STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world byJSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.istor.org/participate-istor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 249 there are many answers. Plautus cared nothing at all about such matters. His indifference to matters of art everybody knows; if illustration of it must be had, see e.g., my remarks in Classical Philology, II, 14, note 1, II, 6, note 1. Fiu'ther, after 880-81, Stalagmum meum qui gnatum surrujmitf the only possible subject of the verb venit in 882, as read by Niemeyer, is, not Philocrates at all, but Stalagmus. Between Philopolemus and his father's thoughts two other personalities have come — Stalagmus and the boy lost twenty years before. lam hodie <.Stalagmus venit>, "Has Stalag- mus come back so soon?" is wildly absurd. To the father's heart the twenty years of Stalagmus' absence had been a long, long time (compare the implications of the prologue and of 759 ff.). There is also a grievous psychological flaw in Niemeyer's text and introduction. Plautus knew humanity, if he did disregard art; he knew too well the soul of a father bereft to make him think, when face to face with a great and imexpected joy, the recovery of a long-lost son, of the trifling and irrelevant question of the possibility or impossibility of making a given journey ia a given time. It is, moreover, entirely possible to keep the manuscript reading. Pro- fessor Elmer nearly saw the truth. He gave the traditional text, but had the acumen to connect iam diu with the preceding surrupuit. Let us bring this out by proper pimctuation, by putting a dash after surrupuit, instead of a question mark; Ergasilus cuts in while Hegio is speaking. The effective- ness of the passage could be brought out far more easily in acting than on the printed page. What Niemeyer has to say about the Schwurapparal applies equally well to the manuscript text, as just interpreted. On 912 A (912 B in Niemeyer), which is given only in A, in a sadly corrupt state, Lindsay, editio maior, remarks that Studemund showed that in this part of the Captivi A had many more verses, perhaps forty more than appear here in the other manuscripts. In 911 ff. Niemeyer inserts two whole verses; in 912 (912 B in his numbering) he inserts several words, mak- ing the verse readable. In 912 B his text strikes me as unhappy, in that it produces a very ineffective hysteron proteron. The insertion of verses to fill up the gap in A in this part of the play is an entertaining exercise for those who like that sort of thing, but the results are not likely to carry con- viction to others. If anyone doubts this, let him compare the readings of Cap. 907, before the Ambrosian palimpsest was clearly deciphered here, with the text of that verse as now given in all the editions!! See Halledie ad loc. Chables Knapp Columbia University Etudes sur le style des Discours de Ciciron. Avec une esquisse de I'histoire du "Cursus." Par L. Lattrand. Paris: Hachette. Pp. xxxix -1-388. Fr. 7.50. In the first of the three books into which this work is divided the author examines the language of Cicero's speeches; in the second, his use of clausulae; 250 Book Reviews and in the third, the different types of oratorical style. He has evidently made a careful study of Cicero's rhetorical treatises, especially of the Orator, and in his analysis of the speeches compares practice with theory, repeatedly demonstrating how Cicero, in some point of style or choice of diction, has adhered strictly to principles expounded in his rhetorical writings. While the work is based on an original investigation of the speeches themselves, Laurand has made himself familiar with the results of the innumerable monographs and articles that have been published on various phases of the subject. He examines conflicting views with a nice discrimi- nation. He is fair in judging other men's work, and for the most part his decisions are soimd. The range of his studies may be inferred from the elaborate bibUographies (more than thirty pages in all) with which the volume is equipped. Where he has not been able to get any of the books or articles listed, he says so. This fact in itself makes his bibliography unique. The Introduction discusses the question whether the form of the orations when published adhered to or differed from the form in which they were originally delivered. Laurand believes (p. 12) that there was, for the most part, but little change. He denies the story related by Dion Cassius,* and regards the changes that undoubtedly were made in the Pro Milone before pubhcation as exceptional. His reasons for rejecting Dion's story are sovmd, but it is extremely doubtful whether the modifications in the Pro Milone constitute a unique case. They are probably exceptional in their extent, rather than in their kind. Laurand does not establish his point here. He does not of course dispute the fact that most of the speeches were written after delivery. In chap, i the author speaks of the care which Cicero exercised in the choice of the words used by him in the orations. To demonstrate the pvu'ity of the orator's vocabulary, he gives a series of lists: one containing the words occurring in quotations made by Cicero, but not used by him in his own speeches; another giving the words used in his poems, but not in his speeches; and others comparing the vocabularies of the letters and the rhetorical writings with that of the orations. These Usts are carefully compiled, and will be found useful in some forms of lexical study, but they only bear upon the question of Cicero's discrimination in the choice of vocabulary in a general way. They do not prove anything except that Cicero recognized the fact that different departments of literature have to a certain extent their own vocabularies; and this point is too patent to require so elaborate an array of evidence. The second book deals with the quality of numerus, under which term are included all those elements which are intended to contribute to harmony of speech. In the section on alliteration (p. 113) it is shown that Cicero, ^Hist. Rom. xlvi. 7. 3, where Calenus addressing Cicero in bitter invective in the Senate says: fl ofa nvi. iyvoetv Sti fojSiva ^uv $aviM