STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 113 to give full data in the critical notes. His deviations from the readings of former editors sometimes seem arbitrary' to the reader, who is unable to con- trol his conclusions by a first-hand examination of the text or photograph. This edition has contributed much to the better understanding of the Menander text and will quicken our approach, necessarily gradual, to a reasonable certainty of what can, and of what cannot, be reconstructed. Feancis G. Allinson Brown Univbbsitt The Semantic Variability and Semantic Equivalents of-oso- and -lento-. By Edward W. Nichols. Yale Dissertation. Lancaster, Pa. : New Era Printing Co., 1914. Pp. 42. The author begins by stating (p. 1): "The purpose of this dissertation is to show (1) that an adjectival termination in Latin may have a wide range of semantic variability, determined primarily by (a) the stem to which it is attached, (6) the noun which the adjective limits; and secondarily (c) by the more remote context; and (2) that there may be a large number of semantic equivalents for such a termination, determined in each instance by the factors (a), (6), and (c) above." For this exposition he has selected adjectives with the suffixes named in the title. His own typical example of the method employed may be cited (p. 5) : "The word 'ventosus' as used by Tacitus, G., V. 3, means 'exposed to the winds.' The sentence is 'terra umidior qua Gallias, ventosior qua Noricum aspicit.' The wind does not necessarily blow all the time; but when it does the land is swept by it. The meaning 'exposed to' is forced on -oso- by 'ventus' and 'terra.' In Ovid, Fasti, IV. 392, 'primaque ventosis palma petetur equis,' -oso- means 'swift as.' The word 'ventus' connotes several qualities, either (sic!) one of which may furnish the tertium quid com- parationis between 'ventus' and another noun. Consequently the precise content of -oso- cannot be known until the noun limited is known." Following the Introduction, chap, i details with examples the various meanings found for the two suffixes: causing, suffering, fraught with, mixed with, li^ang in, growing in, clear as, round as, provided with, subject to, in need of, celebrated in, known to, composed of, fond of or addicted to, under the influence of, prone to, afflicted with, diseased in, as tough as, near, open or exposed to, tossed by, fickle as, swift as, susceptible to or injured by, fit for, clothed in, smelling of, colored like, full of — 31 in all. A certain criticism is forestalled (p. 4 infra) : "No emphasis should be laid on the exact English wording given in the various translations. Translation is merely the imper- fect medium through which the fact that the termination has varying semantic content is indicated." » Possibly this may be due in part to the fact that Sudhaus was prevented (see note above) from revising all his notes himself. 114 Book Reviews The second feature of the investigation is presented in chap, ii, which cites passages in which adjectives with other suflSxes occur with meanings already foimd for those ending in -oso- and -lento-. Such semantic equiva- lents are found among adjectives with the following terminations: -bili^; -ri-; -li-; -eo-, -aceo-, uceo; -estro-; -undo-, -cundo-, -tundo-; -ado-; -do-; -eno-; -ico-; -io-; -fer; -ger; -hiba; -ficus; and the prefix in-. A striking example is quoted (p. 24) from Quint., iv. 2, 52: "Ut fiu^.i reum cupidum, adulterii libidinosum, homicidii temerarium," where -do-, -oso-, and -ario- all convey the idea of "prone to." Besides this, the same meanings may be conveyed by a perfect participle, a present participle, a genitive case, an ablative case, an adjective, a noun, a verb. By " adjective " in this last list, he presumably means an adjective without a suffix readily classifiable. The example of parallel between verb and -oso- adjective (pp. 33-34) seems to the reviewer rather forced. Chap, iii was not a part of the original investigation, but was added to illustrate semantic reciprocity between adjectives of other suffixes than those compared with each other in the second chapter. The material examined comprised (pp. 2-4) 3,587 passages with adjec- tives in -oso- and -knto-, including complete collections from the literature down to the end of the Augustan age, except for Nepos, Varro LL, Ovid, Manilius, and Seneca Rhetor; of later authors, Quintilian, Martial, Juvenal, and Tacitus were collated in full, and Pliny the Elder and Columella in part. In chaps, i and ii, numerous and valuable parallels are given from Sanskrit. The following observations may be made: The numerous citations from Ovid in the body of the dissertation cause a suspicion that this name should be given on p. 2 in the list of authors examined, and that its omission there is an accident. The system of abbreviation is inconsistent: "Cato, R. R." and "Cato, A. C." are both found on p. 24, and "Plin," with and without "N.R." on p. 33. Further, the abbreviations are often obscure, and yet no key is given: "A.," "F.," "T.," "O.," "P." are ambiguous even when preceded by "Cic." We should appreciate being told that the Histories of Tacitus are indicated by "Tac," with a Roman numeral for the book, and the Anncds with an Arabic numeral; but the printer is likely to confuse Roman and Arabic 1, as he does on p. 8, 1. 17. The references to the Elder Pliny lack the last and most important subsection. A quotation from Accius in Cic. N.D. 2, 89, is credited to Cicero on p. 9. At the last line of p. 12, the page reference to "K. Z., 1912," should by all means have been added. There are some misprints, as damnosir oagris, p. 6, 1. 18, for damnosior agris; constant, p. 9, 1. 24, for constent; infamen, p. 28, 1. 2, for infamem. The punctuation has been handled unsatisfactorily; witness the extracts at the beginning of this review, and the excessive use of quotation marks throughout the treatise. Book Reviews 115 Nevertheless, this dissertation is a valuable addition to the literature of semantics, and, as might have been anticipated, confirms the propositions set forth at the outset and quoted above. These propositions are not original with Dr. Nichols, and he expressly disclaims any credit for them (p. 1), seeking merely to accumulate the convincing evidence for them. In this he has succeded. It is to be regretted that it lay outside the scope of his investigation to touch upon the etymology and primary meanings of these suffixes, if such be determinable; for his collections must be enormously superior to the material at the command of those who have hitherto dealt with these problems: cf., e.g.. Fay, KZ, XLV, 111-33, and Skutsch, Glotla, II, 241-46. Possibly Dr. Nichols has in mind to deal with these matters at a later time. Roland G. Kent UmvEKSiTT OP Pennsylvania De Amoris et Psyches Fabella Apuleiana nova quadam ratione explicata. By J. A. ScHEOEDER. Amsterdam, 1916. Like the story of Cupid and Psyche itself in the Metamorphoses, the kernel of this thesis is imbedded in many pages of quite different material. Pre- ceded by a long review of previous theories and followed by a reprint of the text of the Cupid and Psyche story, the "new method of interpretation" is an ingenious application of the psychology of Freud to the literary analysis of Friedlander. For Schroeder holds that the famous story is a primitive folk-tale, somewhat disguised by its Alexandrian dress and satiric embellish- ments, but still a folk-tale, and one that had its origin, not in any myth of the gods, but in the universal dreams that result from repressed desires of sex. This is hardly susceptible of proof, but the presentation is clear and convincing. The reprinting of the text that follows is hardly justified by the few notes, or rather references to the argument, that accompany it. On the other hand, the review of Reitzenstein's Das Mdrchen von Amor und Psyche bei Apuleius in the introductory part of the thesis is valuable for its own sake. For the prestige which Reitzenstein so justly enjoys because of his un- questioned brilliancy might obscure the weaknesses of his highly speculative inaugural. Schroeder finds the weakest spot when he attacks the basic assumption of Reitzenstein that Apuleius took the whole story of his Meta^ morphoses straight from Sisenna who, in turn, merely translated Aristeides. But this is typical of many lesser assumptions and Schroeder clears the air even though his thesis as a whole presents little that is original. C. W. Mendell Yale College