STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 294 Book Reviews yt la-fuv ajcovcrav iraxrav irav ayvoovaav . Douglas Sharp, Epictetus and the New Testament, p. 13, in his strange disquisition on this "Hellenistic idiom," is uncertain whether we are to understand the phrase as a quotation from Plato or not. Again, the interpretation and perhaps the text of iv. 1. 118-19 would have been cleared up by a reference to the doctrine of the Lysis that knowledge is the only justification of power or command and the paradox of the Gorgias that power to do wrong is not power. Paul Shorey The Rhesus of Euripides. Edited with Introduction and Notes by W. H. Porter. Cambridge: University Press, 1916. Pp. lii+97. Signs are not lacking of a revival of interest in the Rhesus. Mr. Porter's own examination of its genuineness in Hermatkena, XVII (1913), 348-80, has now been continued by Professor Bates in Transactions of the American Philogical Association, XL VII (1916), 6-11. The latter states (p. 5, n. 2) that Professor Rolfe has shifted his ground somewhat since his article on the subject in Harvard Studies, IV (1893), 61-97. The present editor devotes a generous portion of his Introduction to the problem (pp. xxxv-lii), but maintains that "the investigations of critics have failed to adduce any facts sufficient to warrant us in disregarding the testimony which assigns it to Euripides." An eagerness to relieve the barrenness of the fourth century by assigning an extant tragedy to that period has certainly been partly responsible for the critical assault upon the Rhesus. Yet any piece con- cerning which its defenders must grant that it "is a peculiar play: peculiar in style, peculiar in subject-matter, peculiar in treatment, peculiar for the suspicions cast upon it in ancient times," compels a certain reserve. The earlier pages of the Introduction are mainly occupied with a discussion, unusually fresh and interesting, of the "Plot and its Sources" (pp. x-xxxi). Steiger's interpretation of the tragedy's meaning is refuted in pages xxxi- xxxiii, the "Literary Significance of the Play." The editor is largely indebted to Professor Gilbert Murray for the con- stitution of his text (p. vii and passim in the notes), for the theory that the Rhesus was a "pro-satyric drama, written by the youthful Euripides in imitation of Aeschylus and revised by another hand for reproduction after the poet's death (p. Hi), for bits of translation (pp. xi, 56, 68, 84, 91, etc.), and for numerous other matters (pp. xv, xix, xxxiii, etc.). When modern emendations have been introduced into the text, the MS readings are briefly recorded at the bottom of the page, even though such passages are regularly discussed at length in the commentary. Schroder's arrangement of the choral songs has been adopted. An appendix dealing with verses 874-78 has been contributed by Professor Norwood (pp. 91 f.). Book Reviews 295 All things considered, this constitutes a useful addition to the editions of the Attic dramatists which are available for classroom work with under- graduates. Care has not always been taken to indicate the edition of modern books to which references are made (cf. p. xiii, n. 2, p. xix, n. 3, etc.). On page 68, Mr. Porter seeks to add "complain" to the meanings of Ko/it7rea> recog- nized in Liddell and Scott; Professor Norwood (p. 92) favors "disdainfully assert." On pages 1 and 76 the erroneous statement of numerous writers to the effect that four actors are required at verses 626 ff. is corrected. On page xii, note 1, read Ajax for Ant. Roy C. Flickingeb Northwestern University Poeti Alessandrini. By Augtjsto Rostagni. Torino: Fratelli Bocca, 1916. Pp. 398. 5 Lire. This is an important study of Theocritus and Callimachus. There is a good chapter, too, on Asclepiades of Samos and his school. To mention a few details: The writer holds that the Panegryic of Ptolemy was written ca. 274, the Charities, ca. 265, the Thalysia, ca. 280. In a long chapter on the myth of Daphnis he decides that in the first Idyl Theocritus has in mind the form of the story which was current at Himera, i.e., Daphnis was changed into a fountain (c/fe pdov). The "Syracosius poeta" of Ovid's Ibis 549, is identified, not with Theocritus, but with the Theodorus who is mentioned by Athenaeus, xiv. 618. As for Callimachus, the four hymns to Zeus, to Delos, to Artemis, to Apollo, reflect something of the political situation of the day; the praises of Apollo and Artemis would remind the reader of the career of Ptolemy or of Arsinoe. Certain passages in the hymn to Apollo are directly imitated in Propertius iv. 4. The introductory chapter " Da Euripide a Teocrito " draws an interesting parallel between the Greek literature of the fourth century and the French literature of the eighteenth. W. P. Mustard Johns Hopkins University Poeti e Personaggi Catulliani. By Carlo Pascal. Catania: Fr. Battiato, 1916. Pp. 250. 4 Lire. This is a very readable review of all that has been gleaned or guessed about the poets and other personages mentioned in the poems of Catullus. The book really gives a great deal more than its title promises. For example, it not only sets forth what is known about the poets Calvus and Cinna, but also discusses the extant fragments of their poems. It even adds a section on the poet Anser because someone once proposed to read Anser for aufert at LXVIII. 157. And, just for good measure, the writer throws in various