STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 400 Book Reviews the student of Pindar. The famous charioteer is presented in four fine illustrations and compared with front and profile views of the Anadumenos Capranesi. The column of the dancing women has a whole chapter to itself which includes a discussion of acanthus leaf ornaments and the true meaning of caryatid. The chapter on the monument of the Thessalian princes is largely concerned with the well-preserved statue of Agias, whose epigram boasting that he was victorious "five times at Nemea, twice in the Pythian, and five times in the Isthmian games," reads like what Tennyson calls "the sandy tracts in Pindar." The inscription at Pharsalus, Agias' home town, in order to make round numbers, boasts of five victories at Delphi too. Dr. Poulsen compares this statue with the art of Polycleitus and of Scopas, and concludes that it represents "an earlier stage in the art of Lysippus" than that embodied in the Apoxyomenos. A richly illustrated chapter on Greek portraits from Delphi, followed by a few eloquent pages on the spirit of Delphi, concludes the volume. The predominance of the sculptural interest does not preclude other things. All the information about Delphi that the ordinary student needs will be found here. The hymn to Apollo, for example, is given both in English translation and in Greek with the music. A number of excellent views and maps refresh the memories of travelers, and almost take the place of autopsy for the untraveled. And the two introductory chapters on the history of the site and the oracle are an adequate preparation for the details that follow. The first of these chapters, on Apollo's conquest of Delphi, is of course largely specula- tive and follows the philological fashions of the day. There is not much use in trying to keep up the rectification of Professor Wilamowitz' genial errors. On Dr. Poulsen's first page stands the statement that Apollo is a non-Greek, enemy god, substantiated by the fact that Achilles calls him "the most destructive of all gods." This last argument of course is a misapprehension of Homeric usage, as was shown in these pages long ago. (See Classical Philology, Vol. IV, p. 329.) Paul Shoeey Vergil and the English Poets. By Elizabeth Nitchie. New York: Columbia University Press, 1919. $1.50. In scope and method Miss Nitchie's dissertation differs widely from that of Miss Goad. The one devotes 626 pages to the influence of Horace on a selection of the authors of the eighteenth century; the other sums up the entire Vergilian tradition of English literature in 244 pages. For Miss Nitchie parallel passages are not an end in themselves. " It is difficult," she says, "to prevent a book of this kind from falling into a mere list of parallel passages from Vergil and English poets." If she had chosen to give us such Book Reviews 401 a list, we should have accepted this gratefully as a contribution to the future history of the subject. But she has undoubtedly made a more readable book by not attempting that kind of completeness. After a brief general introduction, she studies in chapter 2, with the aid of Comparetti, Zappert, Tunison, and Ker, the Vergilian tradition of the Middle Ages, including the question whether Beowulf was acquainted with Vergil. Chapter 3, while containing little that is new, is an interesting survey of the dealings with Vergil of Chaucer and his contemporaries. "The motto on the prioress' 'broche of gold,' Amor vincit omnia," she says, "was probably a common- place in Chaucer's time." She might have confirmed this conjecture by the fact that it appears as a tag in the verse of the Carolingian Latin poets, two or three times, for example, in Paulus Diaconus. Chapter 4, "Vergil and Humanism," though of necessity only a generalizing sketch, is well- proportioned and true in its perspective. It deals rapidly with such topics as "The Thirteenth Century Battle of the Books," already studied by Rashdall and Paetow, the introduction of the Latin poets into the school curriculum, Petrarch's study of Vergil, Alamanni, Elyot, and Ascham, Vida and Scaliger, and Tasso. More space is given to Gavin Douglas, Surrey, Phaer, and Stoneyhurst. Here and elsewhere she brings out well the difference between the Renaissance study of Vergil the artist and critic of life, and Chaucer's interest in him only as a story-teller. She has rather neglected Scaliger and the Latinized literary criticism that for two centuries preferred Vergil to Homer. Chapter 5, "Spenser and the English Ren- aissance," is fairly full on Spenser, and touches lightly Sidney, Sackville, Ben Jonson, and Shakespeare. Chapter 6, "Milton and the Classical Epic," affirms that Milton's classicism is Greek rather than Latin, but that Paradise Lost uses the Aeneid chiefly as the model for epic structure. A considerable, though by no means complete list of Vergilian parallels is given. Chapter 7 sums up fairly well the familiar commonplaces about eighteenth-century diction and appreciation of the classics, and recurs to the topic of the pastoral, already discussed in the chapter on Spenser. The remainder of the book is somewhat perfunctory. There is a chapter on Thompson and the didactic poets, one on Landor and the romanticists, which fails to do justice to the Vergilian echoes and influence in Keats, Shelley, Wordsworth, and Byron; and a chapter on Tennyson, which is sound in principle, but rather dis- cursive and slight in execution. From the point of view of a purely technical and professional scholar- ship Miss Nitchie's sketch still leaves the subject open to the industry of a future chalkenteros. But, as I said in beginning, it is eminently readable, and it will be of more service to teachers of Vergil than a more learned and mechanically exhaustive catalogue of facts would be. And that may well have been Miss Nitchie's intention. Paul Shobey