STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. BOOK REVIEWS Grundfragen der Homerkritik. Von Paul Catjeb. Dritte umgear- britete und erweiterte Auflage. Erste Halfte. Verlag von S. Hirzel in Leipzig, 1921. Pp. 406. The book needs no introduction: since 1895 it has been the manual for Homeric studies, and to see its period of usefulness thus prolonged is a cause for rejoicing. Out of three books of the earlier editions, two Textkritik und Sprach- vrissenschaft and Zur Analyse des Inhalts are contained in the present volume. The second half is to bring the remaining book, Der Didder und seine Kunst, and also an attempt to give a final answer (for the time being at least) to that part of the Homeric question which lies closest to us: " wie und wann sind Ilias und Odyssee in der uns iiberlieferten Gestalt, als literarische Gebilde geschaffen worden." This will be the distinguishing feature of the new edition — for the second (1909) was intentionally limited to the discus- sion of questions of method — and is an indication of the progress made in the last decade. For it we shall have to wait until next Easter, but in the meantime we may note the extent and carefulness of the revision in the part before us. The author calculates that much more than a third of the present volume is written anew, and to the reviewer the estimate seems modest. Important changes of view have not been found necessary, but there is a frequent re-wording and recasting of the old material together with a great and skilful condensation — of polemical passages especially. The space thus gained and the pages now added are devoted to a presentation of new material and a valuable discussion of recent ideas. Work done in Germany up to the time of publication comes into consideration; but — except for Leaf's Homer and History (1915) — the use of foreign literature stopped with the beginning of the war. In the first book the outstanding feature is a new chapter (pp. 180-97) on "Der Hexameter," remarkable because of its break with the eye-system of locating caesurae and diereses. The first fruit is the overturning of Witte's speculation about the genesis of the hexameter; and a still richer harvest may be expected in the future. 1 1 Cf. also Shorey, Classical Philology, XVI (1921), 396. Since the foregoing was written Sturtevant has published "Word-Ends and Pauses in the Hexameter," American Journal of Philology, XLII (1921), 289-308. 90 Book Reviews 91 In the first two chapters (pp. 12-50) the chief addition 1 is the discussion of my article "The Archetype of Our Iliad and the Papyri," American Journal of Philology, XXXV (1914), 125-48. The following articles in which the theory has been further developed and strengthened were inacces- sible to Cauer. Even without them he agrees with me on the main issue: 2 we have "das Bild einer einheitlichen tlberlieferung, die sich .... bis ins 2. Jhdt. vor Chr. aufwarts verfolgen lasst," and the principal examples adduced are ones "in denen das Fehlen eines .... Zusatzes die reinere Uberlieferung darstellt." To Cauer I am indebted for the correction of an important item and the consequent strengthening of the theory. The external evidence points strongly to 2 381 as an interpolation, but I did not see how that conclusion could be accepted. Cauer has now shown the way, and has also communicated Schone's very satisfactory explanation of the scholium. With regard to the superfluous formulae for introducing speeches, we differ, but not so much as Cauer believes. I concur fully in the opinion: "Dass es im 2. Jhdt. vor Chr. irgendwo einen Text gegeben habe, der hierin das einheitliche Bild der Reinheit von allem Entbehrlichen geboten hatte, ist ganz unwahrscheinlich." I would go farther, indeed, and say that such a view is demonstrably false. My position, however, is merely that in this matter the preponderance of the longer version over the shorter was less in the second century B.C. than it was between the tenth and fifteenth centuries of our era, and that thanks to the papyri we can detect at least some of the interpolations of this type. I hope to return elsewhere to this question. In the meantime the emendation of r 453, which would clinch the proof of a single archetype, has become more important than ever. 3 After a careful consideration of my objections, Cauer still (pp. 38 f.) holds to the emendation, and I am still compelled to dissent. Had we a clause beginning (KtvOov av || « tk ISoito it might be conceded that X 253 O 418 would furnish close (not complete) parallels for the position of the particle. We have, however, ov /jiev yap 8' a/x^oTipwv (JuqTio-o/jai «Y0ea Xvypa (T 416) Christ con- jectured — greatly to the improvement of the text p.