STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Aspects, Aorists and the Classical Tripos. By Jane Ellen Harbison. Cambridge: The University Press, 1919. 2s. 6d. Miss Jane Harrison, like many others, has been dabbling in the study of Russian and hastens to tell the world of her new passion and the ineffable things that she has discovered in the aspects of the Russian verb. It appears that there are two chief aspects, the imperfective and the perfective. It is the indeterminateness of the imperfective that expands the hedonistic consciousness of Miss Harrison when her temperament revolts against the austere intellectual yoke of Greek precision — the relative precision of the Greek of Themis and the Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion. The imperfective, if I apprehend her thought, is that crvyKe^v/xevov « which Plato wished mathematics and dialectic to clarify. The imperfective is the holophrastic New Caledonian or Fuegian as President Stanley Hall would and Miss Harrison does say. It expresses the philosophy of Bergson, the duree and the integral action in which by an interesting coincidence another admirer of Bergson, Georges Sorel, in his "Reflections on Violence" discovers the justification of direct action. The imperfective is the Russian soul, the wonderful incalculable, Tolstoian, peasant, and Bolshevist soul, so much more fascinating in its unexpectedness than the stodgy inhibited Briton whose "morality is the vice of the perfective." The imperfective is Oblomov breakfasting in his dressing-gown at eleven-thirty, marrying his landlady, and drinking himself into premature apoplexy. The coming of spring por- trayed as pure seething process and imperfective aspect has power in a Russian ballad to stay a murderer's uplifted hand. The coldly finished, intellectual second aorist of rj\0', r/\6e x«Ai8a>v has no such magic potency. We still, of course, need something of Greek precision and definiteness in our young lives. But if the Cambridge tripos would only combine it with Russian, then temperament and reason would wed in ideal union, and culture could chant its nunc dimittis in Verlaine's Chanson grise — or should it be grisee ? ou 1' Indecis au Precis se joint. Paul Shorey Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome. Vols. I and II. New York: University Press Association, 1917 and 1918. With these two sumptuous volumes begins the new series of the Memoirs of the American Academy, continuing the Supplementary Papers of the American School of Classical Studies (Vol. I, 1905; Vol. II, 1908), but with 302 Book Reviews 303 the wider range necessitated by the inclusion of the work of the School of Fine Arts. They are folios, and both stock and typography are marked by a quality that is becoming very rare in these days of paper shortage and high cost of printing. But what contributes most to the physical excellence of the volumes is the amazing effectiveness of the illustrations. The first volume contains two long articles: one on "The Vatican Livy and the Script of Tours" (by E. K. Rand and George Howe) and the other on "The Military Indebtedness of Early Rome to Etruria" (by Eugene S. McCartney); and several shorter contributions: "The Reorganization of the Roman Priesthoods at the Beginning of the Republic," by the late Jesse B. Carter; "The Aqua Traiana and the Mills on the Janiculum," by A. W. Van Buren and G. P. Stevens; "Ancient Granulated Jewelry of the Seventh Century B.C. and Earlier," by C. Densmore Curtis; "Bartolomeo Caporali," by Stanley Lothrop; and "Capita Desecta and Marble Coiffures," by J. R. Crawford. The article on the Vatican Livy by Rand and Howe is the second important contribution on this manuscript made by the American School. F. W. Shipley made a careful study of it when he was a fellow of the School, and published a series of articles in the American Journal of Archaeology (VII, 13-25, 157-97, and 405-28). The authors of the present article dissent from Shipley's view that the script of the manuscript is "one of the best examples of the calligraphy of Tours." They believe that it is early, and if the Bamberg Bible was done under Alcuin, then the Livy must have appeared before the coming of Alcuin to Tours. One might suppose that the Livy, as the external testimony apparently indicates, was done under Fridugisus, perhaps soon after 804, while the series of which the Bamberg Bible was the first mem- ber started, say, a decade later. In his interesting article, "Capita Desecta and Marble Coiffures," J. R. Crawford demonstrates the flimsiness of the evidence on which Gauckler based his theory that the explanation of the segmented heads, seen in so many museums, is to be found in a rite of anointing connected with cult statues of Syrian divinities whose worship had been introduced into Rome. Gauckler's hypothesis is that if the statue was already made the head was formally cut, the oil applied, and the segment mortised on again. If it was made new for the purpose, the head and its segment (or coiffure) were prepared separately. Crawford shows that the marble coiffures are wholly distinct from the segmented heads and should not be included with them. As regards the latter, he is of the opinion that they may continue to be explained on technical grounds and that Greek and Roman sculptors may have been more ready than is generally admitted to use more than a single block in the making of a marble head. In his treatment of Rome's military indebtedness to Etruria, E. S. McCartney discusses in detail the spear, sword, shield, helmet, cuirass. 