STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 205 done the best I could do under the circumstances. I have taken my Daremberg and looked up the numerous passages which puzzled me or where I had reason to question the soundness of the text. In most instances the difficulties had disappeared, or at least there appeared to be offered some- thing that might lead on further study to a satisfactory solution. If others more familiar with Celsus are as well served by the new edition as I have been in the first rapid survey, the editor will have rendered a distinct service. The only desideratum which seems not to have been fully met is that in regard to the Latin index. The fact that Matthiae prepared a complete index to Van der Linden's text, published in Targa's edition, unsatisfactory and inconvenient as it is, is small comfort; when an edition such as Marx's is issued which offers a greatly improved text and is likely for long to be the standard, it is a pity that it should not be accompanied with a complete index, the value of which to the student cannot be estimated. On the other hand, the generous number of cross-references and parallel texts from other writers, Greek and Latin, added at the foot of the page between the text and the apparatus criticus, is a real boon to the serious student, greatly facilitating the use and enhancing the value of the text. I have here noted the omission of a few parallels from Hippocrates, but they are rather trivial as far as my observation goes. Of the matters considered in the Prolegomena the most interesting to me is the proof (so the editor calls it, and so the critical reader will, I believe, pronounce it) that the Medicina of Celsus is a translation of the Greek treatise of T. Aufidius Siculus. The argument is conducted carefully and methodically, and all reasonable doubt of the correctness of the con- clusion is removed. On the whole one will be pleased also with the editor's judgment in constituting the text. Here, however, the problems, as in all medical writers, are so complicated by our want of intimate knowledge of the ancient remedies that the judicious student will often be in doubt — more often than even the frankest editor will be likely to admit. Some special points at which I now think I might improve the text I will mention later, if they stand the test of maturer consideration. Meanwhile it is a source of satisfaction that we have a text provided with a record of the manuscript tradition on which one may safely proceed in a critical reading of an author from many points of view worth studying. Wesletan University W. A. Heidel Caesars Monarchie und das Principal des Pompeius. Zweite ver- besserte Auflage. By Edtjard Meyer. Stuttgart, 1919. Pp. 632. This second edition contains a score of minor corrections of the first edition, which, published in 1918, reached but few of our libraries. The thesis of the book is, as might be inferred from the title, that the form of 206 Book Reviews government adopted by Augustus — das Principal — was a continuation of that of 52 B.C., when Pompey was sole consul, rather than of the monarchy founded by Julius Caesar. However, it would be unfair to imply that Professor Meyer has to any extent pressed his facts into the service of an argument. Indeed the attentive reader will find that the subtitle "Innere Geschichte Roms von 66 bis 44 v. Chr." best describes the contents, that the work is a straightforward narrative of political events, and that the main title may indeed have been an afterthought . The work has the peculiar qualities that we have learned to expect from the distinguished author's studies of ancient history. It reveals the same remarkable power to grasp and associate an immense number of apparently disjointed facts, and to bring into relationship complex tendencies which ordinary historians pigeonhole as disassociated accidents. The reader' feels that a comprehensive memory and constructive intellect have been set at the task, and not a shuffler of index cards. The book again has that architectonic actuality which Meyer's vivid historical imagination can so successfully evoke. Meyer views his characters at work. His data are no longer scraps of quoted phrases; they stand out as significant acts in the complex struggle of men. Thus, for instance, Cicero's De Republica (pp. 189 ff.) is interpreted in connection with actual political experience, not merely as a notebook of quotations from Greek philosophers, and the changed policy of the Senate in 52 is explained in the light of Caesar's hard experiences in Gaul (pp. 220 ff.). Yet the work leaves the reader disappointed. It was perhaps a mistake to obtrude a thesis. Its adoption apparently induced the author to divide the book into two disjointed sections, in the first of which Caesar is thrust too far into the background in order that the attention may dwell on Pompey. Furthermore, the thesis seems not substantiated. One still feels that Augus- tus reverted empirically to constitutional methods for reasons of caution rather than from a conscious adoption of a clear-cut form evolved by Pompey; that in fact Pompey himself, on Meyer's own demonstration, blundered along without grasping any definite policy. A second disappointment arises from the fact that the work deals too much with externals. There is little significance for history in the twenty- five pages of narrative which describe (from Cicero's letters) the fussy twaddling of the third-rate politicians that held the stage in 57 B.C. On the other hand there is no attempt to describe the social and economic background of the period, as for instance Greenidge pictured that of the Gracchan era. Nor is there a penetrating diagnosis of the political diseases that had gripped the Roman democracy. The author is perhaps too impa- tient with democracy to attempt the task, or perhaps too little acquainted with the phenomenon. In his picture of it there is no chiaroscuro. It is all black. The author apparently believes that because Caesar dared over- ride the constitution in his consulship he was also capable of murdering Book Reviews 207 Vettius in cold blood (p. 87), that because Cicero was weak-kneed at times he also "grafted" in politics (p. 200). And the lack of patient weighing of facts is hardly compensated for by scornful references to "boss rule" in America and quasi-illustrations of Roman politics drawn from the "usurped" autocracy that modern democracies have permitted "Wilson and Lloyd George." One is almost forced at times to the conclusion that the book was meant in part as a counterblast to the approaching revolution of 1918. At any rate, it contains many an impressionistic canvas painted with a liberal use of impulsive subjectivism where the reader would prefer an unimpassioned and analytical study. Finally the author, long known as a keen critic of sources, has here revealed an unwonted lack of skepticism. Cicero and his fellows knew that, especially before elections, speeches and political pamphlets grew reckless of truth. They knew that they must take them with many grains of salt even as we take pre-election headlines. The Greek writers Appian, Plutarch, and Dio, who lived under the imperial censorship at a time when election excitements no longer distorted men's judgments, were too inexperi- enced in democratic politics to know how much needed to be discounted in reading the lurid pamphlets of that earlier time. Meyer, who has spent his scholarly life under a kind of Hadrianic regime, has also failed to discount properly. There is apparently nothing in the sources that surpasses his faculty to believe. He does reject at times when authorities contradict each other, but he has not developed a consciousness of where to draw the line in the case of political gossip. Perhaps that was too much to expect in the circumstances. Despite all this, the book is to be recommended very highly to specialists who will know where the danger lies. At any rate it is a safer and more illuminating history than the corresponding section of Mommsen. Tenney Frank M. Tulli Ciceronis Orationes. Pro Milone, Pro Marcello, Pro Ligario, Pro Rege Deiotaro, Philippicae I-XIV. Recognovit A. C. Clark. Editio altera. Oxford University Press. Few second editions of Latin texts differ so radically from the original edition as does this one. It is an entirely new work and makes the first edition thoroughly obsolete. This is due, not to any fault of the editor's in preparing the first edition, but to his later brilliant work and that of Peterson, his colleague, in editing the Oxford Cicero. This work is one of the most interesting and important chapters in the recent history of our Latin texts . The first edition belongs to the pre-Cluny period, as it were, the second is post-Cluniac. Peterson discovered a ninth-century Cicero at Holkham, and this proved to be identical with a MS described in an old Cluny cata- logue under the number 498. This MS at once took a leading place among