STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 215 Value of the Classics. Princeton University Press, 1917. Value of the Classics contains "a record of the Addresses delivered at the Conference on Classical Studies in Liberal Education held at Princeton University, June 2, 1917, together with an introduction and a collection of statements and statistics." The addresses number eighteen, the longest being by Henry Cabot Lodge. The three hundred or so statements are by men grouped under Public Life; Business; Universities and Colleges; Schools; the Ministry; Law; Medicine; Engineering; Physical and Natural Sciences; Editors; Modern Literature; History, Political Science, Econom- ics, Philosophy, Sociology; Fine Arts; Oriental Studies. They include a number of British and French contributions. The statistics, by W. M. Adriance, C. H. Forbes, Harris Hancock, and various official bodies, are on Enrolment of Classical Students in Secondary Schools, Record of Classical Students in College Entrance Examinations, Record of Classical Students in School and College. The introduction, written by Andrew F. West, who, with the co-operation of F. F. Abbott, Edward Capps, D. R. Stuart, D. B. Durham, and T. A. Miller, edited the book, is entitled "The Present Outlook." The character of Value of the Classics and the use to which it will be put are at once apparent. Nothing on the place of the classics in education has ever before been published so weighted with authority as this thesaurus of addresses and testimonies from men representing the whole breadth and depth of intellectual and professional life. Professors of the classics alone are designedly allowed no voice in it; their arguments appear with infinitely greater effect coming from the lips of impartially minded practical men of long experience in leadership. Any teacher or friend of the classics who wishes to make a wholesome impression upon hostile or unsympathetic colleague, principal, president, trustee, school board, investigator, editor, taxpayer, or doubting student, or who is himself in need of the foundations of faith, will find the book a ready means. Refusal to be influenced by it would be refusal to listen to the most convincing of all witnesses, life itself. Somehow this achievement of Mr. West and his associates makes one think of Justinian and the Pandects. Teachers of the classics have been, not for a thousand years, but for a long time, contributing to the printed and oral aggregate of pedagogical law a great many pronouncements on the value of Greek and Latin. Never was anything so enthusiastically, so thoroughly, and so repeatedly proved — to its own believers, who have been the only persons privileged to see and hear the pronouncements. Now that we have all these proofs digested, so to speak, in convenient form, many will entertain the pious hope that henceforth we may be spared confronting the weekly, monthly, quarterly, annual, biennial, and occasional demonstrations of "The Value of Classical Study," which are all right in moderation, but which have begun to give an atmosphere of discouragement to our programs and periodicals; and that from now on the approved form of demonstration 216 Book Reviews will be a reference to Codex West, page so-and-so. Of course it is beyond the wildest dream to look for a like consummation in the field of the Latin gram- mar, the beginners' book, and the literature of "How to Make Latin Interest- ing"; but if we could arrive at a canon in each of these matters also it might almost be said that our pedagogical decks were cleared for action. „ T Grant Showerman University op Wisconsin Etudes Syriennes. Par Franz Cumont, Membre de l'lnstitut. Paris: Picard, 1917. Pp. xi+379. This most recent of M. Cumont's works is the result of its author's travels in Northern Syria in the spring of 1907, and of subsequent research. It contains chapters on "Le Marche de l'Empereur Julien," "L'Aigle Funeraire et 1'Apotheose," "Les Carrieres Romaines d'Enesh," "Le Temple de Zeus Dolichenus," "Trois Mausolees de Commagene," "Cyrrhus," and "Divinit6s Syriennes," with appendixes giving in admirably ordered detail the author's itinerary, and notes on the inscriptions and Greek manuscripts in Syria employed in his investigation. A hundred illustrations, the greater part from his own photographs, and ten original maps make the text extraordinarily attractive and clear. Illustrations, beautiful typography, and artistic make-up in general have made the volume as great a triumph of the bookmaker as it is of the scholar. M. Cumont's work would be of surpassing interest to classicists and archaeologists merely as presenting the observations of a scholarly and careful traveler, but it possesses a special value as relating to the art and religion of a region which exercised a considerable influence upon Roman civilization in the West. As was to be expected from one whose works on Mithraism and other eastern cults have made him our greatest authority on the oriental religions in their connection with Rome, the Etudes Syriennes are character- ized by broad outlook and comprehensive conclusions. For example, in the chapter on "Trois Mausolees" the Syrian examples are seen to be a link in the long chain beginning with the ordinary earth tumulus, continuing in the pyramid of Egypt, and reaching to Cecilia Metella at Rome and the pretentious tombs of Gaul and Germany, and probably still farther to the ciborium of the church, and even to Mahometan architecture. M. Cumont has been in exile since the outbreak of the war, pursuing his investigations at Paris and Rome. He is at present residing at 19 Corso d'ltalia, Rome. Grant Showerman Die Attische Tragodie als Bild- und Buhnenkunst. Von Eugen Petersen. Mit zwei Tafeln und einem Textbild. Bonn: Friedrich Cohen, 1915. Pp. 660. Greek tragedy is a priceless heritage, a "Pruf stein und Mass" for the testing of all subsequent dramatic art. This is strictly true, however, only