STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 374 Book Reviews ened, the writer points out, by a moment of retardation. The conventional form of the parting scenes — a stichomythy, ending in the Iphigeneia and Alcestis in a lyrical monody — is broken only by the long speech of Macaria. In the chapter on "Der Ausklang der Devotionsszenen " the author defends the original text of the hastily written Heracleidae against the hypothesis of a lacuna after line 608 and Wilamowitz' reconstruction. The Aelian frag- ment (n.h. VII. 39) which is ascribed by Girard and Miiller to a deus ex machina in the Iphigeneia at Aulis is rejected as un-Euripidean in speech and technique. Patriotic fervor, the author believes, reached its height in the Erechtheus produced before the peace of Nicias. The whole drama is a patriotic irpoTp«rTiKos. The old Attic saga was retold as the story of Praxithea's sacrifice of her child for country and the patriotic motive rein- forced by a personal eVairotfavdv — a doubling of the heroic theme which appears also in the Phrixos. The poetic dramas of personal self-devotion of Alcestis, Evadne, and Lao- damia resist at times the schematic analysis of the writer. Admetus in the r61e of the hero of a "retarding moment" is hardly convincing. For the language of sacrifice Euripides, the writer proves, borrowed much from the ritualistic forms. On the question of the originality of Euripides, the writer holds that the episodes of Macaria and Menoiceus and the voluntary motives in the sacrifices of Polyxena and Iphigeneia are innovations of the dramatist. For the theme of self-sacrifice in the Erech- theus and still more in the Phrixos Euripides was indebted to ancient saga. Geneva Misener University of Alberta Seneca the Philosopher and His Modern Message. By Richard Mott Gummehe. Pp. xvi+150. Boston: Marshall Jones Company. The friends of classical studies have been laid under lasting obligation by the generous patrons who have made possible the publication of fifty volumes by well-known European and American scholars dealing with "Our Debt to Greece and Rome." The series, edited by Professors George D. Hadzsits, of the University of Pennsylvania, and David M. Robinson, of Johns Hopkins University, has begun auspiciously with the appearance of the volume on Seneca by a scholar whose studies have so well qualified him for his task. After an introductory chapter dealing with the philosopher-minister's life, Mr. Gummere traces his influence from the first century on through the Middle Ages and the Renaissance down to the present day. The results of his survey are summarized in the following paragraph : We have seen that in periods when new ideas are in the air, Seneca furnishes material for the promoter and for the interpreter of progress. We noted his Book Reviews 375 influence as a forerunner or an ex post facto advocate of the Christian religion. Montaigne, in breaking up the artificialities of a worn-out chivalry in France, draws from the Corduban as from a never-failing spring. Petrarch's return to the classics signalized itself by a close adaptation to the style of Seneca. Chaucer's English leadership, Elizabethan pioneering, the experiments of Rousseau, the various attempts to explain philosopher-kingship during the last eight centuries — all these are indicative of a latent power which has never been sufficiently acknowl- edged [p. 137]. In his "Les Moralistes sous l'Empire Romain" (p. 80), M. Constant Martha has applied to Seneca's moral teachings the familiar words from Tertullian's Apology: "Testimonium animae naturaliter Christianae." And the most interesting section of Mr. Gummere's book is that dealing with the philosopher's appeal to the early Fathers of the Church. The author speaks of Stoicism, the religion of the Neronian Age, as "the porch to Chris- tianity" and dwells at some length on the elements in Seneca's modified creed which led the church for ages to believe in the authenticity of the correspondence supposed to have passed between the Roman philosopher and the Apostle Paul. The originality of Seneca's Stoicism, upon which Mr. Gummere lays emphasis, lies rather in his having so freely "admitted into it the theories of other schools " (p. 60) than in his having been the first to subject the creed to the test of life. For a long line of Seneca's