STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Vie de Porphyre, avec les fragments des traites irepl ayaXfidrcov et De Regressu Animae. Par J. Bidez. Gand: Librairie Scientifique, E. van Goethem, 1913. Pp. vii+ 156+73. In this admirable work of Professor Bidez we have a clear account of the life of Porphyry and of the development of his thought, together with a sympathetic picture of the age in which he lived. Other discussions of Porphyry, including that of Zeller, have suffered from the failure to dis- tinguish sharply enough his different periods and hence have attributed to him doctrines obviously inconsistent, without attempting to settle the ques- tion whether he could have held them at one time. It is one of the chief merits of Bidez to have shown that these seeming inconsistencies, in great part at least, are to be explained from changes in Porphyry's philosophic position. Bidez places a higher value upon Eunapius' Life of Porphyry than do Wolff and Zeller, insisting that in dealing with any statement of this author concerning which we are in doubt we must consider whether he may not have derived his information from work of Porphyry now lost to us. Bidez does not regard it as possible to determine with certainty the questions whether Porphyry was born of Christian parents, and whether he was ever himself a Christian. But it may well be, he suggests, that the fact that he was a pupil of Origen and had a thorough acquaintance with the Scriptures led the Christians to accuse him of being an apostate. Por- phyry's meeting with Origen, Bidez thinks, may perhaps have taken place at Tyre, as Zeller holds, but more probably at Caesarea. The Philosophy of the Oracles, which gives a complete system of theurgy, is, as Eunapius perceived, a very early work. The treatise on the Images of the Gods, itself a defense of paganism, is based upon ideas very different from those contained in the previous work. This difference is noticed by Eusebius. In the treatise on the Images of the Gods there are, however, no traces of the doctrines of Plotinus; hence we are to suppose it written before Porphyry's coming to Rome. To the same general period as the latter work belong also the Homeric Questions and the History of Philosophy. In the Homeric Questions we do not find the method of interpretation by which Porphyry later discovered neo-Platonism in Homer. In the History of Philosophy we have a type of Platonism different from that of Plotinus. The chapter which deals with Porphyry's work against the Christians is perhaps the most attractive in the book. In this Bidez gives a brief but 414 Book Reviews 415 illuminating account of the relations between the pagans and the Christians at this time and presents sympathetically Porphyry's position and his methods of polemics. The Letter to Anebo, intended to purify and transform the popular religions, bears traces, Bidez thinks, of the influence of Plotinus, but it must be earlier than the De Regressu Animae and the De Abstinentia. On page 132 Bidez characterizes the genius of Porphyry thus: "Si l'on voulait le caracteriser avec les expressions qui s'emploient pour un ecrivain de notre temps, on dirait de lui qu'il avait l'esprit vif et rapide d'un excellent publieiste, une plume alerte, des ciseaux adroits, et qu'il mit ces instruments tour a tour au service de la creclulite' et de la superstition des cultes orientaux, de la critique scientifique et litteraire de Longin, enfin de la religiosity de Plotin. Dans tout ce qui nous reste de ses Merits, il n'y a pas une pensee, pas une image dont on puisse affirmer a coup sur qu'elle de lui." And on page 133: "II y a toutefois un domaine ou Porphyre produisit une oeuvre vraiment personelle. C'est celui de la critique. Son trait6 contre les Chretiens est sans doute la partie la plus originale de ce qu'il a publie." In the Orient Porphyry suffered a decline in influence because of the school's increasing absorption in theurgy. Toward the end of the fifth cen- tury, however, at Alexandria, Ammonius, David, and Elias wrote commen- taries upon his introduction to the Organon, and at Athens Simplicius manifested much respect for him. Later, among the Arabs and Syrians, and at Constantinople, he was one of the great names in philosophy. In the Occident the writings of Porphyry had a more sustained success. Influencing Macrobius, and translated by Marius Victorinus and Bothius, he came to be an intermediary between Plotinus and Augustine, and later between Plotinus and the scholastics. Professor Bidez has appended to the main body of his work the fragments of the wept dya\/taTO)v and of the De Regressu Animae, together with a discus- sion of these treatises; extracts from Eunapius, Suidas, and Arabic authors on the life and works of Porphyry; and a list of Porphyry's works, with indication as to where the fragments are to be found. All students of ancient philosophy will await with much eagerness the publication of the fragments of Porphyry's philosophical works which Pro- fessor Bidez projects. ROGEB MlLLEB JONES University of California Plutarch's Lives. With an English translation by Bernadotte Perrin. Vol. V (Loeb Classical Library). London: William Heinemann; New York: Putnam, 1917. Pp. ix+543. In this volume Professor Perrin has included the Lives of Agesilaus and Pompey, Pelopidas and Marcellus. The translation, as in the former volumes, is excellent. I desire, however, to call attention to the following