STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 306 Book Reviews A few passages from Housman's Introduction will bear quotation here: "Liars need not have long memories if they address themselves only to fools, who have short ones; and an astrological poet writing his third book may safely forget his second, because an astrological reader will never remember it." Again in the discussion of an impossible interpretation: "The 12 athla, in not unnatural consternation, have hereupon abandoned the order which Manilius in verse 168 declares to be immutable, and are chasing each other round the circle hind-before. No stranger night-scene was ever witnessed by Walrus or by Carpenter." Manilius is apostrophized in these words: "Alas, alas! This alternative method of yours, my poor Marcus, is none other than the vulgar method which in 218-24 you said you knew, and which in 225-46 you exposed as false. The wolf, to whom in his proper shape you denied admittance, has come back disguised as your mother the goose, and her gosling has opened the door to him." Behind this brilliant exterior there is Housman's usual profound scholarship. It is this which causes his often intolerant contempt for inaccuracy on the part of the author whose work he expounds and on the part of modern interpreters. Several new and convincing interpretations offered in the Introduction are so clearly put that one wonders how scholars failed to see the truth before. The commentary is in a way a return to eighteenth-century methods, in that it combines critical apparatus with interpretative material, all in Latin, though the Introduction is in English. The variant readings are, however, put first and printed in bold face, so that it is easy to pick them out. As in Book II, Housman depends on manuscripts GLM and on the corrector of L (L 2 ) . The names of Scaliger and Bentley are those which are most frequently attached to emendations accepted in the text, for these two are among the few scholars for whom Housman has any respect. Of the former he says in the Introduction: "Scaliger knew, but forgot to say, and consequently no other commentator knows." What a contemptuous fling at the commentators of Manilius! It makes one glad that he is not one of them. The editor's own emendations are indicated by a modest asterisk, instead of the more usual and rather conceited ego. Most of these had been propounded in an appendix to the edition of Book I. The book deserves welcome from those who wish all the light they can get on the obscurities of Manilius. B. L. Ullman University of Iowa Poetae Latini Minores. Post Aemilitjm Baehrens iterum recensuit Friderictjs Vollmer. Vol. V, Dracontius. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1914. Pp. x+268. Baehrens discovered many important manuscripts and made many valuable contributions to Latin scholarship, but he was very free with his emendations and worked with such rapidity that his output was ful Book Reviews 307 of errors. Most of his work, therefore, has been in need of revision. His Poetae Latini Minores is no exception. The careful scholarship of Vollmer is just what was required for a revision of Baehrens' work. The fifth volume is in reality not a revision but an entirely new work, and there is no reason for retaining Baehrens' name on the title-page as far as this volume is concerned. The edition is indeed not altogether new in its pres- ent form, as it is an abridgment of Vollmer's Dracontius in the Monu- menta Germaniae Historica, published in 1905. One-third of Baehrens' edition contained works of Dracontius. The new edition contains Dra- contius only, including the Christian poems, which, following the original plan of the work, were omitted in the first edition. Two short poems which were included by Baehrens and whose Dracontian authorship is based on mere guess are omitted in the new edition. The somewhat doubtful De aegritudine Perdicae is included. The first ten poems of the Carmina Prof ana of Baehrens are now entitled Romuka. This name is found in the Verona Florilegium, a source not used by Baehrens. A very interesting paleographical fact about the Romu- lea is that the single extant manuscript contains two copies of poem X on separate quires, one of which, according to Vollmer, is part of the original from which the entire manuscript was copied. This shows in an interest- ing way how the quires of a manuscript were separated for copying pur- poses. Vollmer's terminology is unsatisfactory and confusing at this point, though, to be sure, he is merely following Baehrens: he calls the manu- script as a whole N, but in the repeated portion he calls the original N and the copy n. On the page explaining the sigla of the manuscript it is disturb- ing to see, in the midst of the Latin discussion, such forms as Briissel, Neapel, Mailand. The text differs considerably from that of Baehrens. Many of the latter's conjectures are rejected in favor of those of Duhn, the first editor of the complete Romulea, or of the manuscript readings. B. L. Ullman University of Iowa Iowa City, Iowa The Master of the Offices in the Later Roman and Byzantine Empires. By A. E. R. Boak. (University of Michigan Studies.) Mac- millan, 1919. Pp. x-f-160. An adequate constitutional history of the Roman Empire has yet to be written. Mommsen, in his Staatsrecht, has assembled with painstaking care the materials for the study of the principate; and Seeck and others have given us admirable general descriptions of the oriental monarchy of the fourth and succeeding centuries. But there is no detailed study of the transition from the one to the other. The ordinary student is left with the