STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. 220 Book Reviews in schol. 1247 are the previous conjectures evippairrax, ■n-poatppairrtu, and irpoo-tpparrat. iKpairrio does not occur elsewhere, nor does it give a suitable meaning here. The conj. rbv ovokivSwv avrov is not as good as to (sc. ovo/m.) ovokivoW avrov of the MSS in schol. 1559, for while the former is intended to mean "his nickname owokiv&os," it may also mean "his donkey-driver." Rutherford's to ovoiaVoW avrov tTvai gives the sense required. Professor White reads xqpvXos with the manuscripts in the text of Aris- tophanes (Av. 299) , against all the editors except Bergk. " The form KcCpvXos is a pure fiction," says he. "To foist it into the text of Aristophanes is a mistake, since it is not the poet's practice to explain his puns." Again in Av. 307 he differs from all the editors in reading miri£own rather than 7Tl7T7ri'£oVO"l. Among the valuable contents of the book one must not fail to mention the three excellent indexes compiled by Professor Capps which greatly facili- tate its use, and the editor's full account of the manuscripts of Aristophanes that contain scholia on the Birds. The completeness and the high character of the work, and the scholarship, sound judgment, and fine discrimination of its author make us hope that he will not keep us waiting long for similar editions of the scholia on the other plays. Charles W. Peppler Trinity College Menschen- und Wettenwerden. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Mikro- kosmosidee. Von Konrat Ziegler. Leipzig u. Berlin : Teub- ner, 1913. Pp. 45. The myth concerning the origin of man put into the mouth of Aristoph- anes in the Platonic Symposium is the subject of the investigation of Professor Ziegler in this monograph, now reprinted from Neue Jahrbucher fur das klassische AUertum, XXXI, 529 ff., with the addition of an autotype cut of a relief at Modena supposed to represent the birth of Phanes. What the author claims to establish is outlined on p. 568, and is as follows : (1) the Symposium myth parodies Empedocles and Anaximander; (2) it touches very closely upon the account of man's creation in Gen., chap. 2; (3) it is an analogue of the Orphic cosmogony. We find that, more exactly, he believes that Plato parodied an unknown philosopher who devised a cosmogonic system based upon Orphism but made to agree with Empedocles to a certain extent. The study falls into two parts, taking up the philosophical and the mythological connections of the Symposium myth respectively. The general fact of a metamorphosis of the human race, which took place before its natural propagation was possible, is common to the myth and Anaximander (pp. 533- 34) and leads Professor Ziegler to find in the latter a Vorbild (p. 546). This may perhaps be doubted; there is nothing else in common between the two, Book Reviews 221 and not only does Empedocles furnish a more probable source for Aris- tophanes' foolery, but, it seems to me, a sufficient one without calling in the aid of Anaximander. It is also to be remarked that Anaximander does not so surely as Professor Ziegler thinks furnish an example of the macrocosmos- microcosmos comparison (cf. Diels, Vorsokr., 3d ed., p. 16, 16 ff. and p. 21, 7 ff.; Ziegler, p. 567), if we accept the contention of Professor Heidel that Anaximander speaks of a circular and not a spherical world (see Proc. Am. Acad, of Arts and Sciences, XL VIII, 686 ff., and Classical Philology, 1, 279 ff.). The author very carefully works out the similarities between the Sym- posium myth and the doctrines of Empedocles, at the same time mentioning with at least partial approval Bury's reference to Hippocrates as a source (p. 532). As, according to the myth, there were at first spherical beings, double-faced and double-breasted, so Empedocles declares that at first there existed various separate bodily members, which, in what may be called the second stage, were united indiscriminately by Love, producing among others something like the Aristophanic monsters (frgg. 57-61 Diels). This genera- tion, incapable of self-perpetuation, perished. Only when self-propagating beings arose did normal man exist (frgg. 62-64) ; so, in the myth, men were loosed by the device of Zeus from their constant embracing of one another and given Lebens- und Fortpflanzungsmoglichkeit (p. 541). Love enters prominently into both narratives (ibid.). Professor Ziegler recognizes that Aristophanes does not use the common motives in the same order and to the same purpose as Empedocles (p. 545). His additions to the narrative are sometimes pure comic fiction, sometimes strokes taken from mythology. Granting that it is only the salient features of the Empedoclean system, not its details, that suggested the trend of Aristophanes' speech, one is disposed to agree that there may be a real relation between the two, and the author's service in so carefully investigating all possible points of contact between them is highly to be commended. But the commonplace parallels of detail are not so convincing as the case taken as a whole. Turning to mythology, and especially to the Orphic cosmogonic myths, the author finds here the source of many of the details of the Aristophanic story. The spherical shape of the double men and their insolence to the gods he thinks were suggested by the giants and monsters of mythology; so, too, the method whereby the double men were propagated calls to mind among others the Greek myth of the birth of Erichthonios (pp. 554-55). The later creation of woman, involved in the narrative, is characteristic of Hesiodic tradition (ibid.), 1 but the peculiar way in which she was made, according to Aristophanes, that is, by division, finds no counterpart in Greek anthropog- ony. It does, however, remind us of the account given in Gen., chap. 2 (pp. 557 ff.), and Professor Ziegler strongly believes that this ultimately 1 On p. 556 the remark is made that the quintessence of the Pandora myth is that a new, less happy, age was introduced by the creation of woman. It should be noted that C. Robert, in Hermes, xlix, 17 ft., argues that Pandora was originally the earth goddess. 222 Book Reviews Babylonian tradition influenced the various Orphic doctrines of the world- egg and its division into male and female parts, which in turn suggested the cutting apart of the double men in the Symposium (pp. 560 ff.). So the double men of Aristophanes are microcosmoi (p. 566); as the world is divided, so are they. 1 Thus Professor Ziegler distinguishes two influences exercised upon the Symposium myth, that of Empedocles and that of the Orphics, and in order to explain how this came about he postulates the existence of the Empedo- clean-Orphic Anonymus mentioned above, who combined features of both systems and was Plato's immediate source. Aristophanes, who twice in his extant plays satirizes Orphism, would more properly be represented as jesting at the Orphics than at Empedocles (p. 570). This of course is only a con- jecture, and an argument might be made against its necessity; granting that the material Plato uses is not original but even very old, must we assume that Plato was not capable of himself mingling in one context for comic effect the ideas of many men — the more incongruous the better? Professor Ziegler's arguments are all interesting and suggestive, some of them convincing; but to secure the complete concurrence of scholarly opinion throughout the complexities of so involved a subject, calling often for conjectural explanation, would be well-nigh impossible. The use of fragmentary text material, over-ready assumption of the existence of real literary parallels, and the nice distinction between actual sources and the far less tangible ancestry of those ideas which filter down from age to age and finally become incorporated in literature — all these have their perils for the investigator. Professor Ziegler, I think, has for the most part avoided these pitfalls, and thus presents in this monograph a valuable study of an important question. Frank Eggleston Robbins University op Michigan Aristotle on the Art of Poetry. An amplified version with supple- mentary illustrations for students of English. By Lane Cooper. New York: Ginn & Co., 1913. Pp. xxix+101. $0.80. Though the author, who is assistant professor of English in Cornell University, is hopeful that his work will not be without suggestiveness even to classical scholars, it is primarily intended for students of literature in 1 It is to be noted that Professor Ziegler finds a reference to the division of the world- egg in the supposedly Orphic cosmogonic passages, Euripides Melanippe fr. 484 and Apoll. Rhod. I. 494 ff. This involves the assumption that the pvopipif) referred to in each is that of an egg, corresponding to other Orphic sources. The usual view is that the word indicates something like the chaos of Hesiod Theog. 116 ff. (cf. Ovid Met. I. 6-7), and, as Miss Harrison remarks about the Hesiod passage (Prolegomena, 627), if the poet meant that the chaos was egg-shaped, he does not say so.