^ trot y(«) — fieWw and firj . If so, this comes close to meeting Wilamowitz' chal- lenge — grossly unfair as it is — to find at least one A. for y. In the matter of "Athenian interpolations" there is a very patient refutation of the views of Allen, of Scott, and of Wilamowitz. A distinction is to be drawn between the latest strata of poetry found in an Attic edition and lines inserted in this edition after its completion. Both are "interpolations" but in a different sense, and the double meaning of the word is a logical trap. It is perhaps not too optimistic to hope that Cauer's warning against this danger will be heeded. 3 The three lines of evidence combine to support the belief 1 Bechtel's kitei' Itos for kfiev tiros in X 454 should not be used (p. 83) as an instance of the violation of this principle, since it is based expressly on the belief that iiros not fivos nor (/r)4iros was used by the author of this section. 2 I regret that Cauer (p. 117) no longer condemns Roemer's theory that A fol- lowed I in Aristarchus' Iliad— K being a separate work. One consequence would be that Aristarchus and the Aristarcheans had different methods of citation — and that fact would have left some trace. Roemer's argument for tjj ixoiikva (,fra5ia) seems to me extremely weak. 8 On p. 121 A 265 should be classed with B 558, that the latter was known to Aristotle cannot be proved, cf. American Journal of Philology, XXXVII (1916), 29. Even Allen, Homeric Catalogue, p. 56, now abandons the defense of this line, being content to let it "fall in with the other lines preserved in a minority of Homeric MSS. of which we do not hesitate to say that they are additions." Book Reviews 93 that our tradition depends wholly upon an Attic edition of the sixth century. Up to that point Cauer's position is, to my mind, impregnable. Whether this was the first writing of the poems is another question, and one which can be answered from internal evidence alone; for the disappearance of earlier Ionic editions, against which Cauer (p. 126) argues, does not seem inexplicable. The remaining chapter (pp. 136-79) "Die Sprachform," brings among much else of interest a brief refutation (p. 150 n.) of Scott's article on patro- nymics and an excellent criticism of Witte's work which reduces to a proper compass the value of his achievement. "Die Heimat des Odysseus" (pp. 201-23) now opens the second book. Cauer, like Leaf, is an adherent of Dorpfeld's hypothesis, and has made a good presentation of his case. He has expanded the chapter by a discussion of the recent adverse German criticism; but, as there has been considerable writing in England (Shewan, Allen) and America (Brewster) which Cauer could not reach, there is still opportunity for a review of the whole con- troversy. Cauer finds the nucleus of the Trojan legend in battles fought by Aeolic colonists, rather than in a punitive expedition of the king of Mycene and his men. The resulting discussion of the views of Eduard Meyer, Chadwick, and Leaf forms the most prominent new element in the following chapter (pp. 224-54) "Der historische Hintergrund der Mas." The third chapter (pp. 255-95), "Umbildungen und Neubildungen der Sage," is formally a new unit, but based in part on old material. In such questions the author is less skeptical than the reviewer. In the absence of historical records the history undoubtedly present in the Iliad, must in the main continue to be a secret. Late accretions such as the Tlepolemos-Sarpedon combat, or the Athenian passages, may at times be recognized. The relation of the Iliad to other works — the Meleager, the Herakles poetry — may be divined. But beyond such matters the value of the discussion must lie in keeping before our minds the manifold possible solutions. 1 In the fourth chapter (pp. 296-349) "Kulturstufen," I may note first the increased appreciation of Piatt's article on "Homer's Similes,"and then the long discussion of Evans' and Poulsen's views. With the conclusion reached, I am heartily in sympathy: the Homeric world is neither Minoan-Mycenaean 1 To mention briefly certain details. Cauer (p. 231) has failed to detect the weakness of Leaf's attack on Aulis, cf. Allen, op. cit., 46 ff. — The linguistic argument (pp. 227, 233 f.) is not cogent, for we do not know the form of "Central Greek" dialect once spoken in the Argolis. It is at least possible that it would form as good a basis as Thessalian-Boeotian for the "Aeolisms" of the epos. — The tp&tov tpevSos in Delia Seta's work (cf. p. 280) is the assumption that 'Ax 30 as instances of tools rather than weapons. I believe it can be shown that the external evidence against A 123 is warrant for regarding it as an interpolation. Then only the mace of Areithoos and the proverb of the Odyssey are left to testify for iron weapons. 2 Bassett's interesting article, "The Palace of Odysseus," American Journal of Archaeology, XXIII (1919), 288-311, 413, was unfortunately inaccessible. It must be the starting-point for future discussion.