STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 212 Book Reviews some of the provincial coin-issues which are valuable in illustrating the architecture and religion of the province. Information afforded by epigraphy is used. A bibliography is given at the close of the volume as well as refer- ences to many works in the footnotes. Each volume contains an outline map and an index which add to their value. A few typographical errors were noticed, but they need not be mentioned. While neither volume aims to be exhaustive, yet the two will prove of great value to students in history and in the classics of the middle and later empire when a general but brief account of either province is desired. The books are quite readable and should find a place along with other works on Roman history. D. T. Schoonover Mabietta Coli^egb Das Griechentum in seiner geschichtlichen Entwicklung. By Rudolf vonScala. Teubner, 1915. Pp.105. M. 1.25. Dos Altertum in Leben der Gegenwart. By Paul Cauer. Teubner, 1915. Pp. 131. M. 1.25. Die Homerische Dichtung. By Georg Finsler. Teubner, 1915. Pp. 113. M. 1.25. These primers of the Teubner series "Aus Natur und Geisteswelt" are, notwithstanding their inexpensiveness, firmly bound in neat linen covers and printed on good paper in a clear type which is a pleasure as well as a com- fort to the eye; and, save for occasional roughnesses of style which appear when the overabundance of material rebels against undue compression, they are very lucid and readable. Professor von Scala's book, after an introductory sketch of the Kultur of the Indo-Germanic stem, attacks at once the difficult subject of the pre-historic peoples of Greece. We may perhaps complain that in his discussion of the Minoans, Mycenaeans, Achaeans, etc., and their relations to each other he states somewhat dogmatically now and then what is at best probable conjec- ture; but many readers, for whom the multitudinous results of the excava- tions in Crete and elsewhere still whirl about in unrelated confusion, will be grateful to a competent scholar for revealing to them some order in this chaos. The treatment of the Homeric age is too scanty even for so brief a book, but in the later pages, which bring the story of Greece down to the fourth century a.d., the balance and emphasis are admirable. The book is not a mere outline of Greek history for beginners, but an account of Greek civiliza- tion in the making which it is worth the while of any Greek student to read. The text is illustrated by a considerable number of half-tones. Book Reviews 213 Professor Cauer's book is only incidentally what its title implies — a setting forth of "what we owe to Greece." It would more properly be called "Die Culturmission des classischen Altertums in unserer Zeit," which was the subject of a set of lectures out of which the book grew. But no single title is sufficiently elastic to stretch over its varied contents; it is partly a plea for the study of classical Greece in the pedagogy of German youth, but the place of ancient Rome in an ideal modern education is also emphasized at some length; it is, however, mainly a popular interpretation of the great achievements in literature, philosophy, politics, and art which Greek civiliza- tion offers as a stimulus and a corrective to the modern world. The book is everywhere marked by the clear thought, mature sanity, and wide knowledge which we should expect of the author, but it is directed to a general public and presents to the special student of the classics little more than a restate- ment of the obvious. Finsler's previously issued studies of Homer are, I believe, well and favorably known. This little volume is condensed from his larger work on Homer and is mainly a recast of the chapter on "Homerische Poesie." It does not, however, read in the least like a digest; the author brings fresh enthusiasm to the briefer labor of love which at times glows with a restrained eloquence of style. Whether he has, as he hopes, improved upon his earlier efforts will depend on the reader's point of view; those who prefer an objec- tive treatment of Homer such as Professor Seymour has given us will not welcome the more pronounced obtrusion here of the author's personal theories about the Homeric question. They are, however, rather conservative: the Iliad is the work of one poet, Melesigenes of Smyrna (Homer is a by-name), who completed and wrote down this epic about 700 B.C.; his attempt to fuse into a single whole materials from independent sagas and poems fails of unity in the Aristotelian sense; inconsistencies and "unevennesses" reveal the poet staggering under the weight of his material; of course he archaizes (a chapter shows his "Streben nach Altertumlichkeit"), not only consciously, but painstakingly, and, with inevitable minor lapses, succeeds marvelously in setting a living picture in an ancient frame. The Odyssey, too, represents a fusion of distinct stories, but into a more perfect unity, by a single author who is simply "Der Dichter," not Melesigenes-Homer. Both epics are, however, drawn upon indifferently for the later chapters on the Homeric view of life and on the style and composition of the poems. The material of these chapters is crowded under too few captions and is not always arranged in logical sequence; the last chapter, "Heiterkeit der homerischen Welt," makes an attractive conclusion but should not be separated from his chapter on Homeric life by the intervening treatment of composition and style. Geobge Noblin University of Colorado