predecessors, following the practice of the Cynics, must have presented their philosophy as an ars vivendi and given it a practical turn, modifying the impossible ideal of the superhuman Sapiens. The hold which Stoicism had obtained in Rome before the Age of Nero leads us to believe that many of its apostles preached a doctrine which squared with human experience: "Non loquor tecum stoica lingua sed hac summissiori." The extent of Seneca's indebted- ness here cannot be estimated owing to the loss of the works of his Stoic forbears. It is of interest to note that his best-known saying, "Neptune, numquam hanc navem nisi rectam" (which Lowell quoted from Mon- taigne's paraphrase in his "Essai de la Gloire"), echoes the popular proverb, 6p6av rav vavv, and goes back several centuries to a work of the Cynic Teles (see Stobaeus Serm. 106; Tyrrell and Purser on Cic. Q. Fr., I, 2, 13). In discussing the popular essay as the medium in which the moralist thought "his message to society might be most effective," Mr. Gummere defends the radicalism of Seneca's style against the Conservatives. Quin- tilian "forgot that in an age when the only piece of work rewarded by a certain emperor was a banquet-dialogue between a mushroom, a reed-bird, and an oyster, an author who hoped to gain a hearing must devise something striking" (p. 35). In this connection should be considered Mr. C. N. Smiley's suggestive article (Classical Studies in Honor of Charles Forster Smith, pp. 50- 61) in which the author points out the extent to which Seneca "adhered to and perpetuated the Stoic theory of literary style" which emphasized the five cardinal virtues of tAAiyviayids (Latinitas) , ^vaa, (rvvro/jua, irpeirov, Karao-Kcirq. 376 Book Reviews That Mr. Gummere is filled with enthusiasm for his task is evident throughout. The style is clear and spirited. One feels inclined, however, to question the appropriateness of such expressions as "bleacherite," "hand- me-downs," and "purple patcher." The Senecan quotations on page 107 are found (among others) in Montaigne's " Essai de 1'Institution des Enfants " and not in his "Essai des Livres." From Ep. 106 the French moralist quotes in "Essais," I, 24; III, 12. To the brief bibliography, which along with three pages of notes and a list of forthcoming volumes brings the book to a close, might be added Francis Holland's Seneca, London, 1920. Mr. Gummere is to be congratulated on the success with which he has accomplished his purpose; for this slender volume will bring home to the general reader the vital appeal made by Seneca's philosophical writings as they have come down the ages to the modern world with a message of uni- versal brotherhood and steadying courage. "Dans les incertitudes et les fluctuations de la vie, il est bon d'avoir l'oeil toujours fixe sur les hauts prin- cipes d'une doctrine vers laquelle on tourne toutes ses actions et ses paroles, comme font les navigateurs qui se reglent sur certaines etoiles." Herbert C. Lipscomb Randolph-Macon Woman's College Vitae patrum. Kritische Untersuchungen iiber Text, Syntax und Wortschatz der spatlateinischen Vitae patrum (Bande III, V, VI, VII). Von Dr. A. H. Salonius. (Acta societatis humaniorum litterarum Lundensis. II). Lund, 1920. This study of the syntax and lexicography of a series of late Latin texts was inspired by Lofstedt's Commentary on the Perigrinatio Aetheriae and has been carried out along the same lines. It is an extremely important con- tribution to our knowledge of sixth-century syntax and of late Latin in general. The author outlines the scope of his study in the first chapter of the Einleitung. The texts chosen are Books III, V, VI, VII, of the so-called Vitae patrum, though, as the author has pointed out, Verba seniorum would seem to be a better title. At first glance it would appear to be a doubtful venture to study a text that has no better manuscript foundation than Migne's reprint of Rosweyd's edition, but the attempt has been surprisingly successful. The author has not attempted to present an exhaustive study— a modern edition would be indispensable for that. He has chosen four books by four different authors (Ps. Rufinus, Pelagius, Ioannes and Paschasius), which contain, however, a considerable number of passages that represent different versions of the same original. This original is Greek (except perhaps