STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 103 contain a chapter on "Anthropology and the Classics." For the present the anthropological scholar, along with Professor Gilbert Murray, Cornford, and the rest, has not been given a chance. The section on Greek religion will then, perhaps, be rewritten by Miss Jane Harrison, whose three pages on "Ritual" have not been revised, and in their bald list of facts do not even hint at the well-known views of the author of Themis. Professor Murray might well rewrite Jebb's coldly correct summary of Greek literature, which was conceived in the eighties. Though naturally it is unimpeachable, as far as it goes, it ignores the modern trend of Homeric studies and the gradual change of attitude due to Rothe, Shewan, Scott, and others. How little has been done to bring this section up to date may be seen in the paragraph on "New Comedy." It was of course originally written before the dis- covery of the "Cairo" Menander, and only the following sentence has been added : "But his recently recovered plays have not enhanced his reputation." In a handbook of this sort we at least expect to be told what plays or, rather, portions of plays, were found, and where, and when. It is, however, the inevitable fate of a book like this that it should fail at almost every point to satisfy the special student who looks up his favorite subject. That does not mean that it is not a most useful work, whose reappearance will be welcome to English-speaking scholars. And the editor may well retort to his critics that he has room only for ascertained facts. I ask then only for more facts. For instance, the bibliographies are unnecessarily meager, and lack the dates of publication, an omission which makes a bibliography almost useless. Wilmeh Cave Weight Brtn Maws College Benutzung der philosophischen Schriften Ciceros durch Lactam: Ein Beitrag zur klassischen Philologie. By Franz Fessler. Leipzig: Teubner, 1913. Pp. vi+56. M. 2.50. The purpose of this work is not entirely clear. For a thorough study of the use by Lactantius of Cicero's philosophical writings there might per- haps be a place, even after the works on the subject cited by Fessler and by Schanz (Gesch. d. rim. Lit, III, 2d ed., p. 472), but such an intention the author in his preface and on pages 1 and 22 expressly disavows, on account of the shortness of time at his disposal. He further states that the collec- tions of Brandt and Laubmann's edition (CSEL, XIX and XXVII) were not used as a basis but merely subsequently compared with his own, a method which might have been justifiable had he then made a thorough use of them, which he has not. Three pages on the life of Lactantius, unnecessary in a treatise of this nature, add nothing new and contain one or two errors. The town in Picenum from which the name Firmianus may be derived is not Firmium, 104 Book Reviews but Firmum, and the fact that in it Lucius was a not uncommon praenomen will hardly appeal to many readers as a strong proof that it was the home- town of the Lactantii. A catalogue of the writings of Lactantius (pp. 4-5) might also be considered a superfluity, but it seems strange that it should make no reference to the questionable authenticity of the work Be mortibus persecutorum, and yet stranger that it should include without comment among the extant writings of Lactantius the Symposium. This work was by Heumann in his edition of 1736 identified with the riddle collection of the so-called Symphosius (cf. Anthol. Lai., ed. Riese, I, 222, n.), and to our sur- prise we learn from p. 56 of Fessler's treatise that it is this antiquated edition, rather than the standard one of Brandt and Laubmann, which he has chosen for his citations, though with the assistance and comparison of others, some of them as ancient as 1570 and 1660! On p. 7 we are told that Lactantius probably knew all the works of Cicero, and a partial list of these is given, including the Be finibus (of which Brandt and Laubmann's index locorum gives no trace; the only parallel cited by Fessler [p. 53] seems to be between Div. inst. iii. 12. 9 and Be fin. v. 7. 20 ff. where the reviewer must plead inability to discover any likeness), the Ad Murenam (sic), and the "Be procidentia." If by this last title there perhaps be meant the Be Fato, no trace of its use has appeared to me in Brandt and Laubmann's index or in Fessler's work, and the same may be said of the orations Pro Caelio, Pro Fonteio, and Pro lege Manilla. This study of Lactantius is restricted by Fessler to the Institutiones, and pp. 8-42 are occupied with a synopsis of books i-ii with a running citation of Ciceronian parallels. Apparently tiring of this method, he compresses the information for book iii (which on p. 7 he stated should be grouped with i and ii as opposed to iv-vii) and for books iv-vii into the form of a table giving the references to Lactantius, the parallels in Cicero, and the subject- matter of the borrowing. By the sign (Br.) he indicates parallels which he has drawn from the collections in Brandt and Laubmann's edition, but the reader must not suppose that all others are Fessler's original contribution to the subject. Comparison reveals the fact that of the parallels not marked (Br.) at least one-half are noted by Brandt and Laubmann, and of the other half a considerable number are rather unconvincing philosophical common- places. Other good parallels noted by Brandt and Laubmann are not here included, to the manifest impoverishment of this work. Inequalities, such as the citing (p. 48) of the " Cat. mai." and two lines below of the "de senect.," and misprints are all too common. These faults and others culminate in a carelessly prepared and in places inapposite bibliography at the end of the pamphlet. In short, there is little in the whole treatise which needed to be done at all which will not have to be reworked with better judgment and greater accuracy. Arthur Stanley Pease University of Illinois