems of this period, which Professor D'Alton sees reflected in the poetry of Horace, are the growth of latifundia, where the poet is plainly on the side of Ofellus, the small farmer, the increase of commercial activity and wealth with their attendant evils, avarice and extravagance in villas, plate, and the table. In the last, the writer remarks, it was Horace's good taste which was offended by the refinements of gastronomy and the vulgarities of the parvenu as much as his moral sense. In the chapter on "Popular Beliefs," Professor D'Alton has compiled from the researches on magic and religion much interesting lore on the sur- vivals of magic in Roman religion, the methods and workers of magic, necromancy, sympathetic magic, carmina and venena, illustrated by the picture of Canidia and her sister-witches, and a few other rare references in Horace. The author cites evidence from the works of Horace for the wide dissemination of another form of unscientific belief, astrology, which Syrian cults and Stoic philosophy had helped to make popular among the uneducated and educated alike at Rome. It was accepted even by Horace's imperial circle though its fatalism was not in harmony with the religious revival. In the eschatology of Horace Professor D'Alton misses the splendid vision of Virgil. Horace's picture of life after death, apart from the imperial kataster- ism, is a medley of the Homeric domusexilis, offabulae manes, and the Tartarus of popular legend whose terrors the Epicurean philosophy had tried to dispel. In literary criticism Professor D'Alton calls attention to the advance of Horace from the bitter polemical spirit of the satires to the sureness of the critic with authority in the epistles. He rejects Norden's Isagogic classi- fication of the Ars Poetica. The disproportionate treatment of drama, the stress on technique, the polemic against purists and archaism, and the stereotyped formulas of literary critics indicate that the epistle to the Pisos was not intended to be a complete art of poetry but to meet particularly the needs of contemporary poets and the literary ambitions of the Pisos. In the controversy over the source of the accounts of the origin of drama in Livy and Horace Professor D'Alton takes issue with Mr. Hendrickson's theory of a common origin from Aristotle's history of comedy and argues that the two accounts are neither parallel nor from the same source. Book Reviews 317 The book is well written in a clear and easy style and despite the mass of details holds the interest of the reader. As a compendium of information on the political, social, and religious movements reflected in the works of Horace, annotated by exact references to that poet and his contemporaries and the modern literature on these subjects, the student of Horace will find it invaluable. From this point of view the author is justified in his anticipa- tory defense of the treatment gemino ah ovo of the Parthians and Ager Publicus, to which the reader may be tempted to add the Spaniards, magic, and astrology. In general, Professor D'Alton's sound judgment has saved him from the common pitfall of higher criticism, the preconceived theory about which he warns the reader in his Preface. The reviewer, however, suspects that a tendency to overstress the dominance of Augustus and the religious revival in Horace's thought has led this conservative scholar to read an uncourtier-like reference to Antony's slanders against the maternal ancestry of Augustus into a general remark of Horace (Satires 1. 6. 34) and to insist on the sincerity of Horace's recantation of Epicurean skepticism in Ode 1. 34. Pro- fessor D'Alton in the historical study of astrology follows Cumont and other modern scholars in ascribing anticipations of astrology to the Pythagorean Plato and Aristotle and in the hypothesis of a fusion of Stoicism and astrology. In a review of Pfeiffer's Studien zum antiken Sternglavben (Classical Philology [July, 1917] pp. 316 ff.) the present reviewer endeavored to show that the evidence for the acceptance of astrology by the Stoics is neither convincing nor positive and that the cosmic theories of Plato and Aristotle precluded a belief in astrology. The reference cited by the author (Cic. de nat. deorum ii. 15. 39) proves only that the Stoics believed that the stars shared in the divinity of the universe. It may seem hypercritical to call attention to two instances of lapsus linguae in a book otherwise so free from errors in style — the use of "enthuse" (p. 120) and the meaning of "apprize" (p. 129). Geneva Misener University op Alberta Procopius' Works. With an English translation by H. B. Dewing. In six volumes. Vols. I and II (Loeb Classical Library). New York: Putnam, 1914, 1916. Pp. xv+583, 488. Not the least of the pleasant surprises offered by the editors of the Loeb Library is their plentiful inclusion of the works of the later and less-known Greek authors. Procopius deserves attention because he is the historian of an important period, and because he has on the whole told his story reliably and interestingly. He has consciously tried to model his style on Herodotus and Thucydides. His very failure is exceedingly instructive to the student