STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 107 The essay is interesting, and the claims of the new theory are well pre- sented. Whether the theory has been proved or not, a determined assault has been made on the old position and some of its defenses damaged; in any new discussion of the question this work should be considered. J. F. Ferguson Bbtn Mawe Poseidonios und die jiidisch-christliche Genesisexegese. Von Dr. Karl Gronau. Leipzig, Berlin: B. G. Teubner, 1914. Pp. viii+ 313. M. 12. In this treatise Dr. Gronau investigates the source of the Hexaemeros and irp6cre)(e (reavria of Basil, the Hexaemeros, irepl KaTotorao-eios awOpiairov and De anima et resurrectione of Gregory of Nyssa. He finds this source in Posidonius' commentary on the Timaeus, amplified, perhaps, by the addi- tion of material from other works of the same author, and handed down in the philosophical schools with little alteration. Gronau takes as the basis of his argument the results of the voluminous literature on Posidonius written in the last forty years. His general method of procedure is this: To prove a Posidonian origin for a passage he cites parallels from authors supposed to depend upon Posidonius. Then by pointing out reminiscences of the Timaeus or by showing, often with the aid of Chalcidius, that the subject falls within the range of a commentary on the Timaeus, he attempts to prove that the source is Posidonius' commentary. While Gronau is able to show the presence in Basil and Gregory of scien- tific ideas which are attested as Posidonius' or which may be plausibly attributed to him, and of commonplaces to which he may well have given expression, but of which he was clearly not the originator, he fails utterly, in my opinion, to prove the use of a single Posidonian source. We know very little about Posidonius' commentary on the Timaeus; there are but few references to it in antiquity. The earliest important attempt to determine its contents and influence was in Schmekel's Die mittlere Stoa; and later writers have used his conclusions as the basis of new investigations without stopping to verify them. Further, the presence of St oic elements in an author of later antiquity does not justify us in assuming that whatever he has of a philosophic nature must come from a Stoic source. We find, indeed, in Basil and Gregory a considerable amount of material which demonstrably cannot go back to the Stoa. Gronau begins with the investigation of Homily 6 of Basil's Hexaemeros. This without question contains scientific material taken ultimately from Posidonius. I see no proof, however, of the presence of anything Posidonian in Homily 1. Gronau tries to explain by reference to Posidonius a some- what striking parallel between Basil 49C ff. and Johannes Lydus De mensibus 108 Book Reviews iii. 3. Basil is answering the question why the first day was called rjp.ipa p.la, not irpwTt) (Gen. 1:5). Lydus does not refer to Genesis, but says that the Pythagoreans ttjv Kt(j>a.Xr]V tov xpovov ov^i trpusrrjv aXXa p.iav wvopturav. Since this was a topic discussed in Genesis-commentaries (cf. Josephus, Ant., I, 29), and since we find nothing at all like this attested for Pythagoreans, we are forced to the conclusion that Lydus has blundered and that both he and Basil are drawing from some commentary on Genesis, not from a philosophical source. In 16D in a discussion of apyr) in the sense of a beginning in time, Basil says it is absurd to imagine a beginning of a beginning. Gronau compares this with Cicero Somnium Scipionis xxv. 27, which Corssen regards as Posidonian. But in the latter passage, which is a paraphrase of Phaedrus 235, principium is not a beginning in time, but a metaphysical principle. The meanings of apxv which Basil gives here are compared by Gronau to the four causes of Philo De cherubim § 125, a passage which Norden thinks is Posidonian; but a careful consideration will satisfy the reader that there is no resemblance whatsoever. In Homily 4 Gronau might be supposed to experience some difficulty, for the theory of the elements is exactly that set forth in Aristotle's De generatione et corruptione. He urges us, however, not to lay too much stress on differences between Aristotle and Posidonius, and then points to this passage as another proof of the use of Posidonius' com- mentary, since the Timaeus discusses the interchange of the elements. In the remaining homilies there is doxographical and scientific material, some of which may go back ultimately to Posidonius. The first question