304 Book Reviews greaves, and cinctura. He deals also with the organization of the legion, musical instruments, standards, chariot, castra, and cavalry. He concludes that whatever were the modifications suggested by encounters with the Sabines, Samnites, Gauls, Iberians and other nations and however resourceful were the fertile brains of Camillus, Marius and Caesar, one may rest assured that the most important of the many stages of Rome's military evolution was Etruscan. It is not surprising that the similarity, and, in many cases, the identity of cus- toms and institutions gave rise to the story that Rome itself was an Etruscan city (Dion. Hal. 1. 29. 2). Greece was not the only nation that led her captor captive. But the chief value of the article is not in any novelty in the conclusion but in the detailed presentation of the evidence on each phase of the question. At the beginning of the second volume is a series of fifteen plates repro- ducing the work of the Fellows of the School of Fine Arts. A similar selec- tion is to be presented in each issue of the Memoirs. Among these we find a capital of the "Temple of Mars Ultor in Rome" (drawn and rendered by Walter L. Ward, fellow in architecture, 1913-16, and measured by Kenneth E. Carpenter, fellow in architecture, 1912-15); "Restoration of the Circu- lar Pavilion at Hadrian's Villa" (by Philip T. Shutze, fellow in architecture, 1915-18); "Villa Gamberaia": planting plan, principal elevation and side elevation (by Edward G. Lawson, landscape architect, 1915-18); and other contributions by the fellows in sculpture and painting. These plates give an excellent idea of the range of the work carried on in the Academy and the high degree of technical skill attained by the students. The rest of the volume is taken up with articles. E. Douglas Van Buren writes on "Terracotta Arulae" (pp. 15-54); Lucy George Roberts on "The Gallic Fire and Roman Archives" (pp. 55-66); A. W. Van Buren on "Studies in the Archaeology of the Forum at Pompeii"; and Stanley Lothrop on "Pietro Cavallini" (pp. 77-98). Mrs. Van Buren's article is a distinct contribution to a subject in regard to which our information up to this time has been somewhat vague. She sums up her conclusions as follows (p. 50) : These arulae originate with the Greek colonies; they are not found however on the Greek mainland, and must therefore reveal a usage and, possibly, a cult either purely local or brought from somewhere other than the mother country of the settlers. The subjects represented are schemes common to oriental art, and here the Loryma basis comes to our assistance: for it shows that precisely on an altar basis just such subjects were treated. Presumably, then, the Greek colonists knew of the use of sculptured altars as tomb monuments in Asia Minor at any rate, if not in Greece proper, and in their new homes they perpetuated this form of memorial, but in miniature, depositing it within instead of upon the tomb. Although this was the original purpose of the arulae, it is easily con- ceivable that they were soon also dedicated as ex-votos in sanctuaries, or even Book Reviews 305 employed in houses for commemorative or domestic cults, which would account for their presence in temples and dwelling houses. The custom must have been carried north by the colonists, for after a long tract of territory where arulae are not found, they appear again in the Greek settlement of Capua and then in Rome and the neighborhood, including Caere and Ardea, both traditional Greek foundations. Miss Roberts' paper is a study of the evidence available for determining the extent of the Gallic fire in 387 b.c. As a result of her investigation it seems probable that almost all the international documents deposited in the Capitoline and other temples were saved. Of the other records, the leges in the temple of Saturn probably survived, as well as the senatus con- sulta. The pontifical records and the Laws of the Twelve Tables apparently perished. All the latter and many of the former were restored from memory. A. W. Van Buren's article on the Pompeian Forum (like his treatment of the Aqua Traiana in Vol. I) shows that command of his subject which we have long since learned to expect from him. For many years his articles have been magna pars of the scholarly output of the School of Classical Studies. Stanley Lothrop's article is a systematic study of Pietro Cavallini's career. It is elaborately and effectively illustrated. It is to be hoped that the Academy will be able to carry out its plan of publishing a volume of this series each year. The Classical School in par- ticular has suffered severely in the past from the lack of a medium for the publication of the important work which it is doing. G. J. Laing University of Chicago M. Manilii Astronomicon Liber Tertius. Recensuit et enarravit A. E. Housman. London: Richards, 1916. Pp. xxx+72. Housman's edition of Book III of Manilius is a continuation of his editions of Books I and II (1903, 1912; the latter was reviewed by Professor E. T. Merrill in Classical Philology, IX [1914], 210). A first glance reveals that it is a continuation, for the Introduction begins abruptly without a heading immediately after the title-page and jumps at once into an explana- tion of some of the technical parts of the book. So sudden is the plunge that at first one feels that a page must be missing. Like all of Housman's work, this edition contains the usual number of scintillating remarks upon which the members of the Housman cult may seize with avidity — and nearly everyone who has once read anything by the scholar-poet becomes at once a devotee. But not even Housman's satire is sufficient, apparently, to interest American readers in Manilius. His subject-matter is difficult and to most of us dull. Manilius is anything but easy and entertaining, though Housman calls him facile and frivolous. In England, on the contrary, Manilius, because of his very difficulty, perhaps, has attracted the attention of many scholars.