STOP Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in the world by JSTOR. Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial purposes. Read more about Early Journal Content at http://about.jstor.org/participate-jstor/individuals/early- journal-content . JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Book Reviews 241 the verbal coincidence of the Dialexeis and the pseudo-Platonic wept Butalov in the expressions iv t with critical notes; a general commentary; statistics and analysis of the meters; analysis of the vocabulary employed; literary reminiscences and imitation; discussion of authorship. The choice of readings and the emendations of the text are, as a rule, well considered (though on Pod. 19 iraflos for iropovs seems hardly warranted). The general notes contribute items of interest, especially the observa- tions on the meters of the chorals in the Tragopodagra, which may well be Lucian's handiwork, either as reminiscent of Anacreontics or as mocking imitations of the curtailed anapaests — "Hinkanapaests," i.e., ending in an iambus — current in the second century after Christ, or of the so-called dactylic "hexametri miuri" — i.e., with an iambus substituted for the last foot. In the case of the parody of the conventional tag appended to four plays of Euripides (which Zimmermann somewhat carelessly speaks of as an imitation of Euripides himself), it might have been some slight reinforcement to his contention for the genuineness of the Tragopodagra to cite the con- clusion of Lucian's Symposium. Zimmermann's notes on the Ocypus — a composition denuded of any choral charm, marred with false syntax, late forms and vocabulary, and devoid of any suspicion of humor — prepare us for his subsequent verdict against its genuineness. The use, however, of irot for irov (line 68), estab- ishing, as it does, Euripidean reminiscence, need hardly be cited as a "not- able" slip. The minute discussion of metrical details not only establishes greater carelessness on the part of the author of the Ocypus but indicates that the metrical habits of the writers of the two pieces were divergent. Although in summing up the vocabulary of the Tragopodagra there is given a somewhat formidable list of Ionic 1 forms (justified, however, by tragic coloring) and of words not elsewhere used by Lucian, yet Zimmer- mann's contention is not unreasonable that this would be quite in keeping, in verse composition, with Lucian's well-known characteristic of employing a special vocabulary for a specific purpose. Both the bad syntax and the inane repetition of dull expressions present in the Ocypus, are at least inconspicuous in the Tragopodagra. The conspectus of reminiscences from the Tragedians is not very convincing but the tragic coloring of the vocabu- lary in the Tragopodagra is evident. The argument from the order observed in the various codices is ingenious and adds weight to the rejection of the Ocypus. Lucian's satire of his con- temporaries is perhaps responsible for the Orphic suggestions and perhaps 'twi', Tragopod. 10, is ignored. Compare Lucian's experiment with imitating Ionic in de dea Syria if this, as is at least possible, be accepted as Lucianic contrary to the general opinion. Book Reviews 243 for the further use of the current fashion of unusual metrical schemes. As Zimmermann suggests, the Carmen Diophantis also employs the "cholana- paests" in introducing a sufferer with the gout. One phase, as it may seem, Zimmerman develops insufficiently. While he does emphasize the mocking satire upon the orthodox gods in the claims put forth by Podagra, and in one sentence briefly remarks: "Nee sane Podagra fabula tarn facete composita Luciani ingenio indigna est," yet he might well have supplemented the more obvious suggestions of vocabulary and meter by a fuller discussion of the delicate criteria of Lucian's humor which may, perhaps, be detected in the Tragopodagra. Although the argument that Lucian would not have repeated this same theme in a second piece seems hardly cogent in view of the many instances to the contrary in the Lucianic canon, the inferior character of the Ocypus itself is made out well enough. Zimmermann, finally, tries to prove that the Ocypus was written in the year 364 a.d. by Acacius the friend of Libanius. This is based on a reference in one of Libanius' letters to a "witty" piece on this theme which Acacius had sent him. Since Acacius and Libanius were both at this time victims of the disease, it would perhaps be only charitable to think of them as already sufficiently punished without attributing to the one the authorship or to the other the commendation of this jejune piece. If the Ocypus was really written by Lucian, and not by Acacius or some other unknown author, we must assume that the gout had by this time attacked him in both feet. In the Tragopodagra he limps, indeed, but can still bustle about like Hephaestus with his cup of humor not wholly emptied. Francis G. Allinson Die Dioskuren als Retter zur See bei den Griechen und Romern, und ihr Fortleben in christlichen Legenden. Von Karl Jaisle. Dis- sertation. Tubingen, 1907. This dissertation is divided into two parts: a good collection chrono- logically arranged of the references in Greek and Latin literature and inscrip- tions to the Dioscuri as protectors on the sea, and a discussion of the supposed survival of these gods in Christian saints. The former has considerable value as a collection of material; the latter is of little worth. In the Iliad and Odyssey, as every reader of Homer knows, Castor is only a master-driver and Polydeuces a master-boxer. But in the Homeric hymn 33, which probably belongs to the sixth century B.C., the brothers appear (vss. 6 ff.) with their later function fully developed: they are awnipes .... iiri,)(6ovitt>v avBpd>Tr