discussed in Gregory's Hexaemeros is d avAos 6 ®eos, 7z66tv y v\rj. The answer is given that God 6p.ov to. iravra 8V re Kal Svvarw OtX-qpari KartfidXeTO irpos ttjv cwrepyacriav tG>v ovriov, to kov(J>ov to ftapv rb vacrrbv .... to ypS>p.a to o-yrjjux ttjv irepiypafprjv to SiAcrrrfpa. a ■nwTa pxv ko.6' iavra Ivvotai €oti .... oi yap ti tovtwv i' iavrov vXr) icrriv, aAAa o-wSpa/iovra irpb's aXXrjXa vXr) •ytveTot. Gronau admits that similar conceptions of matter are found in Plotinus and Philo, but maintains that Gregory goes back to a Stoic source, because of the presence of the definitely Stoic idea of the €/m of souls in the beginning but maintains that the individual soul comes into existence with the body. We can certainly not hold Posidonius responsible for this clumsy attempt to reconcile traducianism and a theory of pre-existence. If Posidonius taught pre-existence at all, we may be sure that he taught the pre-existence of the individual soul. Gronau depends upon parallels with Cicero Tusc. i to prove that the section of Gregory's De anima et resurrectione which contains proofs of immor- tality comes from Posidonius. He thinks that all references to the im- materiality of the soul were added by Gregory himself. While the parallels between Cicero and Gregory cannot be denied, I am not convinced by the arguments of Schmekel and Corssen that the Posidonian elements in the first book of the Tusculans are as great as they think. For example, it seems to me improbable that Tusc. i. 66 and 70, both of which passages Gronau cites as parallel to Gregory, are Posidonian. But even if all of Gronau's parallels in Tusc. i come from Posidonius, this fact proves very little for Gregory's source, since the ideas are such as would constantly occur in Platonists. When Gronau asserts on p. 244 that Plato affirms the unity of the soul only in Republic 611B, he forgets Phaedo 78B, where the immortality of the soul is deduced from its unity and simplicity. Gregory's theory of the relation of the op/Mi to the XoyiKov bears a certain resemblance to Posidonius', but this is too indefinite to allow us to draw any definite conclusions concerning the source. Gronau finds definite traces of Posidonius' in the ideas of the kin- ship of the soul to God and of its consequent ability to know him. But Phaedo 80A contains the thought that the soul is akin to the divine; and 110 Book Reviews we have already spoken of the wide currency of the idea that like is known by like. Gronau lays the most stress, however, on parallels between the De anima el resurrections and the myth of Plutarch's De facie in orbe lunae. Though he declines to decide between the theories of Heinze and Adler concerning the sources of this myth, in reality he follows Adler in giving Posidonius much that Heinze gives Xenocrates. Gronau thinks that the conception of Gregory that all souls after purification return to God is parallel to Plutarch's thought that the souls are absorbed in the heavenly bodies. On p. 272 he says: "Das Eingehen in den Mond selbst geschieht ohne Beihilfe der Leidenschaften. Die unvemunftige Seele ist vorher im Reinigungsprozesse vom Geiste getrennt. Diese Trennung vollzieht sich durch das Verlangen nach dem Bilde der Sonne, durch das das Anziehende, Schone .... hervor- glanzt." With this he compares Gregory 93C where it is said that the soul is drawn to God hia. rrjs ayavvTiKrjs KivrjveoK, but that when it attains its goal, it loses all desire, since this arises only when we do not possess the object of our longing. Now it is clear enough that there is a parallel between the desire of the vovs for the sun and of the soul for God. But Gronau is in considerable confusion in regard to the detail of Plutarch's myth. In the first place, he does not carefully distinguish the return of the vovs eis h-ipov T07rov, which is presumably the sun, from the absorption of the ^vyr) into the moon. The \i\yxn in the moon. But when the soul is united to God, Gregory says that it loses every feeling of desire, since desire arises only because of the absence of the longed-for object. This latter thought, to which we have no parallel in Plutarch, is taken ultimately from Symposium 200 ff. Roger Milleb Jones Grinnell College Menander Studien. By Siegfried Sudhaits. Bonn, 1914. 8vo,pp.94. Menandri reliquiae nuper repertae, iterum ed. Siegfried Sudhaus. Bonn, 1914. Text, critical notes. 12mo, pp. 103. The Menander Studien comprise a series of investigations of the four main plays and of the Fabula incerta contained in the Cairo MS. To the